Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a 'bedroom' without a window cannot be legally described as one?

190 replies

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 12:25

We've had a holiday booked since last year with a UK Holiday Cottage company. Lovely cottage, three bedrooms, great reviews on the website.

I paid the final balance this week and thought I'd have a look at the more recent reviews. Two new reviews point out that the third bedroom does not in fact have a window, it is just a windowless storage room with a bed inside.

This is ridiculous, surely? We need three bedrooms as there will be me and DH plus two teens who will definitely not share. We have paid a significant amount of money for three bedrooms - none of us will sleep in a windowless room, especially not in the summer!

After a quick check on the internet, most seem to agree that a room without a window cannot be legally described as a bedroom under UK law and can definitely not be advertised as one for renting out. This is due to fire safety regulations, as there needs to be at least two exits in the case of a fire.

I emailed the company saying this and have had a reply today to say it IS a bedroom and as such wasn't misdescribed, so they don't see an issue.
I'm so annoyed! We have paid a lot for what's basically a two bedroom cottage unsuitable for our needs, how on earth can they justify this?!

Can anyone help point me to the particular piece of legislation/building regs that confirm this? Obviously, lots of planning/building trade websites mentioned this, but I'd rather have a link to a government site to support this when I email back. I'd be so grateful for any help!

Ugh. I am so peeved. I'd rather they gave me a full refund now, as it's so dishonest that I resent giving them any of my money...any advice/pointers gratefully received!

OP posts:
ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:47

OnTheTuftedWilton · 11/06/2023 13:34

Ask for a copy of the Fire Risk Assessment and details of their insurers, their insurers may well be interested

We definitely will, thank you.

OP posts:
ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:46

ToeJamming · 11/06/2023 13:27

Thank you @ToeJamming , that is extremely helpful!

OP posts:
ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:45

WonderDays · 11/06/2023 13:24

I found this on the internet.

Building Regulation for Windows in Bedrooms
Many buildings in the UK have at least one room that doesn’t have a window. You may be tempted to rent out this room as an extra bedroom or include it when counting the bedrooms in the house to increase value upon sale. However, while it can technically serve as a sleeping place, such a room wouldn’t qualify as a bedroom as per the UK building regulations. In fact, marketing such rooms to lodgers as bedrooms is against the law and can get you into trouble. Without a window, you should label these rooms as studios, playrooms, or home offices.
All bedrooms in the UK must have a window that complies with the specified building regulations. In this article we look at building regulations for windows in bedrooms

Thanks WonderDays, I saw that too - it honestly appears as if they cannot describe it as a bedroom from that excerpt.

OP posts:
BerriesPineCones · 11/06/2023 15:43

I wonder if this is an issue with some Premier inns. They have windows but you can't open them which could be a fire risk. I miss being able to open the window and hear birds sing when I stay in one!

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:43

ToeJamming · 11/06/2023 13:20

What floor is the room on?

'A room where the only escape route
is through another room is termed an ‘inner room’. The occupants of an inner room could be at risk if a fire starts in
the outer room (often referred to as an ‘access room’). Although this arrangement should be avoided wherever possible,
it is acceptable where the inner room is a kitchen, laundry or utility room, bathroom, WC or shower room and where steps have been taken to mitigate the risk

Inner rooms should not be used for any form of sleeping accommodation unless the rooms are on the ground floor and the rooms have direct access to a door or “escape window” that can be used by the occupants to reach a place of safety clear of the accommodation.

Escape windows on the ground floor can only be considered acceptable if they are easily accessed and provide a clear opening of sufficient size to allow able-bodied persons to escape in the event of a fire in the access room. Mobility impaired people should not be accommodated in rooms where the means of escape is reliant on escape windows.'^
^
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachmentt^data/file/1147723/A/Aguideetotomakinggyourursmalllpaying-guest-accommodationonsafeefromom_fire.pdff

It's on the first floor, so according to your info it looks like the exemption wouldn't apply. Thank you for that!

OP posts:
ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:40

CastleTurrets · 11/06/2023 13:15

As PP have mentioned, the comparison to a toilet does not hold any weight. Typically downstairs toilets (under the stairs for example) have an extractor fan and possibly no window. However, while using a toilet you are conscious and only using it for a few minutes. I have no issue with this.

However, in a bedroom, you are unconscious for at least 6 or so hours and massively at risk if a fire breaks out which prevents you from being able to leave via the door. For that reason alone I would refuse to sleep in a windowless room or have my children sleep in one.

