Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alan Carr - stuffs herb into mouth of team member who says she is allergic to it

210 replies

cakeorwine · 10/06/2023 22:59

‘I used to say awful things’: Alan Carr on divorce, dating and the skit that haunts him | Alan Carr | The Guardian

Idiot. There is so much to say about this - power, control and a total lack of understanding of allergies.

"We’re in a big echoing loft with wood floors and he’s talking to his team as if they are all on stage and I – sitting in the corner – am the audience. He wants to know why one of them is picking bits out of her salad. He doesn’t accept that she’s allergic to coriander. Whoever heard of being allergic to coriander?"

There are six of us in this photo studio, including Carr’s manager, makeup, wardrobe and a publicist from ITV. He picks up the coriander and stuffs it into the mouth of the woman who said she was allergic. “See!” he declares, triumphant. “You’re not really allergic. If you were, you’d be dead by now.” He cackles. Everyone else cackles. It’s like the canned laughter of witches"

I just don't know what to say about this. Some allergies are less well known but still cause allergic reactions. And should be taken seriously.

‘I used to say awful things’: Alan Carr on divorce, dating and the skit that haunts him

He’s the extrovert who used to pick on others for laughs. But after struggling in lockdown and a bruising separation, the comic insists he’s grown up – and is happier than ever

https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2023/may/27/alan-carr-interview-i-used-to-say-awful-things

OP posts:
DarkDayforMN · 11/06/2023 03:35

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 01:40

I don't think it matters whether she was allergic or not. It's enough to say you just don't like something to be left alone to get on with organising your plate.

Can't tell if you quoted to agree or disagree! The comment you quoted said it's assault whether she's allergic or not.

Though I think it does matter. If she's allergic it's a more serious assault. He could have caused her a lot of physical discomfort on top of the fact that shoving unwanted food into someone's mouth is weird abusive behaviour in literally any circumstance, let alone from a boss to an employee.

SideProfile · 11/06/2023 03:23

People are getting bogged down with the semantics of whether this woman has a legitimate allergy or not, surely that’s not relevant. Even if she didn’t, you don’t forcibly shove something in another persons mouth?!

Very bizarre article, strange that there’s no further reference

LunaNorth · 11/06/2023 03:11

That’s really crap behaviour.

I’ve always liked him, and was enjoying Changing Ends. Won’t bother with it now.

AngelineGarcia · 11/06/2023 02:38

I have severe nut allergy and mild sesame allergy. Nits cause lip swelling, throat swelling vomiting and potential anaphylaxis (so I have to carry epipen) and no way can I simply pick them off a plate of food and keep eating. However, sesame tastes like soap to me and makes my lips itch. I could pick them off a seeded bun and eat the rest of the bun. I generally wouldn’t, but I could if in a situation where there wasn’t an alternative.
Thankfully I don’t think anyone has ever tried to force me to eat an allergen, however some kids did pin me down at a party and force me to eat a meaty sausage when I was 10, because I had a vegetarian. I was traumatised by that.

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 02:09

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 01:43

Itv aren't going to sack them for refusing to be forced to eat something they're allergic to.

No, but they might sack her for swatting his hand away. Think about it, how else was she going to stop him?

The guy who was hit didn't just sit there and take it. And he did complain. And he did get JC sacked.

My memory of the time is that JC went to his boss once he had sobered up and fessed up. The guy said when interviewed that he feared for his job. JC got JC sacked.

No, but they might sack her for swatting his hand away. Think about it, how else was she going to stop him?

They're not going to sack her for self-defence.

My memory of the time is that JC went to his boss once he had sobered up and fessed up. The guy said when interviewed that he feared for his job. JC got JC sacked.

He was the producer of Top Gear. As far as I know he's never given an interview.
He sued JC and BBC for racial discrimination and personal injury, and received a £100,000+ settlement. He was promoted. And his attacker was, rightly in my opinion, sacked.

