Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To intervene in DS's relationship?

414 replies

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 13/06/2023 12:07

DS and his girlfriend are both 20. Met in 6th form and have dated ever since, now both at different Unis and keeping things going long distance.

She is from a strict religious background and made clear at the start there would be no sex before marriage. 2 years in they are being a bit physical but not even close to or considering having sex.

Her mum has got wind of this and is furious, and blames DS for "corrupting" her. There is no question around consent, it's just the religious principle that she can't accept that her daughter would do anything physical before marriage and so he is to blame.

Her mum has said the relationship can only continue if he agrees to go and have a sit down chat with her so she can explain why she is angry with him and set some ground rules. Girlfriend seems to agree this is a reasonable idea, DS is pretty horrified at the prospect but feels if he doesn't agree then the relationship will end.

I'm trying to bite my tongue because I know he adores her and I have seen how happy they are together. But FFS this seems insane to me and I want to tell him to run for the hills. I feel like even if he does this it's only a matter of time before the mum pipes up and interferes about something else.

TBH it's the girlfriend I'm most angry with as I feel like she has thrown him to the wolves and is letting this happen. I think she is a bit scared of her mum but that doesn't excuse her letting DS get painted as the bad guy.

But if I say this to DS am I being interfering too?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Boxingdayhunts · 27/12/2023 23:33

How are they getting on @AlyssaHasAChaaaaild

saraclara · 16/06/2023 23:44

The mother isn't actually religious at all, is she? She's just using religion as a structure to keep her daughter (and any boyfriend) under her control, consciously or otherwise.

I can see how it happened, I can see why she's scared. But Jeeze, that's one incredibly unhealthy mother and daughter relationship that he's going to be caught up in for the foreseeable future..

And yes, "f you love me you'll..." is the biggest red flag to exist in a relationship. Your DS really needs to recognise that and be very clear with his GF that it's unacceptable.

Ferferksake · 16/06/2023 23:33

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 16/06/2023 14:56

@Ferferksake DS really thinks religion is nonsense but he and GF have talked about her belief a lot and he is understanding of what it means to her.

The fact that she and her mum never go to church is quite significant. Their belief has always been a very personal thing, a moral code, a source of comfort and inspiration etc that made him think it wouldn't be a big divide between them.

Her religion has never impacted any aspect of her own life or decisions before IYSWIM it's just now regarding sex that it has become an issue. She swears, she laughs at religious and other rude jokes, she is not prudish. She doesn't think Sundays are holy days, she doesn't observe any religious traditions eg Lent. Her life and personality have been entirely free of religious influence. Until now.

A Facebook friend of mine who does believe in this stuff just shared a quote and it fits perfectly here:

Christianity is about helping others and controlling yourself. When it becomes about controlling others and helping yourself, it's not Christianity.

The mother has no right to be angry, because nothing happened without consent. It is not for her to dictate what happens, but for her daughter and your son, who are both adults. She is controlling them (or at least trying to). Helping herself? As others have said, I suspect she's helping herself to her daughter's youth and life in her attempts to keep her tied to her apron strings.

He needs to take a very long hard look at her mother, because at the end of the day, that'll be who he's really marrying if that's where it leads. He'll be living under her matriarchy.

Owl55 · 16/06/2023 18:32

Maybe you could insist you his-mother😂 ,attends too!!!!

AcrossthePond55 · 16/06/2023 16:29

Twobyfour · 16/06/2023 15:21

I think the real issue is control and not religion and “permissivenesses”.

The mother’s life since she was about 20 has been her only child, but this child is now an adult and could leave the nest at any time, going to University, having an adult relationship, starting work etc. Her daughter goes to Uni (but is unhappy) so rather than encourage her to join societies, make friends and attend social events she encourages her to come back home every weekend so she is missing out on a big slice of Uni life. Daughter has a boyfriend, but it’s getting more serious, so Mama lays down the law and tries to exert her control so she is in charge of the relationship and they need her permission. “My religious belief is paramount”.

