Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To intervene in DS's relationship?

414 replies

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 12:07

DS and his girlfriend are both 20. Met in 6th form and have dated ever since, now both at different Unis and keeping things going long distance.

She is from a strict religious background and made clear at the start there would be no sex before marriage. 2 years in they are being a bit physical but not even close to or considering having sex.

Her mum has got wind of this and is furious, and blames DS for "corrupting" her. There is no question around consent, it's just the religious principle that she can't accept that her daughter would do anything physical before marriage and so he is to blame.

Her mum has said the relationship can only continue if he agrees to go and have a sit down chat with her so she can explain why she is angry with him and set some ground rules. Girlfriend seems to agree this is a reasonable idea, DS is pretty horrified at the prospect but feels if he doesn't agree then the relationship will end.

I'm trying to bite my tongue because I know he adores her and I have seen how happy they are together. But FFS this seems insane to me and I want to tell him to run for the hills. I feel like even if he does this it's only a matter of time before the mum pipes up and interferes about something else.

TBH it's the girlfriend I'm most angry with as I feel like she has thrown him to the wolves and is letting this happen. I think she is a bit scared of her mum but that doesn't excuse her letting DS get painted as the bad guy.

But if I say this to DS am I being interfering too?

OP posts:
PinkStarAtNight · 13/06/2023 16:29

@AP5Diva

Many parents are more protective of daughters than they are of sons, and who wouldn’t be when 3 women are killed every week by a current or former boyfriend? You see your son, this mother sees an unknown man.

The GF's mother is not concerned about her safety. Her concern is solely based on her own religious beliefs and a desire to control her daughter's life.

You also said it's not unreasonable for the GF to want her boyfriend to engage in 'a conversation' with her mother...but this isn't a conversation. It's a lecture, a dressing down, a meeting where DS will be expected to listen while the mother lays down her rules for their (adult!) relationship, what they can and can't do sexually and what she expects of him. It's inappropriate, unhealthy and indicative of a very worrying level of control. If DS was to go to the meeting it would be showing the GF and her mother that he's willing to let himself be controlled. It would be the first step in becoming trapped in a very unhealthy dynamic. So, its really not just 'a conversation'.

Hankunamatata · 13/06/2023 16:29

He needs to have a serious chat to gf about the future. When will they marry if this is the case? Where will they live? What will children if they want them be raised as? How much will her parents have a say in their relationship?

I was married around their age so isn't that extreme idea but they both have to want it and be in same mind

ThroughGraceAlone · 13/06/2023 16:27

You all have to remember that you're coming from different baselines. As a religious person, her whole paradigm is different than yours. You can mock the religion and say its weird , but the mum is just doing what she feels right. Someone choosing to have sex before marriage is also a choice - and comes with 'rules' even if it is 'no rules'. Abstaining from sex before marriage is also legitimate and I find it very rude to say 'how could faith dictate their sex life'. Why not? You let certain certain hedonistic principles dictate your sex life? Why can't religion not dictate theirs? The mom is trying to do what she sees best for her daugther. I don't think she wrong, but I do think this relationship will probably not work long term. Your son (and you) are atheist and don't understand their faith. Which specifically calls upon parents to 'help' their children when they see them going off on the wrong path (for them). You're allowed to think its not okay to intervene in your sons relationship and what he does sexually, but equally is her mom allowed to decide.

HerMammy · 13/06/2023 16:21

@AP5Diva
I'm unsure which religion encourages controlling and interfering in your adult child's sex life and demanding to quiz their partner.

GalileoHumpkins · 13/06/2023 16:17

@AP5Diva how many of your boyfriends mums did you discuss your sex life with?

AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 16:16

HerMammy · 13/06/2023 16:13

Comments of a different culture etc aren't accurate, her mother has clearly made up her own standards and is using them to control her DD, an anglican priest has stated here that sex before marriage is not frowned upon and neither would Jesus hate her, this is a nasty twist her DM has come up with.

It’s not new nor an uncommon belief amongst more traditionalist Christians that sex before marriage is a sin. The DM didn’t come up with it like she invented it.

HerMammy · 13/06/2023 16:13

Comments of a different culture etc aren't accurate, her mother has clearly made up her own standards and is using them to control her DD, an anglican priest has stated here that sex before marriage is not frowned upon and neither would Jesus hate her, this is a nasty twist her DM has come up with.

AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 16:12

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 16:03

@AP5Diva

Don't you think it's a bit much to demand this conversation and specifically proclaim that until this conversation takes place then GF cannot see him?

More importantly don't you think it's alarming that GF is happy to abide by this?

Remember, they are 20, not 15!

I think you are over-reacting and letting your imagination run wild.
It’s not ideal, but not every parent is rational when it comes to their one and only child. Especially now we know she is a widow and her daughter is all she has in the world.

It can do no harm for your DS to sit and have an adult conversation with her.

I don’t think it is alarming that the GF is happy for her boyfriend and mother to have a conversation with each other, no. I don’t think it is alarming that she has agreed to humour her mother and have the conversation as soon as possible and to not see her boyfriend until they’ve talked.

Many parents are more protective of daughters than they are of sons, and who wouldn’t be when 3 women are killed every week by a current or former boyfriend? You see your son, this mother sees an unknown man.

brainbrian · 13/06/2023 16:07

They are adults. So many PPs are infantilising them. OP, you can’t tell him to run, he will do what he wants.

On the face of it the girlfriend sounds very immature and childish, why as a grown woman can she not stand up to her own mother? Unfortunately the GF hasn’t realised that it’s her mother with the problem and until she does (and one day she will), your DS will never be right and always second place. I would be hoping they meet and things fizzle out.

AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 16:06

J0S · 13/06/2023 15:19

I think it’s mad for you to invite yourself along to a meeting , given that your position is that it’s none of anyone else’s business. So it seems that your DS has several options

  1. say no to the meeting and his Gf will probably end it.
  2. say yes to the meeting, then decide based on the meeting that it’s not going to work and end the relationship.
  3. say yes to the meeting and then come to some agreement with Gf about where their relationship goes from there. Who knows, there might be come sort of compromise that could be agreed . It might work out or it might end some time in the future.

I think it’s really important at that you let him make his own decision. Otherwise you will be the one who split them up, not her mum.

He knew at the beginning when he started dating her that she was from a different culture , he needs to own that decision. I suspect like many young people he thought he could change her beliefs to be more aligned with his own.

But of course things change and he needs to be adult enough to decide where he wants to go from here .

Personally I think that information is a good thing. The more knowledge he has about his Gf, her relationship with her mother , their family beliefs etc the better placed he is to make an informed decision. So I think he should meet the mother and listen hard to her opinions . He doesn’t have to say much at all , just that he will go away and think about what she said.

If he’s not confident , practice some neutral responses / comments with him.

It won’t harm him to hear someone else’s opinion, especially the mother of the girl he loves.

i know MANY people who married into a different culture ( and then divorced ) and most of them wish that they had known more at the start and not gone into it blind. So trying to stop the fact finding meeting is NOT a good idea IMHO.

Great advice here.

AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 16:06

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 15:42

This is tempting!

But the awful thing is, I'm sure somewhere deep down the mum has G's interests at heart but actually she's sort of setting her up to think marriage is some big handover of power to a man.

It's like she's telling her daughter when she gets married she must have sex and do whatever her husband wants. It's so wrong.

How do you know what she has said to her daughter?

PinkStarAtNight · 13/06/2023 16:06

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 15:42

This is tempting!

But the awful thing is, I'm sure somewhere deep down the mum has G's interests at heart but actually she's sort of setting her up to think marriage is some big handover of power to a man.

It's like she's telling her daughter when she gets married she must have sex and do whatever her husband wants. It's so wrong.

As a result of my mother's religion, I was raised with the belief that once you are married your husband is entitled to sex and as his wife it is your duty to give it to him. Also that sex before marriage and masturbation is a sin and if you do this you are 'defiling' your own body. I was also told by my mother that a blow job is 'the most disgusting thing you can do as a woman, please never do it, you will regret it for the rest of your life'. This was said to me when I was around ten years old. I still have issues around blow jobs as an adult and have to talk myself down from feeling weird/dirty. tbh I have all sorts of issues around sex and relationships and have poor mental health.

I genuinely feel that if your son continued a relationship with this girl and they ended up having children, her mother (if she is anything like mine and she sounds like she is) should be considered a safeguarding risk to any grandchildren. DS would need to be careful about how their relationship was managed, because you can guarantee she will be passing her 'values' down to her grandchildren in the same way she has done with her daughter. They believe it's their duty to educate children about what God expects of them.

AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 16:05

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 14:41

I worry that G has already said something to her mum that's misleading re consent which has provoked this?

