Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To intervene in DS's relationship?

414 replies

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 12:07

DS and his girlfriend are both 20. Met in 6th form and have dated ever since, now both at different Unis and keeping things going long distance.

She is from a strict religious background and made clear at the start there would be no sex before marriage. 2 years in they are being a bit physical but not even close to or considering having sex.

Her mum has got wind of this and is furious, and blames DS for "corrupting" her. There is no question around consent, it's just the religious principle that she can't accept that her daughter would do anything physical before marriage and so he is to blame.

Her mum has said the relationship can only continue if he agrees to go and have a sit down chat with her so she can explain why she is angry with him and set some ground rules. Girlfriend seems to agree this is a reasonable idea, DS is pretty horrified at the prospect but feels if he doesn't agree then the relationship will end.

I'm trying to bite my tongue because I know he adores her and I have seen how happy they are together. But FFS this seems insane to me and I want to tell him to run for the hills. I feel like even if he does this it's only a matter of time before the mum pipes up and interferes about something else.

TBH it's the girlfriend I'm most angry with as I feel like she has thrown him to the wolves and is letting this happen. I think she is a bit scared of her mum but that doesn't excuse her letting DS get painted as the bad guy.

But if I say this to DS am I being interfering too?

OP posts:
Thesharkradar · 13/06/2023 13:08

Jesus wept they are 20 years old!
@AlyssaHasAChaaaaild well done for being calm and reasonable, I think I'd want to go round and headbutt the mother.
Obviously I WOULDN'T because that would be ridiculous ....almost as ridiculous as the mother.

AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 13:07

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 13:04

@AP5Diva on the better end of the scale I wonder if this might be something of nothing and a friendly mum wanting to just say a few words about her faith. Which would be a bit odd but fine.

But deep down I'm not sure this is it.

It's been billed as a bit of a dealbreaker, you have to come round and listen to her, she is angry, she wants to set you straight, we can't see each other out of the house until you do this, you'd do it if you loved me...... and the girlfriend is happy to force him into this. It doesn't feel relaxed and casual at all.

It would never be casual. A little anger isn’t anything to be afraid of, personally. If your DS is going to bin his girlfriend of two years because he’s afraid of having a conversation her mother about the nature of their relationship, then he’s not mature enough to have a serious relationship with anyone.

CrotchetyQuaver · 13/06/2023 13:07

I think you support him as an adult, reinforce the notion that their "intimate" behaviour is their own business and nobody else's and point out that mother interfering at this stage doesn't bode well for the future if they stay together.

I would anticipate that mother wants them to get married and if it was my son, I would be very concerned about that happening when they are so young and at 2 different universities. He needs to be 250% certain that is what he wants if he does.

I almost think you should be there as a silent witness when this rather alarming "chat" takes place.
If it does.

OttoGraph · 13/06/2023 13:07

how do you get on with ds best mates? it'd probably be better coming from them, than you

Gettingbysomehow · 13/06/2023 13:07

If that was my son I'd be advising him to tell this woman politely that they are adults and it is none of her business.
He will have to deal with difficult people in life and as such may as well start now.

TripleDaisySummer · 13/06/2023 13:05

In his shoes I would explain to his girlfriend that as they are both adults, a discussion of their intimate life (or indeed their belief system) with a third party is wholly inappropriate.

This. He's allowed to have boundaries as well and frankly this sound like control not religion.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Toxic-Laws-Susan-Forward/dp/0060507853

Probably citing IL it not quite appropriate nor is:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Games-People-Play-Psychology-Relationships/dp/0141040270

But might help him see what he is up against.

I'd also suggest he asks some questions about what his GF has said to her Mum - at 20 still at uni she may just be riding her Mum's behavior out but I;d worry she willing to throw him under the bus at slightest pressure from her Mum and that may be ingrained.

Ultimately though he's 20 and you can only advise and ask some pointed questions.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Toxic-Laws-Susan-Forward/dp/0060507853?tag=mumsnet&ascsubtag=mnforum-am-i-being-unreasonable-4826751-to-intervene-in-dss-relationship

Boltonb · 13/06/2023 13:05

I’d explain to him that the mother is being completely inappropriate. The girlfriend is throwing him under the bus to save herself - not very becoming.

After this issue, the mother will find something else to get involved in and exert her control. Long term, his life is likely to involve feeling like he’s in a controlling relationship with BOTH women, which will be stressful and unhealthy.