Even if your DS and his girlfriend get married, to be able to have sex, then her mother will become the MIL from Hell insisting they live close by (or even in the same house) and still keeping control. Her mother must be about 40ish and she could easily live another 40+ years. Does your DS want to spend most of his adult life under his MIL’s thumb?

I agree. This mother is terrified of losing her daughter and being 'alone'. So she is trying to bring OP's DS firmly under her 'control' to prevent that from happening. She wants to 'gain a son' before she 'loses her daughter'.

Bluetrews25 · 16/06/2023 16:06

This GF is going to wake up in a few decades and wonder why she is single and with no DCs.

Twobyfour · 16/06/2023 15:21

I think the real issue is control and not religion and “permissivenesses”.

The mother’s life since she was about 20 has been her only child, but this child is now an adult and could leave the nest at any time, going to University, having an adult relationship, starting work etc. Her daughter goes to Uni (but is unhappy) so rather than encourage her to join societies, make friends and attend social events she encourages her to come back home every weekend so she is missing out on a big slice of Uni life. Daughter has a boyfriend, but it’s getting more serious, so Mama lays down the law and tries to exert her control so she is in charge of the relationship and they need her permission. “My religious belief is paramount”.

Even if your DS and his girlfriend get married, to be able to have sex, then her mother will become the MIL from Hell insisting they live close by (or even in the same house) and still keeping control. Her mother must be about 40ish and she could easily live another 40+ years. Does your DS want to spend most of his adult life under his MIL’s thumb?

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 16/06/2023 14:56

@Ferferksake DS really thinks religion is nonsense but he and GF have talked about her belief a lot and he is understanding of what it means to her.

The fact that she and her mum never go to church is quite significant. Their belief has always been a very personal thing, a moral code, a source of comfort and inspiration etc that made him think it wouldn't be a big divide between them.

Her religion has never impacted any aspect of her own life or decisions before IYSWIM it's just now regarding sex that it has become an issue. She swears, she laughs at religious and other rude jokes, she is not prudish. She doesn't think Sundays are holy days, she doesn't observe any religious traditions eg Lent. Her life and personality have been entirely free of religious influence. Until now.

OP posts:
AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 16/06/2023 14:49

Throckmorton · 16/06/2023 12:48

Saying "if you loved me then you would do X" is such a massive red flag. Even without the issue of the mum, that alone is enough to suggest your son really would be better off leaving this woman.

This is a huge concern to me too.

After all, how many boys have tried the line, if you loved me then you'd agree to have sex?

OP posts:
2bazookas · 16/06/2023 14:16

Just a wild idea.

How about you suggest he and GF talk to YOU ?

I very much suspect the GF is so repressed she will decline to discuss with you, the nitty grittyof their physical contact.

DS can then say to her "Now you know why I won't discuss my sex life with your Mother. That is the end of it as far as I'm concerned and you must tell her so.".

Naunet · 16/06/2023 13:55

I think you both sound over involved in 2 adults lives. You both should mind your own business.

Sugarfree23 · 16/06/2023 13:17

It's a bit harsh to call religious belief fairy tales.
While you might not believe in the creator god, plenty people do.

Science has never been able to explain what caused the big bang or how single cell organisms manged to evolve into multi organed species.

Male / female and reproduction to my head is far to complicated for it to have happened by chance.

Being fair to most mainstream religions, they are basically a code of conduct for a civil society.

Ferferksake · 16/06/2023 12:58

MasterBeth · 16/06/2023 07:12

Religion can be abnormal or unreasonable.

In fact, strictly speaking, all religion is unreasonable by default. It relies on faith, not reason.

Yes, it's good that he respects her right to believe, but he doesn't have to respect her belief.

Personally I just couldn't do it. If my partner told me they believed in the magic sky daddy and baby cheeses. I would find it as ridiculous as if they told me they believed in Santa Claus. How can you respect somebody as a life partner who believes in fairy tales?