That's before even getting into the discomfort of using the room (lack of any natural light, ventilation, temperature control etc).

I'd 100% fight this OP.

Thank you, that's exactly how I feel about it! It's so frustrating, I feel it is really dishonest to omit mentioning there is no window in the description - there is absolutely no way anyone will be sleeping in that room.

OP posts:
MeeThree · 11/06/2023 15:40

I would also ask for a refund. Beware, I had a similar situation recently and had to do a charge back on my card and it's still not resolved. Apparently there is a massive backlog of unresolved travel requests for refunds at the moment!

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:37

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 11/06/2023 13:09

I'd be asking if their insurer knows they are using a windowless room as a bedroom.

A very good point, Bernadette - I think we'll be asking if we can see the fire risk assessment, too.

OP posts:
ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:36

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 11/06/2023 13:04

YANBU. Bedrooms in the UK should always have a window.

It's a huge fire risk for starters.

"Building regulations in the UK require all bedrooms to have windows. These are primarily meant to lower the risk of injury in case of a fire. They serve as ventilation for the room and also help to provide emergency exits. While the government can’t stop you from using windowless bedrooms, you will get into legal hot water if you rent the room to lodgers or tenants as a bedroom. When selling or renting out the house, you can market any windowless rooms as studios, playrooms, home gyms, or even home offices."

https://buildsafe.co.uk/building-regulation-for-windows-in-bedrooms/#:~:text=Building%20regulations%20in%20the%20UK%20require%20all%20bedrooms%20to%20have,help%20to%20provide%20emergency%20exits.

Thank you! I came across that website when I was doing a bit of research before posting. Hopefully when they are faced with a number of links all saying the same thing, they will reconsider.

OP posts:
ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:33

Thank you so much to everyone for your replies and sage advice!

I'll try and answer specific questions in a second, but just thought I'd update a little - I've just filled DH in, as he was working earlier. He says he knows and works with a fair few people who are highly regarded in the fire safety side of things and is sure that if he contacts them on Monday, they'll be able to provide him with the exact regs we need to quote to the company.

He's just as irritated as me - I'd really like to get a full refund now and just try and book somewhere else...if we end up actually going, I'll really resent one of us having to sleep on the sofa after paying out £1.2k.

OP posts:
Savoury · 11/06/2023 15:33

I had the same last week in the south west: a two bed apartment with parking which we need.

In fact the second bedroom had a window onto a hall (so switching on and off lights woke them up) and was too high to get out of. It was also tiny - nowhere to open a small bag or suitcase. The parking did exist but blocked a fire escape and was too narrow given the parking on the street to swing into. The advertised restaurant and bar didn’t exist which was fine as we wouldn’t have used it.

This was booking.com. We complained to the manager who we don’t think was even in the country. Annoying!

Fifthtimelucky · 11/06/2023 15:31

Any holiday lets should have an up to date fire risk assessment. It might be worth asking to see the one for the property in question, and say you are particularly interested to see what it says about the windowless 'bedroom'.

It could help strengthen your case if they don't have one, refuse to show it to you, or haven't adequately addressed the risks.

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:26

LizzieBananas · 11/06/2023 13:01

Heaven help you when said teens are looking to move out.

Signed, someone whose bathroom doesn't have a window.

Lizzie, this is an ENTIRELY different situation - a holiday cottage actually advertised as three bedrooms when it isn't, not a bathroom in a flat - I don't think it's unreasonable to expect a)what was advertised and b) a bedroom that adheres to current UK legal/safety guidelines for bedrooms.

And I also had a bathroom in my first flat that didn't have a window 🤷‍♀️But it was shown clearly in the description and photos before I bought it, so no misrepresentation.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/06/2023 15:25

I suspect you won’t actually get as far as small claims but thats the message I’d send. I’d be prepared to go there though!

caringcarer · 11/06/2023 15:25

@ABedroomByAnyOtherName if you give them option of giving refund but they do not take that option then you only have 3 choices. 1 go on holiday anyway. 2 refuse to go on holiday and book somewhere else but you will pay twice. 3 do an online claim for small claims court.

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 15:22

caringcarer · 11/06/2023 12:58

Tell them you want a full refund as no one wants to sleep in a room with no window and unless you get a full refund you will take them to small claims court for mis-describing the windowless room as a bedroom.

I'd really rather not take it as far as small claims, but I suppose it depends how annoyed I get and how reasonable/unreasonable they are!

OP posts:
ChimChimeny · 11/06/2023 15:20

Just be mindful that depending on when you want to go if you do get a refund you might struggle to find a replacement that isn't horrifically expensive. It might be better to just suck it up...

whynotwhatknot · 11/06/2023 15:19

when youre payiing out for a holiday let which is ually quite expensive id expect a window in a bedroom not amake shift cupboard with a bed in it

CastleTurrets · 11/06/2023 15:17

People are going on about building regulations and high rise flats etc however the bottom line is - is it reasonable to expect a teenager on holiday to sleep in a windowless room?

I think absolutely not! No natural light, obviously lack of ability to open a window for fresh air and an uncomfortable feeling of claustrophobia.

I go on holiday to relax and enjoy myself - I look to "step up" from the standards I have at home - not move down.

Candymay · 11/06/2023 14:58

mathanxiety · 11/06/2023 14:41

There are separate regs for high rise buildings, which are supposed to have sprinkler systems, properly working fire doors, stairs as well as lifts, etc.

There are stairs and lifts outside my property but if there was a fire inside my property the bedrooms have only one point of egress. That’s the bedroom door into the hallway. Then hallway to front door.
the interior doors are not fire doors and there are no sprinkler systems in the blocks.
I think with high rise living we are used to more risk. Hence the people on this thread who live in houses would not like to stay in a bedroom without a window because of fire safety.

im just pointing out that once over a certain level- about 8th floor the fire brigade told me- there is absolutely no way of being rescued from a window. So you have to hope the fire brigade can come through front door.

obviously a tragedy like Grenfell is when the dangers become clearer to more of the public. But essentially reading a thread like this is an eye opener for someone like me who has raised their family in a property that clearly lots of people wouldn’t be happy with.

And no offence whatever to those of you who have better housing- I’m not bitter! It’s just a very different situation.

Daftasabroom · 11/06/2023 14:50

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 12:25

We've had a holiday booked since last year with a UK Holiday Cottage company. Lovely cottage, three bedrooms, great reviews on the website.

I paid the final balance this week and thought I'd have a look at the more recent reviews. Two new reviews point out that the third bedroom does not in fact have a window, it is just a windowless storage room with a bed inside.

This is ridiculous, surely? We need three bedrooms as there will be me and DH plus two teens who will definitely not share. We have paid a significant amount of money for three bedrooms - none of us will sleep in a windowless room, especially not in the summer!

After a quick check on the internet, most seem to agree that a room without a window cannot be legally described as a bedroom under UK law and can definitely not be advertised as one for renting out. This is due to fire safety regulations, as there needs to be at least two exits in the case of a fire.

I emailed the company saying this and have had a reply today to say it IS a bedroom and as such wasn't misdescribed, so they don't see an issue.
I'm so annoyed! We have paid a lot for what's basically a two bedroom cottage unsuitable for our needs, how on earth can they justify this?!

Can anyone help point me to the particular piece of legislation/building regs that confirm this? Obviously, lots of planning/building trade websites mentioned this, but I'd rather have a link to a government site to support this when I email back. I'd be so grateful for any help!

Ugh. I am so peeved. I'd rather they gave me a full refund now, as it's so dishonest that I resent giving them any of my money...any advice/pointers gratefully received!

All bedrooms (habitable rooms) need a method of escape in case of fire. So if the doorway is r entrance is blocked there is an alternative method of egress. If there is no MoE it cannot be classed as a bedroom and (heaven forbid) anyone should come to harm because of it the insurers would be rightly upset.

mathanxiety · 11/06/2023 14:41

Candymay · 11/06/2023 13:24

I digress but bedroom windows in tower blocks cannot be used as alternative fire escapes. Just have to add this because so many people here are saying they wouldn’t sleep in a bedroom with no alternative fire escape. Millions of people have to.

my family have had to. High rise living. If bedroom door access was to be blocked in a fire there would be no escape. Window could ventilate for a while but not give a means of escape.

There are separate regs for high rise buildings, which are supposed to have sprinkler systems, properly working fire doors, stairs as well as lifts, etc.

mathanxiety · 11/06/2023 14:38

What they're doing is renting out a glorified closet.

If they get away with that, there's nothing to stop you from calling the space under your stairs a bedroom and making money from it.

Astrabees · 11/06/2023 14:36

Bloc Hotel have no windows in their standard rooms and are quite highly rated.

kingtamponthefurred · 11/06/2023 14:33

Whatever the legal position, it is pure unadulterated greed on the part of the owners to try to pass off a windowless cupboard as a third bedroom. Unless they are offering the full Harry Potter experience?