ToeJammed · 11/06/2023 01:58

Can't stand the idiot, never could.
Shame someone didn't stick their fist into his mouth when he did that.
Immature twat.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 01:50

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 01:40

I don't think it matters whether she was allergic or not. It's enough to say you just don't like something to be left alone to get on with organising your plate.

It's yet another case of a man disregarding a woman's boundaries and right to bodily autonomy.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 01:43

Itv aren't going to sack them for refusing to be forced to eat something they're allergic to.

No, but they might sack her for swatting his hand away. Think about it, how else was she going to stop him?

The guy who was hit didn't just sit there and take it. And he did complain. And he did get JC sacked.

My memory of the time is that JC went to his boss once he had sobered up and fessed up. The guy said when interviewed that he feared for his job. JC got JC sacked.

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 01:40

DarkDayforMN · 11/06/2023 01:29

To the people including Carr saying that she can't have been allergic or she wouldn't have been picking the food out: some allergies aren't that serious, not all food allergies cause anaphylaxis.

Google says that allergy to coriander tends to manifest as hives or swelling. She wasn't risking her life. I'm allergic to lanolin but if I'm exposed to a very small amount of it I probably wouldn't even notice the allergy symptoms.

And it's assault anyway, even if she wasn't allergic. What a nauseating dick Carr is.

I don't think it matters whether she was allergic or not. It's enough to say you just don't like something to be left alone to get on with organising your plate.

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 01:38

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 01:32

She does not know how she can stop him, so she freezes. He is the bankable star in the room.

Surely you all remember Jeremy Clarkson punching a member of Top Gear staff who had to get checked for concussion at hospital and the staff member worried that he'd be fired for being punched? Now add being female to that power dynamic. Of course she didn't fight back.

This was a one off photoshoot. Not the most profitable series a channel produces.

The guy who was hit didn't just sit there and take it. And he did complain. And he did get JC sacked.

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 01:34

Especially if you have power over them by dint of being their boss, or being the only bankable star in the room.

There are six of us in this photo studio, including Carr’s manager, makeup, wardrobe and a publicist from ITV.

It's not going to be the manager so a woman employed by itv. Itv aren't going to sack them for refusing to be forced to eat something they're allergic to.

Like I say, it just sounds odd to me.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 01:32

She does not know how she can stop him, so she freezes. He is the bankable star in the room.

Surely you all remember Jeremy Clarkson punching a member of Top Gear staff who had to get checked for concussion at hospital and the staff member worried that he'd be fired for being punched? Now add being female to that power dynamic. Of course she didn't fight back.

DarkDayforMN · 11/06/2023 01:29

To the people including Carr saying that she can't have been allergic or she wouldn't have been picking the food out: some allergies aren't that serious, not all food allergies cause anaphylaxis.

Google says that allergy to coriander tends to manifest as hives or swelling. She wasn't risking her life. I'm allergic to lanolin but if I'm exposed to a very small amount of it I probably wouldn't even notice the allergy symptoms.

And it's assault anyway, even if she wasn't allergic. What a nauseating dick Carr is.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 01:28

How do you stuff something into someone's mouth?

It's easy if you catch someone by suprise

Especially if you have power over them by dint of being their boss, or being the only bankable star in the room.

This is a show of male dominance similar in mechanism to oral rape, existing on the same spectrum of male violence towards women as rape and choking.

Watching his "comedy", my spidey senses told me for a long time that this is not a man I should ever be alone with. He has now demonstrated that I should trust my gut.

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 01:28

That's not what the writer implies, though.

He wants to know why one of them is picking bits out of her salad. He doesn’t accept that she’s allergic to coriander. Whoever heard of being allergic to coriander? (...) He picks up the coriander and stuffs it into the mouth of the woman who said she was allergic.

Talking or not, surely you'd see a hand shooting towards you and ward it off. And stuffing in the bits off her plate? It sticks to your fingers. I know because I pick it out of my salad too. It takes ages but I hate the taste.
I suppose it could happen, it just sounds strange to me.

Theunamedcat · 11/06/2023 01:18

It's easy if you catch someone by suprise perhaps talking to someone else distracted maybe

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 01:13

How do you stuff something into someone's mouth? Wouldn't they just move their head to one side? Did he get them into a headlock and prise open their jaw or something? With everyone watching. You'd think that the reporter would have mentioned that. Sounds a bit bizarre to me.

CheeseTouch · 11/06/2023 01:13

Surely it is assault to force someone with a known allergy that you have been told about into contact with the thing they are allergic to?

GingerScallop · 11/06/2023 01:11

Apricotflanday · 11/06/2023 00:39

I'm allergic to coriander, among other things, and I would pick the leaves out where possible. Obviously if it's chopped into small pieces and mixed in it isn't possible, but I'm allergic to basil also and I just take the leaves off pizza or whatever.

My allergy is serious. Often it means intense itching, lips swelling, and a hoarse voice and wheezy breathing as my throat swells. If someone put something I was allergic to in my mouth it would also cause me panic, fear and distress.

I'm finding it upsetting reading comments here suggesting an allergy can't be serious if we can take the items we're allergic out and avoid eating them. My experience of allergies is that people often try to dismiss, deny and undermine my needs and it can be frightening because although some people will stop at rudely questioning me, others will not bother to avoid putting ingredients I'm allergic to in the food or might go as far as Carr is alleged to have done.
(I have known people do similar, such as putting an allergen in someone's drink as a 'joke'.)

So please stop denying our medical conditions!

am also surprised by how dismissive people are about how another person navigates their allergies simply because thats now how they or their loved ones would do it. Not even considering that allergies vary in hoe they present themselves m And regardless, it's horrible behaviour to force food in someone's mouth. And the oh they could have moved their head or batted it away. Well may be it was a junior and AC has form for this so they have learnt to bear it or laugh even though they hate it. May be the person froze. It doesn't matter. It shouldn't have happened

Timeflieswhenyourehavingfun · 11/06/2023 01:09

Forgot to add Alan Carr is woeful. How anyone finds him entertaining is beyond me.

Timeflieswhenyourehavingfun · 11/06/2023 01:07

LizzieSiddal · 11/06/2023 00:22

Agree with others that it’s rather odd that someone with an allergy would “pick out” that food from a salad. The person cannot have been allergic to it as it would have touched other things they were about to eat!

I like AC and think the writing in that piece is dreadful.

Not odd in the slightest. I’m allergic to strawberries. If I am served something with strawberries I just remove them from my plate.

My allergy only flares up if I eat a strawberry. I can eat everything else on the plate once the strawberries have been removed.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 01:06

You don't go round stuffing food into the mouth of people full stop.

It's called assault.

AndEverWhoKnew · 11/06/2023 00:56

There are different severities of allergies. If I accidentally buy a salad with my allergen in it (because it's been added to everything lately and previously 'safe' salads aren't any longer) I can pick the leaves out that I'm allergic to.
I would not be happy if someone tried to stuff it in my mouth.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 11/06/2023 00:52

There are different types of allergy - of course if you have the anaphylactic type then just picking out the ingredient won't be enough.

As the article linked by a PP points out, coriander is usually the oral allergy syndrome type - not deadly, and for most people the odd contact trace left after picking out the leaves wouldn't be a problem. But having several leaves stuffed directly into your mouth could still be extremely unpleasant.

YukoandHiro · 11/06/2023 00:46

LizzieSiddal · 11/06/2023 00:24

I will add that I have two nieces with allergies and there isn’t a chance in hell they’d be “picking out” the food they’re allergic too. They wouldn’t even touch it.

I agree but it really isn't the point - because clearly he didn't actually say that (which would have been a valid objection)

Swipe left for the next trending thread