Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have felt betrayed by my friend?

139 replies

MammaDaisy · 11/06/2023 21:30

I have been friends with Marie for over 30 years. Long term school friends and then adult friends, living in same town- do a lot together and our children grew up together.

So you can imagine our delight when her DS and my DD started dating each other 5 years ago- both in their mid twenties. It went incredibly well to begin with, and me and my friend were really happy that not only our kids were happy but at the thought of future shared grandchildren etc.

Anyway, last year things turned a little sour when her DS cheated on my DD. It came completely out of the blue for DD the cheating, although she did admit that their relationship had been rocky for a while. Things were bad between them so her DS stayed in their flat and we welcomed DD home with us. We hoped they’d either find their way back together or find a way to split more amicably but we tried not to get involved.

That was until around two months after their split, when I found that Marie had not only known her son was cheating on DD for at least a few months but had also welcomed this woman into her home a few times- and within around four months of DD coming home to live with us- her DS had moved this woman into the flat he used to share with DD.

Now, I’ve been sort of giving Marie the cold shoulder since then- though our DH’s have seen each other a few times. She’s messaged asking to meet but I can’t help but feel a bit betrayed? It hasn’t helped that DD’s mental health has taken such a hit and having her home and witnessing her heartbreak has been hard. DD has said she wouldn’t mind me seeing Marie as I didn’t want to upset her but I don’t know.

Marie has continually messaged and asked that we don’t fall out over the “kids” and that she wants to meet for coffee to talk? So I guess WWYD?

OP posts:
HotelWoes · 11/06/2023 23:21

The way I see it…life is too short for being taken for a cunt. Plenty of nice people in the world without having to be friends with the ones who aren’t nice.

Channellingsophistication · 11/06/2023 23:20

I couldnt forgive her allowing her DS to bring OW home knowing he hadnt broken it off with your DD…. Thats really not on. I’d check this was definitely the case that she knew though.

jacks11 · 11/06/2023 23:16

I think it depends on what, exactly, she knew and what “welcomed the OW into her home” entailed. I might be tempted to hear her out (you might find the situation is not quite as you think, either for better or worse) and make a judgement based on that. But, if you don’t want to as you’ve decided that you can’t move past it no matter what she says (even if the situation is not as you thought) then I would just let her know and ask her to stop contacting you.

As to whether it is forgiveable, I think it depends. She is not responsible for her son’s cheating on your DD. And honestly, she was never going to tell your DD or you about her son’s behaviour (would you have told her if it was the other way round, especially if you thought it might impact on your relationship with your daughter?). For all you know she did tell him that she thought he should tell your DD, but she couldn’t make him do anything and interfering more directly could have had major repercussions within her family. I don’t think I’d end a friendship because of that, though perhaps it’s never be what it was.

When you say she had welcomed this woman into her home- did she know she was the OW from the outset? Or was she introduced as a friend or something? I can see how it could happen- son brings a friend, she thinks nothing of it but then twigs what’s going on but feels stuck in the middle. Maybe getting pressure from her husband or other family members? Who knows. Not saying it’s ok or right, but I can see that she might have been in a difficult position.

all that said, you don’t have to hear her out, far less forgive her, if you don’t want to. I guess it depends on how much you let friendship means and whether you want to try to salvage it. And, probably more crucially, whether you think your DD would really be ok with you continuing the friendship.

determinedtomakethiswork · 11/06/2023 23:14

Summerfun54321 · 11/06/2023 22:36

They are mid 20s. Not married with kids. It's a mother's role to not judge and allow their child to find their best match, not to force a relationship purely due to convenience. He wasn't right for your DD but apart from him ending it in a shitty way, this heartbreak wouldn't have been avoidable. There is no way Marie could have saved your DD from being hurt or upset.

But Marie was welcoming the new woman into her home, while her son was still with his girlfriend. That's what's unforgivable.

FuckNuggets · 11/06/2023 23:13

IsThereAnEchoInHere · 11/06/2023 22:07

Meh 🤷🏽‍♀️
It was just mundane cheating.
Maybe sucks, but it’s so common that who cares?
I wouldn’t lose such a long friendship over so silly thing.

