Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?

383 replies

verdantverdure · 13/06/2023 12:06

On the day the Covid Inquiry convenes I thought I'd ask your opinion on Eat Out To Help Out.

Covid case numbers and deaths were low, as we'd done a phased return out of the first lockdown.

Then we had Eat Out To Help Out and it all kicked off again within weeks.

What did you think? At the time? Now?

YABU Eat Out To Help Out was brilliant, I loved it.

YANBU Eat out To Help Out was a bloody stupid idea that was obviously going to help the virus spread, leading to another wave, more economic devastation, and tens of thousands of us dead. And it didn't even help the hospitality industry because it screwed up Christmas which is usually their most profitable quarter.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 18:21

So, @ChatBFP and @SunnyEgg

What's your explanation for why covid numbers were very low for months before EOTHO and at crisis point sufficient for Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance to go on tv with their graph of doom three weeks afterwards?

OP posts:
ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 17:59

@SunnyEgg agreed!

ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 17:58

@verdantverdure

I don't think that you understand exponential infection rates. We'd have been at weekly doubling regardless - that's how covid works because the r number is what it is. Yes, cases could have doubled from a lower base, but with kids in schools there would have been enough mingling to make infection levels significant amongst students, parents, those who students and parents might be permitted to see, and teachers.

Chris Whitty was never trying to eradicate covid, just keeping levels low so that the NHS wouldn't be overwhelmed - just listen to Patrick valance and CW at the inquiry.

I understand that you want to see things differently, but I don't think that the evidence really supports you.

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 17:22

My preference would have been to understand the damage from lockdowns on everyone more and keep schools fully open, plus try to avoid some other harms

I don’t really care about the four days earlier for 1st lockdown as neither here nor there. But imo we flatlined numbers in that summer for little reason and should have thought about dc and young more

RedPony1 · 22/11/2023 17:19

My friends and l used it 2-3 times a week. But then, we were all meeting up anyway all the way through so it was just nice to go out in public instead of secret meetings at the farm.

Nobody i know bought in to the hysteria so it didn't alarm me, it was cheap eating, it was great.

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 17:15

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 17:11

@SunnyEgg

Covid deaths were at close to zero for months in summer 2020.

Don't you remember?

Idiots were saying that covid was over.

Our country demonstrated for months that covid deaths could be prevented.

Nobody can tell you exactly how many could be prevented but in summer 2020, it was nearly all of them.

Nooo how did you get here.

It was always suggested we’d have rolling waves, CW says this. It will go on long term. Plus we had more infectious variants.

You’ve made a really incorrect assumption from following summer 2020 numbers. It wasn’t ‘over’ of course not. Not many people had been infected by then, how could it be?

I can only suggest you listen to Sir Chris Whitty and understand what he says.

Listen to the inquiry from yesterday and today.

GreekDogRescue · 22/11/2023 17:13

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 17:05

I think it's clear that we went from negligible covid numbers when EOTHO began to Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance calling for increased measures soon after it ended.

Increased contacts leads to increased cases. We knew that.

If we hadn't had EOTHO, if we'd followed the science, if we'd listened to the science advisors, if we'd had prioritised schools over getting people back to the office we might not have been back at weekly doubling ten days after the kids went back to school in England.

We might not even have needed another big lockdown.

Vaccines were coming, if we'd kept covid under better control for another few months maybe 85,000 of us wouldn't have died in the second wave.

We knew how to control it

The government didn't want to though, did they?

I can’t believe you are seriously saying that we needed even more severe Covid lockdowns.
Given that lockdowns have caused such enormous problems for the country with missed cancer diagnoses and a generation of children whose mental health has been so severely impacted, it seems rather a fanatical position to take.
Not everyone was fortunate enough to WFH.
I don’t know anyone who died from Covid but several who died due to issues created from lockdown.

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 17:11

@SunnyEgg

Covid deaths were at close to zero for months in summer 2020.

Don't you remember?

Idiots were saying that covid was over.

Our country demonstrated for months that covid deaths could be prevented.

Nobody can tell you exactly how many could be prevented but in summer 2020, it was nearly all of them.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 17:05

ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 16:41

I don't disagree with the general point @verdantverdure

What I was saying, probably not very well, was:

  1. If they had made the hospitality industry stay closed, teachers would have pushed very hard to stay remote - frankly, in May/june 2020, there were masses of threads on here with teachers saying they didn't want to return to the classroom without measures being taken that wouldn't have been possible to implement for another few months at least, if at all. We'd have had the "well they haven't opened pubs, so why should teachers be unsafe". It wasn't possible to mitigate all risks. (They shouldn't have closed schools in the first place is my personal view). The strong push towards encouraging people to view hospitality as safe also helped the government in their discussions with unions.
  1. If they had reopened hospitality but without EOTHO, would it really have made that much difference to where we ended up in December? I don't think it would have made masses of difference - summer 2020 was beautiful and people were very keen to get out and about, so much of the infection might have happened regardless.

I think it's clear that we went from negligible covid numbers when EOTHO began to Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance calling for increased measures soon after it ended.

Increased contacts leads to increased cases. We knew that.

If we hadn't had EOTHO, if we'd followed the science, if we'd listened to the science advisors, if we'd had prioritised schools over getting people back to the office we might not have been back at weekly doubling ten days after the kids went back to school in England.

We might not even have needed another big lockdown.

Vaccines were coming, if we'd kept covid under better control for another few months maybe 85,000 of us wouldn't have died in the second wave.

We knew how to control it

The government didn't want to though, did they?

OP posts:
SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 17:00

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 16:54

@SunnyEgg

Since we had established the principle that effective covid measures led to a decrease in covid deaths back in 2020 it's not in the least hyperbole to say that covid deaths can be prevented.