Throckmorton · 16/06/2023 12:48

Saying "if you loved me then you would do X" is such a massive red flag. Even without the issue of the mum, that alone is enough to suggest your son really would be better off leaving this woman.

Sugarfree23 · 16/06/2023 12:40

They may well naturally drift apart with them being at different Unis but the girl needs help to see the damage her mum could do.
When is she going to stop her mum chasing away her potential partners, and dictating her relationships?

Fluffmum · 16/06/2023 11:55

He’s 20 in a different uni. It’s time to split up

WhatNoRaisins · 16/06/2023 07:20

If these two people came together with the same beliefs and made this decision for their relationship themselves that's one thing. When only one person wants to wait and that want is coming from something external to the relationship that's going to be more of a problem for the other partner.

There's no sex switch that can suddenly be flipped and I think he could be facing a really difficult long term with this girl and all the other interferences in their relationship. He'd be better off with someone who sex would be a private matter with and they could take their time to explore that side of the relationship without trying to please anyone else.

MasterBeth · 16/06/2023 07:12

AP5Diva · 13/06/2023 12:21

You really shouldn’t be turning different religious beliefs about sex before marriage into something that is abnormal or unreasonable. That’s their religion.

Religion can be abnormal or unreasonable.

In fact, strictly speaking, all religion is unreasonable by default. It relies on faith, not reason.

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 16/06/2023 06:56

This is all horrible and so, so wrong. But a little bell is ringing for me here- this isn't a ploy by the girlfriend to get engaged is it? Maybe I'm being cynical but is she using her mum to force your son into a corner?

Sugarfree23 · 15/06/2023 21:53

It does sound like the Mother / Daughter relationship needs help, to loosen the apron strings.

Could the mother be guilt tripping 'I don't know what I'd do without you, oh I miss you so much when your away, I'm scared something happens to you.

The Dad died young, so it may well have been a sudden death, heart attack, or accident that has left deep fears too.

It's all that stuff at the root of this. But maybe, just maybe, it's a sincere belief that sex before marriage is wrong.

So while my initial thoughts were that his Dad should go with him to 'meet' the mother.
I'm now thinking that she needs help to stand up to her mum and make her mum realise she is a young adult who needs to make her own path in the world.

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 15/06/2023 21:11

...... agree that mum is terrified of losing her, but think GF must also be terrified of cutting loose in any way.

Even if she wants to break away I'm sure she'd feel guilty about going against her mum who has done so much for her.

OP posts:
AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 15/06/2023 21:10

I feel sorry for Mum in some ways as she was widowed so young and has devoted her life to her daughter ever since. On the other hand her devotion seems to have veered somewhat off course IMO.

GF never went on school trips, never had a part time job, was driven to and from school every day and her life just revolves around her mum and slightly wider family. She has the best of everything materially but has been so sheltered. I thought that going off to Uni would be the making of her but then I realised she was going home every weekend and hasn't really developed much of a student life at all.

So I agre

OP posts:
Littledogball · 15/06/2023 18:23

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 14/06/2023 20:39

If he agrees with this stupid plan then he is basically agreeing to their always being a third person in their relationship who has be appeased obeyed and taken into every discussion. He needs to say to gf that he is now actually an adult and as such does not need her mother telling him what is appropriate or how to behave. Perhaps she too needs reminding that she is an adult and not a little girl and os entitled to live her life how she wants

This, exactly this.

Sugarfree23 · 15/06/2023 17:14

@Henrysmycat possibly but only because she is completely lost and sees her next role in life as a Grandma.

Which at 40 is really sad. And thinking about it she must still have been in her 20s when she was widowed.

Her DD is her life and she seems terrified of letting her go and grow up. Guilt tripping her into coming home from Uni every weekend.

I almost think the girl alone should seek some sort of councilling via the church to help her see her mum cannot live her life for her.

wentworthinmate · 15/06/2023 16:55

So your son has to remain a virgin as long as this relationship continues because her mother says so? Imagine what she’d be like if they got married, she sounds a right interfering OB. Tell him it’s between them and not her mother (who will only know what daughter has told her!).