Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for not replacing a broken wine glass on holiday?

311 replies

OtterlyMad · 12/06/2023 11:05

My DH and I have just spent a week in a rural holiday cottage. We accidentally broke a wine glass while washing up on the last night of our trip, so we messaged the owner the next morning to let them know and apologise for the inconvenience.

After we checked out, we received a text from the owner complaining that it’s the norm to either replace breakages ourselves or leave a £5 note. Is everyone else aware of this “rule”?Because we weren’t! In fairness I don’t think we’ve ever broken anything in a holiday let before so no experience of this situation. Obviously if we’d damaged something big or stained a carpet or whatever then I would expect to reimburse them, but I suppose I assumed that breakages of small/cheap things like glassware, crockery etc. would be super common and therefore factored into the price. It’s also quite difficult to buy a singular wine glass. Would they not care about it matching the rest of their glassware? Or do you think they would expect a whole new set?

It got broken around 11pm and we had to check out before 10am the next morning, so frankly we wouldn’t have had time to buy a replacement even if we’d known that was the expectation. The rule wasn’t mentioned anywhere in the online listing or in the welcome pack. We also don’t tend to carry cash, so as above, couldn’t have left a £5 note even if we’d wanted to. Most irritating of all is that lots of the kitchen sets were already incomplete e.g. there were only 3 wine glasses to begin with (the property is advertised for 4 people). We didn’t mind as it was just the 2 of us, but it’s clear the owners don’t actually check and replace items that get lost/broken… makes me think we just shouldn’t have mentioned it. Too honest for our own good!

I feel guilty as we strive to be excellent guests, but I also think it’s a dumb rule and I’m annoyed that they’ve cast a shadow over our holiday for the sake of a £1.50 glass (especially as we paid over £500 for the cottage).

Did we act unreasonably?

YABU - the owner is right, and you should have carried change on you to leave in case of a breakage.
YANBU - the owner is being petty, a broken glass is normal wear and tear.

OP posts:
Clarabellasingsthisbit · 12/06/2023 18:46

We stayed in one cottage many years ago where there was a price list taped inside each kitchen cupboard listing the replacement cost for each glass,cup,mug,plate,bowl,saucer...😄

AP5Diva · 12/06/2023 18:45

That’s what damage deposits are for? I’d have messaged and said deduct from the deposit.

Wasitworthitreally · 12/06/2023 18:43

It is courtesy to tell the owner. Of any restaurant, pub, let or even friend.

And it is courtesy of the owner to say don’t worry it doesn’t matter but thanks for letting me know.

A deliberate spree of vandalism is entirely different to an accidental smash of a cheap glass.

SwedishEdith · 12/06/2023 18:42

Haha, I can't believe the number of people telling you to hand over £5 for a broken wine glass. I'd have told them with the full expectation that they'd say "These things happen. Hope you enjoyed your holiday."

MammaTo · 12/06/2023 18:38

I don’t think I would of even told them tbh.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 12/06/2023 18:34

LookItsMeAgain · 12/06/2023 13:53

I'd expect a friend to at the very very least to offer to replace the glass that they broke. Depending on what glass it was, it could be a cheap glass from Ikea or it could be a crystal glass from a set. It is not normal wear and tear.

Do you have any friends? Embarrassed for you.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 12/06/2023 18:31

Huytffdddc · 12/06/2023 11:11

There is the cost of the glass and their time.

Sorry what? They are likely making a small fortune from their holiday let. Small breakages and some slight inconveniences are a given.

OtterlyMad · 12/06/2023 18:15

Jaxhog · 12/06/2023 17:50

So let me get this right: a broken wine glass is trivial, so what isn't? A broken table, a vase, a teapot? How about a smashed window or large carpet stain from red wine? It isn't up to you as the guest/tenant to make this decision; it's for the owner or landlord to decide what is 'trivial' Same with Hotels in my (extensive) experience of staying in Hotels etc. I

f you admit to the breakage, they will often say forget it. But that is THEIR decision. Not yours.

Have you not bothered to read the rest of this thread? We’re not opposed to paying for a replacement. What we object to the expectation from the owners for us to take a very specific course of action (i.e. to source a replacement ourselves or leave a £5 note) when this instruction is not given anywhere. We’re not mind readers! Plus, we wouldn’t have had the opportunity to buy a replacement or go to a ATM due to the rural location of the property and early check out time.

OP posts:
PonyPatter44 · 12/06/2023 18:15

There is absolutely no such thing as a "£5 rule"! Utter tosh. The owners are trying to pull a fast one on you. You should perhaps have left a note mentioning the breakage, but literally that is all.

I stay in a LOT of holiday cottages.

purplepencilcase · 12/06/2023 18:13

It's a risk of the job! They get paid and should accept things will get broken. They should be allowing for a certain amount of breakage in their costs.

Preps · 12/06/2023 18:09

Jaxhog · 12/06/2023 17:50

So let me get this right: a broken wine glass is trivial, so what isn't? A broken table, a vase, a teapot? How about a smashed window or large carpet stain from red wine? It isn't up to you as the guest/tenant to make this decision; it's for the owner or landlord to decide what is 'trivial' Same with Hotels in my (extensive) experience of staying in Hotels etc. I

f you admit to the breakage, they will often say forget it. But that is THEIR decision. Not yours.

All accidental breakages as a cost of running the business IMO. Small things are routinely replaced, larger ones would be covered by insurance.

The rentals are priced to account for a sensible replacement programme. Nothing precious should be in a holiday let.

Elphame · 12/06/2023 18:01

OtterlyMad · 12/06/2023 11:05

My DH and I have just spent a week in a rural holiday cottage. We accidentally broke a wine glass while washing up on the last night of our trip, so we messaged the owner the next morning to let them know and apologise for the inconvenience.

After we checked out, we received a text from the owner complaining that it’s the norm to either replace breakages ourselves or leave a £5 note. Is everyone else aware of this “rule”?Because we weren’t! In fairness I don’t think we’ve ever broken anything in a holiday let before so no experience of this situation. Obviously if we’d damaged something big or stained a carpet or whatever then I would expect to reimburse them, but I suppose I assumed that breakages of small/cheap things like glassware, crockery etc. would be super common and therefore factored into the price. It’s also quite difficult to buy a singular wine glass. Would they not care about it matching the rest of their glassware? Or do you think they would expect a whole new set?

It got broken around 11pm and we had to check out before 10am the next morning, so frankly we wouldn’t have had time to buy a replacement even if we’d known that was the expectation. The rule wasn’t mentioned anywhere in the online listing or in the welcome pack. We also don’t tend to carry cash, so as above, couldn’t have left a £5 note even if we’d wanted to. Most irritating of all is that lots of the kitchen sets were already incomplete e.g. there were only 3 wine glasses to begin with (the property is advertised for 4 people). We didn’t mind as it was just the 2 of us, but it’s clear the owners don’t actually check and replace items that get lost/broken… makes me think we just shouldn’t have mentioned it. Too honest for our own good!

I feel guilty as we strive to be excellent guests, but I also think it’s a dumb rule and I’m annoyed that they’ve cast a shadow over our holiday for the sake of a £1.50 glass (especially as we paid over £500 for the cottage).

Did we act unreasonably?

YABU - the owner is right, and you should have carried change on you to leave in case of a breakage.
YANBU - the owner is being petty, a broken glass is normal wear and tear.

I treat all glasses as disposable.

Had you messaged me I'd have thanked you for letting me know and got another one out of the cupboard.

I actually don't like guests replacing them as they never match and I end up taking them down to the charity shop. I don't like mismatched glassware or china at the holiday let.

Jaxhog · 12/06/2023 17:50

So let me get this right: a broken wine glass is trivial, so what isn't? A broken table, a vase, a teapot? How about a smashed window or large carpet stain from red wine? It isn't up to you as the guest/tenant to make this decision; it's for the owner or landlord to decide what is 'trivial' Same with Hotels in my (extensive) experience of staying in Hotels etc. I

f you admit to the breakage, they will often say forget it. But that is THEIR decision. Not yours.

Zebedee55 · 12/06/2023 17:49

I broke a glass vase in a lodge and they sent me a bill for £20 to replace it. I couldn't be bothered to argue, so sent them the payment.

Buildingthefuture · 12/06/2023 17:46

Am currently on holiday and did the same thing - broke a glass. Nothing in the welcome pack about breakages but I messaged the owner on the day that we were leaving, told her I’d done it, apologised and said I was going to leave 10 euros. She replied thanking me for telling her and that repayment wasn’t necessary, but I left it anyway. It was a beautiful apartment, someone had put a lot of care and attention into it and I didn’t want them to be out of pocket because I’m clumsy.

rookiemere · 12/06/2023 16:39

I've stayed in many holiday cottages. Cannot recall a single UK one that had written procedures for breakages.

thecatsthecats · 12/06/2023 15:50

ConstantlyConfusedBird · 12/06/2023 11:23

If you break it then you replace it? Why should they be out of pocket and not have enough glasses because you broke something that belongs to someone else in their property?

Because that's not how you run a business that is, in essence, about making sure your customers have a good, relaxing time.

You include a budget of, say, £10 breakages per visit. You include a reasonable deposit structure. You buy double of everything and sub in replacements as needed.

And you don't act like a penny pinching mardy arse because someone didn't follow unwritten rules. That's asking for a bad review, which is the last thing you want.

UsingChangeofName · 12/06/2023 15:47

No, as most have said, it definitely isn't expected that you'd replace something like that. It comes out of the rent you have already paid. It is expected that the odd thing gets broken. You owner is being ridiculous.

weatherheather · 12/06/2023 15:38

Last time we stayed somewhere there was a breakages book - you just popped the breakage on there and it said don't worry if it's a glass/plate etc we understand - obviously if was something really expensive we'd have offered to pay it and they would have charged the insurance payment we had to pay!

TheMonstera · 12/06/2023 15:24

I think it was petty of them. It’s a glass. Pretty sure it wouldn’t cost £5 either.

Dh and I stayed in a cottage with family and 2 glasses broke - one whilst washing up, the other accidentally knocked off a coffee table by the dog. I just messaged the owner to apologise, she said not to worry as they always have spares.

GracePalmer33 · 12/06/2023 15:19

LookItsMeAgain · 12/06/2023 13:39

I don't think breaking a glass goes in under the umbrella of 'normal wear and tear'.
They provide plates, cutlery and glass wear for their guests to use. If each guest broke just one glass and didn't leave some form of compensation, then after 6 or eight guests, they'd be out of glasses. Not normal wear and tear.

Also, lots of these places have a guest information pack (a printed folder with details of tv channels etc.) and usually in that it would include details of what to do if you do break something.

On this matter, I'm completely with the "arsey" owners who you disagree with @OtterlyMad. You should replace the glass.

You should know that if you break something, you should do your best at replacing it, in general. If a friend was visiting you and they broke one of your wine glasses, would you expect them to replace it or find a suitable replacement or pay for the breakage? I would.

My god... would I expect a friend to pay me for a broken glass? Absolutely NOT! Cringe. Tacky. Tight.

Susuwatariandkodama · 12/06/2023 15:17

You can get them for 50p in a supermarket! 😂 I wouldn’t think anymore of it, it was an accident and you informed them.

Spanielsarepainless · 12/06/2023 15:16

The cottage we use regularly says to tell the owners so they can get a replacement. I broke a mug and even though there was a hardware shop within fifty yards they didn't ask me to buy another.

GracePalmer33 · 12/06/2023 15:08

Jaxhog · 12/06/2023 12:11

It's all very well to call the landlord 'petty', but where does it end? Would you expect a hotel to overlook it?

No, if you break it, you replace it or pay for a replacement. End of.

I definitely would not expect to pay to replace a broken wine glass or water glass in a hotel.
I wouldn't pay to replace one in a restaurant. Small accidents like that happen. I have never been to a hotel that was trying to charge for a broken small item like that.

GracePalmer33 · 12/06/2023 15:05

@SunnySaturdayMorning you are outrageous!