Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a 'bedroom' without a window cannot be legally described as one?

190 replies

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 11/06/2023 12:25

We've had a holiday booked since last year with a UK Holiday Cottage company. Lovely cottage, three bedrooms, great reviews on the website.

I paid the final balance this week and thought I'd have a look at the more recent reviews. Two new reviews point out that the third bedroom does not in fact have a window, it is just a windowless storage room with a bed inside.

This is ridiculous, surely? We need three bedrooms as there will be me and DH plus two teens who will definitely not share. We have paid a significant amount of money for three bedrooms - none of us will sleep in a windowless room, especially not in the summer!

After a quick check on the internet, most seem to agree that a room without a window cannot be legally described as a bedroom under UK law and can definitely not be advertised as one for renting out. This is due to fire safety regulations, as there needs to be at least two exits in the case of a fire.

I emailed the company saying this and have had a reply today to say it IS a bedroom and as such wasn't misdescribed, so they don't see an issue.
I'm so annoyed! We have paid a lot for what's basically a two bedroom cottage unsuitable for our needs, how on earth can they justify this?!

Can anyone help point me to the particular piece of legislation/building regs that confirm this? Obviously, lots of planning/building trade websites mentioned this, but I'd rather have a link to a government site to support this when I email back. I'd be so grateful for any help!

Ugh. I am so peeved. I'd rather they gave me a full refund now, as it's so dishonest that I resent giving them any of my money...any advice/pointers gratefully received!

OP posts:
Sensibletrousers · 14/06/2023 20:21

Go straight to the press now!

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 14/06/2023 20:15

Well...just received an email from Sykes Holiday Cottages as follows:

"We nor do any other leading competitive companies advertise information of properties windows as it is not what an average person looks for when searching a property.

* Cottage is priced as a 3 bedroom cottage which it has 3 rooms to sleep 5 people. It is not sold as a 3 bedroom property with or without windows as this has not impact of a property's pricing.

If you were to cancel your booking on this basis then you would forfeit your full payment of £1222.00.

We are the most senior team within the business and this decision cannot be changed.

I appreciate it is not the outcome you were looking for and would advise contacting before making a booking to ensure each property's room has a window in future for your needs."

So there you go everyone - an average person does not apparently search for properties that have bedrooms with windows...yes Customer service person, that's because we EXPECT that there will be a window, as standard!

I'm not completely surprised tbh, but it's extremely disappointing nonetheless.

And obviously, the lesson we should all take from this is to make sure to contact Sykes Holiday Cottages before we book any property to make sure each bedroom has a window.

I don't think I actually have words to describe Sykes right now.

OP posts:
25sheets · 14/06/2023 15:24

I wouldn't be able to sleep in a room without fresh air. We have windows open all year round just for that purpose. Seems like you're going to be sleeping in a cupboard.

EsmeSusanOgg · 14/06/2023 15:12

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 13/06/2023 21:27

No, I'm afraid not. They did take a couple of days to reply to my initial email, so hopefully they'll reply soon.

It really is in their interests to refund me - if they don't, we can't afford to rebook anything else, so we would have to go and try and make the best of it, rather than lose the money AND holiday. But if we do, my review will be an honest one which will mention the lack of window and I imagine will put more people off booking it 🤷

I'd contact the fire service where the cottage is based. Ask them if it is legally allowed, perhaps ask if they can do a fire safety check before your holiday.

Plasticplantpot · 14/06/2023 15:05

I’d be going for Twitter now, OP. Sykes are a big company. They should be doing all they can to help you.

Mirabai · 13/06/2023 21:57

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 13/06/2023 21:27

No, I'm afraid not. They did take a couple of days to reply to my initial email, so hopefully they'll reply soon.

It really is in their interests to refund me - if they don't, we can't afford to rebook anything else, so we would have to go and try and make the best of it, rather than lose the money AND holiday. But if we do, my review will be an honest one which will mention the lack of window and I imagine will put more people off booking it 🤷

Remember you’re not just reviewing the cottage, you’re also reviewing Sykes who behaved dishonestly.

Have you tried their Twitter or FB?

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 13/06/2023 21:27

CastleTurrets · 13/06/2023 18:24

@ABedroomByAnyOtherName any response to your complaint yet?

No, I'm afraid not. They did take a couple of days to reply to my initial email, so hopefully they'll reply soon.

It really is in their interests to refund me - if they don't, we can't afford to rebook anything else, so we would have to go and try and make the best of it, rather than lose the money AND holiday. But if we do, my review will be an honest one which will mention the lack of window and I imagine will put more people off booking it 🤷

OP posts:
Roselilly36 · 13/06/2023 18:34

Some hotel rooms in central London don’t have windows.

CastleTurrets · 13/06/2023 18:24

@ABedroomByAnyOtherName any response to your complaint yet?

Daftasabroom · 13/06/2023 14:00

Fightyouforthatpie · 13/06/2023 12:04

I am a bit confused about this building regs stuff - I have stayed in quite a few hotels where my room had no windows - how did they get the OK for that?

Different types of buildings have very different regulations. The aim is the same, to ensure buildings are safe and meet standards, but the way they do that can be very different.

Fightyouforthatpie · 13/06/2023 12:04

I am a bit confused about this building regs stuff - I have stayed in quite a few hotels where my room had no windows - how did they get the OK for that?

JudgeJ · 13/06/2023 11:56

BriarHare · 11/06/2023 13:02

It can can be a bedroom without a window, but I’d be asking about how it’s ventilated and what the fire strategy for the property is.

I thought it had to have a window to be a bedroom, it's the reason that some loft conversions cannot be called bedrooms, though they are being used as such.
Bathroom without a window doesn't bother me, our house in Germany didn't have one though it led to a problem. I friend advised me to leave our houseplants in the bathroom on damp towels when we were away for a week, sadly they died from lack of light!

Ginmonkeyagain · 13/06/2023 11:34

We staying in an apartment in France a few years ago which was advertised as a two bed apartment but was clearly carved out of the attic of an old apartment block. It was basically a pretty large studio room with two sliding doors opening on to a roof terrace. There was kitchenette in the corner and then (only just) a double bedroom and a bath room had been carved out of either side of the room with partitioning. The bedroom had the tiniest window (literally a square porthole!).

As it was just Mr Monkey and I, we were happy with it but I would have been a bit pissed off if we were a family group or two couples sharing.

Mirabai · 13/06/2023 09:37

Let us know how you get on OP. I hope Sykes are reasonable.

ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 12/06/2023 12:00

LemonjeIIo · 11/06/2023 16:06

See if there is anything else you can book and cancel this one as it isn't fit for purpose

There's lots I could book, some look beautiful...but if I cancel this myself, I forfeit the entire amount as per the booking conditions. So I need them to refund me, otherwise no money available for the holiday...and I can't afford to just chuck over a grand down the drain.

OP posts:
ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 12/06/2023 11:58

Plasticplantpot · 11/06/2023 16:20

So much misinformation on this thread. Half of the examples being given as ‘evidence’ that the OP is wrong are irrelevant.

It is not a bedroom and never has been. It’s a glorified cupboard, at most, a large walk-in wardrobe. You have paid over the odds for a two bed property. You have been missold.

Had similar some years ago overseas. Booked a 4 bed place, us, two DC and PIL. Ended up with three rooms and a mezzanine that overlooked the main living space as ‘bedroom’ 4. It wasn’t a bedroom. There was no privacy, and the lights in the living area lit up the whole of the sleeping area. As with you OP, the owner didn’t seem to think there was anything wrong. We did get a partial refund eventually.

Thank you, that's exactly my point! I'll just have to see how they respond now...

OP posts:
ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 12/06/2023 11:55

https://www.visitbritain.org/business-advice/unfair-trading-practices

This is the link detailing the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations of 2008 - it might come in useful for someone else in a similar situation!

Unfair trading practices | VisitEngland

What you can and can’t say when advertising your business, including online review sites.

https://www.visitbritain.org/business-advice/unfair-trading-practices

OP posts:
ABedroomByAnyOtherName · 12/06/2023 11:54

I've just submitted a further complaint to Sykes, on the basis of the property being misdescribed and quoting some relevant parts of the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations of 2008. The regs were very helpful and make a point that if a business makes 'false or deceptive statements ' or 'omits important information ' that would have meant that the consumer/customer would not have made the decision to purchase, then that counts as 'unfair trading'.

I've asked for my complaint to be escalated and for a full refund, as I need that money to book a cottage that IS suitable for us... otherwise, no holiday 🤷‍♀️ I've also expressly asked them NOT to cancel on my say so, as I will lose the entire amount paid under the booking conditions.
If they are still unwilling to re consider, I'll contact the credit card company or one of those consumer champion type people.

Interestingly, I noticed when searching for 'bedroom without a window' or similar on Google that this thread was very near the top! I can only hope that they will be fair and reasonable about this and refund...it really hasn't helped that I was up all night being sick, it's the last thing I need!

Thanks so much again to everyone, I'll update the thread when/if I get a response - positive or negative 😬

OP posts:
Florissant · 11/06/2023 20:36

DismantledKing · 11/06/2023 14:29

No way would I be staying in a bedroom without a window.

Agreed.

unsync · 11/06/2023 20:25

Ask them about means of escape and fire suppression for the room.

miniegg3 · 11/06/2023 20:23

maximist · 11/06/2023 16:35

It was! It looked lovely on the website, and ideal for my elderly parents, but was very disappointing in reality. The main bedroom only had French doors onto a balcony, so they couldn’t be left open overnight as they would swing about. Thankfully my parents sleep with their window firmly closed!

Haha I was there last year 😅

Mirabai · 11/06/2023 17:16

Again, the owner will have the insurance policy not the letting agent who does not own the building.

It may be that the owner is insured for 2 beds and the agent is letting it out as 3.

Throwncrumbs · 11/06/2023 17:14

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 11/06/2023 13:09

I'd be asking if their insurer knows they are using a windowless room as a bedroom.

Ask for the insurance details as a request for the type of cover they have

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 11/06/2023 17:08

With respect to high rise flats the regulations for safe egress & advice about what to do in case of fire ia obviously different to a standard 2 floor residential property.

For example, there are dry risers on every floor (like a big pipe you connect your fire tender to get water to the fire), and emergency firefighting lifts (usually a normal lift) which has a separate, protected circuit which is enabled via a firefighter key to get equipment to the floor swiftly & safely.

Also, to stop fire spread, fire doors would ideally be on every front door & would increase the time a resident could shelter before fire breaks through, whilst there may be a shelter -in - place recommendation for tenants to wait until rescued by firefighters. There should be fire exits, exit signage, alarms on all floors & smoke alarms in all residences plus a myriad of other safety features in each home & in common areas.

There should also be regular visits by independent, qualified Fire Risk Assessors to complete Fire Risk Assessments (obviously enough) & if action is needed it can be monitored, checked & reassessed if necessary. Working with about a billion FRAs at my last job, most, if not all, are ex-firefighters or come from a building regs background.

We were in stunned silence around the office on the day of Grenfell; there were obvious failures which, as the tragic events unfolded, it was obvious there had been a catastrophic failure in the building materials used on the recent refit. As the outside of the building’s cladding was behind the wicking of the fire upwards from the relatively low floor where the fire originated, shelter-in-place should’ve been replaced with a standard evacuation order, but it wasn’t because the outside of buildings shouldn’t catch fire.

As our colleagues were pulled into the investigation within 48hrs (our firm did not hold the contract for the Royal Kensington & Chelsea council, but were experts in the field), it was alleged that RK&C had done the assessments themselves with unqualified assessors (unknown on the FireBase register of assessors), with catastrophic consequences. Which one could extrapolate was a money saving decision, which was allegedly why poor, cheaper cladding was used in the first place. Allegedly of course.

In 2021, the government issued new guidelines on fire safety for new high rise homes (over 7 storeys) as a result of the Grenfell tragedy https://www.gov.uk/government/news/fire-safety-guidance-strengthened-for-new-high-rise-homes

We moved on from the FRA client a year or so ago so some of the regs have been lost to the idiocies of my menopausal grey matter (& I only have a vague overview of anything relevant post leaving to be honest!) but I hope to have given a brief overview.

As for the issue of the windowless bedrooms; as it’s a property being rented out for profit, the owner should have their own Fire Risk Assessment available to be viewed when asked as simple good practice. Use that as your starting point.

As the old boss used to say, there’s never a stupid question when it comes to safety.

Fire safety guidance strengthened for new high-rise homes 

New improvements to fire safety guidance form part of a wider update to tighten building regulations and provide clearer fire safety rules for the design or construction of residential developments.

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/fire-safety-guidance-strengthened-for-new-high-rise-homes

Mirabai · 11/06/2023 17:04

Insurance is irrelevant. The insurance will be held by the cottage owner not by the rental company. Your beef is with the company. They should have flagged the lack of window on the description.

If you paid by PayPal you should be protected. If not, it’s worth contacting your credit card company for their rules on holiday properties not as described as you may be able to get a chargeback if the rental company don’t cooperate.