Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To intervene in DS's relationship?

414 replies

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 12:07

DS and his girlfriend are both 20. Met in 6th form and have dated ever since, now both at different Unis and keeping things going long distance.

She is from a strict religious background and made clear at the start there would be no sex before marriage. 2 years in they are being a bit physical but not even close to or considering having sex.

Her mum has got wind of this and is furious, and blames DS for "corrupting" her. There is no question around consent, it's just the religious principle that she can't accept that her daughter would do anything physical before marriage and so he is to blame.

Her mum has said the relationship can only continue if he agrees to go and have a sit down chat with her so she can explain why she is angry with him and set some ground rules. Girlfriend seems to agree this is a reasonable idea, DS is pretty horrified at the prospect but feels if he doesn't agree then the relationship will end.

I'm trying to bite my tongue because I know he adores her and I have seen how happy they are together. But FFS this seems insane to me and I want to tell him to run for the hills. I feel like even if he does this it's only a matter of time before the mum pipes up and interferes about something else.

TBH it's the girlfriend I'm most angry with as I feel like she has thrown him to the wolves and is letting this happen. I think she is a bit scared of her mum but that doesn't excuse her letting DS get painted as the bad guy.

But if I say this to DS am I being interfering too?

OP posts:
saraclara · 15/06/2023 06:42

This is not about religion. They're (notionally) CofE, for goodness sake!

The mother is using religion as a cover for intense control. And while you're focusing on the chat at this point, whether it happens or not, this is only the beginning of a life where he and GF will be tightly controlled by her mum.

I world be desperately worried about this relationship if it continues and they marry and have children. This woman will never let them be independent or make their own decisions. Your son would be signing himself up for a kind of prison, and his GF will never have his back in any disagreement about life decisions, if her mother has a different opinion from his..

I'd be talking to him about this. To get him to look beyond this chat to their life together for decades. Is he prepared to be controlled by this woman and for his life decisions to be made under threat of "if you loved me you would...."?

HerbsandSpices · 15/06/2023 06:29

The girlfriend is old enough to convey her own values directly to your son. She doesn't need Mummy doing it for her. These are two adults. It's really inappropriate that the GF's mother talk to your son about this. She might not agree with their choices but it's their choice to make. I think your son has handled it well. He needs to think about the long term, if he continues with this relationship. Setting a precedent that his possible MIL has input into their relationship isn't a good idea.

Godlovesall26 · 15/06/2023 06:28

Godlovesall26 · 15/06/2023 05:56

Hi @AlyssaHasAChaaaaild
Have only read for now about half the thread tbh, but have read all your updates.

Couple things

  • the not attending any church when you’re a member of such a frequent denomination here stands out to me, I’ll be honest I have many friends from different faiths and they only do it because they’re the more ‘relaxed’ type who doesn’t want to spend their weekends there / kept the faith but not all the practices as adults, etc. Some of this previous ‘category’ also attend for the social aspect. Or they have to work etc. I admit I don’t know any people who claim to be fervent believers but don’t participate in the life of the faith they claim to be central to their lives.
  • I admit I don’t know any 20yo with parents with this view who then share details of their intimacy with their parents ! Most, especially at uni, do whatever and don’t tell them, or adhere by choice. GF sounds confused in herself.
  • I would be extremely worried about your son being ‘blamed’ for corrupting her, that’s the main thing that stands out to me from your post. I would suggest if this conversation does happen, you invite the mum to dinner with both you and your husband present. These situations are unfortunate but not inexistant sadly, and the GF has already shown how she would react.
  • The point is supposed to be (for most) that Jesus/other prophets/God/…. love you…. Not have a camera over you to decide if they’ll hate you…
  • I also don’t know any very practicing people who marry outside of their faiths. For those who hold these views re sex outside of marriage, those I know married young (around 21-22 is a bit more common now than 18, then again they’d have been engaged and marriage planning for a while), with partners in agreement (hence one aspect of the places of worship socializing which can be more intense usually in these cases : they need to meet those partners first!). So they’ve made their decision by 20 usually around how they wish to live their lives. And no future headaches about practices.