Poor DS had a mega grilling from me because of course I'm only hearing his version of events and I was concerned something bad had happened.

But after giving me a lot more detail than any mum really wants to hear I was almost giggling because seriously very little has actually happened at all physically.

And yet the mum is "angry"? So there's a big question over what G has told her mum, not to mention why she has started this conversation?

So you don’t know whether the GF actually threw your son under the bus? Or has misled her mother in any way? You are worried she might have done so.

I think it’s important not to jump to conclusions here.

brainbrian · 13/06/2023 16:03

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 14:12

The mum is 40

Bizarre-r still. She was only their age-20 when she conceived her own daughter ha ha

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 16:03

@AP5Diva

Don't you think it's a bit much to demand this conversation and specifically proclaim that until this conversation takes place then GF cannot see him?

More importantly don't you think it's alarming that GF is happy to abide by this?

Remember, they are 20, not 15!

OP posts:
ColdHandsHotHead · 13/06/2023 16:01

So the mum is deeply religious but doesn't go to church? She sounds to me as though she's deeply controlling and using religion as an excuse. Unless her daughter breaks free, this is going to be ongoing, even if they get married.

AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 16:00

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/06/2023 13:37

It isn't just "having a conversation & communicating" though, is it?

The mother is demanding a conversation and putting all sorts of conditions on it. Can't you see that that's totally different from the OP, who has proactively invited others to comment?

It’s a demand for a conversation. That’s not interfering nor does it warrant the panic and drama being attached to it.

diddl · 13/06/2023 15:58

So neither of them live at home but her mum has a say in things?

She seems to be afraid of her mum & not taking responsibility.

Tbh I'd be worried that he will be accused of coercing her into being "a bit physical".

Perhaps he should tell his GF that he doesn't need to talk to her mum as they will not do anything physical at all in future!

Emotionalsupportviper · 13/06/2023 15:56

J0S · 13/06/2023 15:23

I think that’s a very bad idea, many posters have made hugely disrespectful comments about this vulnerable young woman and her culture /beliefs . And that of millions of Christians around the world.

not the best basis for wise and sensible advice.

Agree - and even if the comments were overwhelmingly positive, no-one wants to think that their relationship has been opened to public scrutiny, no matter how anonymous

Tulip2478 · 13/06/2023 15:54

PinkStarAtNight · 13/06/2023 15:28

So GF's mum is a hypocrite as well as everything else 🙄 She sounds awful.

As someone who was brought up in a very intense and restrictive religion with the same beliefs and sentiments as this one, I would not want my child to be involved in a serious relationship with anyone who had this background. Its incredibly controlling and if this is the way GF's mum is behaving now, I don't think she'll get any better and if he did choose to stay with GF I'd be worried about what his life will be like.

You say that they work well together despite the difference in their religious beliefs, but do they really work that well if he is now being pressured to sit and listen to a sermon from her mum about beliefs that he doesn't share? He respects his GF's beliefs and religion, but she's not respecting his lack of belief if she's forcing him to be part of an uncomfortable and inappropriate conversation with her mother just because she has these beliefs.

I really feel for you as this is wrong on so many levels. I agree you have to be careful about interfering but I also agree with others that if your son is coming to you for advice about this, there's nothing wrong with sharing your concerns re: control, inappropriate behaviour etc and ask him to think about what the future might look like for him if he allows his GF and her mother to basically force him into things like this.

The mother sounds awful and I'd be really concerned about your son being controlled by her, the effect on any future children etc

From personal experience of an organised, restrictive religion I would be telling DS to think very carefully about whether he wants to be involved in this. It might be fine if his GF respected his lack of religion and her mother was not controlling her, or even if she could stand up to her mother and make clear that she cannot ask an adult man to come and be lectured and forced to talk about sex, and that her mother cannot control their relationship...but its really concerning that GF isn't willing to do this.

If GF wants to allow herself to be controlled by her mother (and her religion, because I believe that organised religion is by its nature extremely controlling) then that's her choice, but she cannot put this onto your son and ask him to live that life. I'd be concerned that she is taking her mother's side on this, it indicates that she herself is controlled by the religion and, in turn, willing to let this control her relationship. I would gently encourage DS to think about what this means for him, and any potential children he might have with this girl.

The mother sounds like she could potentially be emotionally harmful to children/young people. If she's anything like my own mother she won't think twice about trying to 'educate' young children about God and what he finds sinful (including reference to sex) and won't hesitate to sit her grandchildren down and have the kind of talk you've described. (Although tbf my own mum didn't go as far as subjecting my DB to things like this, as she realised that he was an adult and it wasn't her place to summon him for a lecture!)

Unless GF is able and willing to put boundaries in place, your DS's life could end up being very difficult. I hope he can find a way though this. Best thing you can do is be there for him and gently encourage him to carefully consider all of the above before making a decision about what to do. It has to be his choice, but you can be there to advise and support. Best of luck OP Flowers

Agree with this. I don't think anything good can come of this. I do feel very sorry for the girl however. Being raised a Jehovah's Witness it was like that for us but worse. Its such a shame she is controlled like she is, but the desire for her to please her mum will also be very strong. I only really got married when I did because I did not want my mother to shun me which she would have been forced to do. It's a very difficult situation.

alittleadvicepls · 13/06/2023 15:50

This is all a bit intense for a 20 yr old. I’d let him chat to her mum and sooner or later he’ll realise how crazy this is. Just hoping she doesn’t now declare them ‘engaged’ because of the little physical affection they’ve had!

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 15:42

Ferferksake · 13/06/2023 15:11

@AlyssaHasAChaaaaild Just get him to remind the mother (In a very authoritative voice) about 1 Timothy 2:12 "I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man; rather, she is to remain quiet."

He could then suggest that her mother ought to sell her to him as a slave wife for six years as per Exodus 21:7-11. This does only allow for a man to make the sale though, so that might be a problem.

If she's not keen on that, then he could just go with the other option which is Deuteronomy 22:28-29 where he could always just rape her, pay her father 50 shekels of silver and marry her (but as her father is dead, there's nobody to pay, so he's got her for free).

Maybe ask the mother then if she would prefer that he treats her daughter with love, kindness and respect; never pressuring her to do anything that she didn't want to; or would she rather he used a centuries old text written by primitive goatherders and edited by misogynistic paedophiles as a handbook for morals to live by?

This is tempting!

But the awful thing is, I'm sure somewhere deep down the mum has G's interests at heart but actually she's sort of setting her up to think marriage is some big handover of power to a man.

It's like she's telling her daughter when she gets married she must have sex and do whatever her husband wants. It's so wrong.

OP posts:
Thebigblueballoon · 13/06/2023 15:41

Ferferksake · 13/06/2023 15:11

@AlyssaHasAChaaaaild Just get him to remind the mother (In a very authoritative voice) about 1 Timothy 2:12 "I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man; rather, she is to remain quiet."

He could then suggest that her mother ought to sell her to him as a slave wife for six years as per Exodus 21:7-11. This does only allow for a man to make the sale though, so that might be a problem.

If she's not keen on that, then he could just go with the other option which is Deuteronomy 22:28-29 where he could always just rape her, pay her father 50 shekels of silver and marry her (but as her father is dead, there's nobody to pay, so he's got her for free).

Maybe ask the mother then if she would prefer that he treats her daughter with love, kindness and respect; never pressuring her to do anything that she didn't want to; or would she rather he used a centuries old text written by primitive goatherders and edited by misogynistic paedophiles as a handbook for morals to live by?

😂👍🙏

crazyaboutcats · 13/06/2023 15:35

I grew up in CoE church, schools and clubs and almost none of families were anywhere strict like this, it is highly unusual and the two families I knew girls from who may have been as strict as this were totally bonkers and highly questionable as in possible abuse

PinkStarAtNight · 13/06/2023 15:33

Ferferksake · 13/06/2023 15:11

@AlyssaHasAChaaaaild Just get him to remind the mother (In a very authoritative voice) about 1 Timothy 2:12 "I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man; rather, she is to remain quiet."

He could then suggest that her mother ought to sell her to him as a slave wife for six years as per Exodus 21:7-11. This does only allow for a man to make the sale though, so that might be a problem.

If she's not keen on that, then he could just go with the other option which is Deuteronomy 22:28-29 where he could always just rape her, pay her father 50 shekels of silver and marry her (but as her father is dead, there's nobody to pay, so he's got her for free).

Maybe ask the mother then if she would prefer that he treats her daughter with love, kindness and respect; never pressuring her to do anything that she didn't want to; or would she rather he used a centuries old text written by primitive goatherders and edited by misogynistic paedophiles as a handbook for morals to live by?

Love this 😂