Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parent gifts/Inheritance- unfair?

429 replies

ducksandquackers · 11/06/2023 18:14

I’ll start with a little background, my parents were both from low income families, my dad went on to be a lawyer and my mum a teacher. My dad is now 77 my mum passed away 6 years ago.
I have one brother, he’s 50, I’m 42. He has one daughter who is 18, I have one son who is 8 months.
When my mum passed away my dad sold their home, bought a small one bedroom flat. Never really thought twice about what happened with the money. I guess I assumed it was out away in savings or something similar.
My brother is an accountant, makes £150,000+ a year, his wife passed away 7 years ago, he used her life insurance to pay off their mortgage and has been financially comfortable since. I’m a nurse, my husband a police officer. We aren’t struggling per se but in my family we are the worst off.

We met for a family meal last night, my brother, niece, husband, dad and son. I asked my niece if the new student loan changes would impact her as she’s due to go to uni after summer. She said no, she wouldn’t be getting a student loan. My husband joked asking how she would afford everything then and she said “Grandad gave me money for course fees and Accomodation”. I could tell my dad and brother didn’t want that to be something I knew.
I questioned my brother today. He told me when my dad sold the house, he gave a chunk of the money (£150,000) to my niece. At the time I’d said I’d never have children, so he wanted to give it to his granddaughter now rather than once he’s gone and can’t see her make use of it. My brother and I would get the split of the flat he’s currently in, anything left in pensions and some moneys he’s saved after he passes.
Now when I didn’t have kids this would be fair I think. I get that. But I do have a son now, not only has he missed out on a grandma on my side, and a grandad young enough to be able to play and look after him, he’s missed out on holidays with grandparents and all sorts. But also, he’s missed out on inheritance.
For years my brother has been putting £500-£1000 a month in savings for my niece, so she has a good amount in savings anyway. My husband and I have a mortgage and don’t make enough to save that sort of money for my son. My husbands parents won’t leave much in the way of inheritance and what they do is split between 6 grandkids.

So AIBU to think it’s not fair my niece gets all the money from my parents house? Even if she was the only grandchild at the point of the deal? She isn’t now and surely my son is just as entitled to that as she is? Should I talk to my dad?

OP posts:
Hannahsbananas · 11/06/2023 20:06

Wenfy · 11/06/2023 19:49

View it as your Dad paying in advance for all the help your Brother and his daughter will be providing him as he gets older and focus on enjoying your son now. It’s shit having to focus on a baby and provide care to an ageing parent & now you don’t have to do it.

As for your brother - I think what he did by accepting the full amount for his daughter was despicable. I had kids later than my siblings and there was an inheritance received early that was intended for gc. But my siblings (who had kids) insisted on sharing it equally between ‘parents’ rather than GC & I am the wealthiest one out of them. That is the right thing to do.

This post is both sad and appalling in equal measure.
Imagine living your life on such a transactional basis.

MumFeelingHopeless · 11/06/2023 20:06

Perhaps talk to your Dad about it, if you feel comfortable. It might be like "the elephant in the room" otherwise.

That being said, I also think you should let go of your bitterness. These things happen: my grandfather left my aunt's (who hadn't been to uni yet) kids tens of thousands to pay for their university. Me and my uncle's children were all left a token amount: we're older, but some of us have young children ourselves, others could do with help getting on the property ladder in their late 30s.

As PP have pointed out be grateful for what you have now (a Dad who you can spend time with), be happy for your niece that she won't build up debt going to uni, and when you do inherent be grateful for that. It isn't really fair to ask your niece to share the money as she has likely made her own plans based on the inheritance.

People don't get the same lot in life. Your Dad made his decision, in hind sight it could have been done differently. Don't let the bitterness eat you. If your Dad spent the money elsewhere (like you initially thought) you would still be in the same position you're in now. Stop feeling so hard done by.

In sum, cognitive reframing might help if your Dad has no more money to give.

PrinnyPree · 11/06/2023 20:05

A couple of things going on here, she was his only Grandchild at the time and also she lost her mother at a very young age.

I'll have to say you don't talk very kindly of your DN though OP. :/ Your brother and neice have been through alot, they may be financially comfortable but I bet they'd swap that in a heartbeat to have their wife/mother back.

ACynicalDad · 11/06/2023 20:04

In his position I'd put the first £150k of his estate in a trust for your children, even if you have 2 or 3 I think half going to his son's kids and half to his daughters is fine. Then I'd split all that is left 50/50 but you have no entitlement and your brothers' income and life choices make no difference. I am by far the worst off of my siblings but don't think I should get more to compensate, I may think differently if I also say had a disabled child or was widowed, but not because he chose a path that earns more.

WulyJmpr · 11/06/2023 20:04

Of course they're doing the right thing by not taking out the student loan. It's a 9% hit to her wages for 40 years of her career.

It is no longer a 'good loan to have'- you are way out of date. It is a graduate tax.

Frankly you sound extremely jealous of your niece which will be quite obvious to everyone around you.

Catcactus · 11/06/2023 20:04

YANBU. The money from the sale should have been split between you and your brother and then your brother could have passed his part on to your niece if he wanted.

Strictly1 · 11/06/2023 20:03

Your last post is really mean about a young girl who has lost her mum. Not a good look.

Apricotflanday · 11/06/2023 20:03

Hannahsbananas · 11/06/2023 19:58

I wasn’t putting it forward as an actual solution.
The jealousy of someone earning more is downright weird, though.

It isn't weird, it's natural considering we live in an increasingly unequal society where inequality has been shown to lead to many negative outcomes for society and individuals.

febrezeme · 11/06/2023 20:03

There is 18 year's difference between the cousins - it's another 18 years before yours goes to uni (which they may choose not to do) - sometimes that's just how the cookie crumbles especially when you don't have kids until you are in your 40s and your mum died years before and inheritance was passed on then

whumpthereitis · 11/06/2023 20:02

ducksandquackers · 11/06/2023 19:59

He claims it’s not his money to split, and he won’t be asking my niece to. Our dad gave it to her (she got access to it when she turned 18 a few months ago) as a gift.
So far she’s paid for a trip this summer, plans to pay uni and accommodation with it but hasn’t spend much else of it and has asked her dad to help her with make good use of it.
Ofcourse she hasn’t spent it though as between my brother and dad, one flutter of the eye lashes and she has whatever she wants!!

Feel free to sit and seethe about it I guess 🤷🏻‍♀️

jenandberrys · 11/06/2023 20:02

ducksandquackers · 11/06/2023 19:59

He claims it’s not his money to split, and he won’t be asking my niece to. Our dad gave it to her (she got access to it when she turned 18 a few months ago) as a gift.
So far she’s paid for a trip this summer, plans to pay uni and accommodation with it but hasn’t spend much else of it and has asked her dad to help her with make good use of it.
Ofcourse she hasn’t spent it though as between my brother and dad, one flutter of the eye lashes and she has whatever she wants!!

Being this bitter and jealous of your niece really isn't a good look. Imagine if the rest of the family spoke about your son they way you speak about your niece. Horrible.

sammylady37 · 11/06/2023 20:01

Ofcourse she hasn’t spent it though as between my brother and dad, one flutter of the eye lashes and she has whatever she wants!!

you sound nastier and nastier with every post, tbh

whumpthereitis · 11/06/2023 20:01

Wenfy · 11/06/2023 19:49

View it as your Dad paying in advance for all the help your Brother and his daughter will be providing him as he gets older and focus on enjoying your son now. It’s shit having to focus on a baby and provide care to an ageing parent & now you don’t have to do it.

As for your brother - I think what he did by accepting the full amount for his daughter was despicable. I had kids later than my siblings and there was an inheritance received early that was intended for gc. But my siblings (who had kids) insisted on sharing it equally between ‘parents’ rather than GC & I am the wealthiest one out of them. That is the right thing to do.

LMFAO, more spite aimed at the niece who has done fuck all wrong. Elder care as a punishment for having the audacity to accept money offered. If the grandfather wants to give help to his adult niece that’s up to him, it’s not for OP or her brother to tell him not to.

It may be that it’s never ‘evened up’ between the grandchildren. That’s entirely up to OP’s father. OP and her son aren’t owed money that isn’t theirs.

Apricotflanday · 11/06/2023 20:01

Nothingisblackandwhite · 11/06/2023 19:59

It’s not up to you to decide where that money goes and your dad can not make revision to a child that was not there . What dobrou expect your dada to do now , ask her for the money to give a 8 month baby ? Your child is 8 months you have over a decade to put money aside

£150,000 in a decade? On normal salaries in a cost of living crisis? It would be unusual if they're able to save a tenth of that.

Strictly1 · 11/06/2023 20:01

Your dad did a nice thing which was fair at the time. Things change but getting bitter about it will not end well.
When he dies will you be wanting the value of missed birthday and Christmas gifts or accepting that your choice to have children later means things are different.
I’d let it go or you will only come across as money grabbing.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 11/06/2023 19:59

It’s not up to you to decide where that money goes and your dad can not make revision to a child that was not there . What dobrou expect your dada to do now , ask her for the money to give a 8 month baby ? Your child is 8 months you have over a decade to put money aside

Apricotflanday · 11/06/2023 19:59

Dacadactyl · 11/06/2023 19:56

Well yes, we all need money to survive.

However OPs dad is still alive (and for all we know his circumsatnces may have changed since he gifted his grandaughter the money) And, as I said in the very first post on this thread, he may well have made provision for OPs kids in his will. As it stands, he was told she never wanted kids when he gave the 150k to his only grandchild. An 8 month old baby does not need access to 150k and he could well be planning to even things up when he finally dies.

BIT, even if he doesn't, OP shouldn't fall out with her brother. That would be madness.

I agree. I think the fact it was kept from her intentionally, rather than discussed openly by her father at the time the decision was made, is what is hurtful.

If the OP is able to talk about it with her father and ask if there's any way he can help her child in the future should they need it, that would be sensible, rather than falling out with her brother.

ducksandquackers · 11/06/2023 19:59

Hellenabe · 11/06/2023 19:55

@ducksandquackers what has your brother said? Has he offered to split it?

He claims it’s not his money to split, and he won’t be asking my niece to. Our dad gave it to her (she got access to it when she turned 18 a few months ago) as a gift.
So far she’s paid for a trip this summer, plans to pay uni and accommodation with it but hasn’t spend much else of it and has asked her dad to help her with make good use of it.
Ofcourse she hasn’t spent it though as between my brother and dad, one flutter of the eye lashes and she has whatever she wants!!

OP posts:
Matronic6 · 11/06/2023 19:58

This is a tricky one. Whilst it is very much his prerogative to do what he wants with his money, my family have always taken the 'what you do for one, you have to do for the others.'

It does sound like your brother is the golden child. But he did make the decision based on the information he had at the time. It is still entirely his choice what he does with his money and how he splits the inheritance. So I don't really think you are in the position to raise it. Personally, I think the decent thing would be to gift grandson same or to assign same amount to him in will them the rest split. But it's entirely his prerogative and he's not obliged to. But you can certainly be sad that it seems your son is not going to get the same advantage as your niece.

Riverlee · 11/06/2023 19:58

Although it seems unfair, your grandad did a nice gesture to what he thought was going to be his only grandchild, and wanted to give practical help to her. Yours and your siblings incomes are irrelevant to this.

Hannahsbananas · 11/06/2023 19:58

Apricotflanday · 11/06/2023 19:56

Obviously it's appalling that people in essential and difficult jobs such as nursing don't earn as much, but the solution isn't to have an excess of accountants and an even greater deficit of nurses!

I wasn’t putting it forward as an actual solution.
The jealousy of someone earning more is downright weird, though.

Honeychickpea · 11/06/2023 19:58

Lefteyetwitch · 11/06/2023 19:38

Sometimes on MN I wonder. Are they the golden child. Or are they just likeable as a human compared to the other person?

The bus doesn't go there...

Hannahsbananas · 11/06/2023 19:56

Wenfy · 11/06/2023 19:53

There’s a good chance he became financially comfortable because of his wife’s death - I know quite a few people who have done really well after getting life insurance. But his daughter became financially comfortable because of a grandad who decided to give her all of the inheritance early. That girl has 150k plus another 150k her dad’s been saving for her from his income, plus there is very likely to be insurance money / inheritance from her mum’s family on top.

Meanwhile the grandson gets nothing.

Yet. His Grandfather is alive and kicking.
Although to be fair, yes, his parents have given him nothing.
Maybe op could have a go at her brother about that too? Get him to right that obvious wrong?

Apricotflanday · 11/06/2023 19:56

Hannahsbananas · 11/06/2023 19:51

Because she was bitching about not earning as much as an accountant.
There’s only one answer to that, really.

Obviously it's appalling that people in essential and difficult jobs such as nursing don't earn as much, but the solution isn't to have an excess of accountants and an even greater deficit of nurses!

ssd · 11/06/2023 19:56

Your dad and brother tried to hide it from you as they both know its wrong.