Sorry, a little long, I’m pretty ‘liberal’ myself but never mind me, Ive always liked hearing about different faiths/viewpoints so have quite a wide circle, this particular family sounds way too complicated tbh, I couldn’t deal personally sorry

Sorry all my bullet points have disappeared, hope it still shows up on your screens with a semblance of paragraphs☺️
Also mentioning for ref Im 32, and we’ve always been more of a ‘faith is between you and God’ and ‘all faiths have common values’ (well, the main monotheistic ones in my upbringing, although my circle has extended), and we don’t believe in heaven/hell, I have atheist friends also. We’ve never been pushed to actually do anything really, except be respectful of others and if you’re in a certain place try to adapt to the rules of that place, basic politeness really.

Most of my friends I would say have been like me, no intimacy before being adult, but relationships afterwards (not one night stands to caricature for most, but some definitely have, we don’t judge either, it’s just been a personal choice for most) and settled at various ages, but definitely more after 25 I’d say.

Most parents (even the ones who wish no sex - they just ensure intense earlier social connections) have moved way past the bullsh*t and don’t want their kid to get screwed over by some partner just because the faith is supposedly the same officially, so getting to know the person as much as possible (which everyone defines differently).

Even my 91yo old grandmother, bless her, very fragile and very conservative (definitely no sex) said not too long ago ‘I don’t know, times have changed, I’d at least buy him a puppy first (poor puppy) to see what he’ll look like with a baby, wait at least 20yo to see if he’s started working/studying, and I mean, not live together (!!), but maybe a nice cheap 2 week holiday with separate rooms where you’re both responsible for cooking and cleaning’.☺️

Henrysmycat · 15/06/2023 06:28

Having experienced first hand of “religious” control, whether your DS stays or not, religion and religious control will always be the 3rd person in the relationship.
He’ll end up being married young or stay with a person out of duty because once they messed around in bed (With her consent).
Religion will always be used as an excuse at everything including quick wedding. Her parents will always interfere. Will he ever live his life with Jesus playing such a huge role? It’s insanely horrible, tiring and controlling. Look at cults. He needs to run. The world is full of people and many of them are nice, lovely, thoughtful and whatever else he wants, he can do better. I can put him in contact with a person that did follow the instruction of religious inlaws and kept on making allowances and agreeing to more and more controlling life, it destroyed his life. He divorced at 45 and starting to rebuild his life.

Godlovesall26 · 15/06/2023 05:56

Hi @AlyssaHasAChaaaaild
Have only read for now about half the thread tbh, but have read all your updates.

Couple things

  • the not attending any church when you’re a member of such a frequent denomination here stands out to me, I’ll be honest I have many friends from different faiths and they only do it because they’re the more ‘relaxed’ type who doesn’t want to spend their weekends there / kept the faith but not all the practices as adults, etc. Some of this previous ‘category’ also attend for the social aspect. Or they have to work etc. I admit I don’t know any people who claim to be fervent believers but don’t participate in the life of the faith they claim to be central to their lives.
  • I admit I don’t know any 20yo with parents with this view who then share details of their intimacy with their parents ! Most, especially at uni, do whatever and don’t tell them, or adhere by choice. GF sounds confused in herself.
  • I would be extremely worried about your son being ‘blamed’ for corrupting her, that’s the main thing that stands out to me from your post. I would suggest if this conversation does happen, you invite the mum to dinner with both you and your husband present. These situations are unfortunate but not inexistant sadly, and the GF has already shown how she would react.
  • The point is supposed to be (for most) that Jesus/other prophets/God/…. love you…. Not have a camera over you to decide if they’ll hate you…
  • I also don’t know any very practicing people who marry outside of their faiths. For those who hold these views re sex outside of marriage, those I know married young (around 21-22 is a bit more common now than 18, then again they’d have been engaged and marriage planning for a while), with partners in agreement (hence one aspect of the places of worship socializing which can be more intense usually in these cases : they need to meet those partners first!). So they’ve made their decision by 20 usually around how they wish to live their lives. And no future headaches about practices.