You’ve left out the key part. Is that an admission of hyperbole? Probably

Most of the 230k deaths

That hyperbole is why the headline you appreciate is clickbait.

It is not correct. Only a copy writer can get away with that level of falsity.

Not anyone making scientifically sound statements under scrutiny,

Everanewbie · 22/11/2023 16:57

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 16:54

@SunnyEgg

Since we had established the principle that effective covid measures led to a decrease in covid deaths back in 2020 it's not in the least hyperbole to say that covid deaths can be prevented.

By locking the country down forever you might have a chance, but that would be like beheading yourself because of a spot on your nose.

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 16:54

@SunnyEgg

Since we had established the principle that effective covid measures led to a decrease in covid deaths back in 2020 it's not in the least hyperbole to say that covid deaths can be prevented.

OP posts:
ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 16:41

I don't disagree with the general point @verdantverdure

What I was saying, probably not very well, was:

  1. If they had made the hospitality industry stay closed, teachers would have pushed very hard to stay remote - frankly, in May/june 2020, there were masses of threads on here with teachers saying they didn't want to return to the classroom without measures being taken that wouldn't have been possible to implement for another few months at least, if at all. We'd have had the "well they haven't opened pubs, so why should teachers be unsafe". It wasn't possible to mitigate all risks. (They shouldn't have closed schools in the first place is my personal view). The strong push towards encouraging people to view hospitality as safe also helped the government in their discussions with unions.
  1. If they had reopened hospitality but without EOTHO, would it really have made that much difference to where we ended up in December? I don't think it would have made masses of difference - summer 2020 was beautiful and people were very keen to get out and about, so much of the infection might have happened regardless.
SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 16:40

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 16:30

@SunnyEgg

My views are based on the empirical evidence of what happened.

When our government chose to have effective covid measures in place covid deaths decreased.

When our government chose not to have effective covid measures in place covid deaths increased.

You still need to be within the bounds of what is actually true

Hence Chris Whitty carefully responding in the enquiry. He very carefully does not just throw out lines such as the one you put up.

He did not say most of the 230k deaths were preventable

If he did it would be the cover of every paper for ages. So ask why the Editor of the Lancet has lower standards than the Daily Mail and any clickbait media. Primarily to sell to you and others easily sucked in to a bit of clickbait copy.

Try to apply some clear view thinking. You’ll be better off if you can prioritise informed views from a CMO over hyperbole.

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 16:32

JVT on EOTHO:

EOTHO - were you consulted or involved? Absolutely not. 'First I heard about it was when it was on TV.' 'It didn't feel sensible to me.'

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 16:30

@SunnyEgg

My views are based on the empirical evidence of what happened.

When our government chose to have effective covid measures in place covid deaths decreased.

When our government chose not to have effective covid measures in place covid deaths increased.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 16:08

I think they should have prioritised our children's education over other areas of life to be honest @ChatBFP.

But this is the same government who were told there was a threat to life from RAAC concrete in schools in 2018 unless they rebuilt 300-400 schools a year.

And they decided not to bother.

So it's pretty clear that the education and welfare of ordinary British children is pretty low down their list of priorities.

OP posts:
ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 15:34

Honestly, I think it's pretty clear that EOTHO might have accelerated things over the summer and I'm not sure whether or not it was the best use of money, but I don't think it is clear that it made things substantially worse overall, because it depends on what you compare it with. Would we still have reopened schools, have allowed bosses to encourage people to go into the office? What would or wouldn't have happened without EOTHO?

Personally, I think that the one positive about EOTHO was that it broke the argument in favour of not resuming school properly around the same time, tbh. This will be controversial with the teachers on here, but honestly the harm to kids' education had gone on long enough and no one could afford to spend another few months negotiating about when or whether protective measures were sufficiently bulletproof. The government should have done more and earlier for education, should be doing more now, but schools had to go back when they went back and EOTHO made it ridiculous not to.

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 14:06

wildfirewonder · 22/11/2023 14:03

Just to point out there can be no 'substantiated' figures for any hypothetical or modelled scenario, by definition.

There are plenty of sound views at the Covid inquiry, eg from Sir Chris Whitty who has not said anything along those lines.

That line written by an editor is not one of them.

It’s ill-informed hyperbole for sales. Which unfortunately some believe.

wildfirewonder · 22/11/2023 14:03

Just to point out there can be no 'substantiated' figures for any hypothetical or modelled scenario, by definition.

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 13:29

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 13:21

The evidence is in any news article about covid numbers in 2020.

That's when it was proven that we could prevent covid deaths.

Your views are not based on substantiated figures.

You’ve also incorrectly referenced Whitty etc who have not given the view most of the 230k deaths were preventable.

You are doubling down, sadly as you were pulled in by a sales technique, yes by a line written by the Editor in Chief of magazine, but you don’t have to continue.

It’s on par with any clickbait from the DM or other

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 13:25

wildfirewonder · 22/11/2023 13:18

It was The Lancet who argued most of the deaths were preventable, I thought.

Indeed.

Although to be fair, anyone with a working memory of 2020 knows that they are preventable because we did prevent them.

Predictably when we stopped preventing them another 85,000 of us died.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 13:21

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 13:16

You can keep posting opinions but you still cannot substantiate that line.

If you post most of the 230k deaths were preventable you’ll need to back it up with evidence from a reputable source

Otherwise you are spreading pure clickbait

The evidence is in any news article about covid numbers in 2020.

That's when it was proven that we could prevent covid deaths.

OP posts:
wildfirewonder · 22/11/2023 13:18

It was The Lancet who argued most of the deaths were preventable, I thought.

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 13:16

You can keep posting opinions but you still cannot substantiate that line.

If you post most of the 230k deaths were preventable you’ll need to back it up with evidence from a reputable source

Otherwise you are spreading pure clickbait