Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?

383 replies

verdantverdure · 13/06/2023 12:06

On the day the Covid Inquiry convenes I thought I'd ask your opinion on Eat Out To Help Out.

Covid case numbers and deaths were low, as we'd done a phased return out of the first lockdown.

Then we had Eat Out To Help Out and it all kicked off again within weeks.

What did you think? At the time? Now?

YABU Eat Out To Help Out was brilliant, I loved it.

YANBU Eat out To Help Out was a bloody stupid idea that was obviously going to help the virus spread, leading to another wave, more economic devastation, and tens of thousands of us dead. And it didn't even help the hospitality industry because it screwed up Christmas which is usually their most profitable quarter.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 19:48

ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 19:46

Yes, cases and deaths were low for a bit, but you have a lag between people getting it, people passing it to others, people dying from it.

Plus exponential effect is that

Week 1 - 1 case
Week 2 - 2
Week 3 - 4
Week 4 - 8
Week 5 - 16
Week 6 - 32

You don't get masses of cases imminently.

Plus I suspect people were cautious in mid May, didn't have plans, made plans - that takes a while too!

What's your explanation for why covid numbers were very low for months before EOTHO but at a crisis point sufficient for Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance to go on tv with their graph of doom three weeks after EOTHO?

• Why were covid numbers low for months from mid May to mid-September 2020.

  1. Why did they rise?
OP posts:
ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 19:46

Yes, cases and deaths were low for a bit, but you have a lag between people getting it, people passing it to others, people dying from it.

Plus exponential effect is that

Week 1 - 1 case
Week 2 - 2
Week 3 - 4
Week 4 - 8
Week 5 - 16
Week 6 - 32

You don't get masses of cases imminently.

Plus I suspect people were cautious in mid May, didn't have plans, made plans - that takes a while too!

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 19:46

So again, @SunnyEgg & @ChatBFP

What's your explanation for why covid numbers were very low for months before EOTHO but at a crisis point sufficient for Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance to go on tv with their graph of doom three weeks after EOTHO?

  1. Why were covid numbers low for months from mid May to mid-September 2020.
  1. Why did they rise?
Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?
Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?
OP posts:
SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 19:45

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 19:42

We weren't in lockdown from mid- May to Mid -September 2020 but covid hospitalisations and deaths were low.

So you missed Chris Whitty talking about waves and the length of the pandemic

Do you think he was wrong?

I mean he’s not, not even mners can make those claims

Can you accept he is right though?

Please find the part of your brain that can update with expert information (look up CW if doubting he said above)

ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 19:42

Ps - I'm not anti lockdown - I supported the idea of encouraging people to limit interactions in early 2020 to "squash the sombrero" - flatten the peak - in order to prevent health system overwhelm.

I never supported taking kids out of education settings, locking university students in halls, or policing who could use a sodding park bench. Nor did I support scaring people into thinking that the objective was to avoid getting the virus forever - people are getting it now. People will die of it this winter - far fewer, due to herd immunity through vaccines and transmission, but still people will die of it.

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 19:42

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 19:36

@verdantverdure I’ll add to @ChatBFP post were you expecting full lockdown from summer 2020 to when the vaccine rollout had passed through all vulnerable groups?

We weren't in lockdown from mid- May to Mid -September 2020 but covid hospitalisations and deaths were low.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 19:41

Children went back to school on June 1st @TooOldForThisNonsense. People were at work, hospitality was open.

We live in the U.K. plenty of our mixing happens indoors year round.

OP posts:
ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 19:37

And @verdantverdure

There were 15,000 excess deaths in the 2022/2023 flu season. Do you think we should be locking everyone down for this too? Where does one draw a line and accept a balancing act between health, the economy and personal liberty?

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 19:36

@verdantverdure I’ll add to @ChatBFP post were you expecting full lockdown from summer 2020 to when the vaccine rollout had passed through all vulnerable groups?

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 19:34

I’ve already said

I would recommend learning and understanding more. Start with CW at the inquiry, also statistics generally (More or Less is good on R4)

You’re missing a fair of the basics though

If you’re assuming it was over after summer 2020 that’s the first basic error to be corrected

ChatBFP · 22/11/2023 19:33

@verdantverdure

What @SunnyEgg said about rolling waves.

I'm sure that EOTHO encouraged some people to use hospitality settings more. BUT around the time of the launch of EOTHO, lockdown was removed, people could mingle in private settings again - even if no hospitality settings were open at all, people would have tried to catch up with friends and family as they were permitted to do.

Would you have kept all hospitality settings closed even without EOTHO?

Would you have banned private gatherings altogether?

Those happened around the same time at EOTHO - I'm not sure whether or not it was a good use of funds but don't think that you can say it is the only cause. Frankly, if people had decided to meet up in private homes because they couldn't meet at the pub, you'd have had another wave and the Treasury would have been utterly stuffed trying to support businesses who had to stay closed despite people being able to mingle elsewhere.

