Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 5/6 year old little girls don’t need to wear shorts under dresses to “protect their modesty”

605 replies

Darthwazette · 13/06/2023 11:08

Just what the subject like says really. I’d be interested to know other parents thoughts. I’m not a weirdo, this request has been made of my daughters from school and it makes me feel a bit icky.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Allthingsbrightandbeautifulx · 13/06/2023 14:02

Going to school, park, play centre, basically any wear where she would be showing her underwear during an activity then yes, my DD has shorts underneath her dress/skirt. If we’re out for a meal or regular day out then no. But her underwear underneath would be boy short type anyway.
Never been a request from school though, but a few years back when I was at the park with my friend and my Goddaughter who was only 3 at the time. An older man came over and told my friend that she should put trousers or shorts on her DD as his Grandson (about 4) could see her knickers and it was making him uncomfortable. To this day we’re still not sure if he meant it made him uncomfortable or his grandson but either way he gave us the creeps 😳

FrostyFifi · 13/06/2023 14:01

I think this mostly proves that dresses and skirts are a silly idea for active little children.

Rapunzzel · 13/06/2023 14:00

Also - who on earth is the poster who says they wear cycling shorts under a dress as an adult? Has the world gone properly mad?

I thought a lot of people did. Certainly my adult daughter and some of her peers do. For some it avoids the soreness you get in hot weather from sweaty thighs when walking. Or in the odd gust of wind I've noticed people wearing little shorts under dresses. I don't think it's that unusual.

stunning71 · 13/06/2023 13:59

I just think it’s a question of good taste ! My daughter doesn’t wear shorts under her school dress because I don’t want boys to see her pants , she wears them because I don’t think anyone should be showing their pants.

Chasingadvice · 13/06/2023 13:59

@DataNotLore
Oh I see your agenda. You're one of them.

Oh dear. Never mind. Well all the best to you and your children.

Chickychoccyegg · 13/06/2023 13:59

As others have said, it's because a lot of the girls are constantly doing handstands and cartwheels,underwear moves/can be loose fitting, so it's to prevent them inadvertently showing their genitals.
My teenage dd wears very short skirts to high school, and always wears short shorts underneath, lile the style of cycling shorts, but much shorter, think they might actually be called modesty shorts.

Bunnycat101 · 13/06/2023 13:59

The gingham jump suits are a good alternative. My daughter prefers them now to the dresses. If she asks for shorts I’ll get some and not stress but equally I won’t make her wear them just yet but girls do spend a lot of time doing handstands and cartwheeling so I can see how schools can sometimes ask for shorts when there are loads of girls hanging upside down with their knickers on show.

Sirzy · 13/06/2023 13:57

LaMaG · 13/06/2023 13:53

I think it's very different to be honest because a woman's private parts are a sexualised thing, a little girls are not.

In my view I think in line with the sensible teaching of consent having a clear line of “nobody else should see your underwear” sets a clear boundary for them from a young age.

part of the problem is girls school uniform is on the whole completly impractical when it comes to playing and being a child!

HeartOrHeadDecision · 13/06/2023 13:57

I have been buying shorty type knickers only. And preferably in dark colours. Works fine for us.

stunning71 · 13/06/2023 13:56

That in itself is not a reason for woman not to show their underwear! Underwear is called underwear for a reason. It’s worn under clothes as not to be seen and that should apply to everyone!
men , boys , girls and women alike !

VasariMichelangelo · 13/06/2023 13:55

stunning71 · 13/06/2023 13:50

I don’t think it’s bigotry to teach your child to not show their underwear. As an adult you wouldn’t show your underwear to others , so why force that on a small child?

I agree but you'll be accused of sexualising and shaming girls, despite (I'm assuming) referring to both sexes.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 13/06/2023 13:54

SouperWoman · 13/06/2023 12:08

Perhaps the school should require the boys and male teachers to wear modesty blinkers to stop them looking at girls’ knickers?

Is like to see this too

stunning71 · 13/06/2023 13:54

Maybe it’s just about girls not showing their pants . Boys don’t show their pants do they ? And as for adults not wearing shorts underneath dresses and skirts surely if it’s their choice then it makes no difference to you or your life .

ZiriForEver · 13/06/2023 13:53

VasariMichelangelo · 13/06/2023 13:39

The boys and girls get changed separately. I remember some boys who used to use a ruler to lift your skirt up, not many but even one is too many. I know it would be nice to think all children are innocent but some are not so much. My DD has no issues getting changed in front of other girls which is something she has just naturally been fine with (quick costume changes for dance have likely helped with that!). But boys and girls have different parts which they understand from a young age, they are curious about each others bodies and will look which would make anyone feel uncomfortable.

I'm unsure on the school enforcing it, but it may be something has happened to get to the point they are at.

If a boy uses a ruler, the issue is the boy and school should deal with that, not change girl's clothes.
Having second shorts doesn't change how bad upskirting is (it isn't about knickers as such, it is about violation).

About different parts - what is the difference between one and two layers? Especially the very tight cycling shorts.

LaMaG · 13/06/2023 13:53

stunning71 · 13/06/2023 13:50

I don’t think it’s bigotry to teach your child to not show their underwear. As an adult you wouldn’t show your underwear to others , so why force that on a small child?

I think it's very different to be honest because a woman's private parts are a sexualised thing, a little girls are not.

VasariMichelangelo · 13/06/2023 13:51

BreatheAndFocus · 13/06/2023 13:42

Weird! I’m a grown woman (obviously!) and I’ve never worn shorts under my skirts or dresses, not as a child and not as an adult. Why don’t we just stay indoors in case someone catches a glimpse of our immodesty? 🙄 FRO!

Once when I was at primary school, a boy was standing watching us do handstands because he could see our knickers (his words). He was only about 8 and he was sniggering a bit and generally being annoying. The teacher came along and told him off and got him to move away and play with the other boys. At no point did she try to shame us or send a note home that we wear bloody shorts under our dresses! She dealt with the nuisance (sniggering boy).

I have two DDs and they’ve never worn shorts under their dresses nor have they asked to, and nor has the school requested that they should.

It's not about shaming the girls AT ALL and I have no idea why people are thinking along these lines. I wouldn't like my DD to have to deal with sniggering anyone and as stated repeatedly, it would be exactly the same for boys - but they normally don't wear dresses so their underpants are always covered. If they were on show I would bet others would be sniggering at them too and why would anyone want that for their child?

DS boxers are practically the same as shorts, doesn't mean I was ok with him running about in them without shorts over the top!

stunning71 · 13/06/2023 13:50

I don’t think it’s bigotry to teach your child to not show their underwear. As an adult you wouldn’t show your underwear to others , so why force that on a small child?

YoucancallmeKAREN · 13/06/2023 13:49

dreamingperfect · 13/06/2023 11:11

If I'm honest with you I have always put shorts on underneath my daughters dresses or skirts. When she was a baby she would wear them knickers to go over a nappy. In nursery she would wear coloured cycle shorts under a dress and now in school at age 5 she wears black cycle shorts under her dress.
As someone who used to work in an education setting, trust me when your little girls are upside down or kicking there legs up, knickers move and you see what you don't want to see. It's just a polite gesture to wear shorts underneath and protect their modesty. Even myself a n adult, if wearing a skirt or dress I wear cycling shorts underneath

Since when was it impolite for a little girl to not wear short under a dress. Do you thing these little ones are rude and ill mannered ?

Thoughtful2355 · 13/06/2023 13:45

Sometimes my daughter's underwear can go to the side and you get a view of her private parts. I would rather it was properly covered.

wouldthatbeworse · 13/06/2023 13:44

I don’t think this is about paedophiles at the school gate.

we all know we’re not meant to show our pants in public. Wearing shorts means no pants on show.

I’m not ‘protecting’ my DD putting her in shorts I’m just teaching her not to show her pants in public.

LaMaG · 13/06/2023 13:43

InTodaysNews · 13/06/2023 13:27

I never put shorts under my daughter's skirts or dresses, nor do I wear them under mine ( though to be fair I don't tend to do cartwheels unless I've had a vodka too many, then I turn into a gymnast)
If the school had asked me to do this, I would have been down there tearing strips off the head.
Why should my daughter be told to cover up or worse, called immodest!
How do you think we went on years ago? We did cartwheels and handstands, climbed on monkey bars and up tree's in a dress, hell, we even used to tuck those dresses into our knickers to make it easier, and no one gave a shit.
Contrary to popular opinion, there are no more paedophiles and perverts around now than there were back then, it's just that now children are encouraged to report anything untoward happening to them, and are more likely to be believed, which is a great thing and so the perpetrators are quite rightly punished.
I know of four girls and two boys in separate families who were being sexually abused by their own father's when we were kids. No one knew anything about it until we were young adults and they were finally brave enough to report it to the police. Yet, three of them were my friends whose homes I was in and out of.
So no, I refused to cover my daughter up. Maybe the schools should concentrate on teaching the boys to bloody show respect for girls instead.

Agree 100%
Honestly til i read this thread it never occurred to me that seeing a flash of a kids underwear while doing a cartwheel was an issue. So what? We are talking about 5 year olds. Two or 3 years earlier they were only coming out of nappies. It seems like people are desperately trying to sexualise them. And so what if a similar aged boy sees something, is the human body wrong or disgusting? It's not sexual to a 5 yr old boy so why make it so? I work with 4 and 5 year olds and we tell those in skirts to pull theirs down, but it's also not uncommon for a boy to wander out of the toilet with his underwear around his ankles, and they are also immediately asked to cover up. Its just not a big deal at all it's part of being 5 and innocent.

BezMills · 13/06/2023 13:43

My DD has worn Leggings + Pinafore over winter (almost 6, finishing up Receptionyear) and Leggings + Polo shirt for PE. Her summer uniform is just a gingham dress, too hot for tights or leggings and she hasn't asked to wear shorts.

VasariMichelangelo · 13/06/2023 13:42

@ZiriForEver so I suppose not if EVERYONE saw her pants, but there is a time and a place where it is expected - ie changing rooms. Any other time even other girls would say 'I can see your pants'. Same as adults, you expect it in a certain setting.

BreatheAndFocus · 13/06/2023 13:42

Weird! I’m a grown woman (obviously!) and I’ve never worn shorts under my skirts or dresses, not as a child and not as an adult. Why don’t we just stay indoors in case someone catches a glimpse of our immodesty? 🙄 FRO!

Once when I was at primary school, a boy was standing watching us do handstands because he could see our knickers (his words). He was only about 8 and he was sniggering a bit and generally being annoying. The teacher came along and told him off and got him to move away and play with the other boys. At no point did she try to shame us or send a note home that we wear bloody shorts under our dresses! She dealt with the nuisance (sniggering boy).

I have two DDs and they’ve never worn shorts under their dresses nor have they asked to, and nor has the school requested that they should.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 13/06/2023 13:41

Wouldn't it be better if schools just had practical uniforms that allowed children to play?

If girls are wearing shorts why do they need a dress over the top?