I’d also gently point out that healthy relationships in your 20s involve fun and sex. There should be no serious stress factors in your relationship at 20 years old. Fun, enjoyment, consensual sex, respect etc etc. Not control/jealousy/stress.

I’d try and make him see that his life and relationships could be fun, and there is nothing wrong with realising that you are with the wrong person and you’re ultimately not compatible

WaterIris · 13/06/2023 13:04

OP I would definitely push the point about the fact that his GF is supposed to love him as well. And if she really does care about him, then why would she want to lie to her Mum and blame it all on him? If her religious values were truly important to her, she wouldn't want to lie anyway, would she?

Ask him if the tables were turned, would be lie to you and blame it all on the GF to protect himself, and insist the GF has to come and have a lecture off you for 'leading him astray'?

BlueMongoose · 13/06/2023 13:04

I was brought up pretty strictly by modern standards, including going to church. I'm still pretty straight laced on a lot of matters (things like lying, for example). But in thems of this issue, time, observation, and experience brings wisdom, and I now think it's little short of insane to contemplate marriage without making very sure that you are sexually compatible. Whilst, of course, taking all precautions against pregnancy or STDs.
People who attempt to interfere in their kids' sex lives on religious grounds rather than just giving advice on the health aspects of sex (if they really must chip in) are definitely religious bigots/extremists, by definition. And very, very unwise. Also, anyone adult enough to be contemplating marriage ought also to be adult enough to be able to tell their parents to mind their own business and not be laying down the law about such intimate things. I'd be very concerned about any adult still under the thumb of their parents to this extent- I certainly would not want one as a DIL or SonIL.

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 13:04

@AP5Diva on the better end of the scale I wonder if this might be something of nothing and a friendly mum wanting to just say a few words about her faith. Which would be a bit odd but fine.

But deep down I'm not sure this is it.

It's been billed as a bit of a dealbreaker, you have to come round and listen to her, she is angry, she wants to set you straight, we can't see each other out of the house until you do this, you'd do it if you loved me...... and the girlfriend is happy to force him into this. It doesn't feel relaxed and casual at all.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 13/06/2023 13:04

I would be very concerned that her mothers involvement is such that should they let loose, an accusation of coercion could be used against him to calm them down.

He sounds very very vulnerable and the mother sounds very controlling.

What if this is a level of involvement his girlfriend will be content with long term?

It sounds deeply unhealthy and I absolutely would be laying it all out for him.

He needs to protect himself IMO.

Mulhollandmagoo · 13/06/2023 13:03

WeightInLine · 13/06/2023 12:34

I would be speaking to my son about adult boundaries.

Does he want to discuss his relationship with this woman? If not, then he doesn’t have to.

Completely agree, respect and boundaries work both ways, and religion or not, yours sons, girlfriends mother has no business talking to your sone about this, if she is unhappy with it then she needs to take it up with her daughter.

Also, strictly religious but doesn't go to church??

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 13/06/2023 13:03

WaterIris · 13/06/2023 12:51

My advice to your son is this:

Your GF is saying "if you love me you'll do this".

My response would be "if YOU love ME then you would be honest with your Mum. You have been an enthusiastic and willing part of everything we have done together. If you aren't prepared to be upfront with your Mum, and you think that it's fair to let her blame everything on me, then I don't think this is going to work."

He doesn't want to lose the relationship - that's clear. But he needs to take a step back and think about what this puts on him. That his GF is prepared to throw him under the bus, carry on pretending to be the sweet innocent religious girl who got led astray and lay 100% of the blame at his feet.

You've said take away religion and they are compatible. The problem is that you cannot take away the religion - it's intrinsic to her life. She'd have to walk away from it, and by the sounds of it her family, which doesn't sound likely. So unfortunately they are not compatible.

Absolutely perfectly put @WaterIris

Perhaps show your son some of these responses OP as I fear he maybe so blinkered by his love and devotion for his GF, that he can't see the wood for the trees.

If her mother is able to interfere into the level of intimacy her 20 yr old daughter has with a long term boyfriend, I dread to think what beholds them in the future where she is concerned! Probably expect to share the suite on their wedding night and go away with them on honeymoon! 😂

Joking aside, your DS does need to see all sides to this and how it may impact him in the future if he progresses with the relationship.

Bubbylana · 13/06/2023 13:03

They are very religious but dont go to church and C of E sounds a bit whacky to me and why is their sex life anybodys business. I would be mortified if my sex life or lack of it,was discussed by my parents.
They are nor 15 they are old enough to make their own minds up. Jeeze some parents.

