Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that in years to come there will be studies into the social isolation caused by working from home?

132 replies

MySugarBabyLove · 12/06/2023 12:41

I think that on many levels working from home is beneficial, so I’m not looking at slating the existence of WFH.

But I do believe that in years to come we will start to look at the social isolation that wfh has led to.

It’s already known that people who don’t work, be that because they’re home with the kids, or because they have disabilities are more socially isolated, purely because they just don’t get the same opportunities to speak to people as people do when they’re at work. In fact there have been many threads on here over the years from SAHMs who say they feel lonely and isolated, and the suggestion has been that they should go back to work.

Let’s face it, most of our interactions happen at work, and even if we don’t end up with lasting friendships, we do end up with regular opportunities to interact with people.

And now many people are working from home. And while there are many other benefits, the work/life balance, the ability to go to work without a commute, and be home at a decent hour etc, but I do think that the lack of interaction that WFH has led to should be acknowledged.

I work entirely from home. It works for me because I have a disability as well as another health condition, so while a commute would have been possible, not having to do so does benefit me.

And yet I feel more isolated now than before I started this job. Because although I work with people, a quick chat on teams isn’t a substitute for being able to have a laugh in the office, pass people going in and out, seeing someone at the coffee point.

My job started as WFH, I’ve been there since last July, and I have never and likely will never meet any of my colleagues in person.

And the longer I do it, the more I realise how different it is to when I used to work in an office.

I don’t miss the office politics, but I do think that WFH will possibly have a negative impact on people’s social abilities and their sense of belonging and isolation, and that this is something there will be studies on in the future.

OP posts:
FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 12/06/2023 20:07

I find working from home as sociable as when I was working in the office, but my workplace actively encourage social chats and provide mechanisms for that. We have Teams sessions booked in where you can just turn up and chat to the CEO, only rule is that there be no work talk, coffee breaks scheduled where we're encouraged to stop working, have a break and join one of many Teams calls that are open to everyone and just chat, we share recipes companywide, globally across dozens of countries and timezones, photos of events/achievements, good news, bad news. There's somewhere to share it and someone to talk to.

How isolated people WFH feel is driven hugely by the company culture and how much effort they are willing to put in to maintaining the social aspects.

Tinybrother · 12/06/2023 20:05

StormShadow · 12/06/2023 19:09

Having a similar career path hardly means you're more likely to get on with someone!

Really, the issue is generalisations. You're right that there's no reason why having one particular thing in common with someone means you're going to get on, be that the choice to have a baby or where you live. But that principle is also applicable to work. It just doesn't follow that because two people do their wage labour for the same organisation, they've anything substantial in common or like each other.

And that goes for a lot of the discussion about wfh in general. There's pretty much nothing that applies across the board. It's not better or worse for young people, for productivity, for promotion, for anything at all really. The answer is always, it depends.

I completely agree that it depends, you can’t generalise across industries or roles

StormShadow · 12/06/2023 20:02

The word 'actually' is taking some abuse there.

Sissynova · 12/06/2023 19:58

Tinybrother · 12/06/2023 19:52

Almost certainly.

it doesn’t change the fact that there are many industries where training juniors is best achieved with a certain amount of time working alongside more experienced people - not just in teams meetings but physically in the same place. It doesn’t have to be all the time, but it does need to be some of the time, because important skills will not be passed on otherwise.

Totally agree. Actually an ironic twist is it’s actually older people who are more hardline about remaining wfh for longer/ full time. This is because they have larger, nicer homes, with home offices etc. I did some consulting with a law firm recently and they admitted they assumed it would be young workers who pushed back on returning to the office but actually it’s their 50+ demographic.
In a way it’s actually selfish to have squeezed everything you can put of a company and career and work mostly from home and not take part in investing back in the next generation.

cryinginhmart · 12/06/2023 19:57

Yep. I honestly appreciate the practical benefits of wfh and I guess it suits some people but I would go absolutely mad if I wfh. I work with my best friends but even before, the interactions with people and the kids in my class were what made my day lots of times. I’m busy every weekend and multiple days in the week as well so it’s not like all my socialising comes from work but even with that, if I was home alone all day every day or just seeing my partner (if I had one), I think I’d go mental.

