Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask friends DD3 to say please??

43 replies

MooMa83 · 12/06/2023 14:08

Interested in the consensus here and whether I overstepped today. My friends parenting style is on the 'free' side and I have noticed that DD3 barks the orders and is not prompted to say please or thank you. Today she ordered me to pass her something and I automatically said 'please?', to which she responded 'please'. I didn't really think, and friend didn't say anything, but is this OK to do?? In the future should I follow their lead and not do this? It doesn't sit well with me being ordered around by a 3 year old! But perhaps I should be more respectful of how they are choosing to parent their child?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MooMa83 · 12/06/2023 20:10

Bookworm20 · 12/06/2023 15:52

This is a really tricky one to be honest. without knowing your whole friendship setup. I agree dc should use please and thankyou and they won't learn if they aren't shown or reminded, especially when little. so many friends of my dc don't ever use please or thankyou and I just think they are really rude. But I rarely correct them. Just make sure my own have manners and hope they say please and thankyou when i'm not around!

As he isn't your child, it isn't really your place to be teaching him it, especially when his mother is sat right there. The only parents I know of who don't give a toss if someone corrects their dc manners like this are the ones who enforce it themselves. If they don't, you may end up offending your friend as it is essentially correcting her parenting, if you see what I mean.
Like I say, tricky one!

Maybe encourage it and make sure he uses manners when he is with you and without his parents. But to do this in front of his mum, I think is not the best thing to do in terms of your friendship, unless she has said to you she is trying to get him to remember his pleases etc, so no issue with you reminding him if he forgets sometimes.

If I had my way, I'd remind all the friends of my dc who never say please and thankyou! But I can't do that, because I'd just look like a dick and have no friends!

Thank you for this...on reflection I agree with you. I think it was my friend sat right there which has made me question whether I was right. It just came out so automatically as I always prompt my own children if needed. It's very grating though, but I don't see how I can correct with mum/dad there as it does feel like I'm criticising them. Tricky one!

And just for the record there are no language delays and she is NT. She's a lovely, sweet and confident thing...proper threenager at the moment! It just grates on me how much she barks her orders at people, and mum/dad don't say anything!

OP posts:
BusyMum47 · 12/06/2023 19:08

Totally did the right thing.

I'm a Teacher & the amount of 10/11 yr olds that I have to remind to say please & thank you, on a DAILY basis, is utterly shocking!! Some of them look at me with either confusion or derision. Drives me INSANE. I never let it go. Ever. Manners need instilling from as early as possible!

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 12/06/2023 18:37

Random child in the street, no I wouldn’t you don’t know what delays or neurodivergence they may have. Your friends child, as I would assume being friends you would be aware of any difficulties and make allowances for that, absolutely fair enough.

I correct DD2s boyfriend all the time when it come to manners. No one’s cares, but people tend to be less precious about 15 year olds than they are about 3 year olds and your far less likely to upset the parent.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 12/06/2023 18:26

This isn’t true for children with situational mutism. Please and thank you can be the hardest, most anxiety provoking words according to dd’s specialist SALT

But this isn't the case. It's a normal and demanding 3 yr old. There's no reason not to gently remind her to say please and thank you. It will be drilled into her at school anyway.

Fivebyfive2 · 12/06/2023 17:24

My son is 3.5 and we always remind him to say please and thank you. He usually has better manners with other people than with us, but I guess that's typical boundary pushing/feeling more comfortable at home and forgetting.

Gumbo · 12/06/2023 16:33

I had the same situation with my nephew when he was 3. He just looked at me blankly when I did the 'please' prompt - and my vile SIL said, "oh, we were concerned that he might be slightly behind with his speech, so we aren't bothering teaching him 'unnecessary' words" Shock Hmm

To be clear, his speech was fine and there was actually no speech delay. And how are please and thank you not a necessity in society? Some parents do their kids no favours...

Ffsmakeitstop · 12/06/2023 16:33

A child who barks orders at adults is not anxious in any way. All these poor excuses for terrible behaviour.
I work in a shop and had a customer who every day would shop and the only word he said was "bag" eventually I started saying "please" before giving him it. We now have proper conversations.

VikingLady · 12/06/2023 16:25

DD has selective mutism and stress makes it much worse. She knows to do her pleases and thank yous, and if she forgets I prompt her. If someone else prompted her however, she'd feel like she'd lock down and start to spiral into beating herself up for getting it wrong.

I bear her in mind when I correct other kids, plus most of our friends are neurodiverse. Usually I smile and ask "was there a silent please on the end of that?" in a friendly way, so it's not too much for anyone.

Works well, and no other parent has complained, even the ones with "spirited" kids. I hate, hate, hate bad manners.

SleepingStandingUp · 12/06/2023 16:25

WeightInLine · 12/06/2023 14:25

I don’t think you should. Basically, you don’t know the child, the mother is right there and you are going to make no positive difference and could end up antagonising.

I remember my shy, shy DS saying please and thank you quietly under his breath while deaf or distracted people did their ‘what’s the magic word?’ At him. Frankly, I thought they were dicks.

But OP isn't deaf it distracted. The child issued an order directly, op said please and she copied immediately. No one was ignoring the kid.

FatGirlSwim · 12/06/2023 16:24

I have no idea about this particular child. None of us can. But neurodivergent children can be misinterpreted as ‘barking’ etc when they don’t have the tone of voice / intonation/ reciprocity that NT people expect. But they may actually be anxious about asking.

Personally I’d prefer to give the benefit of the doubt.

tattygrl · 12/06/2023 16:21

WeightInLine · 12/06/2023 14:25

I don’t think you should. Basically, you don’t know the child, the mother is right there and you are going to make no positive difference and could end up antagonising.

I remember my shy, shy DS saying please and thank you quietly under his breath while deaf or distracted people did their ‘what’s the magic word?’ At him. Frankly, I thought they were dicks.

You've actually changed my mind on this. Thanks for posting. It always pays to be more understanding than we might assume necessary. There are other ways to model and teach manners and sensitivity than reprimanding like an Enid Blyton school ma'am 😄

FatGirlSwim · 12/06/2023 16:19

OhComeOnFFS · 12/06/2023 16:17

@FatGirlSwim But this child doesn't have any kind of mutism - she's barking orders at the OP. That's a very different situation.

Children who are shy or struggle to talk usually blush and wriggle and struggle to meet your eyes when they ask for something - I wouldn't do anything to make them feel uncomfortable, but if a child barked an order at me I'd certainly remind them what to say.

We don’t know whether the child does or not.

I’m not saying they do… but I’m pointing out that being able to ask for something doesn’t mean that a child can say please and thank you. Children can have a low profile selective mutism and be able to say some things but not others.

tescocreditcard · 12/06/2023 16:17

You did the right thing. Anyone who wants something from me has to ask nicely.

FatGirlSwim · 12/06/2023 16:17

You also don’t know how the child will react. One child might be able to cope with that correction from an unrelated adult, another might have their confidence damaged by it. I think mine would feel upset and reluctant to ask in future. It would have taken them some courage to ask another adult for something.

OhComeOnFFS · 12/06/2023 16:17

@FatGirlSwim But this child doesn't have any kind of mutism - she's barking orders at the OP. That's a very different situation.

Children who are shy or struggle to talk usually blush and wriggle and struggle to meet your eyes when they ask for something - I wouldn't do anything to make them feel uncomfortable, but if a child barked an order at me I'd certainly remind them what to say.

FatGirlSwim · 12/06/2023 16:14

I wouldn’t prompt someone else’s child. There’s more than one way to encourage good manners. Some parents are choosing to model it rather than humiliate, which prompting can be.

I personally did prompt my children, but there are valid reasons not to and it is up to the parent. I’d be annoyed at another adult correcting my child.

FatGirlSwim · 12/06/2023 16:12

saveforthat · 12/06/2023 14:29

I wouldn't pass a child something unless they said please clearly. Shyness is not an excuse. If they can express their request audibly they can say please/thank you audibly.

This isn’t true for children with situational mutism. Please and thank you can be the hardest, most anxiety provoking words according to dd’s specialist SALT

Mariposista · 12/06/2023 16:10

You are absolutely right. Please, thank you and excuse me are non negotiable.

Bookworm20 · 12/06/2023 15:52

This is a really tricky one to be honest. without knowing your whole friendship setup. I agree dc should use please and thankyou and they won't learn if they aren't shown or reminded, especially when little. so many friends of my dc don't ever use please or thankyou and I just think they are really rude. But I rarely correct them. Just make sure my own have manners and hope they say please and thankyou when i'm not around!

As he isn't your child, it isn't really your place to be teaching him it, especially when his mother is sat right there. The only parents I know of who don't give a toss if someone corrects their dc manners like this are the ones who enforce it themselves. If they don't, you may end up offending your friend as it is essentially correcting her parenting, if you see what I mean.
Like I say, tricky one!

Maybe encourage it and make sure he uses manners when he is with you and without his parents. But to do this in front of his mum, I think is not the best thing to do in terms of your friendship, unless she has said to you she is trying to get him to remember his pleases etc, so no issue with you reminding him if he forgets sometimes.

If I had my way, I'd remind all the friends of my dc who never say please and thankyou! But I can't do that, because I'd just look like a dick and have no friends!

Hotandverybothered · 12/06/2023 15:48

PuffinsRocks · 12/06/2023 15:44

Actually if she's a 3 year old I think you're expecting too much of her and I do think you're overstepping.

I would be very surprised if a 3 year old didn’t know that please and thank you is what is expected . My three year old granddaughter also says excuse me if she wants to interrupt…she learnt that at nursery.

PuffinsRocks · 12/06/2023 15:44

Actually if she's a 3 year old I think you're expecting too much of her and I do think you're overstepping.

UsingChangeofName · 12/06/2023 15:42

The ‘takes a village’ people are wrong. There is so much shot parenting out there. Do not presume you know best.

........but we should presume that you know best ??? Hmm

If someone demands something from me without a please, then they won't get it. Basic manners. I don't care if they are a child or an adult. If you want someone to help you, then you ask them nicely.
We would be doing a disservice to any child if we didn't help them understand that / learn it whilst they were young.

billy1966 · 12/06/2023 15:29

MooMooSharoo · 12/06/2023 14:46

I helped out at my friend's kid's birthday party once. Class of 30 kids there. Only my friend's kid and maybe 2 or 3 more ever said please or thank you (I was manning the drinks table!). They just wandered over and said "Orange" or "Water". I didn't say anything then as I didn't know any of the children, but even my friend commented afterwards about how rude they were.

If a child I know is addressing me and doesn't say please or thank you I'd do the same as you OP, especially if it's in your own home - it's very easy then to say "in this house we say please and thank you for things".

I just don't understand it. Really where is there any harm in teaching children to be polite?!

Similarly helping out in our tennis/hockey club shops during tournaments, as a volunteer, having orders barked at me.

Screw that.

I loudly said the shop was closed to anyone who didn't know the words please and thank you and I couldn't care less about the parents standing around that heard me.

I certainly wouldn't tolerate it and neither would the other women helping out.

In my home it was ALWAYS a case of " in this house we say please and thank you" on the rare occasion I had to point it out to visitors, and the children reacted very well to it.

I don't care whose child it is, no one is barking orders at me!

My children have always had beautiful manners, often remarked upon.

We never had to teach them as such, just by using please and thank to them from their earliest stage, knocking on their door from an early age, meant it was all they ever knew by example.

Excellent manners are a life skill IMO and make life that bit easier to navigate when you have them.

MooMa83 · 12/06/2023 15:16

MooMooSharoo · 12/06/2023 14:47

😂I'm the master of the PA "Oh, thanks ever so much!" when someone lets a door go in your face! It will get me in to trouble one day...!

I do this...and mutter 'you're welcome!' to drivers who don't wave thank you when I let them through, even though they can't hear me!

OP posts:
MooMa83 · 12/06/2023 15:14

MooMooSharoo · 12/06/2023 14:46

I helped out at my friend's kid's birthday party once. Class of 30 kids there. Only my friend's kid and maybe 2 or 3 more ever said please or thank you (I was manning the drinks table!). They just wandered over and said "Orange" or "Water". I didn't say anything then as I didn't know any of the children, but even my friend commented afterwards about how rude they were.

If a child I know is addressing me and doesn't say please or thank you I'd do the same as you OP, especially if it's in your own home - it's very easy then to say "in this house we say please and thank you for things".

I just don't understand it. Really where is there any harm in teaching children to be polite?!

Funnily enough I had a similar experience with my 7 year old's party recently and I did prompt the children to say please, but this felt OK as the parent weren't there and I would absolutely want someone to prompt my DC if she forgot to be polite and I wasn't there to pull her up. I think there was something about the friend just sitting there that didn't feel quite right. I think if it happens again I may just check with her...'is that OK to remind her to say please'?

OP posts: