Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 5/6 year old little girls don’t need to wear shorts under dresses to “protect their modesty”

605 replies

Darthwazette · 13/06/2023 11:08

Just what the subject like says really. I’d be interested to know other parents thoughts. I’m not a weirdo, this request has been made of my daughters from school and it makes me feel a bit icky.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
voxnihili · 14/06/2023 00:43

@mumlikeaboss - I have those ones from Next that a previous poster linked to for my 4 year old. She is also tall and skinny - currently wears 3-4 in those shorts.

mumlikeaboss · 13/06/2023 22:36

NerrSnerr · 13/06/2023 14:58

It's also worth noting that the 'just buy bigger pants and it'll cover more' doesn't work for all children. Any bigger for my daughter and they'd just fall down/ gape even more! Ones that fit around the waist and thighs are smaller then I'd like as she had to wear a size or two smaller because she's slim.

EXACTLY the same problem, really struggle to get decent-fitting pants for my daughter 😭

I'm not going to get queasy at the thought of teachers seeing a flash of knickers if she's upside down on the climbing frame, but I know from experience that if she's assing around with her legs wide apart it's not just knickers you'd see!!!

I might try those Amazon shorts that PP referenced, but I worry that even those will gape as she has slim thighs...

Kanaloa · 13/06/2023 22:20

ContinuousProcrastination · 13/06/2023 22:04

The pants are already there providing the apparently needed "modesty" (urgh).

Why do shorts then need to cover the pants? Tons of little boys emerge from school with their pants showing above shorts or trousers, why is it only little girls who need to be modest?

Only baggy/badly fitting pants with knackered reveal anything. A family that can afford to buy shorts can afford to replace pants with some suitable ones that fit. Pants themselves are nothing to hide and ffs, a cartwheeling child reveals them for seconds.

This is all about imposing old fashioned standards of modesty on girls.

I don’t see ‘tons of little boys’ coming out of school with their underwear showing. If I did and it was my child I’d say ‘pull your pants up, they’re not on properly.’

So it isn’t ‘only little girls.’ Boys wear shorts or trousers that cover their underwear. I don’t know any parents that would happily send their son out to school in clothes that leave their underwear exposed.

ContinuousProcrastination · 13/06/2023 22:04

The pants are already there providing the apparently needed "modesty" (urgh).

Why do shorts then need to cover the pants? Tons of little boys emerge from school with their pants showing above shorts or trousers, why is it only little girls who need to be modest?

Only baggy/badly fitting pants with knackered reveal anything. A family that can afford to buy shorts can afford to replace pants with some suitable ones that fit. Pants themselves are nothing to hide and ffs, a cartwheeling child reveals them for seconds.

This is all about imposing old fashioned standards of modesty on girls.

ContinuousProcrastination · 13/06/2023 21:46

We had this from school too.

Pants that actually fit without shot elastic shouldnt be flapping around revealing anything etc. Our school is gated and its not possible to see into the playground/field unless you are stood by the office window. It feels a bit weird making a 6y o girl hide pants from other children/dbs checked staff, when half of them don't bother closing the door when they go to the loo etc.

Children who are bothered will tend to choose to wear shorts when they get a bit older.

I can't even see how they can police it either, without watching kids constantly. Can you imagine a 6 yo getting in trouble for doing handstands that reveal their pants? In 2023?!

mumlikeaboss · 13/06/2023 21:40

CatMattress · 13/06/2023 11:46

I bought DD huggggge 'boxer' style knickers from Next because she hated pants going up her bum. She loves them, they're super comfy and they look like short-legged cycling shorts. She's even started wearing a pair with a vest as summer PJs. I think I need to buy another pack!
Buy Shorts 5 Pack (2-16yrs) from the Next UK online shop

I'm tempted to buy some for myself!

I love the look of these, although they are pricey, gulp!!

What are they like for size? I really struggle to get the right size pants for DD (4) because she's super skinny and if I buy her correct age they usually fall down and annoy her... But smaller sizes are often too shallow from crotch to waistband iyswim! Or too narrow in width so they don't cover her bum cheeks 🙈😂

ZiriForEver · 13/06/2023 21:21

Rapunzzel · 13/06/2023 20:27

Saying this peice of cotton is underwear and must never be seen, and this peice of cotton is designated shorts and so is fine to be seen is nuts in my opinion

I don't think that's what people are saying at all. What people are saying is that if a girl's knickers are not up to the job of covering up bum cheeks and labia when the child is cross legged or upside down, then a pair of light cotton shorts will do the job. Nobody is saying knickers should never be seen. (Although I'd prefer not to flash mine) You can even buy actual nice soft cotton knickers that go some way down the upper leg, and they are just knickers and are fine, and nobody will be shocked by seeing those knickers. No shorts required if you have non-flashing knickers. It's when knickers are not doing their job of keeping private parts private that light exercise shorts come into their own. There are knickers now widely available to wear with dresses, for girls and women who suffer chub rub or don't want to flash their arse cheeks when they bend over. I know many people, girls and women, who have welcomed the advent of these comfortable undergarments, to wear under dresses.
This seems to me a whole massive fuss about defending female rights to 'wear what they like' I completely agree that adult women should wear whatever they want, wherever they want. They are grown ups with autonomy.

But having been a TA in primary school for more years than I care to remember,
I'm sure there would be a few mothers of the girls in the front row who would reconsider their child's undergarments if they'd had the sometimes sad and sometimes startling views of ill fitting and frankly inadequate knickers.

It's never the boys. I've never seen one willy in all the years I've been there.
I've seen more female genitalia than I care to remember. It's really not rocket science. Let the girls have underwear that covers their genitalia.
It's not anti-feminist to want to keep your private parts private.

And I have 3 daughters, no sons, and 5 nieces. So I'm fairly conversant with little girls and how their underwear can often let them down whilst they are completely unaware.

Many people on this thread really do say so.
Some even tried to explain etymology of the word underwear as "under clothes and therefore never visible"...

This thread is so long because half says "two layers are unnecessary, well fitting knickers, maybe boxer style, should do the job" and second half says "it is underwear, it is private and it should never be seen".

MrsMikeDrop · 13/06/2023 21:17

When people are given weird messages at a young age about sex and sexuality, they are likely to have messed up views when they are older. This is playing out now in society (notice how cultures who are more relaxed in this area aren't as peverted in general)

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/06/2023 21:11

Cantonet · 13/06/2023 21:03

I find this really strange.
Children are being sexualised earlier & earlier. This wasn't the case a few years ago with my 2 girls who are now 18 . It seems to be ok for teens to wear revealing minis & leggings. But not appropriate for tiny innocent children to show their knickers.

Why do you want them to show their knickers? What is the advantage? It's not about sex it's about dignity.

bendmeoverbackwards · 13/06/2023 21:05

CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 19:38

@SparklingMarkling I hate to tell you this- but "the local paedo" doesn't mind what little girls are wearing.

Exactly. @SparklingMarkling putting a pair of tight fitting shorts on your dd won’t protect her from paedolohiles sadly.

Cantonet · 13/06/2023 21:03

I find this really strange.
Children are being sexualised earlier & earlier. This wasn't the case a few years ago with my 2 girls who are now 18 . It seems to be ok for teens to wear revealing minis & leggings. But not appropriate for tiny innocent children to show their knickers.

poormanspombears · 13/06/2023 21:02

@7eleven I work in a school as an ADSL and while on the surface I agree with you, some teachers get overzealous with reporting and I have seen some very ridiculous concerns.

I have also had to send girls home this week to change because they are only wearing 'modesty' shorts! I felt uncomfortable as a female member of staff, nothing left to the imagination at all.

stunning71 · 13/06/2023 21:01

@Tandora who’s telling them ? As I said maybe they want to wear them . Or are girls not allowed to choose what they wear anymore?

immigrant002 · 13/06/2023 20:59

dreamingperfect · 13/06/2023 11:11

If I'm honest with you I have always put shorts on underneath my daughters dresses or skirts. When she was a baby she would wear them knickers to go over a nappy. In nursery she would wear coloured cycle shorts under a dress and now in school at age 5 she wears black cycle shorts under her dress.
As someone who used to work in an education setting, trust me when your little girls are upside down or kicking there legs up, knickers move and you see what you don't want to see. It's just a polite gesture to wear shorts underneath and protect their modesty. Even myself a n adult, if wearing a skirt or dress I wear cycling shorts underneath

Same dont see any issue with it !!

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/06/2023 20:56

Tandora · 13/06/2023 20:34

If it’s about girls feeling comfortable then no need for them to be told is there? And no need whatsoever for the school to get involved.
Girls can chose to wear shorts as a when they like, and sit however they bloody well choose. Simples.

These girls are wearing school uniform. They are not wearing comfortable clothes that they have chosen. Why do you care so much that they are allowed to flash their undies when everything else they wear is under school's control? It would make more sense to me, from the point of view of comfort and choice, to say they can wear anything as long as their underwear is covered.

7eleven · 13/06/2023 20:55

poormanspombears · 13/06/2023 20:53

I put shorts on my 3 year old but probably because I'm projecting my own worries on to her. I know it's irrational, but it makes me feel a little better.