Tinybrother · 12/06/2023 19:52

Catchasingmewithspiders · 12/06/2023 19:24

In my experience the people who moan about new peoples lack of skills, grads or otherwise, are the same people who moaned about peoples lack of skills when they were all in an office anyway.

Almost certainly.

it doesn’t change the fact that there are many industries where training juniors is best achieved with a certain amount of time working alongside more experienced people - not just in teams meetings but physically in the same place. It doesn’t have to be all the time, but it does need to be some of the time, because important skills will not be passed on otherwise.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 12/06/2023 19:24

Tinybrother · 12/06/2023 19:04

I agree that it’s absolutely not necessary to have everyone in full time, but I also notice that where I work the senior people who complain most about new grads’ lack of skills are the ones who are never in the office to give the grads the opportunity to learn from them.

In my experience the people who moan about new peoples lack of skills, grads or otherwise, are the same people who moaned about peoples lack of skills when they were all in an office anyway.

Modernmuse · 12/06/2023 19:12

My young son loves WFH, He is 21, He already has a good circle of close friends, plus his girlfriend. He has previously work in offices and a bank, customers drove him mad, much prefers WFH. l think a lot of it depends on your personality, some people are just not very good at being alone, they need other people around them constantly, where as others like myself much prefer their own company.

theswoot · 12/06/2023 19:10

@Tinybrother truth!

StormShadow · 12/06/2023 19:09

Q2C4 · 12/06/2023 18:06

I find this ironic because, having have 2 stints on maternity leave, I found the concept that I'd get on with other parents I met at baby groups odd - largely the only thing we had in common was having kids of similar ages. Same with neighbours - all we have in common is a little patch of shared geography. Whereas, with work colleagues, you are likely to have a similar skill set, career path and possibly even interests (having chosen the same career), so you've more in common and are more likely to get on with each other.

Having a similar career path hardly means you're more likely to get on with someone!

Really, the issue is generalisations. You're right that there's no reason why having one particular thing in common with someone means you're going to get on, be that the choice to have a baby or where you live. But that principle is also applicable to work. It just doesn't follow that because two people do their wage labour for the same organisation, they've anything substantial in common or like each other.

And that goes for a lot of the discussion about wfh in general. There's pretty much nothing that applies across the board. It's not better or worse for young people, for productivity, for promotion, for anything at all really. The answer is always, it depends.

Tinybrother · 12/06/2023 19:04

theswoot · 12/06/2023 18:55

@Q2C4 those underperformers aren’t necessarily socially isolated though, it’s workplace skills that they are lacking, which is a different issue. There absolutely needs to be a way to make sure those new to the workplace are equipped to handle whatever their career might throw at them, but I am always amused when the solution seems to be “put everyone in the office more”. For better or for worse, the way we work is changing, so the way we upskill people has to as well. It’s no good teaching people how to thrive in an office full-time if there’s a low likelihood of that being the norm!

I agree that it’s absolutely not necessary to have everyone in full time, but I also notice that where I work the senior people who complain most about new grads’ lack of skills are the ones who are never in the office to give the grads the opportunity to learn from them.

LoobyDop · 12/06/2023 19:01

kelsaycobbles · 12/06/2023 13:18

Perhaps there will be studies as to the harm caused by building a life around work

About the harm caused when you work so much that your only friends can be work friends

Or about the harm to introverted people
Forced to work in the office

I am very fed up of the endless bashing about working from home
Which is Proven to be more productive
And is Proven to improve work life balance for sone people
And on average will reduce carbon emissions
Yes, Proven not to suit others but we are humans not machines - we are all different not identical robots

Why all the hate about WFH? Because office work exhausts people which makes them spend more on stuff they don't want or need which keeps the rich rich and the poor in their place?
Because crap managers like to see their underlings to gloat ?