Sorry, a little long, I’m pretty ‘liberal’ myself but never mind me, Ive always liked hearing about different faiths/viewpoints so have quite a wide circle, this particular family sounds way too complicated tbh, I couldn’t deal personally sorry

changeme4this · 15/06/2023 04:15

imagine not image...

changeme4this · 15/06/2023 04:14

Its a no from me. Image if a father wanted to speak to his Son's GF about sex/values etc in their relationship, it would not be seen as being appropriate in any form, so I don't see why the Mother feels its acceptable for her to speak with your Son nor interfere in their relationship.

I would be tempted to have a chat with GF and probs even the mother and mention the adult couple's entitlement to privacy. Its all very well being honest with family, but there's a line of what you should say and what is no one else's business to know or ask, including family.

WordsandSentences · 15/06/2023 04:01

It’s actually a bit creepy, as though she’s somehow trying to be involved in their sex life vs stopping it. She doesn’t want her daughter doing something she’s not able to control / be involved with. I don’t think it’s about Jesus…

There’s no way on earth she wouldn’t be a creepy controlling MIL and the thought of grandchildren - he’d never be rid of her.

It’s sad for the daughter but clear she’s no way near disentangling herself and likely will struggle to do so at all.

Trying2understand · 15/06/2023 03:51

I had to chuckle a bit about the C of E but don't go to Church yet have all these rules and a lack of respect for boundaries? I can see why you are worried @AlyssaHasAChaaaaild

I imagine the girl has experienced a lot of control and may just be repeated what her parents have said. I would try not to lay too much blame on the girlfriend. But very hard situation all round.

QueenBitch666 · 15/06/2023 03:43

Carrie vibes 😳

To intervene in DS's relationship?
QueenBitch666 · 15/06/2023 00:26

Mum sounds unhinged. I'd be encouraging ds to run a mile

DietrichandDiMaggio · 14/06/2023 23:28

Sorry, posted accidentally before finishing. I'd be concerned that her wanting to wait until she was married, could lead to your son feeling pressured to marry someone who he doesn't really know properly and who actually might not be the right person for him. It would mean they wouldn't have lived together or even really spent any length of time together alone. Most men don't marry before they are in their thirties these days, so I'm guessing he's not going to wait another 10 years? Getting married young so you can have a sexual relationship isn't really the best reason, is it?

DietrichandDiMaggio · 14/06/2023 23:18

There are so many things that are 'off' with the way their relationship is expected to be conducted, but even if things are smoothed over and they continue as they did before

Middleagedspreadisreal · 14/06/2023 22:17

CofE? Blimey. Don't they know we're in the 21st Century now? So many alarm bells ringing. Unfortunately all you can do is remain calm, listen and advise. And be there for your DS if and when they hopefully split up

Santina · 14/06/2023 21:46

It's a really difficult one, but if you tell your son to run for the hills, it could push them together more. I wanted to tell my son the exact same with the girl he is with, but I don't want to push him away or fall out with him. As hard as it is, you just have to sometimes let them make mistakes, you've got to just be there for them. When I was young, my parents told me the exact same thing, I left home and went to live with him. If I wasn't told to get rid of him, I wouldn't have continued with the relationship probably anyway.

It's really tough, but think of the consequences of the relationship with you and your son if you push too hard.

Good luck.

Shelby2010 · 14/06/2023 21:44

Sounds like you need to play the mum at her own game & suggest that you & her sit down & discuss your children’s sex life or lack of.

I suspect that she will tell DS that he needs to marry GF if the relationship continues. I worry that your DS will be coerced into agreeing when he is much too young.

As nuts as it sounds I think you need to accompany him for this chat. I suspect GF or MM (Mad Mother) will object to you being there, which says it all really.

Agapornis · 14/06/2023 21:43

Please remind GF that every time she masturbates, God kills a kitten Wink

(showing my internet age here)

To intervene in DS's relationship?
Agapornis · 14/06/2023 21:37

It's madness and he can do better. The GF needs therapy.

