Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fellow mum never reciprocates with play dates

181 replies

Voodoo43 · 12/06/2023 20:10

My dd is friends with a local mother’s kids. She is a nice woman. We have a lot in common & get on. I have invited her & her kids over many times but we never get a reciprocal invite. I have known her nearly 5 years now. I know she has some issue with people coming round. She has said her house is messy. Mine is too & we do not have an impressive lifestyle at all. The lack of reciprocation has got me down so I now tend to just suggest we only meet up outside my home. She is always keen to meet. She likes me. I am too scared to ask her why she doesn’t like people to come round in case it is due to some trauma. She is a very private person. AIBU in finding her lack of reciprocation unfair?

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 20:56

ChristmasCwtch · 13/06/2023 20:15

I think 3 play dates is max I’d do at our house without a return invite. I like hosting, but I don’t want to be the only one arranging and then tidying up after.

Having said that, one of the mums we know is in an very unpleasant marriage. She can only have other children over when her husband is away. Otherwise she takes it in turn to ask if we want to meet them at the park and then she usually brings biscuits or muffins she’s made for everyone. That I don’t mind, as I know the situation and she makes an effort too to keep up the friendship.

Yep. The mum is not in that situation. I have done a lot more than 3 play dates. I’ve not been given a good explanation of why my daughter is not allowed at hers except a vague excuse about messiness. I have known the mum for 5 years now. I feel like a mug for allowing it to carry on so Iong

OP posts:
ChristmasCwtch · 13/06/2023 20:15

I think 3 play dates is max I’d do at our house without a return invite. I like hosting, but I don’t want to be the only one arranging and then tidying up after.

Having said that, one of the mums we know is in an very unpleasant marriage. She can only have other children over when her husband is away. Otherwise she takes it in turn to ask if we want to meet them at the park and then she usually brings biscuits or muffins she’s made for everyone. That I don’t mind, as I know the situation and she makes an effort too to keep up the friendship.

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 20:04

SarahDippity · 13/06/2023 18:42

But didn’t @Voodoo43 mention a nanny in one post?

I don’t have a nanny! The other mum has an occasional nanny. Two afternoons a week.

OP posts:
SarahDippity · 13/06/2023 20:02

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 19:43

I don’t have a nanny. She has an occasional nanny. Like two afternoons a week.

Sorry about my wording; yes, I meant the other mum’s nanny

SarahDippity · 13/06/2023 19:58

For those of you who don’t like to have children in your homes on play dates, what do you intend to do when your children are older eg early teens and want to have friends over? Will they be allowed to do so?

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 19:52

Cam22 · 13/06/2023 19:03

Completely understandable. You’re having to labour your point for some posters who must surely get it - as we all do.

It sounds a pain, tbh, so no wonder you feel aggrieved. It’s a perfectly normal reaction.

Thank you. Yeah I feel some people just don’t get it. Like I have done a lot of hosting of her kids - 8 year old twins - without her in my v small flat and there has been little reciprocation & I am knackered. And no explanation from her except her flat is messy. I work, I do not have a nanny, I do not have much money. My job is badly paid. She has a good job. She is a single mum. I do have a partner but he works all weekend thus I host the kids alone. I don’t always want to meet up outside. She does sometimes take them all to the park without me and she has taken my daughter on one trip out with her kids. I find it weird that so many people think I am the bad person in this situation. The other mother is not a bad person but I do not understand why she is so odd about having anyone else back & I can only assume it is some sort of neurosis and/or extreme boundary setting. I do not keep a tally, but after 5 years I am tired of it even though I do find her nice to chat to. She is not a close friend, prob because she won’t let me in, so to speak. Emotionally or literally. And no she is not neuro diverse. And nor are her kids. She does not have a violent partner or someone else living in her flat that is problematic.

OP posts:
Leftlegwest · 13/06/2023 19:50

I hate having people to ours. I feel ashamed of our perfectly standard three bed new build semi. A lot of the parents at our school live in very big houses. The last one I was at they had four reception rooms! I know it's my problem, not there's but I can't help but feeling judged. It could be something like that.

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 19:43

I don’t have a nanny. She has an occasional nanny. Like two afternoons a week.

OP posts:
Cam22 · 13/06/2023 19:03

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 16:25

Er...thanks for your charming way with words. No, I realise it is not my business, and obviously I would not pry but, you know, you can't help wondering what on earth is going on. Like it is normal human curiosity.

Completely understandable. You’re having to labour your point for some posters who must surely get it - as we all do.

It sounds a pain, tbh, so no wonder you feel aggrieved. It’s a perfectly normal reaction.

