Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I dated a man whilst Husband and I split

41 replies

bigmistake12 · 12/06/2023 03:21

This is a really long story so I'll keep it as short as possible, I've also changed username.

DH and I suffered years of infertility, we did IVF etc to no avail. I have endometriosis and I fell into a deep depression. I refused help to the point where DH didn't know what to do to help me anymore, I wouldn't get out of bed, see a dr, go to counselling. I just wanted to die.

He left me, for his own sanity, I understand how difficult it was now for him to walk away but at the time I felt abandoned and heartbroken.

I moved in with my parents for a year, I stayed as an inpatient for my depression after 2 suicide attempts in a psychiatric hospital where I finally got the help I needed.

DH kept in touch to see how I was doing etc.

When I came out, I think I just lost my head a little bit and I met a man on Tinder. He was lovely to begin with then I realised he had massive anger issues (I didn't know he was using steroids and cocaine on nights out with friends and I've never touched drugs, massive no no for me) and it got to the point where one night he was in such a bad mood that I had to sit in his bath pretending I had bad period pain until I heard him snoring. I text my aunt to let her know his address and said if I hadn't text her by 10am to say that I was back at my parents then please come to his house or call me to make out there was a family emergency and I had to go home. I went to bed and when he left for work that morning I packed my stuff and never went back. Over the next couple of months I received quite nasty texts from him and I thanked my lucky stars I saw sense and left when I did.

When I was with him, he'd do little things and I'd think "DH would never have spoke to me like that/did that" and found myself missing him more than ever.

After it ended, DH asked if I'd like to try marriage counselling. We did and worked at it for months and came back stronger than ever. We moved back in together and I've recently given birth to our beautiful miracle DD. We are happier than ever, counselling helped him understand my depression and anxiety from my childhood, and it helped me understand that it wasn't easy for him to live with.

He's never found out about the guy I was seeing, I thought I could put it to the back of my mind but since having our daughter, it plays on my mind so much. The guilt is horrible. I didn't cheat, we weren't together but I've heard from his friends that he was in a really bad place when he left me and they knew we'd end up back together because he wasn't interested in anyone or anything but me and how I was doing.

I'm not sure what I do, my Dad and Stepmum obviously know about other guy as I was staying at his whilst living with them. They warned me off but ultimately they could see that I had a "new lease of life" as such as and my Dad loves my DH and always hoped we'd be back together one day so he was relieved when I never saw other guy again.

Like k said, we are better than ever. I feel supported, we have date nights now, I enjoy going on days out with him which I never did as I didn't want to leave the house, he's a fantastic dad and Husband and I realise now what I would have lost permanently if he'd of found out.

Do I tell him? And deal with the repercussions? Do I forget it and forgive myself and move on with my family? It's eating my alive and I don't know what to do for the best.

OP posts:
tackling · 12/06/2023 07:08

I don't think you're just going to be able to forget this OP - I don't think I'd be able to keep it a secret either, and I wouldn't want to.

However I agree that I don't get the blame posts either - the person you trusted most in the world left you, presumably after a lifetime of trust issues because of your mum, and you were recovering from depression. You didn't do anything "wrong" to date someone new.

Can I suggest personal therapy to focus on your issues and needs first?

Then you can plan the most sensitive way of telling him if you choose to? It might be at that point that couples therapy again could be helpful, maybe even with your original therapist?

Doingmybest12 · 12/06/2023 07:05

Your op doesn't give a time frame for all this or a sense of if you both stayed locally or you moved away while you were apart. If he always hoped and waited for reunification and if you stayed locally to him I expect he knows , if he hasn't directly asked you I don't think he wants to know/doesn't care. You'd broken up, you were dreadfully ill. You've moved on.

MadamWhiteleigh · 12/06/2023 06:54

What are the chances he will find out from someone else?

Freefall212 · 12/06/2023 06:53

colddrytoast · 12/06/2023 06:49

I don't understand the 'don't tell him' posts.

He could easily find out at any time from someone else with just an accidental slip of the tongue? He'd left you so you were a free agent at the time, and suffering greatly, feeling abandoned by him.

So what if you met someone else, even sought out someone else? If you try to keep this secret then what is that going to do to your head long term?

The other man just made you realise what you had lost with your lovely DH. If he had turned out to be a huge deal then you might well feel you legitimately have something to hide, but he wasn't. He was a lucky escape, and I'm not sure that your brief affair with him constitutes a secret that merits being important enough to hide if you see what I mean.

Your DH would be so much more hurt if he finds out accidentally and he won't be able to listen properly to your side then, as he will think you are hiding something from him, crucially because there is something worth hiding.

Don't underestimate the psychological impact of being abandoned by your husband especially in the state you were in at the time. You might understand intellectually why he left in retrospect, but your emotions would have been overwhelmingly fucked up at the time as you were very vulnerable and DH by leaving you played his part in that.

You understand him and where he was coming from at the time, now he needs to understand the full impact it had on you, so carefully address this issue and then you can get on with life in the present. (Very carefully, but still do it for your sake.)