But if he does want to go ahead, could you invite GF & mum to your home? That way your son will feel safer, the mum will probably reign it in a bit, you'll be there to protect him and to debrief afterwards.

canigetitmyself · 14/06/2023 21:36

The thought that jesus is watching is creepy AF

Jesus, you pervy dead spirit! Be gone

canigetitmyself · 14/06/2023 21:34

Are you sure they're C of E and not something else? Sounds awfully controlling and god fearing

Got to wonder how compatible they are really. I wonder if GF mum is going to suggest they get married? How long is a 20 year old going to want to be in a relationship with no physical intimacy? He is too young to settle. Then he's stuck with batshit in laws

Crikey, the mums younger than me and I don't think i could face the 'doing bits' chat with her myself. Mega cringe

ScotsBluebell · 14/06/2023 21:12

I have a grown up son and I would be advising him - as tactfully and lovingly as I could - to run for the hills. This isn't about chastity or virtue. It's about power and control. There would always be not just three people in the relationship - DS, GF and her mum - but some strange concept of Jesus too, who let's face it, never paid much attention to people's sex lives when he was alive, except for telling a bunch of misogynist guys that they weren't too chaste themselves. The very idea of JC taking a prurient interest in a little light petting is - when you think about it - laughable. Except that in this case, it's having serious consequences. This almost cult-like version of Christianity would frighten me. (Read Megan Phelps-Roper's book Unfollow for an interesting perspective.) They are both quite young and inexperienced. But it's one thing to caution people to be careful and respectful of each other in that situation - quite another to ban all physical contact. DS should be having a good summer, not agonising over somebody else's unreasonable beliefs and demands. My only other piece of advice to you would be to make it absolutely clear that you support him, that he has no need to be intimidated or defensive - and that he has no need at all to appease the mother, given that he has done nothing wrong - but you're probably doing that already.

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 14/06/2023 20:39

If he agrees with this stupid plan then he is basically agreeing to their always being a third person in their relationship who has be appeased obeyed and taken into every discussion. He needs to say to gf that he is now actually an adult and as such does not need her mother telling him what is appropriate or how to behave. Perhaps she too needs reminding that she is an adult and not a little girl and os entitled to live her life how she wants

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 14/06/2023 20:23

It sounds to me like the mother is used to getting her way and the daughter perhaps due to cultural differences does what she is told. The problem is if he caves on this the mil will think she can call the shots and where will it end? Will she try and exert control over their wedding, choice of place to live, how they name and raise any kids etc etc… He needs to think carefully about their future and setting boundaries

AcrossthePond55 · 14/06/2023 20:23

@AlyssaHasAChaaaaild

Since he's told her he wants to 'think about it', if I were you I'd encourage him to set up a meet-up or two with his mates in the next day or two to kick around a ball or do some gaming (or whatever it is they do). Not that they're going to talk about it, but to give him something to do AND to show him there is 'life after GF' if she (and her mum) decide to take a hard line.

Because it sounds to me as if Mum has drawn a hard line in the sand and GF isn't going to even try to cross over it. And in a way, I don't blame her as she's probably scared of the consequences. Chances are Mum's is her only home & source of financial support so I think uppermost in her mind is "Where will I go and how will I live if I defy her?". Not that it makes it right, of course.

Honestly, I think right now it's nothing about 'chastity' and much about control and showing DS his proper place in the relationship. First is GF's mum, then GF, then him.

I have two grown sons and I tell you now I'd be telling them that what GF's mum is demanding is way off the charts. And that I would be giving serious thought as to what the future might look like with this girl. I wouldn't offer to go with him as I think that would make me almost as, IDK, not as 'bad' as her, but still overstepping my place in an adult child's life. I think it would have made either of my son's feel like "Oh God, here comes Mummy running to the rescue" and neither of them would have liked that.

Poor DS. He should be having the time of his life, not having to figure out his boundaries with his GF's mother!

Pinkbasketcase · 14/06/2023 20:08

Your poor lad!! His feelings are normal and very valid, he needs to allow himself to express to his gf and if he wants, to the mother- while also telling her to mind her own! I understand religion is extremely important however, the mother is controlling behaviour to condition their relationship. I would highlight healthy relationships because this is very much toxic, especially if the gf's mother is heavily involved. If this is not assertive now, how does he feel about his future like this?! No doubt it will get worse.

You're right, if you do go along, you are in a sense condoning and giving permission for her to speak to him like he is behaving badly, when is actual fact they're both consensual adults.. this, I feel, is on the daughter NOT your son. Both need to evaluate their relationship on their own!

Swipe left for the next trending thread