Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taking away pocket money for bad behaviour?

35 replies

Notesonaconditionalform · 11/06/2023 00:51

DS is 6 and has a kids rooster card/account for pocket money (£10 a month) it's quite a new thing and the first month he's had it. His brother spent all his money the day he was given it whereas he saved most of his because he wants to save up for a toy.
They're at their dads this weekend and his dad told me he took £3 out of his account today because he "had a tantrum" about going to Tesco.
I think that's not a fair punishment because he's basically getting punished for saving his money? So this month when he gets his pocket money, why would he bother saving any of it when it could just get taken away?

As far at the Tesco tantrums go- He seems to have "tantrums" every time his dad takes him, he hates the supermarket. his dad won't take my advice on that but I used to have similar difficulties with DS and have found pre-warning him if we have to go to the supermarket stopped all of the issues.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Notesonaconditionalform · 11/06/2023 22:27

LlynTegid · 11/06/2023 11:41

I'm with his dad, providing it is consistently applied. Better would be something given for maintaining good behaviour.

A child should be able to go to a supermarket and behave reasonably.

He can go to the supermarket and behave, he just really hates it so prior warning helps him and then he's fine.
surely It's a parents job to help them manage emotions rather than just punish them for their emotions

OP posts:
minisoksmakehardwork · 11/06/2023 12:02

Yeah. Not ok to 'fine' a child for natural child behaviour in that way. Nothing will be learned expect his Dad's crap at parenting.

Ours earn their pocket money by doing jobs, so if jobs aren't done there is a reduction in pocket money. Helps them understand societal expectations around earning a living and consequences.

But I'd never remove their pocket money because they were having a tantrum.

I think you need to separate your ex from the account. If he wants to take money off them, he can be the one who is giving it to them.

pointythings · 11/06/2023 11:48

@LlynTegid the child can behave in a supermarket, if he is told in advance that going to a supermarket will happen. The dad fails to do this.

Changington · 11/06/2023 11:46

LlynTegid · 11/06/2023 11:41

I'm with his dad, providing it is consistently applied. Better would be something given for maintaining good behaviour.

A child should be able to go to a supermarket and behave reasonably.

Hahaha. I'm a grown adult and there's a supermarket near me which has been known to make me cry because it's crazy overstimulating.

I only go in because it has a Cinnabon and I'm in and out in 2 minutes. If someone forced me to actually go shopping there I'd probably have a meltdown too. 🤣 We're not all perfect.

LlynTegid · 11/06/2023 11:41

I'm with his dad, providing it is consistently applied. Better would be something given for maintaining good behaviour.

A child should be able to go to a supermarket and behave reasonably.

Changington · 11/06/2023 11:39

I tend to "punish" my kids in a way that teaches natural consequences, like what will happen when they are adults.

If they break something of someone else's I might take the money from them to replace it, for example. But taking money you've already earned isn't a consequence that would happen in the real world for having a meltdown, is it?

I'd be tempted to say to my son that we're going to the shop and if he's good (lay out what "good" behaviour is beforehand) then he can have £1 back, try and turn it into a teaching moment of how to behave in the shop so he will be better prepared next time he's with his dad. See if you can get him to do extra chores around the house, like wash your car or something and top it back up.

And on a side note, whoever set the Rooster account up can delete the "other guardians" in the settings.

caramac04 · 11/06/2023 11:34

Very, very unfair and certainly doesn’t encourage saving/delayed gratification.
I would not take away something that has already been given.
Even stuff like screen time I would give as a reward for good behaviour rather than remove as a punishment.
I’m not keen on the supermarket myself and would plan to avoid taking a child who hates it if I could.

Stupidpeoplesuck · 11/06/2023 11:29

You’re spot on. He needs to find other ways to address bad behaviour, because this just supports your worry about kids attitudes to saving.

Good luck, I know you have little control over what another parent does, but this really isn’t fair.

Lcb123 · 11/06/2023 11:17

That’s very unfair to take money he already has. Reducing the next pocket money is fairer. I mean, going to Tesco is horrific - I can understand why he made a fuss. Can’t his dad be organised and shop beforehand.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 11/06/2023 11:15

I'm on your side.
A compromise would be reducing the next lot of money that goes in (ie next month he only get £9) then he'd still get t a consequence/punishment for behaviour (not that I agreee with that) but not penalized for saving up.
If you can't agree on this then you need separate accounts/pocket money systems each with your own rules.

junebirthdaygirl · 11/06/2023 10:31

Surely he has the whole bloody week to go to Tesco without going on his dcs time. Your child may be sensitive to lighting or loud music there. It's difficult as sounds like a dad who won't listen. This will only get worse as a teenager will not go with: what l say goes and that's it. There will be war up ahead.
Think the idea of you giving him a bonus mid week by catching him doing something good like helping or working hard at his homework.
But l think an account df can't access has to be the long term solution.

pointythings · 11/06/2023 10:15

@Notesonaconditionalform so basically you are parenting effectively using a tested approach that works, and he is going for shouty and authoritarian. How bloody typical. He'll ruin his relationship with his DC and then complain that they don't want to see him when they're older. I hope you find a way of preventing him from stealing from your DS again.

Crumpleton · 11/06/2023 10:14

Does your son's dad contribute to the pocket money?
Either way it's wrong what he has done tantrum or no tantrum there are other ways in which a child can be taught that having tantrums isn't acceptable.
This punishment sounds like your ex has been judge and jury and given your DS a fine.

Notesonaconditionalform · 11/06/2023 10:08

pointythings · 11/06/2023 09:48

That's really bad parenting, especially if you have a strategy which wards off the tantrums successfully. I bet he's one of those authoritarian assholes who thinks you're too soft, am I right?

Time to sort out the accounts situation so that he can't do this again.

Yeah pretty much
His brother is autistic and has adhd so I've kind of learnt to parent from a helping the kids manage their emotions/behaviour rather than trying to blindly punish into obedience but he thinks that's pandering to them so we definitely have different parenting styles but they both behave very well for me so it works for us.

OP posts:
Notesonaconditionalform · 11/06/2023 10:04

XelaM · 11/06/2023 09:57

When you transfer money to the Rooster Money account it will appear in the "parent account" and then you need to top up your son's card with in on the app. Once it's on your son's card you can't transfer it back out again. Make sure the money is actually on your son's card

I've had a look on the app and under the child's account if you click on the three dots it has the option of "remove" so it
looks like you can remove it via the app it says "removed by dad bad behaviour" on the transactions

OP posts:
snitzelvoncrumb · 11/06/2023 10:01

I would give him a bonus for doing something so you can give it back without undermining his dad.

Ducksurprise · 11/06/2023 09:58

SadieLia · 11/06/2023 09:43

Well he didn't have any prior warning to add the consequence, so mid tantrum was his only opportunity. I'm on the fence. He's trying to teach him boundaries which is not a bad thing.

Taking from this weeks not yet given pocket money is different. That is still the parents, the money in the bank is the child's.

No one has learnt boundaries by being threatened mid tantrum.

XelaM · 11/06/2023 09:57

When you transfer money to the Rooster Money account it will appear in the "parent account" and then you need to top up your son's card with in on the app. Once it's on your son's card you can't transfer it back out again. Make sure the money is actually on your son's card

Notesonaconditionalform · 11/06/2023 09:57

XelaM · 11/06/2023 09:53

How did he take it out of his account? My daughter has the same account and it's VERY difficult to take money back out once it's on the child's card. Did he use your son's card?

He moved it from the child's account back to the parent account, I don't actually know how he did it it just says "removed by dad" ds does have his card with him so possibly

OP posts:
XelaM · 11/06/2023 09:53

How did he take it out of his account? My daughter has the same account and it's VERY difficult to take money back out once it's on the child's card. Did he use your son's card?

Notesonaconditionalform · 11/06/2023 09:50

SadieLia · 11/06/2023 09:43

Well he didn't have any prior warning to add the consequence, so mid tantrum was his only opportunity. I'm on the fence. He's trying to teach him boundaries which is not a bad thing.

He would have known because according to him he does this every time they go shopping and always has done. I don't think a bit of proactive parenting is a lot to ask for. His current method clearly isn't working and he has no patience or understanding for him.
DS used to also do it here too and now he never does because I always tell him "we have to go to Sainsbury's after school" or whatever and that's enough to solve the problem.

OP posts:
pointythings · 11/06/2023 09:48

That's really bad parenting, especially if you have a strategy which wards off the tantrums successfully. I bet he's one of those authoritarian assholes who thinks you're too soft, am I right?

Time to sort out the accounts situation so that he can't do this again.

SadieLia · 11/06/2023 09:43

Well he didn't have any prior warning to add the consequence, so mid tantrum was his only opportunity. I'm on the fence. He's trying to teach him boundaries which is not a bad thing.

Notesonaconditionalform · 11/06/2023 09:38

SadieLia · 11/06/2023 09:31

The only way I'd think this is acceptable is if he warned him and said if you do this then I am taking £3, and yet he still done it. But if it didn't work like that and he just took the money its harsh.

On the other hand, it might make him think and not have a tantrum because he will know it has consequences.

He said it once he was already mid-tantrum which I think is never going to work, the middle of a tantrum is not really the time to start adding consequences I'm not sure any kids ever calmed down that way.

I do also thinks it's quite unfair for ds thst there are quite simple things his dad could have done that would have prevented the whole situation but he won't do it on the principe of "he should do what I say when I say I shouldn't have to tell him where we're going" which I get to a certaint extent but is it really that difficult to say "we're going to Tesco after cricket and then we're going home" plus a reminder before getting in the car, he just likes to know what's expected of him then he can manage his emotions easier

OP posts:
SadieLia · 11/06/2023 09:31

The only way I'd think this is acceptable is if he warned him and said if you do this then I am taking £3, and yet he still done it. But if it didn't work like that and he just took the money its harsh.

On the other hand, it might make him think and not have a tantrum because he will know it has consequences.