She also has a habit of picking her undies out of her bum in the most 'unladylike' ways and I wouldn't want her, or a member of staff in her school, to be put in a position that could cause any concern or end up on a safeguarding file.

Honestly, undoing a wedgie wouldn’t end up on a list in school, I promise you.

SadAsHell · 13/06/2023 20:53

@Rapunzzel yessssss you have hit the nail on the head with everything you have said!!!!!

@Tandora no sorry I disagree with you. As I said earlier in the post, I'm a secondary school teacher, and I do not want to stand on front of girls with their skirts yanked above their knees, legs wide open, lots on show!!! And as others have mentioned, we are not just talking about material of a knickers being on show here!

poormanspombears · 13/06/2023 20:53

I put shorts on my 3 year old but probably because I'm projecting my own worries on to her. I know it's irrational, but it makes me feel a little better.

She also has a habit of picking her undies out of her bum in the most 'unladylike' ways and I wouldn't want her, or a member of staff in her school, to be put in a position that could cause any concern or end up on a safeguarding file.

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/06/2023 20:52

I put shorts under dresses on my daughter from when she came out of nappies. Once she is old enough to sit with her legs together (i.e. not have to sit cross legged on the floor at school!) and not hang upsidedown etc then she can wear what she wants. Until then, I want her clothes to allow her the freedom to do what she wants without issues, in the same way boys can.
It's not protecting a child's innocence to let them display their underwear while playing or sitting down for carpet time. What a weird viewpoint.

BravoMyDear · 13/06/2023 20:50

Tandora · 13/06/2023 19:50

Today as a teacher a 12 year old girl sat opposite me and I had to tell her how to sit

please don’t do this. The girl can sit how she fucking well wants/ is comfortable. I still remember being told to “sit like a lady” by my teacher in primary school. It made me feel ill with shame.

I’m a teacher and I will absolutely ask a female pupil to sit differently if she is flashing her genitals. That’s just common sense.

7eleven · 13/06/2023 20:49

RoyalGala · 13/06/2023 20:41

So tell me, if your daughter came home and said the boys were sitting with their legs open and you could see their scrotums or penises through their gapey shorts, you’d tell your daughter ‘they can sit however they like’, off course you’re not.

So we can all sit with our legs open and underwear on show or more now because it’s our body? That would be classed as public indecency 🤦🏻‍♀️

Have you seen the episode of Friends, where Phoebe’s boyfriend keeps putting one leg up, whilst not wearing underpants?

Gunther walks past and says “Dude. Put the mouse back in the house!” 😂

BravoMyDear · 13/06/2023 20:46

MrsMikeDrop · 13/06/2023 11:23

Sorry, as an adult you do this? Why? Are you doing cartwheels??

I do it to prevent chub rub 😂

RoyalGala · 13/06/2023 20:41

Tandora · 13/06/2023 20:32

No one has to conform to your standards of “decency” with regard to their own body and boundaries, let alone a 12 year old CHILD. She can sit however the fuck she likes and so can any adult woman for that matter. If you have a problem with that, that’s for you to sort out.

So tell me, if your daughter came home and said the boys were sitting with their legs open and you could see their scrotums or penises through their gapey shorts, you’d tell your daughter ‘they can sit however they like’, off course you’re not.

So we can all sit with our legs open and underwear on show or more now because it’s our body? That would be classed as public indecency 🤦🏻‍♀️

7eleven · 13/06/2023 20:40

Tandora · 13/06/2023 20:32

No one has to conform to your standards of “decency” with regard to their own body and boundaries, let alone a 12 year old CHILD. She can sit however the fuck she likes and so can any adult woman for that matter. If you have a problem with that, that’s for you to sort out.

I think maybe you’re being silly. How often do you exercise your right to display your genitals or underwear? On the bus? At work? I predict that you don’t.

I would say it was a safeguarding issue if a member of staff didn’t, discreetly, indicate to a 12 year old to change the way they were sitting, for their dignity (not saying modesty).

The girl undoubtedly was unaware of what she was showing and I’m sure her parents would much rather their child’s labia were kept private than her right to ‘burn her bra’ upheld.

Tandora · 13/06/2023 20:34

stunning71 · 13/06/2023 20:19

@Tandora maybe it’s just about the girls feeling comfortable and not about others being embarrassed? Maybe the child wants to wear them ! Maybe young children don’t think in terms of modesty, maybe it’s just what they want !

If it’s about girls feeling comfortable then no need for them to be told is there? And no need whatsoever for the school to get involved.
Girls can chose to wear shorts as a when they like, and sit however they bloody well choose. Simples.