Her DH did exactly what the advice is on here all the time. To leave when someone's mental health is having a major impact on you and they won't do anything to deal with it. He didn't abandon her. He got himself out of what was a very unhealthy and potentially harmful situation - and as I said, it is what is ALWAYS told to posters to do themselves.

Op choosing to get with someone else is 100% on her. She is an adult who can make her own decisions. He didn't make her do it. Do we really want to start making someone else resposible for how another person feels and acts. That someone's anger and abusive actions are the fault of the person who made them feel that way? That is a very dangerous road to go down.

I do agree that if there is nothing to hide, given they were both on board with a separation and had no intention at the time of getting back togetehr and this was rthe marriage ending, that keeping it from him as though it was wrong and that it is something to hide will majorly backfire.

colddrytoast · 12/06/2023 06:49

I don't understand the 'don't tell him' posts.

He could easily find out at any time from someone else with just an accidental slip of the tongue? He'd left you so you were a free agent at the time, and suffering greatly, feeling abandoned by him.

So what if you met someone else, even sought out someone else? If you try to keep this secret then what is that going to do to your head long term?

The other man just made you realise what you had lost with your lovely DH. If he had turned out to be a huge deal then you might well feel you legitimately have something to hide, but he wasn't. He was a lucky escape, and I'm not sure that your brief affair with him constitutes a secret that merits being important enough to hide if you see what I mean.

Your DH would be so much more hurt if he finds out accidentally and he won't be able to listen properly to your side then, as he will think you are hiding something from him, crucially because there is something worth hiding.

Don't underestimate the psychological impact of being abandoned by your husband especially in the state you were in at the time. You might understand intellectually why he left in retrospect, but your emotions would have been overwhelmingly fucked up at the time as you were very vulnerable and DH by leaving you played his part in that.

You understand him and where he was coming from at the time, now he needs to understand the full impact it had on you, so carefully address this issue and then you can get on with life in the present. (Very carefully, but still do it for your sake.)

WalterWitty · 12/06/2023 06:25

OP it’s doubtful your DH was celibate for the 12 months you were split. Do you want to know about his dates?

Freefall212 · 12/06/2023 06:19

It seems there is a chance he will find out given all the people who knew that are still in your life. You can't ask them to lie or keep a secret for you.

You were still married and the instant you had a chance you went on apps and got with other men. That isn't really related to having depression. It could be related to the childhood sexual abuse and trauma you had but it was still your decision to do.

I know people on here will always tell you to never tell anything, keep it to yourself (even with cheating while married and together) but you are the one who has to decide what you want to do. Do you want to live with this anxiety of knowing he can find out any day from someone else - that will likely end the marriage for sure. Or you can talk to a therapist to discuss it and see how might be the best way to tell him that would do the least damage.

Parky04 · 12/06/2023 06:09

If he was interested he would've asked if you saw someone during the break up. I would just forget about it as you still have a lot to deal with.

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 12/06/2023 05:51

I'd usually say tell him/her, but morally you didn't do anything wrong and telling him would only cause harm to him and your DD. He deserves not to know.

WildFlowerBees · 12/06/2023 05:38

Forget about it and focus on the present, you're in a good place so why try and sabotage that? It's not fair to knowingly hurt someone to absolve yourself of guilt. If you were going to tell him the time would've been when you first discussed getting back together. That ship has sailed.

JandalsAlways · 12/06/2023 03:48

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 12/06/2023 03:24

You can't tell him to make yourself feel better. Chalk it up as part of your illness and move on.

I think this is a good point. People often do this to make themselves feel better even though it's worse for the recipient of the information. Forget about it. The time for telling him has gone.

bigmistake12 · 12/06/2023 03:33

I think I might go back to counselling anyway as having a daughter has bought back awful memories of the CSA I suffered at the hands of my mum's drug dealers. I'm petrified somebody will hurt her. So I don't think this would be a bad idea anyway. Thank you.

OP posts:
stayflufft · 12/06/2023 03:32

Chalk it up to the past and move on OP. Enjoy your beautiful DD and renewed relationship with DH. It was a blip, you weren’t together. Seek counselling if necessary.

bigmistake12 · 12/06/2023 03:32

I don't think we'd be able to come back from the fact that I didn't tell him asap and when we were in counselling and to split my family up over a terrible mistake and point in my life fills me with horror. He absolutely dotes on our DD and he makes a point of sitting for an hour every week to discuss how I'm feeling/if I need more support etc. our communication is amazing now and drs finally have me on the right antidepressants. I've never felt better, even with a 4 week old. Life feels like a dream, this is all I've ever wanted. I know deep down I need to keep quiet but how do I forgive myself?!

OP posts:
bigmistake12 · 12/06/2023 03:26

I understand your point, I just feel like I'm living a lie by not telling him about what happened and he doesn't deserve that. It's the biggest regret of my life and I honestly don't know what I was thinking other than I was utterly heartbroken and got caught up in the excitement and attention.

OP posts:
AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 12/06/2023 03:24

You can't tell him to make yourself feel better. Chalk it up as part of your illness and move on.