Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Our local Catholic church doesn't want us there. I can't understand why

454 replies

BlueMediterranean · 11/06/2023 20:21

Hi everyone,

I wanted to share an issue my partner and I have been facing at our local Catholic church and get your thoughts on it. We moved to a new city about a year and a half ago and bought a house here. The schools in the area are somewhat average, and the best one by far is a Catholic school. Being Catholics ourselves, we thought we wouldn't have any issues.

Initially, we didn't attend church because I was heavily pregnant, and after that, I experienced postpartum depression, which made it difficult for me to feel comfortable leaving the house with my baby. However, my partner started going to the evening mass on Sundays instead of the morning one. We officially registered with the church when we moved here.

After about 6-7 months, I joined him at the evening mass. From the very beginning, we found it strange that the priest never greeted anyone. As soon as he finished his sermon, he would disappear. Everyone would leave, and there was no socializing whatsoever.

One day, we went to talk to him about baptizing our baby, but he told us that he didn't know us well enough and asked us to continue attending the mass. We found this odd but decided to keep going. A few months later, we asked again, and he gave us the same response. In fact, he didn't remember us and thought we wanted to register as new members.

That's when we started to worry. If the priest never greets anyone and leaves immediately after the sermon, how can he get to know anyone? We could attend mass for years, and he wouldn't even know our names.

We had to rearrange some personal commitments to attend the Sunday morning mass to see if things were different, but he still doesn't greet anyone. We persisted in asking about the baptism and were given the contact information of a church volunteer who organizes the baptism course. Unfortunately, our emails to this person have gone unanswered, and when we asked in person, they claimed not to have received them.

I am truly baffled by all of this. Why does the church ignore us in this manner? I am now worried about how we'll obtain the necessary paperwork to register our daughter at the Catholic school if they won't even baptize her.

There must be a reason behind all of this, but I honestly can't comprehend it. I have considered volunteering, but both my partner and I work full-time jobs, which makes it challenging.

If anyone has any insights or suggestions, please share them. We would greatly appreciate it.

Thank you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LBFseBrom · 16/12/2023 08:41

Mumof2teens79 · 26/06/2023 23:12

Seems likely that most new couples attending only do so for the baptism/schools and they are trying to discourage this

Oh yes, I get that and it's awful, however I didn't think the op was attending the church in order for her child to be admitted to the nearest Catholic school (& it doesn't automatically follow anyway, schools can only admit so many). I knew a couple with two children who went to a nearby Catholic primary, quite a good one actually but these parents, who went to church, were not all that happy with it. They moved to another house and had their children admitted to a local CofE school which was considered 'outstanding, then started going to the CofE - even became school governors! I kid you not and it took a long time for me to twig as they were previously so involved with the local Catholic church and primary school.

However, I did not know that a priest was allowed to refuse to baptise a child. On the contrary, the church is usually keen to bring children into the fold. I also didn't realise the op is not married. Of course you don't have to be married and it's normal for couples to live together and sometimes have a child or children without being married; however, most church goers do believe in marriage and the parish priest certainly will.

As the op only has a young baby she surely doesn't have to worry too much about schools just yet and, as I suggested earlier on, if she is not happy with her parish church she can surely find another not too far away. She did say that would mean another postcode but, honestly, would that matter as long as it isn't too far and if she liked the atmosphere of the church more? Lots of people go to churches in the next town or village for all sorts of reasons.

LBFseBrom · 15/12/2023 17:42

Is there another Catholic church not far away that you could try? Near me there are a couple or three and all quite different in atmosphere and in their clergy's outlook.

I think it is bad that you are not made more welcome, frankly. A church should be inclusive and cater for all tastes.

Over the years, I have come across a few people who have felt obliged to leave a particular church congregation (not Catholic), and have felt hurt by the church but could never quite work out why and did not want to pry. I've also heard someone say that they breathed a sigh of relief when a family left their church which sounds awful but it was a quite reasonable and friendly person who said it.

All I can is, "Different strokes for different folks". It could be OK if you stick it out for a bit but only you can judge. I also think it should not matter which Mass you attend. I used to regularly go to a Saturday evening one, 'First Mass of the Sabbath', and nobody batted an eyelid. It was well attended.

Good luck, you seem sincere and that is what counts.

Mumof2teens79 · 26/06/2023 23:12

Seems likely that most new couples attending only do so for the baptism/schools and they are trying to discourage this

Noodles1234 · 15/06/2023 22:03

Also need to add, churches often need to see regular attendance at church for 1 year or can be more. If there is a kids club they often require child to attend for a minimum amount of time. This all may seem overbearing, but when they can be inundated by new parents wanting forms signed you can see they have to do something.
apparently 25% of primary schools are religious and only a much smaller % of secondaries. Catholic schools are a smaller % of this and are often well sought after by parents and rival private schools.

DorritLittle · 15/06/2023 18:56

I always called it the sermon but it was listed as homily on the newsletter which I studied in depth instead of listening to it!

DorritLittle · 15/06/2023 18:55

I was baptised catholic at about two weeks old and stopped going at 18. I was not married when I had DD and yet she was baptised without query, and the same priest then married us later on - he was very old school (e.g read us a letter of St Paul at the marriage class - helpful) and has some bigwig priest job, so it really doesn’t usually matter. We barely go to mass but even so, I get asked when my son is making his first communion as though we’re regulars.

Oh and I also didn’t know what transubstantiation was, as in hadn’t heard that word, til I was an adult (didn’t do catholic school and vetoed them for my kids). I do remember at FC classes being told it was now the body and blood and being ‘ooh wow’. But I was six and I’m afraid that awe soon wore off.

DeanElderberry · 15/06/2023 15:58

I think the OP used the word sermon to describe the whole Mass, which is a little odd (as variants on the word Mass, derived from Latin, are used in most languages), but hey, if English isn't their first language they did a lot better than I would.

mathanxiety · 15/06/2023 15:43

Holy Communion is always after the gospel/sermon/homily. It was confusing for regular mass attendees as the priest and congregation leaving at this point, before Holy Communion, would be utterly bizarre. If this is happening at the OP's church, it should definitely be reported to the bishop (which many of us have suggested).

Agree the leaving after the sermon/homily is bizarre.

The Rite of Communion is after the Eucharistic Prayer and Consecration, well after the Gospel and sermon/homily.

highlandcoos · 15/06/2023 10:01

Hollyppp · 13/06/2023 23:14

I think the not married thing shows you are not serious about Catholicism

This. And taking part in all the relevant Sacraments.

PinkIcedCream · 15/06/2023 08:55

We’re not Catholic but our son went to the local Catholic primary school, because we live in Ireland, and it was our nearest National school.

I only go to the church if there’s something school related happening (as I’m not religious), but there’s no way you’d be ignored by the other church members here, especially with a cute baby. The other families always hang around outside for ages chatting and they’re very nosey so they’d be quizzing you about your family etc. till the cows come home.

I think you’d be better off trying to find another friendlier church and forget this one.

CriticalAlert · 14/06/2023 18:32

Has the priest found out that you are Satanists?

Nutterjacks · 14/06/2023 09:49

Ok so you're not married.

Are both you and your partner Catholic?

I ask this because my daughter and her partner had no problem having their daughter baptised. (They are both catholic).

I too find it strange that the priest doesn't socialise with the parishioners after mass. Our priests have always stood by the door and shook hands with the congregation on their way out.

Try and get involved in parish activities, there's usually always something going on.
Maybe also arrange a meeting with the schools headteacher for some insight.

goldierocks · 14/06/2023 09:30

"I went to Catholic schools and wouldn't know that sermon isnt correct. I don't see what difference that makes to your post anyway."

Hi @IndiaRose22 just to answer your question. The OP said this:

"As soon as he finished his sermon, he would disappear. Everyone would leave, and there was no socializing whatsoever."

The sermon/homily is given by the priest/celebrant immediately after the gospel. In a Catholic mass, this happens in the first third of service, approx 10-15 mins after it starts.

Holy Communion is always after the gospel/sermon/homily. It was confusing for regular mass attendees as the priest and congregation leaving at this point, before Holy Communion, would be utterly bizarre. If this is happening at the OP's church, it should definitely be reported to the bishop (which many of us have suggested).

It's been fascinating to read everyone's experience of their Catholic church and how they differ. It's abdundently clear the 'strictness' of the parish priest varies massively between parishes. The OP may have a completely different experience at another Catholic church.

The word 'Catholic' means 'universal'. No parent(s) should be denied the sacrament of Baptism for their child purely on the basis of their marital status. The official guidance says:

"Baptism should not be denied if the parent(s) are unmarried or not married in the Roman Catholic Church. However, there may be reason to postpone Baptism if parents are not practicing the Faith, or have no intention of living a Catholic life in harmony with the Gospel."

notokaywiththetropes · 14/06/2023 09:18

PaigeMatthews · 11/06/2023 22:56

I know a lot of people are focused on the word sermon. But ive never in over 40 years of going to regular mass, and working with the Church, including briefly in a convent, heard it referred to as a sermon in an RC church. It is a homily.

It's a sermon in all the RC churches I've ever been in. Google it and you will find podcasts of Catholic sermons, much talk of catholic sermons.

And I never knew of a Catholic church who actually cared who was married or not, for the people who think its that. It's not that.

StormShadow · 14/06/2023 09:10

Lissadell · 13/06/2023 23:22

It really isn’t. Posters on this thread have some very peculiar ideas about Catholicism.

Not remotely my experience either. Mind you, couldn't really be an issue round our way or there really would be nobody in the churches. Nor do the Catholic schools have any requirements about being practicing!

But British Catholics are a really broad spectrum. There are people who are very religious, and there are others for whom it's more of a cultural identity. We're hearing from both ends in this thread.

PostOpOp · 14/06/2023 08:39

Hollyppp · 13/06/2023 23:14

I think the not married thing shows you are not serious about Catholicism

This.

If you don't understand why the Catholic Church isn't happy/comfortable/accepting regarding you not being married, then you're missing something important.

I'm not Catholic but DH is. We had to go through a marriage preparation course and while the priest was very nice and the discussions were interesting, it was clear how central marriage is to Catholic family. It was really a non negotiable. When my children were baptised, the fact we were married was clearly more important than our church attendance (don't attend) or that I'm not Catholic.

I reckon he thinks you're playing pick and choose with the religion.

user1493379562 · 14/06/2023 06:40

I am a very very lapsed Catholic. In fact I don't practice any religion now. When my mother married my father (mother Catholic, Father C of E) many many years ago they got married in a registry office. My mother had moved away from home and married my father in his home town. When they came back to my mother's home time the local priest couldn't get them into church quick enough to give them a blessing as in the churches eyes they were living in sin. My mother was told the children had to be brought up as Catholics. My eldest brother indeed went to a Catholic school but the rest of us attended state schools.
Years later my mother was working in a care home for the elderly where she saw the old priest talking to an elderly lady in the corridor. He saw my mother and asked 'Was she one of ours?'
My mother replied 'If you mean is she a Catholic, then no Father!' To which the priest dismissed the elderly lady and walked away. My mother was disgusted!
I don't know if attitudes have changed over the years.

sashh · 14/06/2023 03:59

Platypuslover · 13/06/2023 18:25

Unless it’s a private school the same admission criteria apply as for all other schools. And living right by the school in some areas you are still out of catchment. Amd there could well be a load of older siblings they don’t know about for their precious only child/first born.

under equality law any school that is not a public school is not allowed to discriminate on account of religion. And putting you higher on the list on acct of religion would be positive discrimination.

That's not true.

There are exceptions in Equality legislation for religious observance and RC schools, along with Jewish, Muslim, Hindu etc schools can discriminate both in school places and in the staff they employ in some roles.

So an RC school can give preference to an RC teacher when recruiting teachers but not with cleaners or other staff.

Oh the day the catering staff at my school didn't know it was a day of abstinence and cooked meat.

Sr Mary Joseph had to call the bishop to give us a, well I don't know what, permission to eat meat.

Anyway we all had to go to the hall before the angelus bell to be told we were to eat the meat.

Yes we had an angelus bell. No I was not brought up in Ireland.

Lissadell · 13/06/2023 23:22

SteveBuscemisRheumyEye · 13/06/2023 22:18

Just seen you're not married. Are you planning to get married? Sorry, but it IS a big deal for Catholics. Can't have it both ways.

It really isn’t. Posters on this thread have some very peculiar ideas about Catholicism.

Hollyppp · 13/06/2023 23:14

I think the not married thing shows you are not serious about Catholicism

SteveBuscemisRheumyEye · 13/06/2023 22:24

And you say you're Catholic, but in the nicest possible way, it doesn't sound like either of you are "practising".

Just rocking up to mass occasionally isn't it.

Yes, Catholics have lots of rules and ways of being. But, they are what they are. If you want to BE Catholic you have to love like one. You have to take the sacrament of marriage. It's not modern and it's not inclusive, but it very much is what it is.

Sunday and Holy Day mass, unless you're physically incapable, is the absolute minimum.

SteveBuscemisRheumyEye · 13/06/2023 22:18

Just seen you're not married. Are you planning to get married? Sorry, but it IS a big deal for Catholics. Can't have it both ways.

SteveBuscemisRheumyEye · 13/06/2023 22:15

After the sermon? Are you sure?

The "main" part of mass is the Liturgy of the Eucharist, which is after the sermon.

Sure, some priests may not chat after mass on a Sunday, but it's VERY normal for them not to on a weekday, for example.

I mean this kindly, but being pregnant is not an excuse to miss Mass. I'm sorry to hear you had PDN (I did, too 😞), but the expected thing would be to talk to the priest and arrange to have communion at home, if you weren't able to attend.

I'm sorry you've been struggling. Please teach out to your priest. He WILL support, but sounds like you're in one of those areas where people just turn up the the odd Mass in the hope of getting their children into a good school.

nidgey · 13/06/2023 22:09

Platypuslover · 13/06/2023 18:25

Unless it’s a private school the same admission criteria apply as for all other schools. And living right by the school in some areas you are still out of catchment. Amd there could well be a load of older siblings they don’t know about for their precious only child/first born.

under equality law any school that is not a public school is not allowed to discriminate on account of religion. And putting you higher on the list on acct of religion would be positive discrimination.

not true - see the priority list here attached for the Catholic school our ds went to for a while

Our local Catholic church doesn't want us there. I can't understand why
IndiaRose22 · 13/06/2023 21:52

I think people are picking on unnecessary things for pickings sake!

I went to Catholic schools and wouldn't know that sermon isnt correct. I don't see what difference that makes to your post anyway.

Also, my friend had her children all christened Catholic and sent to the local Catholic schools and her and her DP were not even engaged, and still aren't married!

I'd probably try the other one even if it's further away to see what that is like. I now attend CofE and they are so lovely!! The vicar speaks to everyone as they leave, then goes to the church hall for tea and cake with the congregation, and the congregation are so welcoming!