If coffee shops and take out lunches were that attractive you could have the shops near where people live rather than the offices and people would still go - but that doesn't work , you need to wear people down before they want to use them

Oh god, this x1000. If you don’t want to wfh, don’t do it. Hundreds and hundreds of posters have explained hundreds of times over why it works for them, and you still bore on fretting about it. It’s infuriating.

Q2C4 · 12/06/2023 19:00

@theswoot I think employers are now realising the damage that WFH is doing to the skills of its workforce and are taking steps to reverse it.

The juniors I work with are often renting a room in shared accommodation so are working & sleeping 24/7 in the same room. Some are describing this as akin to being in prison. No wonder they are lacking in motivation.

The people who I find are more comfortable WFH are the senior managers with longer commutes who have nice leafy pads with large gardens etc.

theswoot · 12/06/2023 18:55

@Q2C4 those underperformers aren’t necessarily socially isolated though, it’s workplace skills that they are lacking, which is a different issue. There absolutely needs to be a way to make sure those new to the workplace are equipped to handle whatever their career might throw at them, but I am always amused when the solution seems to be “put everyone in the office more”. For better or for worse, the way we work is changing, so the way we upskill people has to as well. It’s no good teaching people how to thrive in an office full-time if there’s a low likelihood of that being the norm!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/06/2023 18:53

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/06/2023 18:37

What strikes me about this is the politicisation of the attitudes to this and the polarisation.

The Wall Street Journal and the Daily Mail and other right wing rags have been writing for months about how wfh is unpicking the moral fabric of society.

There are certainly some drawbacks associated with wfh and some negative impacts.

Bur a lot of people find it life changingly liberating. It has enabled many of us to work flexibilbly, allowed us to consider out children’s needs and to save a lot of money.

I can’t help thinking quite a lot of the objections to it are pretty misogynistic and nonsensical. I think when it come down to brass tacks a lot of it is people objecting to the fact women no longer have to fit their work schedule around arbitrary structures dictated by the needs of men.

The trouble is that it also facilitates the control of women by men.

My ex would have loved me wfh as I'd have been under his supervision 24/7. He'd have hated the fact that I would have emails and messages from men and would have hovered around or constantly interrupted during virtual meetings. I tried taking a short study course with online lectures, just one a month, and he didn't leave me alone for more than five minutes without coming in and seeking attention/checking up on me (and then the 'So, what men are on the course?' 'Are you emailing a man?' 'Next time you're doing it, I want to sit in and see who you're talking to and get to know them' type of shit for the next four weeks).

At least with in person courses, office based work and hybrid working, there would be the opportunity to interact with other people who weren't crazy coercive shits - and there would be a blissful hour or so travelling, which is also good exercise.

In short, if there's a way for men to control women, they will find it, whether it's through 'dictating women's work schedule' outside the home or monitoring it inside the home.

Tinybrother · 12/06/2023 18:50

Catchasingmewithspiders · 12/06/2023 18:47

I can’t help thinking quite a lot of the objections to it are pretty misogynistic and nonsensical. I think when it come down to brass tacks a lot of it is people objecting to the fact women no longer have to fit their work schedule around arbitrary structures dictated by the needs of men.

I totally agree with this

I completely agree

Catchasingmewithspiders · 12/06/2023 18:47

I can’t help thinking quite a lot of the objections to it are pretty misogynistic and nonsensical. I think when it come down to brass tacks a lot of it is people objecting to the fact women no longer have to fit their work schedule around arbitrary structures dictated by the needs of men.

I totally agree with this

Catchasingmewithspiders · 12/06/2023 18:46

I've been wfh since long before the pandemic. In fact due to my disabilities it's the only way I can work.

Instead of taking to no one today I spoke to 7 different people. I feel less isolated not more.

And despite people (not young grads) saying its bad for grads, our grads are thriving. We keep asking if they want more time in the office and more people from the team present in the office and they don't. Because this way they have more time to socialise with their actual friends. And honestly their work is amazing.

