Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fellow mum never reciprocates with play dates

181 replies

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 20:10

My dd is friends with a local mother’s kids. She is a nice woman. We have a lot in common & get on. I have invited her & her kids over many times but we never get a reciprocal invite. I have known her nearly 5 years now. I know she has some issue with people coming round. She has said her house is messy. Mine is too & we do not have an impressive lifestyle at all. The lack of reciprocation has got me down so I now tend to just suggest we only meet up outside my home. She is always keen to meet. She likes me. I am too scared to ask her why she doesn’t like people to come round in case it is due to some trauma. She is a very private person. AIBU in finding her lack of reciprocation unfair?

OP posts:
OrderOfTheKookaburra · 13/06/2023 00:40

Sadly though her attitude will have an effect on her DC because people DO expect some reciprocity! As you say, it's tiring and also can financially affect you being the one hosting all the time.

You could try asking in advance if she could have your DD over for the day as you and your DH are going somewhere. See what happens? If it's because the house is a mess that will give her time to sort it. If she says a straight out no then sadly I would have to rethink it, myself.

And I say that as someone who struggles with getting my crap sorted but would always have a tidying blitz to enable DC's friends to come over.

Mopbucketmoo · 13/06/2023 00:12

I feel like my house is a total shit hole compared to other peoples so I'm embarrassed to have people over

Ontheperiphery79 · 12/06/2023 23:36

You said you don't understand it, but then have explored it might be down to the fact that she's a single parent with quite full on sounding twins and a full on sounding job. You've also mentioned that she's a private person, who may not have the headspace to host.
So, I can only speak from my experience, but as a single parent to full on (and ND) 5 year old twins, a pretty run down flat in a pretty run down area, my home be shabby, but it's my safe space that I can retreat to from the world. The only place.
I don't host play dates ever. Never have and never will. I also don't regularly share exactly why I don't 'do' them. But, it's my personal boundary across the board and, actually, it's perfectly fine that I don't feel the need to explain this to anyone.
Good on your friend for maintaining her own boundaries.

JudgeRudy · 12/06/2023 23:21

of course I can’t impose my daughter on her if she doesn’t want to invite her. It’s just odd, that’s all. It isn’t something I’ve ever encountered before.

I agree it's not the norm but I know lots of people who don't like visitors. I'm one of them. I also know people who want everyone to come to their home. It's maybe like being left handed....not the norm but definitely not rare.

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 23:00

KingOfThieves · 12/06/2023 22:35

If you value her friendship, I’d drop it.

I really, really get your point. It is important to remember we all have our soft spots.

I grew up in a really unclean, messy and disorganised home. I was embarrassed to have friends over. As an adult I cannot afford to make my home perfect and I have extreme stress over people being in my home despite it being clean and tidy (yet not perfectly decorated and needs new furnishings) it’s hard to break down that wall. We all have our sticky points. For many different reasons

Yeah I take all this on board. My flat is pretty messy but I don’t care. People can take me as they find me when it comes to my flat. I guess I grew up in a sociable home and my parents were always inviting people over so I don’t understand when people don’t want to do that & I’ve not encountered this sort of behaviour before.

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 12/06/2023 22:59

I don't think has to be an exact match but it is unfair if one person puts a lot more effort in than another, whether that is hosting, money, asking questions/listening, time however it works

So yes and can feel unfair if one person is doing all something another isnt

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:56

ANewAdventure · 12/06/2023 22:48

I think there is a socially contract that invitations should generally be reciprocated, but as examples in this thread have shown, there are plenty of understandable reasons why people may not feel able to meet that expectation.

I’d find it irritating if there were zero reciprocity though. Eg she doesn’t invite to her house but would take all the kids to the park, or offers to walk yours home from school occasionally, that kind of thing. Friendships do need some balance.

There is some reciprocity. She has sometimes taken my daughter out alone with her kids & I’ve appreciated that.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:55

JudgeRudy · 12/06/2023 22:38

I'm not sure it's unfair. It would be extremely unfair for you to insist someone who doesnt want to host invites you round. If you don't like to host then dont, but don't impose your choices on others.
If you say you'll only host if she does, she'll say fine, let's meet outside.

of course I can’t impose my daughter on her if she doesn’t want to invite her. It’s just odd, that’s all. It isn’t something I’ve ever encountered before.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:53

changeyerheadworzel · 12/06/2023 22:42

Let it go, she has her reasons and I can guarantee it is not her just trying to be awkward. There will be a legitimate reason, almost like this unspoken thing between you. She knows that you are aware she doesn't invite. Believe me.

Yeah, I think you’re right. She’s not stupid. She’ll be aware that I’m aware. It is this unspoken thing between us now & it’s gone on so long that it makes it even harder to ask why. There is obviously a legitimate reason. I will let it go.

OP posts:
Rollonannualeave · 12/06/2023 22:51

I don't reciprocate because I have a small home and 2 silly bouncy dogs. Could be something like that.

ANewAdventure · 12/06/2023 22:48

I think there is a socially contract that invitations should generally be reciprocated, but as examples in this thread have shown, there are plenty of understandable reasons why people may not feel able to meet that expectation.

I’d find it irritating if there were zero reciprocity though. Eg she doesn’t invite to her house but would take all the kids to the park, or offers to walk yours home from school occasionally, that kind of thing. Friendships do need some balance.

Tigofigo · 12/06/2023 22:42

I struggle to keep on top of the house - we are four naturally messy people and everyone just dumps stuff everywhere - and as a result I don't like having people over. Most of my friend's houses are immaculate and newly renovated. Ours is tired and cluttered (unless I spend days tidying and cleaning). Ironically I feel like clearing up is all I bloody do!

changeyerheadworzel · 12/06/2023 22:42

Let it go, she has her reasons and I can guarantee it is not her just trying to be awkward. There will be a legitimate reason, almost like this unspoken thing between you. She knows that you are aware she doesn't invite. Believe me.

JudgeRudy · 12/06/2023 22:38

I'm not sure it's unfair. It would be extremely unfair for you to insist someone who doesnt want to host invites you round. If you don't like to host then dont, but don't impose your choices on others.
If you say you'll only host if she does, she'll say fine, let's meet outside.

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:38

Kanaloa · 12/06/2023 22:34

She doesn’t want to though. I understand that you want her to, but she either doesn’t want to or feels she can’t host at her home. If you can’t tolerate that, you can decide to keep meeting up outside the home so your child can see her friends. Or not meet them at all. But for whatever reason she can’t take your child to give you a break.

Yeah I have come to that conclusion. It is annoying though from my point of view! Like I do wish my daughter could be best friends with a mum who is more reciprocal but you can’t choose who your kids make friends with and I guess I have to just be glad she has got a pair of best friends that she really loves.

OP posts:
KingOfThieves · 12/06/2023 22:35

If you value her friendship, I’d drop it.

I really, really get your point. It is important to remember we all have our soft spots.

I grew up in a really unclean, messy and disorganised home. I was embarrassed to have friends over. As an adult I cannot afford to make my home perfect and I have extreme stress over people being in my home despite it being clean and tidy (yet not perfectly decorated and needs new furnishings) it’s hard to break down that wall. We all have our sticky points. For many different reasons

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:35

Chupyloo · 12/06/2023 22:27

I’ve been that mum and I’m still that mum. We live in a tiny, cramped house with too much stuff and we are bursting at the seams. Not due to hoarding, just that the house is so small. My son and daughter have to share a room. It really embarrasses me as I can’t help but view my home over critically, especially as many of my children’s friends are pretty affluent

Fair enough. We’re in a small cramped flat. She’s prob in a small cramped flat too. She actually has a better job than me so it’s not like I’m richer and have a much more fancy lifestyle at all. My lifestyle is very modest. But I think it is just she doesn’t have the headspace.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 12/06/2023 22:34

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:30

It’s more that she doesn’t invite my daughter over. I don’t necessarily want to be invited over. Sometimes I just want a break and for her to host my kid as I’ve hosted hers a lot.

She doesn’t want to though. I understand that you want her to, but she either doesn’t want to or feels she can’t host at her home. If you can’t tolerate that, you can decide to keep meeting up outside the home so your child can see her friends. Or not meet them at all. But for whatever reason she can’t take your child to give you a break.

Morphmorph · 12/06/2023 22:32

I would reciprocate too and I'm happy to host but she hasn't and you need to let it go tbh. She doesn't need to have your daughter over and you need to stop if it's bothering you. You can't undo what you have done before.

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:30

Kanaloa · 12/06/2023 21:31

I think you are unreasonable. If you don’t like her and don’t want her to come then of course don’t invite her. But don’t do it because she’s ‘unfair’ for not inviting you back. There’s a thousand reasons someone may not be able to host. I would continue to invite (I did with some of my kids’ friends) because of the possibility that this is a bad home situation. The only thing worse than being a kid growing up in a chaotic home is being excluded from society because of the chaotic home situation.

It’s more that she doesn’t invite my daughter over. I don’t necessarily want to be invited over. Sometimes I just want a break and for her to host my kid as I’ve hosted hers a lot.

OP posts:
Morphmorph · 12/06/2023 22:29

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:09

my kid is an only child and v sociable so I do want to facilitate her social life especially as she loves this woman’s kids. They are her best friends.

But it's not her sole responsibility to do this for you. She's not obligated to have you over and you're not obligated either.

Chupyloo · 12/06/2023 22:27

I’ve been that mum and I’m still that mum. We live in a tiny, cramped house with too much stuff and we are bursting at the seams. Not due to hoarding, just that the house is so small. My son and daughter have to share a room. It really embarrasses me as I can’t help but view my home over critically, especially as many of my children’s friends are pretty affluent

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:25

Fair enough. I think I’m just used to reciprocal hosting with other friends.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 22:22

JeandeServiette · 12/06/2023 20:35

She might mean hoarding level messy?

That has crossed my mind.

OP posts:
Mary0nTheHandlebars · 12/06/2023 22:21

I only have one mum friend where I live but I'm sure she wonders this too. Our daughters are good friends.

In my case I don't reciprocate because because my DS has severe autism and his needs would completely dominate the play date. He's very loud, boisterous and very territorial of "his" things. His meltdowns can be upsetting and would be hovering around them the entire time trying to prevent one. It wouldn't be fun for anybody.

DD's play dates with her friend at the park and at her friends house / the hobbies they do together is the only time she gets to just be her iykwim? She misses out on alot, being the Sibling of a significantly disabled child and really benefits from the odd day out without DS.

I've also got some very unpleasant neighbours who object to any and all children's noise, so there's also that.