Sugarfree23 · 13/06/2023 13:02

She sounds incredibly controlling.
If your DS and GF want to continue their relationship then they together need to stand up to the MIL.

Now it's much easier for your DS to stand up to her as he doesn't live with her the GF presumably does and needs to face the consequences every day.

She sounds like she's always been controlled and now MIL is trying to control him too.

Witchcraftandhokum · 13/06/2023 13:02

This isn't about religion it's about control.

AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 13:02

Lissadell · 13/06/2023 12:56

But it is abnormal and unreasonable. And a key element of patriarchal religion has always been controlling women’s sexuality. The fact that a 20 year old young adult woman is letting her mother and a deity dictate her sex life is abnormal. Even leaving aside the Jesus-freakery, it is ridiculously infantilising that Mummy ‘won’t allow’ two adults to visit one another at university, and that the daughter is going along with that. Bad news all round. I’m not surprised you’re alarmed, OP. Your son is sleepwalking into allowing his own life to be closed down.

That’s your opinion. It is a different set of equally valid values. While religious shouldn’t impose their beliefs on others, neither should the nonreligious mock their beliefs as “abnormal” or “infantilising” or call it “Jesus-fakery”

Plasticplantpot · 13/06/2023 13:02

How ridiculous! How can mum possibly control where she is all the time?

Lissadell · 13/06/2023 13:02

Beautiful3 · 13/06/2023 12:58

My mum was deeply religious too. No sex allowed before marriage too. To be honest the mum wants to ask what his intentions are with her daughter, are they going to get married soon? She is reminding him not to have sex with her before marriage. It's not going to work is it? They're in a 2 year relationship without sex unless they're married. He's best off moving on or proposing to her.

The daughter is an adult. It is 2023. Parental intervention about ‘honourable intentions’ was last appropriate many years ago, before women got access to the vote, the professional world, and reliable contraception.

My mother is also deeply devout, and strongly anti-sex before marriage. Within marriage, no contraception. That was my upbringing. Fortunately, I grew out of this long before the age of 20.

RedHelenB · 13/06/2023 13:01

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 12:15

She actually said to him, If you love me then you'd be happy to listen to what my mum has to say. Which seemed incredibly controlling to me.

They are both adults Nothing to do with parents on both sides.

Gracewithoutend · 13/06/2023 13:00

Mariposista · 13/06/2023 12:52

I am C of E - my MIL (sat next to me) is a C of E priest, and we both think that this woman is out of order. The Anglican Church does not preach this (heck's sake even MIL has been divorced and remarried and they still ordained her, and DH and I lived together way before we were married). GF mother is indoctrinating her, and your son should steer well away.

I'm CofE and I don't think CofE vicars should be trying to break relationships of others up when they have absolutely no idea of what the full truth of the situation is. I really don't think that is within the faith.

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 12:59

"He doesn't want to lose the relationship - that's clear. But he needs to take a step back and think about what this puts on him. That his GF is prepared to throw him under the bus, carry on pretending to be the sweet innocent religious girl who got led astray and lay 100% of the blame at his feet."

@WaterIris Completely agree with this.

OP posts:
AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 12:59

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 12:54

Girlfriend was clear from the beginning and DS accepted her stance. I'm sure it's frustrating at times, but he knows what her views are and was prepared to go along with that.

As her boundaries have softened a bit he's happy to go along with that too, but I've talked to him so much about consent and boundaries and he is clear that it's all about the two of them agreeing things between them, that's all that matters.

It's the fact the mum wants to make him hear her opinion and rules that's worrying. Plus the fact that the girlfriend is happy with this.

I see no issue with just hearing her out. Listening to another person say their opinion doesn’t mean you have to agree with or obey them. I’ve had very religious relatives and in amongst the religious forest of verbosity, there were usually simple messages about love and respect that I could find common ground with. There’s no reason to fear this woman from what you’ve said so far.

Beautiful3 · 13/06/2023 12:58

My mum was deeply religious too. No sex allowed before marriage too. To be honest the mum wants to ask what his intentions are with her daughter, are they going to get married soon? She is reminding him not to have sex with her before marriage. It's not going to work is it? They're in a 2 year relationship without sex unless they're married. He's best off moving on or proposing to her.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/06/2023 12:56

Leastsaidsoonestscrewed · 13/06/2023 12:50

It's also quite OK not to. Why would abstaining always be about "hang ups"?

Abstaining because god is always watching is a hang up I don't think anyone should have personally.