Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?

383 replies

verdantverdure · 13/06/2023 12:06

On the day the Covid Inquiry convenes I thought I'd ask your opinion on Eat Out To Help Out.

Covid case numbers and deaths were low, as we'd done a phased return out of the first lockdown.

Then we had Eat Out To Help Out and it all kicked off again within weeks.

What did you think? At the time? Now?

YABU Eat Out To Help Out was brilliant, I loved it.

YANBU Eat out To Help Out was a bloody stupid idea that was obviously going to help the virus spread, leading to another wave, more economic devastation, and tens of thousands of us dead. And it didn't even help the hospitality industry because it screwed up Christmas which is usually their most profitable quarter.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
TempestTost · 22/11/2023 10:49

verdantverdure · 21/11/2023 12:45

More people died in the second wave than the first where they did next to nothing from December 31st to March 23rd.

Why do you think that is a response to the comment?

One of the very basic science things that is important to understand is that just because one thing follows another, it does not mean there is a causal relationship.

Most of the measures tried for managing covid don't really seem to have affected its trajectory. It went up and down in the way new viruses do, rather than in response to attempted interventions which had minimal effects, at least on covid (they did have effects of other kinds on people.)

It was understood early on, within weeks actually, that a large % of the population would have covid over the first two year period and that was inevitable. And that it would almost certainly become endemic after that, which is to say just like other endemic viruses, people would be exposed regularly. And there was, and is, no real way to mitigate that.

The media was very quiet about all of that though it was well understood by people in public health and epidemiology.

Everanewbie · 22/11/2023 10:04

I liked it and still like it. It not only attempted to break people's state induced germaphobia but also bring people through the doors of the decimated (also state induced) hospitality industry.

At the time, Boris was talking about a normal Christmas, and we were step by step removing the worst excesses of government overreach and overreaction.

Given that they panicked once more in Autumn, and far too long into the summer of 2021 I can see how EOTHO in August 2020 now looks a rather disjointed idea. But it was a policy from that short lived period of optimism.

Now, EOTHO represents a great stick for political opponents of Rishi to beat him with, a proverbial open goal.

nether · 22/11/2023 09:28

And we trust them now with the complete dismantling of it all?

To the extent that cancer patients (some of the most vulnerable in the country) are not safe - because our hospitals are not safe. They are still trying to kill off the CEV

It's an ongoing disgrace

Covid kills more DC than chicken pox, btw. But you wouldn't think so from the messaging.

Covid depresses immune function, making many diseases more severe - but lets blame a years-ago lockdown instead

Many countries, including UK, are seeing more people off work or shortening hours than ever before, but lets overlook a disease that impairs many body systems and instead blame malingering and threaten to remove free prescriptions

And of course, lets make sure that everyone gets it, so there is no longer a group in previous normal health, so we can continue to lie, and say the "new normal" twas ever thus, and find all sorts of excuses to attribute the change in the nation's health to anything but covid.

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 09:17

God almighty.

I can't help being shocked by the callousness, the lazy uselessness and the lack of understanding 9 or so months into the pandemic.

Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak had recently had a meeting with people from HART and Great Barrington Declaration so perhaps that's why they were so gung ho for our parents and grandparents to die.

Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?
Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?
Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?
OP posts:
Ramalangadingdong · 21/11/2023 23:37

verdantverdure · 21/11/2023 20:02

Hasn't he though?

Or did he just not care if people died?

He didn’t care f poor people died.

WestwardHo1 · 21/11/2023 22:40

Alexandra2001 · 21/11/2023 15:22

Disagree, there may not be another pandemic for a 100 years (might be one next year) we need to hold people to account too and that requires blame and consequence for their actions.

Learning the lessons is all very well if people did what they were supposed to have done but they didn't, they cut investment, had parties, locked down too late, lied......

Young people were let down v badly, my DD one of them, but what is the Govt doing to help make up lost ground? Sweet fuck all.

How about attaching blame and accountability for that?

You must have missed the bit where I said they should be held to account

DonnaBanana · 21/11/2023 20:04

I made my husband take the policy at its word and he didn’t catch anything 😉

verdantverdure · 21/11/2023 20:02

Ramalangadingdong · 21/11/2023 14:52

At the time I thought it was nuts and refused to participate although friends of mine happily tucked in and avoided the virus.

Rishi Sunak, like many highly educated people, has no common sense.

Hasn't he though?

Or did he just not care if people died?

Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?
OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 21/11/2023 15:22

WestwardHo1 · 21/11/2023 14:44

I fear this enquiry is a witch hunt rather than a "what should be learned for next time?". And there will be a next time

Absolutely those who led us so dreadfully should be held accountable. But this should not be the main aim.

. So many things were done badly. People seem to be fixating only on "we should have locked down sooner" rather than how, for example, our children and young people were so terribly badly let down

Disagree, there may not be another pandemic for a 100 years (might be one next year) we need to hold people to account too and that requires blame and consequence for their actions.

Learning the lessons is all very well if people did what they were supposed to have done but they didn't, they cut investment, had parties, locked down too late, lied......

Young people were let down v badly, my DD one of them, but what is the Govt doing to help make up lost ground? Sweet fuck all.

How about attaching blame and accountability for that?

Ramalangadingdong · 21/11/2023 14:52

At the time I thought it was nuts and refused to participate although friends of mine happily tucked in and avoided the virus.

Rishi Sunak, like many highly educated people, has no common sense.

SunnyEgg · 21/11/2023 14:49

WestwardHo1 · 21/11/2023 14:44

I fear this enquiry is a witch hunt rather than a "what should be learned for next time?". And there will be a next time

Absolutely those who led us so dreadfully should be held accountable. But this should not be the main aim.

. So many things were done badly. People seem to be fixating only on "we should have locked down sooner" rather than how, for example, our children and young people were so terribly badly let down

Yes I hope there’s more on that. It also seems to be a barrister looking for media lines and blame

We keep asking people who were there but if we lacked anyone who was there for young people and children at the time who do we get to give evidence speaking about harm to them?

WestwardHo1 · 21/11/2023 14:44

I fear this enquiry is a witch hunt rather than a "what should be learned for next time?". And there will be a next time

Absolutely those who led us so dreadfully should be held accountable. But this should not be the main aim.

. So many things were done badly. People seem to be fixating only on "we should have locked down sooner" rather than how, for example, our children and young people were so terribly badly let down

verdantverdure · 21/11/2023 13:26

The Lancet view:

Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?
OP posts:
JenniferBooth · 21/11/2023 13:17

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/11/2023 10:55

DisquietintheRanks · Today 10:52
**
It's pretty silly to post about what you would or wouldn't do in some future pandemic without any knowledge of the nature of the threat you will be facing.”

This ^. If the modern day equivalent of the plague appears, people will choose to lock themselves indoors.

Including essential workers

JenniferBooth · 21/11/2023 13:16

megletthesecond · 21/11/2023 09:00

Sweden are probably healthier and more outdoorsy than the UK is. Over here half the population is allergic to using their legs or getting any exercise.

There were people on here who were questioned where they were going when they went out to get excersise. Two young women were fined for meeting for a hot drink. Do i really need to link articles again to stop the gaslighting!

Alexandra2001 · 21/11/2023 12:55

SunnyEgg · 21/11/2023 11:37

Did you notice any harms from lockdowns?

Or do you think they were downside free?

The ultimate harm though is clearly dying, not yet got a vaccine for that.

'Course there are harms, nothing is free in the LD world but given we knew little about the path CV would take, eat out scheme was bonkers.

Kids still not attending/falling behind in school now is down to lack of action by schools/authorities and Govt, same with MH provision, lack of services, not caused by LD's.

Waiting lists huge before lockdowns.

verdantverdure · 21/11/2023 12:45

WestwardHo1 · 21/11/2023 12:34

It was inevitable there was going to be a wave in the autumn. Not having EOTHO would not have prevented it.

More people died in the second wave than the first where they did next to nothing from December 31st to March 23rd.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 21/11/2023 12:42

wildfirewonder · 21/11/2023 12:38

The view of scientific community seems to be EOTHO did not cause the wave (that was inevitable), but did contribute to a change in behaviour that increased transmission.

All through it feels like England pinged between 'let it rip' and 'lock everything down'.

Like a trolley?

OP posts:
wildfirewonder · 21/11/2023 12:38

The view of scientific community seems to be EOTHO did not cause the wave (that was inevitable), but did contribute to a change in behaviour that increased transmission.

All through it feels like England pinged between 'let it rip' and 'lock everything down'.

WestwardHo1 · 21/11/2023 12:34

It was inevitable there was going to be a wave in the autumn. Not having EOTHO would not have prevented it.

verdantverdure · 21/11/2023 12:33

I'm one of the people who thinks that if you are told about what covid has done to China on NYE 2019, and you do nothing in January 2020, when Germany is ordering in gallons of the chemicals needed for testing in January, and you do nothing, then you watch what covid is doing in Italy in February 2020 and you still do nothing...

When in February and March universities are offering to take on testing, when British textile manufacturers are offering to switch production to PPE and you still do nothing..

Then a lockdown is inevitable.

That they did much the same again in the autumn after bringing the numbers down is unfathomable to me.

And to give the virus a good head start with EOTHO was madness.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 21/11/2023 12:24

We talked to our local pub landlord about the topic of lockdowns and EOTHO etc one quiet evening and he says the times where we weren't locked down but covid prevalence was high were the worst for their business, because they had to be open, heated, lit, stocked and staffed, but hardly anybody came.

He said business was already down in February and March 2020 as people stayed away because of covid, then there was lockdown, then EOTHO when you needed more staff on EOTHO days AND you had to buy stock and staff Friday night, Saturday night and Sunday lunch as usual in case people came out but generally they didn't.

Then trade fell off a cliff early in October 2020 and didn't recover until summer 2021. The massively profitable Office Christmas Lunch season and Christmas itself just didn't happen.

He says since the government knew the vaccine was coming soon he would rather they had planned ahead and closed hospitality rather than let him order all the Christmas food, keep employing the chefs, keep lighting the fires and lighting the candles, complying with the covid measures, doing extra cleaning, dealing with staff sickness rates, stocking the kitchen with produce and bringing the staff in day after day after day and running at a loss. The constant changing of rules was a nightmare,

You could really see in his face how hard 2020 had been for him. He said they nearly gave up, lots of people in the trade did.

OP posts:
wildfirewonder · 21/11/2023 12:06

SunnyEgg · 21/11/2023 12:00

I didn’t say ‘everyone’.

But yes I stand by the general mood and reaction, I take it by your use of the ‘anti-lockdown posters’ phrase you were one of the majority of posters who were pro restrictions.

Irl was different here, we discussed impact of schools closing easily and without challenge

Also no not ‘my memory’ it’s all recorded on mn, that’s useful, people can see why people were so pro restrictions even though damage was there

Edited

I didn't say you said everyone, I said some posters say everyone.

I think I was firmly middle ground!

If a lockdown were not needed, surely everyone would be happy?

I have little time for the idea a lockdown could have been avoided without serious impacts on health services and other essential services.

Those who say we could have just carried on as normal never explain how that would have come to pass.

SunnyEgg · 21/11/2023 12:00

wildfirewonder · 21/11/2023 11:56

That's possibly your memory. The downsides of lockdown were discussed here a lot.

At work we all talked extensively about our children and older relatives, our neighbours.

I have noticed there are a few anti-lockdown posters who say 'everyone' on MN wanted lockdown. That's not accurate.

Many people will have felt lockdown was inevitable at certain points. That is not the same as 'wanting' it.

I didn’t say ‘everyone’.

But yes I stand by the general mood and reaction, I take it by your use of the ‘anti-lockdown posters’ phrase you were one of the majority of posters who were pro restrictions.

Irl was different here, we discussed impact of schools closing easily and without challenge

Also no not ‘my memory’ it’s all recorded on mn, that’s useful, people can see why people were so pro restrictions even though damage was there

verdantverdure · 21/11/2023 12:00

@wildfirewonder I agree that to me none of the "pandemic maths" etc seemed hard to understand.

And I agree that it's letting them off the hook to say they didn't understand it because it was their job to understand it.

Don't run a country during a global pandemic if you can't understand simple graphs, multiplication and basic scientific concepts.

I just want it out there.

I want us to know.

OP posts: