Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parent gifts/Inheritance- unfair?

429 replies

ducksandquackers · 11/06/2023 18:14

I’ll start with a little background, my parents were both from low income families, my dad went on to be a lawyer and my mum a teacher. My dad is now 77 my mum passed away 6 years ago.
I have one brother, he’s 50, I’m 42. He has one daughter who is 18, I have one son who is 8 months.
When my mum passed away my dad sold their home, bought a small one bedroom flat. Never really thought twice about what happened with the money. I guess I assumed it was out away in savings or something similar.
My brother is an accountant, makes £150,000+ a year, his wife passed away 7 years ago, he used her life insurance to pay off their mortgage and has been financially comfortable since. I’m a nurse, my husband a police officer. We aren’t struggling per se but in my family we are the worst off.

We met for a family meal last night, my brother, niece, husband, dad and son. I asked my niece if the new student loan changes would impact her as she’s due to go to uni after summer. She said no, she wouldn’t be getting a student loan. My husband joked asking how she would afford everything then and she said “Grandad gave me money for course fees and Accomodation”. I could tell my dad and brother didn’t want that to be something I knew.
I questioned my brother today. He told me when my dad sold the house, he gave a chunk of the money (£150,000) to my niece. At the time I’d said I’d never have children, so he wanted to give it to his granddaughter now rather than once he’s gone and can’t see her make use of it. My brother and I would get the split of the flat he’s currently in, anything left in pensions and some moneys he’s saved after he passes.
Now when I didn’t have kids this would be fair I think. I get that. But I do have a son now, not only has he missed out on a grandma on my side, and a grandad young enough to be able to play and look after him, he’s missed out on holidays with grandparents and all sorts. But also, he’s missed out on inheritance.
For years my brother has been putting £500-£1000 a month in savings for my niece, so she has a good amount in savings anyway. My husband and I have a mortgage and don’t make enough to save that sort of money for my son. My husbands parents won’t leave much in the way of inheritance and what they do is split between 6 grandkids.

So AIBU to think it’s not fair my niece gets all the money from my parents house? Even if she was the only grandchild at the point of the deal? She isn’t now and surely my son is just as entitled to that as she is? Should I talk to my dad?

OP posts:
HamBone · 11/06/2023 20:42

It’s a crappy outcome for your DS, but given your explanation, I can see how it happened. When he made the gift, your Dad assumed that he’d only have one GC and wanted to give her a substantial gift.

I wouldn’t rule out him leaving a gift to your son when the time comes though, your brother may think that he knows your Dad’s intentions re. his will but he may have added a codicil after your DS was born. Also, as your DS is still a baby, it’s possible that your Dad intends to give him a gift as well?

FrostyFifi · 11/06/2023 20:40

@watermeloncougar I find MN weird about the inheritence thing, like it's the height of entitlement to expect anything. But in the real world of course people are going to feel like shit if they're not treated the same. You'd feel less loved. And if you're less well off to top it off you can't even comfort yourself with maybe the parent was just trying to be financially fair.

Saynowt · 11/06/2023 20:39

@ducksandquackers you have a horrible attitude towards your niece (in fact towards your brother and dad too.) The poor girl presumably lost her mum when she was 11 and then her grandma aged 12. She's using the money she was bequeathed to fund her education and future not piss it up a wall!

Presumably you are regretting your statement about remaining childless. It would be shitty of you to pull your dad up on it now. It's also unfair to blame him for his age / level of involvement (when you had your son was none of his doing!) You also don't know what your Dad is thinking of for your son in the future but he sounds like a caring grandfather somay well try and make some provision for him.

Life isn't always 'fair' just as bereavement isn't.

Hankunamatata · 11/06/2023 20:39

So dn lost her mum at 11. You said you would never have children. Usually I'd say fait split but in this case I cam see why your parents wanted to help dn out

Dacadactyl · 11/06/2023 20:38

ducksandquackers · 11/06/2023 20:29

Just to clarify - we said we wouldn’t be having children due to fertility issues, we tried IVF to no avail and decided to stop trying, this was 10 years ago!! When we had DS we weren’t actively trying.
We weren’t lying and didn’t chose to wait until we were older to have children that’s just the hand we were dealt !

My point still stands.

You are 42, with a dual income, presumably both of you worked FT for many years. Both you and your DH have secure jobs.

If you're not in a good financial position at your age then that's on you. Not your dad, your brother or your niece.

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 11/06/2023 20:38

This makes me so sad but not for you.

You are jealous of your niece.

What do you propose happens now?

watermeloncougar · 11/06/2023 20:38

@FrostyFifi completely agree. I don't understand how any loving parent can treat their children or grandchildren so unfairly.

Hannahsbananas · 11/06/2023 20:37

Or did you mean countries, sorry.
Op’s Dad is actually STILL ALIVE, though? Nobody had inherited anything yet.

FirstDogOnTheMoon · 11/06/2023 20:37

FrostyFifi · 11/06/2023 20:35

Get over yourself. No child is owed an inheritance

Actually in many companies they legally are.

When my parents made their will in Spain all money automatically went to my brother because he’s a man. They had to specifically say I would partly inherit.

what other countries do isn’t a yard stick. It’s about what happens here.

FrostyFifi · 11/06/2023 20:36

Companies?

Countries. Autocorrect.

Hannahsbananas · 11/06/2023 20:35

FrostyFifi · 11/06/2023 20:35

Get over yourself. No child is owed an inheritance

Actually in many companies they legally are.

Companies?

Lefteyetwitch · 11/06/2023 20:35

grimmers44 · 11/06/2023 20:32

Also why not get a better job?

Love it when people say this on MN. Like you can just walk into a "better" more well paid job at the drop of a hat 😂

It's in response to the OP stopping over the fact her brother strived for a well paying job and that's not given him more money.

She is using this as a stick to beat them with. Instead of doing something about it or just accepting he was smarter.

FrostyFifi · 11/06/2023 20:35

Get over yourself. No child is owed an inheritance

Actually in many companies they legally are.

FrostyFifi · 11/06/2023 20:34

In general yes it's shit when there's unfairness in families like this, it's damaging and causes bad feeling, which is a pretty crappy legacy to leave behind really.

LifeExperience · 11/06/2023 20:34

OP, you are way out of line. As someone who has adult children I would be incensed at them questioning what I did with my money. It is your father's money and you have no say whatsoever about what he chooses to do with it.

Get over yourself. No child is owed an inheritance.

FrostyFifi · 11/06/2023 20:33

You could just as easily argue your niece in fact deserves it all because she lost her mum age 10 & your son gets to grow up with a mum

That's not a given though - OP could also die at any point.

grimmers44 · 11/06/2023 20:32

Also why not get a better job?

Love it when people say this on MN. Like you can just walk into a "better" more well paid job at the drop of a hat 😂

ChampagneBlossom44 · 11/06/2023 20:32

I was really sympathetic until

not only has he missed out on a grandma on my side, and a grandad young enough to be able to play and look after him, he’s missed out on holidays with grandparents and all sorts.

while this is sad these are circumstances beyond anyones control. You could just as easily argue your niece in fact deserves it all because she lost her mum age 10 & your son gets to grow up with a mum, which wouldn’t be a rational argument either.

I do think it’s desperately sad but if your dad was convinced she would be the only GC, I can see how this happened. It is sad for your son & I hope your dad has made separate provisions for him. Ideally the fairest thing to do here, though potentially unpopular, would be upon his death to will your son 150k from the sale of his flat & split the remainder (however that much is) between you & your brother. Who’s the highest earner between you two shouldn’t be a consideration your dad should have to make.

FirstDogOnTheMoon · 11/06/2023 20:32

Hellenabe · 11/06/2023 19:55

@ducksandquackers what has your brother said? Has he offered to split it?

He can’t, it’s not his money. It’s his daughters money, it’s has nothing to do with the Op or her brother. It’s between their grandfather and the OPs niece. She’s an individual, she was gifted the money. It’s her business, not her dads.

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 11/06/2023 20:30

I've just seen this girl lost her grandma and mum.

And her aunt despises her because she's got 150 grand. Poor kid.
.

Gershwining · 11/06/2023 20:29

I think you are being unreasonable here and need to just enjoy your son for the next 18 years. If when your son is heading to university and your dad hasn't made any provision for him, then you are entitled to let the green eyed monster out for a bit. But until that time, don't let this fester as it could eat you up needlessly. It sounds like you are rich in what matters in life.

ducksandquackers · 11/06/2023 20:29

Just to clarify - we said we wouldn’t be having children due to fertility issues, we tried IVF to no avail and decided to stop trying, this was 10 years ago!! When we had DS we weren’t actively trying.
We weren’t lying and didn’t chose to wait until we were older to have children that’s just the hand we were dealt !

OP posts:
VDisappointing · 11/06/2023 20:28

It's likely he put it into her name long ago to avoid inheritance tax.
He doesn't have a crystal ball to know you would have a child one day.
But since your niece brought it up I think its Ok for you to raise it with him. You don't have to ask for money for your son - just mention in passing your niece brought it up and it might trigger him to think about your son or it might not.

Tryagainplease · 11/06/2023 20:28

MumFeelingHopeless · 11/06/2023 20:06

Perhaps talk to your Dad about it, if you feel comfortable. It might be like "the elephant in the room" otherwise.

That being said, I also think you should let go of your bitterness. These things happen: my grandfather left my aunt's (who hadn't been to uni yet) kids tens of thousands to pay for their university. Me and my uncle's children were all left a token amount: we're older, but some of us have young children ourselves, others could do with help getting on the property ladder in their late 30s.

As PP have pointed out be grateful for what you have now (a Dad who you can spend time with), be happy for your niece that she won't build up debt going to uni, and when you do inherent be grateful for that. It isn't really fair to ask your niece to share the money as she has likely made her own plans based on the inheritance.

People don't get the same lot in life. Your Dad made his decision, in hind sight it could have been done differently. Don't let the bitterness eat you. If your Dad spent the money elsewhere (like you initially thought) you would still be in the same position you're in now. Stop feeling so hard done by.

In sum, cognitive reframing might help if your Dad has no more money to give.

I agree with this

rebbles1 · 11/06/2023 20:28

Yes I would why do people find it so strange to talk about inheritance with their own parents? Obviously don't have a very open and honest relationship if you find that sort of conversation awkward.