So what you are asking for, in order to mean absolutely no Covid wave after first lockdown, is that no one was allowed to gather socially indoors, in hospitality settings or otherwise. How long do you really feel people would have kept this up? And how long could we have afforded it?

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 19:30

So again, @SunnyEgg

What's your explanation for why covid numbers were very low for months before EOTHO but at a crisis point sufficient for Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance to go on tv with their graph of doom three weeks after EOTHO?

  1. Why were covid numbers low for months from mid May to mid-September 2020.
  1. Why did they rise?
Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?
Eat Out To Help Out: Brilliance or Lunacy?
OP posts:
TooOldForThisNonsense · 22/11/2023 19:24

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 18:21

So, @ChatBFP and @SunnyEgg

What's your explanation for why covid numbers were very low for months before EOTHO and at crisis point sufficient for Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance to go on tv with their graph of doom three weeks afterwards?

Lack of mixing and when it did finally occur people met outside as it was summer

What else was ever going to feasibly happen, EOTHO or not? Keep everything shut forever and not let people meet up?

TooOldForThisNonsense · 22/11/2023 19:21

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 19:15

So are you saying that a rolling wave is some kind of act of god that we mere mortals can do nothing about @SunnyEgg?

We just have to submit to it and sacrifice 85,000 British people?

Well yes. It’s a pandemic. People die. It’s shit and we all wish it hadn’t happened. But the economy tanking and lack of social interaction causes ill health and death as well. August was also when schools went back (in Scotland) and September (rUK). That had a significant impact on numbers too. But kids needed to go to school again.

I think some people honestly think that there was a course of action the Government could have taken which meant no one died. There wasn’t. Yes they f’d up yes more people died than needed to but it’s over 3 years ago now. Other than learning lessons of how to manage things in future there’s no point raking over all this time and again.

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 19:19

I’m not saying it Chris Whitty did at the start and today pointed out many didn’t get it. There would always be waves and we’d need the vaccine to change that

Not sure why you are focusing on that number in particular but deaths were not avoidable, of course not. CW says this too

I take it you haven’t watched his evidence, that’s fine it’s long and time consuming, but if you really want to understand he’s great at explaining

It’s probably much better than unpicking each erroneous conclusion one by one!

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 19:15

So are you saying that a rolling wave is some kind of act of god that we mere mortals can do nothing about @SunnyEgg?

We just have to submit to it and sacrifice 85,000 British people?

OP posts:
SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 19:02

I’ve already said it.

We knew we’d get rolling waves - you do concede that yes?

The next wave was a few days earlier

To me that’s no big deal and other greater harms matter so much more

And yes waves were inevitable - did you listen to Chris Whitty at the inquiry?

One key point was so few got that it would be a long pandemic, ie the two years. That was a known fact right at the beginning.

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 18:58

So, @SunnyEgg

What's your explanation for why covid numbers were very low for months before EOTHO but at a crisis point sufficient for Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance to go on tv with their graph of doom three weeks after EOTHO?

On 24 August 2020 Matt Hancock said they had already had feedback that EOTHO was "causing problems in our intervention areas" but that he had "protected Treasury" and "kept it out of the news"

On September 14th the Rule of Six was brought in.

On September 22nd numbers were already so bad that they introduced a 10pm curfew in hospitality and people were told to go back to WFH if they could.

On 30th September Boris Johnson said we were at a critical moment in the pandemic.

The Tiers were introduced on the 14th October.

The second lockdown began on November 5th.

And that was all just inevitable was it?

OP posts:
JenniferBooth · 22/11/2023 18:54

@verdantverdure It was no surprise to me. I live above an abusive alchoholic who is likely classed as "vulnerable"

It was no surprise to me that the drinkers got a free pass.............AGAIN

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 18:49

Take it up with the people that made the rules @JenniferBooth.

OP posts:
JenniferBooth · 22/11/2023 18:48

Completely agree with you @SunnyEgg

SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 18:46

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 18:41

We weren't in lockdown when EOTHO happened @SunnyEgg

It takes time for a wave to pick up but it was inevitable

You would always have another wave. Maybe brought forward by three or so days - look for statistician Sir David Spiegelhalter on this

You’d still get a wave.

All this freaking out over four days here or there is bizarre to me

We had much bigger issues such as damage to children despite negligible risk

JenniferBooth · 22/11/2023 18:46

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 18:41

We weren't in lockdown when EOTHO happened @SunnyEgg

No but i had to wear a fucking mask to go round Tesco and put it on while walking round THREE pubs where people were hugging and kissing each other

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 18:41

We weren't in lockdown when EOTHO happened @SunnyEgg

OP posts:
SunnyEgg · 22/11/2023 18:30

verdantverdure · 22/11/2023 18:21

So, @ChatBFP and @SunnyEgg

What's your explanation for why covid numbers were very low for months before EOTHO and at crisis point sufficient for Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance to go on tv with their graph of doom three weeks afterwards?

After the first lockdown ended cases would always pick up.

The only way you could keep at summer 2020 levels was by keeping lockdown in place

That’s not a viable option long term