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/06/2023 18:37

What strikes me about this is the politicisation of the attitudes to this and the polarisation.

The Wall Street Journal and the Daily Mail and other right wing rags have been writing for months about how wfh is unpicking the moral fabric of society.

There are certainly some drawbacks associated with wfh and some negative impacts.

Bur a lot of people find it life changingly liberating. It has enabled many of us to work flexibilbly, allowed us to consider out children’s needs and to save a lot of money.

I can’t help thinking quite a lot of the objections to it are pretty misogynistic and nonsensical. I think when it come down to brass tacks a lot of it is people objecting to the fact women no longer have to fit their work schedule around arbitrary structures dictated by the needs of men.

Trees6 · 12/06/2023 18:33

I loved the social side of the office when I was in my twenties but thinking about it, the pub-after-work-on-a-Friday thing isn’t terribly inclusive.

I like that WFH maybe encourages diversity in the workplace - we’ll soon see if that’s true. It’s also good for the sandwich generation which is juggling ageing parents and minor kids at the same time, because the absence of a commute and the possibility of - cliche alert - putting on a load of washing at lunch time, must be very helpful. And let’s face it, the bulk of this pressure falls on women.

Tinybrother · 12/06/2023 18:25

In some industries, if senior people want juniors to learn then they need to sacrifice some of the advantages of wfh and be around to be learnt from.

in that scenario hybrid working, with a reasonable time in the office, works best for everyone

Tinybrother · 12/06/2023 18:20

Ghastisflabbered · 12/06/2023 17:09

You were very confident in your assertion that it was awful for them.

I was interested in a viewpoint from that demographic that differed from the ones I was hearing from the grads and young starters we employ.

Massively depends on the industry. It has been pretty difficult for those that work on an apprentice type model, acquiring the skills without more senior people around takes much longer

Q2C4 · 12/06/2023 18:08

W0tnow · 12/06/2023 13:55

I think wfh is awful for recent grads and younger folks.

It certainly reduces the opportunity for office romances!

Q2C4 · 12/06/2023 18:06

user4567890754 · 12/06/2023 13:12

Well, I think SAHMs only feel lonely and isolated if they don’t know any other SAHMs. If there’s a group of you, or even one other, then you can meet up and the kids play while you have a natter.

As more people WFH options may grow. You could choose to WFH with a friend, or meet up for a walk or a coffee at lunch time. With more people around, more facilities and services will open up
making local communities more vibrant and sociable.

we could try to get to know our neighbours better instead of leaving and returning under cover of darkness.

I have met some nice people at work, but so many offices have been miserable soulless grindingly awful places. You waste an hour getting there in stress and discomfort and then sit in a little cubicle prison with no outdoor light, either too cold or too hot, surrounded by irritating people who you would never choose to be friends with.

I’d much prefer to WFH and save my time and energy and spend it enjoying the company of my family and friends instead.

I find this ironic because, having have 2 stints on maternity leave, I found the concept that I'd get on with other parents I met at baby groups odd - largely the only thing we had in common was having kids of similar ages. Same with neighbours - all we have in common is a little patch of shared geography. Whereas, with work colleagues, you are likely to have a similar skill set, career path and possibly even interests (having chosen the same career), so you've more in common and are more likely to get on with each other.

Q2C4 · 12/06/2023 18:01

theswoot · 12/06/2023 13:09

There have been studies done about how bad working in offices can be but nothing really changes. Hot desking, open-plan, presenteeism are often terrible for people’s
health, wellbeing and productivity.

The difference is that with WFH, the social isolation is symptomatic of wider problems with the way our lives are set up and society operates, rather than being a problem with the working practice itself. And lots of contemporary reporting suggests how beneficial WFH can be for those traditionally locked out of career progression.

That is interesting - we've found the opposite in that the juniors we recruited shortly before lockdown are all under performing. The evidence suggests it's the lack of office time with Senior Managers - essentially the juniors have no/limited role modelled behaviour to observe. There's also a chronic lack of team spirit due to lack of fun/banter/chat/the occasional office lunch out etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread