Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband and his incredibly tight budget

93 replies

henevieve1 · 12/06/2023 17:54

My Husband wants to save for a house.
I also want the same. We married and he moved in a few months ago and prior to him moving in we did not share finances.
We differ on how much money we should be saving each month and what is a necessity. For example I feel the odd meal out, some treats are fine while he thinks we should be saving every penny.

I just spend where I feel is reasonable and he has to accept it.

However the food shop is another matter.

I have always got a food shop online at Asda. I get this every month with a top up every two weeks. This ensured we all had fresh fruit and veg in and some treats with nutritious meals. I have two children.

He says he does not want to spend the delivery fee (I have the monthly pass) and he can easily pick this up in the car. I don't think there's much difference.

Problem is he likes to shop a little bit at a time. Today we had no food in so my children had no veg, beef burgers with no bun or salad or chips for tea! I had to give them a baked potato. I know that's not then starving but it's not ideal.
He is going out later and I can pick up a good few bits then but we will use up the fresh food before he is up for another shop.
When at the shop he will be okay with buying basics but make a face when I buy cake, ice lollies etc. It is hot my children like ice lollies in the summer it's really not extravagant.
I feel guilty for adding some ice lollies or ice cream to the trolley!

We ran out of fruit 4 days ago and my children have had none since then.

I am going to put my foot down now and insist on a monthly online shop. I can't keep the shop upto date with him taking me shopping and I can't relax with him huffing about what I'm buying.
I'm not letting my children go without fresh food because he thinks it's not needed.
I will no longer be involving him in the food shop.
AIBU?

OP posts:
AmeIia · 12/06/2023 19:35

I'd struggle getting regular nails done or meals out or shopping for what I think is reasonable on a household income of £45k. I'd want to be very careful. But nothing and no one would stop me feeding my kids a decent meal. He's being an idiot over the delivery pass. Does his car run off piss or does it run off petrol like normal people's cars?

ArcticSkewer · 12/06/2023 19:34

Willmafrockfit · 12/06/2023 19:17

jacket potatoes surely count as your 5 a day, plenty of vitamin c in their skins

sigh.

Just. No.

grazeeeee · 12/06/2023 19:30

Why on earth did you marry this man? I'm assuming he isn't the father of your children, to judge from what you've said.

Just why do women (because it's nearly always women) do this? Why not focus on your own house, your own income and your own children, rather than moving someone else completely unrelated in with them? Why end up being the one who funds the whole shebang? Is he so very special that he's worth disrupting your children's home life for?

JanesBlond · 12/06/2023 19:23

Willmafrockfit · 12/06/2023 19:17

jacket potatoes surely count as your 5 a day, plenty of vitamin c in their skins

Nope. Potatoes don’t count towards 5 a day in any format. Neither do other starchy veg like cassava and yams. https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/eat-well/5-a-day/5-a-day-what-counts/

TiredCatLady · 12/06/2023 19:21

Willmafrockfit · 12/06/2023 19:17

jacket potatoes surely count as your 5 a day, plenty of vitamin c in their skins

No, they don’t. Potatoes are a starch and not in your 5 a day.

Also prolonged and high temperature cooking will destroy vitamin C.

namechange55465 · 12/06/2023 19:19

He is BU, his way of shopping doesn't work for a family. He can pick up a click and collect shop once a week if spending on delivery bothers him.

If you're rural, he might end up spending more in fuel by popping out shopping for bits every few days than you would on the delivery - have you pointed this out?

cestlavielife · 12/06/2023 19:18

He s controlling your and dc food
Just say no
You always did asda delivery
Zero need to change
But maybe he likes that you have to beg him to go in car
Maybe he likes to escape
Poor dc

Willmafrockfit · 12/06/2023 19:17

jacket potatoes surely count as your 5 a day, plenty of vitamin c in their skins

WiddlinDiddlin · 12/06/2023 19:17

Surely shopping every few days is costing more in fuel than shopping less frequently and paying for the delivery pass?

Show him those costings, if he still objects, and he objects to click and collect, then the issue is not the cost of delivery at all, the issue is he does want to control what you buy/what everyone eats.

YoucancallmeKAREN · 12/06/2023 19:16

Why is this an issue? You explain to him that you are not willing to serve up another meal without fresh veg/salad, that his way isn't working. End of. You both have an equal say, he is not the boss.

JanesBlond · 12/06/2023 19:16

Willmafrockfit · 12/06/2023 19:10

jacked potatoes are vegetable and there is nothing wrong with eating them

There’s nothing wrong with a jacket potato no but they don’t count towards your 5 a day.

theemmadilemma · 12/06/2023 19:15

I gave up my Asda delivery well over a year ago.

I now make the Aldi run and a quick Tesco (next to Aldi) run for anything I absolutely can't get at Aldi.

Prices are rocketing. It's an easy way to reduce outgoings. Maybe you need to compromise here a bit.

We're by no means hard up, but we've kept our costs level by making these changes and it will leave you more room for treats.

LolaSmiles · 12/06/2023 19:13

WRT the money, he’s just had his income cut by half, and in truth on 40/50k and living alone he’s likely never had to budget that hard before, and so now having to watch what he’s spending means that he’s becoming aware of prices and costs and is hanging on to every penny he can.

Firstly, I would tell him that you’re going to start shopping from Asda or wherever it is now.

If you shop regularly enough get a delivery pass.

Buying fruit and veg for the kids is non-negotiable, ice cream and lollies and other treats, well it depends on how many you’re buying. He’s not unreasonable if you’re e.g spending half the monthly shop on junk food for the kids, but a treat is a treat. It doesn’t have to be an every day thing

Agree with all of this.

There's been a huge change in household income, you're saving for a house and by all accounts he is being very frugal himself on his personal expenditure.

Insisting you're having the delivery pass so you can be organised with the food shop and not run out of items is sensible.

Whether he's unreasonable on the treats, cakes and ice lollies depends on how much you're buying

Cakes, treats and ice lollies all add up and unless me and my friends live on another planet, it seems standard that kids will often gobble up as many treats and snacks that you buy as a parent even if they're not that hungry. They're also expensive, not filling and a fairly obvious way to make some trimming to the food shop by substituting to make your own/cut back.

BeastOfBODMAS · 12/06/2023 19:12

Sounds like he needs some common sense instilling. If your income halves your don’t eat half as much and have one hand of nails done, you cut your discretionary spending first!
Maybe there are some logical budgeting concessions to be agreed, can he do your top up shops when the yellow sticker stuff goes out then batch cook with a load of cheap fruit and veg?

Willmafrockfit · 12/06/2023 19:10

jacked potatoes are vegetable and there is nothing wrong with eating them

Willmafrockfit · 12/06/2023 19:10

you are the main bread winner
you dont have a car?
anyway,
just get a delivery, weekly if necessary.

SophieStew · 12/06/2023 19:06

MrsElsa · 12/06/2023 18:56

He lives with your children and is happily denying them food?!!

What did I just read. The hills are that way

Absolutely!

As you pay for the pass, can you not have weekly deliveries?

Just do it. He can protest all he likes, but no bloke would ever stop me from feeding my children.

Legaldrama · 12/06/2023 19:05

If you've got a delivery pass have a £40 delivery every 4 or 5 days, you shouldn't run out of anything that way.
You can't let your kids eat shit to save for a mortgage. You're likely not going to get one with him on 21k anyway, and you're kids will have scurvy by then.

Daisydu · 12/06/2023 19:02

MrsSamR · 12/06/2023 18:06

I'll probably get flamed for this but if they're your kids, not his, I kind of get why he doesn't want to pay for half of the food shop. Does your ex pay some maintenance? Could you split the monthly food bill for all of you and then you and your ex put in extra for treats for the kids if it bothers your DH?

Horrible way to look at it. When you move in with someone who has children, you accept you need to also provide for them. This is why csa is based on how many dependents you have. My dp pays maintenance but the fact he is financially responsible for my children (not his) means the csa says he has to pay less. (He actually pays more than csa say he has to but that’s besides the point.) for example, before my dp moved in, I worked but got a top op from universal credit. Once he moved in I was entitled to nothing. So if he had your view and said well they arnt my kids im not paying for their food, my kids would go without. Just such a small minded way to look at it in my opinion

Undisclosedlocation · 12/06/2023 19:02

henevieve1 · 12/06/2023 18:08

I think he's genuinely worried about finances.
Wants to save for what's really important.

I get it to an extent.

I've given up me two weekly nails appointment but I'm not giving up my children eating a healthy diet

The issue is he doesn’t view feeding your children properly as ‘really important’
That is a HUGE red flag! No house is more important than that

NOTANUM · 12/06/2023 19:02

Is this his first time living as a family especially one with children?

When I think back to how I used to live pre-kids when young, it was all quite different - i mooched around and ate what was in the cupboard and freezer if I hadn’t been to the shops. Or I went last minute to the shops and picked up what I fancied, it was no big deal.

Of course with kids it is a huge deal. You need to plan meals in advance somewhat and ensure there is fruit/veg/basics as running out isn’t an option.

I think you’ll need to firmly speak to him about how this looks and come up with a strategy, be that ordering online once a month (he can collect if he wishes!), and topping up weekly or even twice weekly.

OrbandSpectacle · 12/06/2023 19:02

Slippery slope. Be careful and wary of any other controlling behaviours creeping in.

MayThe4th · 12/06/2023 18:57

I would love to know what profession pays from 40-150k?! likely IT depending on what it is you do.

OP this is mn where women are desperate to tell other women how controlling they are, how everything is a red flag.

It’s absolutely not a red flag that he lost his job and is now in a minimum wage job. What would people have him do? Sign on the dole or worse, live off the OP until a job in his field came along. As someone who is preferred to do a job instead of waiting for a particular job, I can assure you that employers will take him a lot more seriously, because he clearly has a decent work ethic.

WRT the money, he’s just had his income cut by half, and in truth on 40/50k and living alone he’s likely never had to budget that hard before, and so now having to watch what he’s spending means that he’s becoming aware of prices and costs and is hanging on to every penny he can.

Firstly, I would tell him that you’re going to start shopping from Asda or wherever it is now.

If you shop regularly enough get a delivery pass.

Buying fruit and veg for the kids is non-negotiable, ice cream and lollies and other treats, well it depends on how many you’re buying. He’s not unreasonable if you’re e.g spending half the monthly shop on junk food for the kids, but a treat is a treat. It doesn’t have to be an every day thing.

MrsElsa · 12/06/2023 18:56

He lives with your children and is happily denying them food?!!

What did I just read. The hills are that way

SmilingHappyBeaver · 12/06/2023 18:55

I've got a great idea how he can save for a house quicker... stop scrimping and saving worrying about the supermarket shop, and get a job on £150k. Easier to earn his way into security than try and achieve minuscule savings from monitoring what the spend at the supermarket.

Problem solved.