Mary46 · 13/06/2023 19:00

Its tiring with twins. Op I think do a playcentre or park. Used find it stressful the kid would ask in front of the mam could they come ours!! But yes we both kept it fair/returned the favours. Maybe some mams dont get into it

SarahDippity · 13/06/2023 18:42

Chamomileteaplease · 13/06/2023 16:45

I think @Voodoo43 you have been given a hard time because you didn't state clearly from the outset about you hosting these two children all the time and usually (?) without the mum?

I think people see it as different if the mum isn't there because after all who cares who provides the tea and biscuits? Especially if she bring biscuits sometimes.

Basically you are providing an awful lot of childcare and usually on MN people are extremely hot on that. Which is why I think it is the way you have said it.

I hope that before these wild kids go home that you get all three of them to tidy up? I used to find that that helped a lot.

Has the mother ever specifically said to you "thank you so much for doing all the hosting aka childcare for five years. It is really kind of you and I so appreciate it."??

But didn’t @Voodoo43 mention a nanny in one post?

SarahDippity · 13/06/2023 18:41

CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 10:07

@SarahDippity "I’ll never know why and I have no problem saying I think it was poor form on the parents’ part to not participate in the exchange of hospitality, even occasionally."

Have the posts on this thread not given you even a hint of a clue of why it might have been?

Yes, there are lots of possible reasons, I’m sure, but no point in me speculating. No reason was ever offered, and I never sought one.

On the face if it, this particular mum was a very engaged and amiable person, seemed to have a stable family life, lovely daughters who did the same activities as mine. She and her husband were always really thankful and chatty, but for reasons unknown were quite comfortable to never extend an invitation to my child over the ten years.

As I said above, no benefit to me speculating why, but I feel justified in thinking it was bad form on their part. Not keeping score 😬, but approx 50-0, seriously?!

VikingLady · 13/06/2023 17:08

We don't have anyone over, ever. DD has ASD and home is her safe space; when we had people over when she was smaller she freaked out completely and it set her back months, in terms of mental health.

I am ALWAYS upfront about it though. If we're invited to someone's house for a play date I drop into that conversation that we can't reciprocate, so is there anything I can do to even the scales? Like what snacks should I bring? If it's repeated I'll bake a cake or something. It has to even put in some way.

(Plus I have high levels of social anxiety and used to throw up at the thought of people in my personal space, having to work out how to host, what to do, what to say, how much of what food to offer and when... )

CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 16:53

Honestly- I think a friend to tea and childcare are two completely different things! But I certainly didn't realise that the visiting children trashed the OP's house. As I said- I was always happy to have kids round and didn't expect reciprocation but it was always my house my rules.....

Chamomileteaplease · 13/06/2023 16:45

I think @Voodoo43 you have been given a hard time because you didn't state clearly from the outset about you hosting these two children all the time and usually (?) without the mum?

I think people see it as different if the mum isn't there because after all who cares who provides the tea and biscuits? Especially if she bring biscuits sometimes.

Basically you are providing an awful lot of childcare and usually on MN people are extremely hot on that. Which is why I think it is the way you have said it.

I hope that before these wild kids go home that you get all three of them to tidy up? I used to find that that helped a lot.

Has the mother ever specifically said to you "thank you so much for doing all the hosting aka childcare for five years. It is really kind of you and I so appreciate it."??

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 16:36

Anaemiafog · 13/06/2023 07:25

DD leaves school this week. She has a friend who we've known since nursery. She has come here, stayed over, been on expensive days out, never missed one of DD's events, etc. that we always paid for. DD has never once been invited there. She is DD friend and that's why we invite her.
The friend comes from a large complicated family with several step and half siblings. They don't have a lot of money. I realised ten years ago it wouldn't be a reciprocal arrangement, like with other friends. If I'd stopped it, the only ones losing out would have been this child and mine. She's a great kid and it's not her fault.

Yeah, understand this, but this is not the case with these twins. The mum has a v good corporate job (earns a lot more than me) and they are not like the family you talk about. They are not a chaotic family. Well, apart from the twins are pretty full on and hard to discipline because there's two of them.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 16:33

letsgojo · 13/06/2023 07:20

I have crippling ocd and I can't have people here. Our besties we've been to hundreds of times over 5 years and they've been here twice. I explained when I first met her and she said she really doesn't mind hosting, but sometimes we meet out and I'll buy or bring take away coffees and snacks so that's me kinda reciprocating the tea and biscuits if that makes sense.
If you like her and she's a good friend please just accept the fact you don't go to hers. If you find it too much hosting then meet out.
She's probably extremely grateful for a friend like you xx

She does reciprocate in that she is generous about buying snacks etc when we are out. I don't think she has OCD, think it is just she is single mum of twins and knackered and has a small flat (as do I). I do like her, but she has never explained what the issue is, I am too polite to ask, and I just try and enjoy her company when we are out but have had to stop having her twins over all the time as they cause havoc and are hard to contorl and i can't cope and end up feeling resentful. I think if she explained that it was some mental health thing I would completely understand and respect that as I too suffer from anxiety and depression. We have known each other long enough that she could have told me. She knows all about my mental health probs. I am very open tho. She is not. It is hard when someone is so private. You feel that you will ultimately never be able to reach them and you do end up veering towards ppl who are more open.

OP posts:
drpet49 · 13/06/2023 16:30

Completely agree with this.

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 16:28

LlynTegid · 13/06/2023 07:19

Her choice, if it is just messy then fair enough. I'd only be concerned if it is a result of coercive control from a DH/DP or to hide something illegal such as drugs.

No, there is no partner in the picture. And I highly doubt it is illegal activity. She has a v good corporate job. She is a very respectable seeming person. I think it is just her place is messy, small, she is knackered and can't face it. But neither can I. So am putting my foot down and not having her kids round, despite my daughter's endless moaning. I am giving myself a break.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 16:26

CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 16:22

@Voodoo43 But surely the issue is not that you're "hosting" but that the children are wreaking havoc! I wouldn't have allowed that to happen. Or maybe I would have let it pass once, but not twice. If you don't feel up to disciplining them, then don't have them over again. Because they're brats-not because their mother doesn't reciprocate.

They're ok kids, but just hard to control & there are two of them, they are twins. Yeah, I have stopped having them round cos I can't cope! But my daughter moans on and on about wanting to see them.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 16:25

SunnySaturdayMorning · 13/06/2023 11:30

You don’t need to “get to the bottom of it”. It’s really none of your business.

Er...thanks for your charming way with words. No, I realise it is not my business, and obviously I would not pry but, you know, you can't help wondering what on earth is going on. Like it is normal human curiosity.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 16:22

@Voodoo43 But surely the issue is not that you're "hosting" but that the children are wreaking havoc! I wouldn't have allowed that to happen. Or maybe I would have let it pass once, but not twice. If you don't feel up to disciplining them, then don't have them over again. Because they're brats-not because their mother doesn't reciprocate.

Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 16:17

CurlewKate · 13/06/2023 07:16

I always did the "hosting"- although that does seem a bizarre word for cooking an extra handful of pasta. I had no anxiety or other MH issues, I was a SAHM, I had plenty of outdoor space, a super child friendly dog, children who loved to have other children in their space, a partner who enjoyed having people round. Why would I mind? Emergency child care is an entirely different matter, and there were parents I knew I could ring if I needed to. Having play dates is not building up credit for free childcare. It's letting your child have a nice time with a friend. And not having to entertain them yourself after school!

I am not a SAHM, I have no garden, v small flat etc etc. I do host a lot because it is easier with an only child to have another kid around to play with so I dont have to entertain her, but I guess I am worn out with having to host a pair of twins who cause havoc in my already messy flat when the favour is never returned. We now meet up outside as I have decided to instil some boundaries for myself as I am fed up of the one way traffic but sometimes I just do not want to meet up outside.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 16:13

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 13/06/2023 00:40

Sadly though her attitude will have an effect on her DC because people DO expect some reciprocity! As you say, it's tiring and also can financially affect you being the one hosting all the time.

You could try asking in advance if she could have your DD over for the day as you and your DH are going somewhere. See what happens? If it's because the house is a mess that will give her time to sort it. If she says a straight out no then sadly I would have to rethink it, myself.

And I say that as someone who struggles with getting my crap sorted but would always have a tidying blitz to enable DC's friends to come over.

Yep, I have attempted this and it has been a flat no. So I have had a rethink.

OP posts:
Voodoo43 · 13/06/2023 16:11

Ontheperiphery79 · 12/06/2023 23:36

You said you don't understand it, but then have explored it might be down to the fact that she's a single parent with quite full on sounding twins and a full on sounding job. You've also mentioned that she's a private person, who may not have the headspace to host.
So, I can only speak from my experience, but as a single parent to full on (and ND) 5 year old twins, a pretty run down flat in a pretty run down area, my home be shabby, but it's my safe space that I can retreat to from the world. The only place.
I don't host play dates ever. Never have and never will. I also don't regularly share exactly why I don't 'do' them. But, it's my personal boundary across the board and, actually, it's perfectly fine that I don't feel the need to explain this to anyone.
Good on your friend for maintaining her own boundaries.

Yeah, take all your points but sometimes when people maintain their boundaries so very firmly it can come across as basically somewhat uptight/ungenerous/tiresome/neurotic. Sorry if that sounds mean but I don't quite know how else to put it. I also have only so much bandwidth, am skint, busy, stressed out, suffer anxiety, small flat etc etc, and yet I attempt to be a generous hospitable person because I know it's good for my kid. But I have set my boundaries in that I have her kids round much less, despite my daughter's constant moaning about it, as she loves them. And I am trying to expand her friendship group beyond these twins.

OP posts: