Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that in years to come there will be studies into the social isolation caused by working from home?

132 replies

MySugarBabyLove · 12/06/2023 12:41

I think that on many levels working from home is beneficial, so I’m not looking at slating the existence of WFH.

But I do believe that in years to come we will start to look at the social isolation that wfh has led to.

It’s already known that people who don’t work, be that because they’re home with the kids, or because they have disabilities are more socially isolated, purely because they just don’t get the same opportunities to speak to people as people do when they’re at work. In fact there have been many threads on here over the years from SAHMs who say they feel lonely and isolated, and the suggestion has been that they should go back to work.

Let’s face it, most of our interactions happen at work, and even if we don’t end up with lasting friendships, we do end up with regular opportunities to interact with people.

And now many people are working from home. And while there are many other benefits, the work/life balance, the ability to go to work without a commute, and be home at a decent hour etc, but I do think that the lack of interaction that WFH has led to should be acknowledged.

I work entirely from home. It works for me because I have a disability as well as another health condition, so while a commute would have been possible, not having to do so does benefit me.

And yet I feel more isolated now than before I started this job. Because although I work with people, a quick chat on teams isn’t a substitute for being able to have a laugh in the office, pass people going in and out, seeing someone at the coffee point.

My job started as WFH, I’ve been there since last July, and I have never and likely will never meet any of my colleagues in person.

And the longer I do it, the more I realise how different it is to when I used to work in an office.

I don’t miss the office politics, but I do think that WFH will possibly have a negative impact on people’s social abilities and their sense of belonging and isolation, and that this is something there will be studies on in the future.

OP posts:
Icannoteven · 12/06/2023 14:10

I only know one person who is socially isolated as a result of wfh.

Most people still interact with colleagues on teams and for teams days, still socialise with family and friends, still talk to people they bump into on their dog walks/ shop runs/ school runs etc, still visit the gym/church/allotment/whatever their hobby.

In fact, I think I have probably spent more time socialising since wfh because a) I am not too knackered from my commute to do anything of an evening and b) I have more flexibility to pop out during the day and do things like dog walking, reading with school kids, lunch time swim or yoga.

Locally, there seems to be more going on during the day time since wfh became more widespread too. Gosh, look at all that social time and choice that working from an office and commuting has stolen from us previously!

Work places don’t need to be social hubs. In fact, I am guessing that work colleagues are the last people on earth most want to be socialising with!

DeeCeeCherry · 12/06/2023 14:09

I mostly work from home & I'm happy enough. I have friends and a social life so I'm not depending on work colleagues for company. I also work far better without commute and work distractions.

I'd say thinking about it, anyone I know who's said they're fed up/lonely etc are those who are screen-addicted - ie sitting indoors watching others' lives via Facebook etc instead of making a life for themselves. 1 person I know wastes ages getting into political arguments on FB. I'm baffled as to why, when she doesn't even know these people? Faux company. It's just a waste of hours of your life.

Screen-addiction in favour of interacting in the real world is more likely to lead to loneliness than WFH.

Eldest DC does a hybrid job but when WFH goes out to a co-working space as feels the need to get out of the house. I think it's different for young people

SunnyEgg · 12/06/2023 14:05

I’m glad they’ve kept some time not wfh, and there’s more flexibility all over

But I do feel for people if it’s full wfh and not working for them

People seem so much happier though just from being released from daily presenteeism. It was long hours and meant you’d not get as many fathers as pick up as you do now (where I am)

Hillarious · 12/06/2023 14:01

Working from home certainly has its advantages, but you shouldn't overlook the importance of social interaction in person in the workplace. In an admin role, you learn a lot from being aware of what's going on around you, what issues are being dealt with by others, which may also cross your path. I enjoy the different people I meet at work, many of whom I would never meet or have the opportunity to speak to outside of that environment.

Choice3FruitBowl · 12/06/2023 14:01

WFH is good for some people that I know, especially those who had a long commute or who always wanted a WFH job

However, it isn't good for everyone

Some people take advantage of the situation & take the xxxx

I prefer to seperate my work & home life & prefer to work our of the home

StormShadow · 12/06/2023 13:59

JamSandle · 12/06/2023 13:56

Yes, this is the group I think are most negatively impacted.

This always gets argued on here, but leaves out that some younger people have more opportunities now, not less, because of remote work. Young people just like everyone else may be disabled, have caring responsibilities, be unable to live in close physical proximity to the best job markets, be neurodiverse or have any other characteristic that means full or partial workplace attendance is a problem. Young people aren't a monolith and don't all have the same characteristics.

SunnyEgg · 12/06/2023 13:58

It seems to have settled into a place where most people are happier in the sector I know

Usually wfh Monday and Friday with the option to go in if you want, plus more flexibility so if you’ve got a thing after work and wfh helps with timing you can

janeseymour78 · 12/06/2023 13:58

Same as @SpeckledlyHen I worked from home.for years before covid. I then went back to an office job in between.

Im much happier when I work from home as I have an active social life and I do still have a day in the office to see and mix with colleagues.

I think it won't work for some people, but not some widespread problem.

gwenneh · 12/06/2023 13:57

Why should the office be the centre point of your social life in the first place? I don't feel the need to come into the office to be my colleagues' source of interaction; I have a family, hobbies, and friends.

emmylousings · 12/06/2023 13:57

When the inevitable studies do take place, what it finds will depend on who the participants are. It doesn't suit everyone, but if you take this MN sample, the conclusion is, on balance WFH doesn't create loneliness.
Personally, I much prefer not having to waste energy on false relationships with colleagues.

JamSandle · 12/06/2023 13:56

W0tnow · 12/06/2023 13:55

I think wfh is awful for recent grads and younger folks.

Yes, this is the group I think are most negatively impacted.

KimberleyClark · 12/06/2023 13:55

It’s already known that people who don’t work, be that because they’re home with the kids, or because they have disabilities are more socially isolated, purely because they just don’t get the same opportunities to speak to people as people do when they’re at work. In fact there have been many threads on here over the years from SAHMs who say they feel lonely and isolated, and the suggestion has been that they should go back to work.

Do you include retired people in this? I am retired, after the best part of 40 years in full time employment, and I don’t feel isolated. I get as much social interaction as I need.

W0tnow · 12/06/2023 13:55

I think wfh is awful for recent grads and younger folks.

SpeckledlyHen · 12/06/2023 13:48

I work from home and have done for many years prior to the pandemic. I used to maybe go and visit clients one or two days a week but now with better technology those meetings can just as easily be done on teams/zoom without the need for a 3 hour each way road trip.

I don't feel lonely or isolated because I walk my dog everyday and invariably meet lots of people, I live in a very small village and a walk round there with the dog can take forever and you meet lots of neighbours. I also have a horse and go riding with other people, the yard becomes the social space.

When I used to commute to london I had the social interaction at work but never in the evenings/weekends so much as I never had the time.

WFH has just flipped the social side to outside working hours now.

5128gap · 12/06/2023 13:39

I'm not sure we need a study, your own post lays out the pros and cons pretty succinctly.
What is needed is an acknowledgement that different people need a different balance between home working and office working, with hybrid models offered wherever possible, and people allowed flexibility and choice so they can create the balance right for them.

WhatNoRaisins · 12/06/2023 13:33

Maybe with more people WFH there will be more people with the time and energy to create better social opportunities. It could go either way.

Nordicrain · 12/06/2023 13:27

KnitMePurlMe · 12/06/2023 13:08

@Nordicrain my office allows us to go in but it’s so hit and miss who else is in that often it’s not worth it. I miss working with my team so much. Don’t assume that because people aren’t going in that they don’t want to 😢.

OP I totally agree with u. Hybrid fine but f/t wfh is not a good idea for many many people - I feel especially sorry for young people just starting out. My work was my social life - I’d have been desperately lonely without it.

I guess your team don't feel the same though, and why should they be forced in because they are your social life?

People can now work in a way that - generally - gives much more work life balance. People with small children. People will disability. People with chronic illness. All those people can now work in a way that was much more difficult before. Of course that comes with consequences, but the flexibility that gives people is - to me at least - more important than facilitating office socialising.

I do think people need to be more proactive in seeking out socialising outside work now though. But it can be done.

Florissante · 12/06/2023 13:24

Sure. But there are studies on all sorts of things.

kelsaycobbles · 12/06/2023 13:18

Perhaps there will be studies as to the harm caused by building a life around work

About the harm caused when you work so much that your only friends can be work friends

Or about the harm to introverted people
Forced to work in the office

I am very fed up of the endless bashing about working from home
Which is Proven to be more productive
And is Proven to improve work life balance for sone people
And on average will reduce carbon emissions
Yes, Proven not to suit others but we are humans not machines - we are all different not identical robots

Why all the hate about WFH? Because office work exhausts people which makes them spend more on stuff they don't want or need which keeps the rich rich and the poor in their place?
Because crap managers like to see their underlings to gloat ?

If coffee shops and take out lunches were that attractive you could have the shops near where people live rather than the offices and people would still go - but that doesn't work , you need to wear people down before they want to use them

Lcb123 · 12/06/2023 13:14

Opti46 · 12/06/2023 12:59

I work most of the time at home and don’t share your concerns. If you want to have more social interactions you can join clubs, gather with family, build friendships etc…

Those social interactions can be with likeminded people rather than colleagues or clients. Most people have a life outside of work and the real job is to make that fulfilling.

this! Im more social when I WFH because I have the time and energy to go out after work and do hobbies, see friends etc. I prefer that to mindless chat at the office

BarbedButterfly · 12/06/2023 13:14

I can see that for some this may be an issue but I wfh and love it. I don't want to interact with co workers any more than i have to. It was always the worst thing about offices for me.

JamSandle · 12/06/2023 13:13

I've become more social since working from home. I do more in the evenings and on weekends than I did when I used to commute.

user4567890754 · 12/06/2023 13:12

Well, I think SAHMs only feel lonely and isolated if they don’t know any other SAHMs. If there’s a group of you, or even one other, then you can meet up and the kids play while you have a natter.

As more people WFH options may grow. You could choose to WFH with a friend, or meet up for a walk or a coffee at lunch time. With more people around, more facilities and services will open up
making local communities more vibrant and sociable.

we could try to get to know our neighbours better instead of leaving and returning under cover of darkness.

I have met some nice people at work, but so many offices have been miserable soulless grindingly awful places. You waste an hour getting there in stress and discomfort and then sit in a little cubicle prison with no outdoor light, either too cold or too hot, surrounded by irritating people who you would never choose to be friends with.

I’d much prefer to WFH and save my time and energy and spend it enjoying the company of my family and friends instead.

theswoot · 12/06/2023 13:09

There have been studies done about how bad working in offices can be but nothing really changes. Hot desking, open-plan, presenteeism are often terrible for people’s
health, wellbeing and productivity.

The difference is that with WFH, the social isolation is symptomatic of wider problems with the way our lives are set up and society operates, rather than being a problem with the working practice itself. And lots of contemporary reporting suggests how beneficial WFH can be for those traditionally locked out of career progression.

KnitMePurlMe · 12/06/2023 13:08

@Nordicrain my office allows us to go in but it’s so hit and miss who else is in that often it’s not worth it. I miss working with my team so much. Don’t assume that because people aren’t going in that they don’t want to 😢.

OP I totally agree with u. Hybrid fine but f/t wfh is not a good idea for many many people - I feel especially sorry for young people just starting out. My work was my social life - I’d have been desperately lonely without it.