Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fellow mum never reciprocates with play dates

181 replies

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 20:10

My dd is friends with a local mother’s kids. She is a nice woman. We have a lot in common & get on. I have invited her & her kids over many times but we never get a reciprocal invite. I have known her nearly 5 years now. I know she has some issue with people coming round. She has said her house is messy. Mine is too & we do not have an impressive lifestyle at all. The lack of reciprocation has got me down so I now tend to just suggest we only meet up outside my home. She is always keen to meet. She likes me. I am too scared to ask her why she doesn’t like people to come round in case it is due to some trauma. She is a very private person. AIBU in finding her lack of reciprocation unfair?

OP posts:
Anaemiafog · 13/06/2023 07:25

DD leaves school this week. She has a friend who we've known since nursery. She has come here, stayed over, been on expensive days out, never missed one of DD's events, etc. that we always paid for. DD has never once been invited there. She is DD friend and that's why we invite her.
The friend comes from a large complicated family with several step and half siblings. They don't have a lot of money. I realised ten years ago it wouldn't be a reciprocal arrangement, like with other friends. If I'd stopped it, the only ones losing out would have been this child and mine. She's a great kid and it's not her fault.

letsgojo · 13/06/2023 07:20

I have crippling ocd and I can't have people here. Our besties we've been to hundreds of times over 5 years and they've been here twice. I explained when I first met her and she said she really doesn't mind hosting, but sometimes we meet out and I'll buy or bring take away coffees and snacks so that's me kinda reciprocating the tea and biscuits if that makes sense.
If you like her and she's a good friend please just accept the fact you don't go to hers. If you find it too much hosting then meet out.
She's probably extremely grateful for a friend like you xx

LlynTegid · 13/06/2023 07:19

Her choice, if it is just messy then fair enough. I'd only be concerned if it is a result of coercive control from a DH/DP or to hide something illegal such as drugs.

CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 07:16

I always did the "hosting"- although that does seem a bizarre word for cooking an extra handful of pasta. I had no anxiety or other MH issues, I was a SAHM, I had plenty of outdoor space, a super child friendly dog, children who loved to have other children in their space, a partner who enjoyed having people round. Why would I mind? Emergency child care is an entirely different matter, and there were parents I knew I could ring if I needed to. Having play dates is not building up credit for free childcare. It's letting your child have a nice time with a friend. And not having to entertain them yourself after school!

Thatsridiculous · 13/06/2023 07:15

My perspective - I don’t quite understand the constant need to socialise out of school. It’s nice sometimes, but not as a regular thing.

When my daughter was younger she was frequently invited to another friends home. The mum worked part time and was always home for school pick up. I work full time and was not back in time for school pick up - we had a childminder.

I know she was resentful that I didn’t reciprocate because she moaned about it to other mums - I’m not saying I didn’t ever, we had her child over plenty of times over the years, but I couldn’t do it regularly and tbh, I found the constant offers to have DD round to play quite intense. It was constant - something every week. And always mentioned in front of DD and she of course always wanted to go.

That’s just not for me. When I come home from work I don’t want to be hosting other peoples children. Maybe I should have said no to DD going round to hers more often but I felt quite pressured and DD of course was desperate to go. Had the mum not suggested a play date it wouldn’t have happened as regularly and I was fine with that. They saw each other in school every day and at clubs anyway.

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 07:05

whatchagonnado · 13/06/2023 07:03

You said she's a very private person and there will be a reason for that. You might never get to the bottom of it. I'm sure she really values you as a friend though if she's got something going on in the background and you are not prying too much.
I'd just let it go. Time passes so quickly, it'll all change again in a few years time when they're all teenagers

Yeah you’re right. I have come to this conclusion. I don’t want to pry & you’re right that soon they will be teenagers. I don’t think I will ever get to the bottom of it.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 07:04

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 13/06/2023 00:40

Sadly though her attitude will have an effect on her DC because people DO expect some reciprocity! As you say, it's tiring and also can financially affect you being the one hosting all the time.

You could try asking in advance if she could have your DD over for the day as you and your DH are going somewhere. See what happens? If it's because the house is a mess that will give her time to sort it. If she says a straight out no then sadly I would have to rethink it, myself.

And I say that as someone who struggles with getting my crap sorted but would always have a tidying blitz to enable DC's friends to come over.

Yeah I have asked and it was a flat no. And I asked another time. Again a fiat no. Because house was messy. I realised she had an issue. I withdrew a bit but my kid adores her kids so I can’t deny her playing with them.

OP posts:
SilverGlitterBaubles · 13/06/2023 07:04

DCs had friends who's mums did not work, they had all day to plan play dates, clean their house, make cupcakes etc ready for after school. I always felt stressed, rushed from work and inadequate when ever I hosted.

whatchagonnado · 13/06/2023 07:03

You said she's a very private person and there will be a reason for that. You might never get to the bottom of it. I'm sure she really values you as a friend though if she's got something going on in the background and you are not prying too much.
I'd just let it go. Time passes so quickly, it'll all change again in a few years time when they're all teenagers

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 07:01

Rubyupbeat · 13/06/2023 05:49

My friend is a hoarder, on level with those you see on tv. Her children are never allowed anyone back and now are aware after being at other childrens houses, that their house is different. It's really sad. Your friend could be similar, or living in bad conditions?

I am now wondering this. She owns her flat though & earns decent money & she’s well turned out/groomed, as are her kids. Her nanny is allowed in just no one else. But yeah I think maybe it is messy in a way that she’s embarrassed about.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 06:59

ThanksAntsThants23 · 13/06/2023 06:57

I never invite adults to my house these days. it’s tiny, messy and falling to bits, it’s embarrassing when everyone else lives in a instagram worthy home these days.

And people will say ‘normal houses are messy’ etc - yes, a nice house that’s a bit messy /cluttered is fine but when you live in a pokey council house with falling to bits kitchen, bathroom and doors that’s also prone to being a bit messy it’s completely different.

my kids also share a bedroom which makes having friends over difficult for them. In the summer they often have friends over to play and they mostly play outside, I always offer to drop kids back home after to avoid the parents coming to my house.

My flat is no way instagramable btw! It’s rented and pretty battered.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 06:58

ThanksAntsThants23 · 13/06/2023 06:57

I never invite adults to my house these days. it’s tiny, messy and falling to bits, it’s embarrassing when everyone else lives in a instagram worthy home these days.

And people will say ‘normal houses are messy’ etc - yes, a nice house that’s a bit messy /cluttered is fine but when you live in a pokey council house with falling to bits kitchen, bathroom and doors that’s also prone to being a bit messy it’s completely different.

my kids also share a bedroom which makes having friends over difficult for them. In the summer they often have friends over to play and they mostly play outside, I always offer to drop kids back home after to avoid the parents coming to my house.

Fair enough. Our flat is tiny and we all share a bedroom but I don’t care, it is what it is.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 06:57

CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 05:55

@OrderOfTheKookaburra "Sadly though her attitude will have an effect on her DC because people DO expect some reciprocity! "

Only not very nice people with no imaginations, though.

No, just people with a normal level of back and forth. It’s tiring to always be the one who has their flat trashed by rampaging kids.

OP posts:
ThanksAntsThants23 · 13/06/2023 06:57

I never invite adults to my house these days. it’s tiny, messy and falling to bits, it’s embarrassing when everyone else lives in a instagram worthy home these days.

And people will say ‘normal houses are messy’ etc - yes, a nice house that’s a bit messy /cluttered is fine but when you live in a pokey council house with falling to bits kitchen, bathroom and doors that’s also prone to being a bit messy it’s completely different.

my kids also share a bedroom which makes having friends over difficult for them. In the summer they often have friends over to play and they mostly play outside, I always offer to drop kids back home after to avoid the parents coming to my house.

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 06:55

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 13/06/2023 06:07

This.

I "hosted" (which in normal people's lives means "Can X come and play" "yeah" X and Y play. I throw a biscuit round the door every so often) more than dd's best friend looking back. When DD went to her friend's it was full on organised FUN! Mother had done a deep clean, bought craft supplies and baked.

Nice if you have time or inclination. I have neither.

Another friend spent every single afternoon of every school holiday at mine. Including having her tea most nights. Win-win. DD was happy with the company. I didn't have to think about glittery shit and going into full on hi-de-hi yellowcoat mode.

When I host I just let the kids get on with it. I don’t do any actual hosting. But my flat does get trashed. Which is tiring for me.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 06:53

Irked · 13/06/2023 06:07

Of course you are being unreasonable - she isn't obligated to host you. If you like to host, good for you. If you don't, don't.

I like to be able to leave playdates when I've had enough, which is much easier to do at someone else's house or a park than if you've got people in your space that you have to ask to leave.

All these people suggesting reasons (DV, hoarding etc) are probably the same people who would tell this woman "no is a complete sentence - don't explain why you don't want them over"

I’m not expecting to be hosted myself. Just a bit of back and forth letting each others’ kids come round. But it’s not going to happen. I’m afraid it does just come across as weird to me.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 06:50

TshirtInColour · 13/06/2023 06:26

Oh god I’m that parent. House is a mess I’m afraid. Older kids / adults leave mess. Kitchen clean for eating but messy. Sitting room tidy, study awful dumping ground. Dining room, more stuff dumped, as garage full. Upstairs, bedrooms messy .
Could never invite people, as hardly ever get it sorted. Need a thousand trips to the tip, but then they damn want to go through and recycle aggghh.

Maybe we are accidental hoarders, and it’s hard to get rid of all our accumulated stuff now

Kids don’t care about mess. Im not expecting to get invited over & even if I was I’d be relieved if her flat was as disorganized and messy as mine.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 06:41

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 13/06/2023 06:08

(I think when this stuff used to be called "going round to your friends to play" it caused a lot less stress and antagonism. Now it's a "playdate" and "hosted" it brings out the zillas on both sides)

yeah I agree. Kids don’t care about mess. I don’t really do any hosting anyway. I just sit and read and let the kids get on with it and occasionally throw snacks their way. I don’t tidy up beforehand. Play date is an American concept I think.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 06:39

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 13/06/2023 00:40

Sadly though her attitude will have an effect on her DC because people DO expect some reciprocity! As you say, it's tiring and also can financially affect you being the one hosting all the time.

You could try asking in advance if she could have your DD over for the day as you and your DH are going somewhere. See what happens? If it's because the house is a mess that will give her time to sort it. If she says a straight out no then sadly I would have to rethink it, myself.

And I say that as someone who struggles with getting my crap sorted but would always have a tidying blitz to enable DC's friends to come over.

I did try asking once and she said no because the house was a mess. It will have an effect on her kids. And it is tiring for me. I do understand that she has boundaries as per what other people are saying & I empathize that she’s a single mum and knackered but when people are so unwilling to share hospitality it is wearing on the other person and you end up withdrawing and turning away towards people who are hospitable. I’m not expecting her to be hospitable to me but to my daughter but yeah I’ve given up expecting and will just accept she is as she is.

OP posts:
TshirtInColour · 13/06/2023 06:26

Oh god I’m that parent. House is a mess I’m afraid. Older kids / adults leave mess. Kitchen clean for eating but messy. Sitting room tidy, study awful dumping ground. Dining room, more stuff dumped, as garage full. Upstairs, bedrooms messy .
Could never invite people, as hardly ever get it sorted. Need a thousand trips to the tip, but then they damn want to go through and recycle aggghh.

Maybe we are accidental hoarders, and it’s hard to get rid of all our accumulated stuff now

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 13/06/2023 06:08

(I think when this stuff used to be called "going round to your friends to play" it caused a lot less stress and antagonism. Now it's a "playdate" and "hosted" it brings out the zillas on both sides)

Irked · 13/06/2023 06:07

Of course you are being unreasonable - she isn't obligated to host you. If you like to host, good for you. If you don't, don't.

I like to be able to leave playdates when I've had enough, which is much easier to do at someone else's house or a park than if you've got people in your space that you have to ask to leave.

All these people suggesting reasons (DV, hoarding etc) are probably the same people who would tell this woman "no is a complete sentence - don't explain why you don't want them over"

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 13/06/2023 06:07

CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 05:55

@OrderOfTheKookaburra "Sadly though her attitude will have an effect on her DC because people DO expect some reciprocity! "

Only not very nice people with no imaginations, though.

This.

I "hosted" (which in normal people's lives means "Can X come and play" "yeah" X and Y play. I throw a biscuit round the door every so often) more than dd's best friend looking back. When DD went to her friend's it was full on organised FUN! Mother had done a deep clean, bought craft supplies and baked.

Nice if you have time or inclination. I have neither.

Another friend spent every single afternoon of every school holiday at mine. Including having her tea most nights. Win-win. DD was happy with the company. I didn't have to think about glittery shit and going into full on hi-de-hi yellowcoat mode.

CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 05:55

@OrderOfTheKookaburra "Sadly though her attitude will have an effect on her DC because people DO expect some reciprocity! "

Only not very nice people with no imaginations, though.

Rubyupbeat · 13/06/2023 05:49

My friend is a hoarder, on level with those you see on tv. Her children are never allowed anyone back and now are aware after being at other childrens houses, that their house is different. It's really sad. Your friend could be similar, or living in bad conditions?