Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel weird about meeting BIL’s new girlfriend

345 replies

vibecheck · 11/06/2023 00:45

I want to preface this with I know that I’m being unreasonable, but I just need to rant and hopefully get some advice from some women who’ve been through similar…

My BIL (husband’s brother) left his wife and twin girls 6 months ago, for another woman. It was a classic situation of he said there wasn’t another woman, and some people in the family (cough - MIL - cough) believe there wasn’t another woman, but he immediately started seeing a woman who he worked with and now they live together.

I know my BIL’s ex-wife more as a friend than anything else. She was bridesmaid at my wedding, we are very close. At the time of the split she told me a lot of things as a friend that have coloured my view of BIL and of his new girlfriend. It’s been hard to navigate being her friend and DH’s wife/member of his family during this time because of the complications of the split and crossover of women.

Anyway - we’re meeting BIL and his new girlfriend this week. I’ve been civil with BIL since the split despite my private feelings because he’s DH’s family, but I am dreading this meeting. I will be polite because I always am, but I just hate the idea of sitting having dinner with someone I know was the other woman and caused someone I love so much hurt (not to mention the disruption to my gorgeous nieces!) . I know I have to do it for DH and I will do it, it’s just going to be a difficult evening where I’ll be keeping my gob shut!

Anyone had to do similar and have any advice?

OP posts:
burnoutbabe · 11/06/2023 09:05

A short coffee or quick drink sounds a better bet than a long awkward dinner.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 11/06/2023 09:04

I agree, some of these responses are really immature. Everyone has the right to leave a relationship and meet someone new. Who really knows what was going on in their marriage anyway.

And if people have affairs, they should expect there will be consequences from that.
I wouldn't go OP. And seeing how welcoming the family is to the OW, would make me think a lot less of them. Wonder how quickly they'd welcome the OW if your husband cheated on you

Justalittlebitduckling · 11/06/2023 08:57

I probably wouldn’t go. I’d delay meeting her for as long as possible and I wouldn’t be particularly nice.

DoubleTime · 11/06/2023 08:57

pictoosh · 11/06/2023 08:46

"But its not about telling people who to love is it ? Its about the OP rightly not wanting to spend an evening having dinner with two people who have hurt her close friend."

Yes I know but life has a funny way of chucking curveballs left right and centre...and in this instance it's her dh's brother, with whom her dh has a close relationship, so the compromise is required.
We do a lot of this in the real world of the the grown ups and actual stuff that happens. It's not like on the telly.

No, its not like on TV is it ? Not all brothers are close, and its not possible to tell whether they are from the OP's post. But it is possible to tell that OP and her friend are close. Not sure why people think OP has to attend a dinner just with BIL and new partner if she has reasons not to ? Different if it was a family gathering or special event, but it doesn't seem to be.

whumpthereitis · 11/06/2023 08:57

Getting together with someone quickly after ending a marriage doesn’t actually mean he was cheating. People may assume, but they don’t know what really goes on in someone else’s relationships. It may be that he did what is advised - if you’re not happy and find yourself looking at someone else, don’t cheat - leave.

Either way I just wouldn’t insert myself into, and add to, the drama. Your husband may not approve of what he did, but he loves his brother and understandably doesn’t want to cut him off (I wouldn’t either). He can’t change what his brother has done and holding onto it like a dog with a bone doesn’t help anyone.

aSofaNearYou · 11/06/2023 08:56

AnImmenseDislikeOfPeople · 11/06/2023 08:51

I'd probably go and fondly talk about ex-SIL and my nieces/nephews as much as possible, as long as I was 100% sure the new gf knew she was part of an affair and chose to date BIL anyway.

Might as well just start an argument - people will know what she's doing and it will be perceived as confrontational.

sandyhappypeople · 11/06/2023 08:56

this Is always really awkward.. if it was me, I’d be honest with new girlfriend in a very sympathetic way and say you’re sorry if you’re not your normal chatty happy self, and that you feel like you’re being pressured into being okay with something that you’re not really okay with because of how close you are to SIL, say you’ll probably feel better as time goes on but it’s too soon at the moment for you to feel okay with it.

I wouldn’t EVER sit there and pretend to be fine, but I also wouldn’t be a dick, as ultimately you don’t know the full situation with BIL and ex SIL, no one ever does.

just be honest, but DO NOT allow your emotions to draw you into an argument, matter of fact is the way to go.

Codlingmoths · 11/06/2023 08:54

I’d be grown up about it… but not yet. If my Dh expected me to go to a dinner he’d know he’d bloody well better make sure there was no dinner for the first year.

it does tell you a lot about how your mil would react- if my mil accused me of not being supportive in this situation I’d say I’m supporting the mother of your grandchildren, who now has primary custody of them. It’s a tough situation for a mum and my close friend and she has ALL my sympathy right now.

aSofaNearYou · 11/06/2023 08:54

YANBU to be sad for your friend but ultimately YWBVU to be rude to her whilst being polite to your BIL.

I also agree with others that she might end up part of the family, so I wouldn't ostracise her. If your MIL treats her like part of the family, it makes no difference to whether ex SIL is still your friend. Going forward, ex SIL will be your friend and his new gf will (possibly) become family. There's no reason to be personally upset about that change.

pictoosh · 11/06/2023 08:52

Good post @Sceptre86

I agree.

Sceptre86 · 11/06/2023 08:51

I think you have to be grown up about it. The new woman may well end up being a part of rhe family long term and go on to have kids with your bil. She will remember how you treat her and it could cause issues down the road between your family and theirs, affecting your dhs relationship with his brother. Your ex sil might well move on and find a new partner and your friendhip might dwindle.

I would be polite and welcoming. I would also be kind to your ex sil but not share details about the new woman or engage in chat about her or your bil They are separate entities now and I'd treat them as such. I wouldn't want to cultivate a friendship though and I'd make that clear.

It isn't up to you to pass judgement yet I agree it's a horrible situation to be put in and hard not to feel loyal towards the injured party.

AnImmenseDislikeOfPeople · 11/06/2023 08:51

I'd probably go and fondly talk about ex-SIL and my nieces/nephews as much as possible, as long as I was 100% sure the new gf knew she was part of an affair and chose to date BIL anyway.

RedRosette2023 · 11/06/2023 08:49

JennyForeigner · 11/06/2023 07:36

Integrity is not a zero sum game.

That’s why I said “save” BIL should have received some of this hostility before.

pictoosh · 11/06/2023 08:46

"But its not about telling people who to love is it ? Its about the OP rightly not wanting to spend an evening having dinner with two people who have hurt her close friend."

Yes I know but life has a funny way of chucking curveballs left right and centre...and in this instance it's her dh's brother, with whom her dh has a close relationship, so the compromise is required.
We do a lot of this in the real world of the the grown ups and actual stuff that happens. It's not like on the telly.

SophieStew · 11/06/2023 08:45

vibecheck · 11/06/2023 01:24

God I’m so glad everyone feels the same as me.

I just can’t not go though. My DH would never forgive me.

Well DH can’t tell you how to feel about people.

I appreciate it’s difficult, and I would probably have to get on with tolerating OW as time went on (she might not be around for long though) but DH is asking you to be disloyal to your friend.

In all honesty, I don’t know why you have to have this double date meet up. It’s all very contrived. I would probably feign illness last minute, but I’m quite old and tend not to do things I don’t really want to do.

SallyWD · 11/06/2023 08:45

It is a difficult situation and I can understand why you feel like that. At the same time, you've managed to be civil to your BIL. It was HE who betrayed his wife. The new woman isn't as guilty as he is. If you can be civil to him perhaps you can be civil to her.
Assuming you're British, us Brits are masters at hiding our feelings, being polite to people that we really dislike! I'd try and be breezily pleasant and just get through it.

VDisappointing · 11/06/2023 08:45

If I have learnt one thing about extended families - swallowing your feelings to help ensure cordial relations has a detrimental effect.
In my opinion you should ask to have a coffee with b'n'law - tell him how you feel and tell him that you want to move forward and will move forward for the sake of your husband - but that you need to get this off your chest or you would forever just be pretending around him.

DoubleTime · 11/06/2023 08:41

pictoosh · 11/06/2023 08:32

I agree with you @My2pence2day .

Some very silly, childish responses here. Who are you to tell people who to love?

No one knows if there was even an actual affair. It seems likely of course but sometimes one having their head turned is enough to put paid to a stale, unhappy marriage. He didn't have his cake and eat it, he did the right thing and ended the marriage.

No one has to stay just because. Grow up people.

But its not about telling people who to love is it ? Its about the OP rightly not wanting to spend an evening having dinner with two people who have hurt her close friend. She clearly would prefer not be put into that situation and would choose not to go if it wasn't for the family connection. OP is already being polite with them. Why should she have to do more than that and appear friendly and visit their home for dinner too ?

AlltheFs · 11/06/2023 08:39

I wouldn’t go. There’s absolutely no need for it. Civil at family occasions is one thing, actively socialising with them on their own-no chance, not yet. Maybe in a decade if you decide you like her but otherwise they can jog on.

If you don’t have that agency in your marriage I’d say that was a bigger issue tbh!

pictoosh · 11/06/2023 08:35

As for you OP, yeah you have to go...she' your bil's partner now. However sour you feel on your sil's behalf, you don't get to choose them for him.

Of course it's deeplu upsetting for your sil...but so is being married to someone who'd rather be with someone else.

ColadhSamh · 11/06/2023 08:34

You have to do what is right for you. Remind your husband and MIL of how quickly all have moved on. 6 months is nothing but already BIL is living with another woman, MIL and your husband arranging meet ups while no doubt other members of the family are hurting badly.

Little consideration given to daughter/SIL or indeed granddaughters/nieces. Picture of the future should you and your husband's relationship run into difficulties. Tread carefully.

christmastreewithhairyfairy · 11/06/2023 08:34

OP I've been through exactly the same. A few years on now and we're expected to have big happy family weekends with OW and her kids.
OW is very over the top "oh it's so lovely to meet you and let's all be great friends" which MIL had lapped up of course.

I avoid it when I can, or if not I get through it with a polite but distant smile, regularly messaging ex-SIL about how irritating it all is. It helps that ex-SIL has moved on and is now living a great life

Maddy70 · 11/06/2023 08:33

Keep out of the drama. He's your bil. You don't have to approve of what he's done , but it's done. Be polite. Make small talk. Eat your dinner and go

pictoosh · 11/06/2023 08:32

I agree with you @My2pence2day .

Some very silly, childish responses here. Who are you to tell people who to love?

No one knows if there was even an actual affair. It seems likely of course but sometimes one having their head turned is enough to put paid to a stale, unhappy marriage. He didn't have his cake and eat it, he did the right thing and ended the marriage.

No one has to stay just because. Grow up people.

lalaloopyhead · 11/06/2023 08:32

I think I would go with an open mind and see if you actually like gf when you meet. I totally understand you having bad feeling towards Bil and Gf but surely it will be exhausting in the long run to maintain the moral high ground position and be permanently offhand/avoid them.
If you are a direct person you could make your feelings clear 'i think you have both , particularly you Bil, treated ex sil terribly and I am honestly struggling with that at the moment' and then see where dinner goes.