So mundane it's affected her dd's mental health. Have you ever been cheated on? How would you feel if someone said, "meh, it's just mundane cheating, get over it"? 🙄

knockyknees · 11/06/2023 23:13

Marie would be dead to me after she facilitated in the betrayal of my child.

Your daughter has to come first, and both you AND your husband need to show her that you have her back, by cutting off this vile family.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/06/2023 23:12

I do think you should hear her out. On the face of it I can understand how betrayed you feel but there may be an angle you’re not aware of. She may well have been furious with him but not felt able to challenge him for reasons you don’t know.

I would at least hear her side of it before throwing away a three decade friendship.

CoffeeBean5 · 11/06/2023 23:12

Marie knew her that her shitty son was cheating on your daughter. A true friend would’ve told you. Marie kept quiet. I would tell Marie that she should’ve told your Dd that her son was cheating on her and saved the humiliation of this going on for so long. I wouldn’t forgive her for humiliating your Dd.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 11/06/2023 23:11

I wouldn't see her for a while and explain why. When your daughter is happy with a new man, perhaps you could see the old friend again, but now this would be too painful for your daughter.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 11/06/2023 23:08

I would not meet with her or continue the friendship.

Hankunamatata · 11/06/2023 23:05

I would meet her and hear her out.

Tbh she was in a no win situation. She tells you and your dd, her son possibly cuts her off. She doesn't tell you then you cut her off. Who know she may have had the - you have to tell her chats with her son.

I don't think your friendship will recover but I'd hear her side.

ClairDeLaLune · 11/06/2023 23:02

I couldn’t continue the friendship. She betrayed your daughter in a dreadful way. I’d put my daughter first, in your shoes.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 11/06/2023 22:59

MammaDaisy · 11/06/2023 21:34

Sorry if I didn’t make it clear in my post. She was welcoming the new woman while my DD and her son were still together.

and of course not, I’m not expecting her to disown her son.

I was initially in agreement with @MeMyCatsAndMyBooks but your update makes m change my mind. If she knew he was cheating before they broke up and welcomed the other woman then that would be it. Whilst she cannot force him to remain with your daughter I would expect her to tell him he was wrong and if he didn’t want to be with your DD anymore he should end it not cheat behind her back.

MrsPerfect12 · 11/06/2023 22:58

Mammamia2023 · 11/06/2023 22:22

Hi Marie, no we shouldn’t fall out over the kids. The reason why I am avoiding you is that I am devastated and hurt that YOU knew this affair was happening and didn’t tell me or dd. The cheating, the breakup is all things I can deal with. What I am struggling to comprehend is how I can get past my supposed friend knowing that my dd was being cheated on and during that time instead of standing up for what was right welcoming her into your home whilst ur ds still lived with my her?! You try explaining that to me.

This x 100

Beautiful3 · 11/06/2023 22:56

All she had to do was tell her son not to bring another girlfriend over, until he broke up with your daughter. But no, she welcomed the new girlfriend over, and knew he was going to move her into the flat! With friends like her, who needs enemies. I think that's really bad, I'm sure you wouldn't have done the same to her.

mainsfed · 11/06/2023 22:56

Trying2understand · 11/06/2023 22:45

I see your point fully OP. It isn't that they broke up, it's that she seems to have enabled the cheating. Having said that I wonder if she did tell her son it wasn't okay and suggested he come clean? But then if she did she may at least say to you over text she was very sorry to see how things turned out. It's hard to know if she addressed cheating with her son or not. If she did I'd be inclined to keep the friendship. If she didn't, it would be hard to put behind you.

What about an honest text:

'Thanks for the text, Marie. I'm sorry I've been quiet. Our friendship has meant a lot to me and I agree our dc dating and/or ending their relationship doesn't need to impact our friendship. We were dear friends before they were even born! However, what has been hard for me is it appears you knew your son was cheating and while he was still with my daughter, who I know you care about, welcomed him and the person he was cheating with. I'm sure you can understand why that feels hard to ignore and knowing how much you love your son if the tables were turned and it was my DD cheating, I'm sure you'd be hurt on his behalf if I welcomed them into my home knowing she was cheating.

I do want our friendship to continue, I'm just struggling with these feelings right now. Your family means a lot to us too and it would be sad for things to end decades of friendship.

I may need a bit more time and will be in touch soon. Maybe we could meet for coffee and either agree to talk this through or just move on from it so it doesn't impact things going forward'.

After you send something like that if she gets sulky or defending her son, you kind of have your answer.

Really sorry your DD went through this. Must be painful!

Like it!

flimsywhimsy · 11/06/2023 22:54

She should have told her son he needed to end things with your daughter rather than going behind her back. But maybe she did... It wasn't an easy situation for her, I imagine, though of course it's much worse for your daughter. I think your friend is being a bit naïve if she thinks the friendship can go on exactly as before. This new history will inevitably have an effect on your friendship, even if you try to get past it.

Sometimeswinning · 11/06/2023 22:52

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 11/06/2023 21:32

Of course Marie is going to have to welcome the "new woman", that's her son what do you expect her to do? Disown him.

She's right, you shouldn't allow it to effect your friendship. She didn't force him to cheat, it's not her fault about your daughter neither. It's not fair to punish her.

Are you Marie? Or did you just not read the op?

It's a no brainer. Loyalty is the most important part of a friendship. She wasn't just disloyal to you she facilitated an affair which has badly affected your daughter. I wouldn't give her the time of day!

Natty13 · 11/06/2023 22:50

I'd tell her you aren't falling out over the "kids", you just have no interest in a friendship with someone who has no loyalty"

The knowing about her DS cheating was bad enough BUT TO BOOT having the other girl round would be the end of any friendship for me. I wouldn't want to be friends with someone who did that to a woman who wasn't my daughter either.

Trying2understand · 11/06/2023 22:45

I see your point fully OP. It isn't that they broke up, it's that she seems to have enabled the cheating. Having said that I wonder if she did tell her son it wasn't okay and suggested he come clean? But then if she did she may at least say to you over text she was very sorry to see how things turned out. It's hard to know if she addressed cheating with her son or not. If she did I'd be inclined to keep the friendship. If she didn't, it would be hard to put behind you.

What about an honest text:

'Thanks for the text, Marie. I'm sorry I've been quiet. Our friendship has meant a lot to me and I agree our dc dating and/or ending their relationship doesn't need to impact our friendship. We were dear friends before they were even born! However, what has been hard for me is it appears you knew your son was cheating and while he was still with my daughter, who I know you care about, welcomed him and the person he was cheating with. I'm sure you can understand why that feels hard to ignore and knowing how much you love your son if the tables were turned and it was my DD cheating, I'm sure you'd be hurt on his behalf if I welcomed them into my home knowing she was cheating.

I do want our friendship to continue, I'm just struggling with these feelings right now. Your family means a lot to us too and it would be sad for things to end decades of friendship.

I may need a bit more time and will be in touch soon. Maybe we could meet for coffee and either agree to talk this through or just move on from it so it doesn't impact things going forward'.

After you send something like that if she gets sulky or defending her son, you kind of have your answer.

Really sorry your DD went through this. Must be painful!

JustMaggie · 11/06/2023 22:45

No, i would end the relationship with her. What she did was plain wrong, no if's no but's no coconuts.

Justalittlebitduckling · 11/06/2023 22:44

Personally I don’t think I’d be able to let that go.

Soapyspuds · 11/06/2023 22:43

She put her son above your family. Not nice given what he was doing but her loyalty will be to her son above you.

However, if you never speak to her again that is completely understandable.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 11/06/2023 22:43

I would hear here out before ending a 30 year friendship.

I doubt it will make any difference but I would. She couldn't stop him cheating, she couldn't force him to tell your daughter or tel her directly but I would expect her not to allow the OW into her home until her son dealt with the situation properly.

Dooopylally · 11/06/2023 22:42

You don't get many friendships in your life that last for over 30 years.