Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alan Carr - stuffs herb into mouth of team member who says she is allergic to it

210 replies

cakeorwine · 10/06/2023 22:59

‘I used to say awful things’: Alan Carr on divorce, dating and the skit that haunts him | Alan Carr | The Guardian

Idiot. There is so much to say about this - power, control and a total lack of understanding of allergies.

"We’re in a big echoing loft with wood floors and he’s talking to his team as if they are all on stage and I – sitting in the corner – am the audience. He wants to know why one of them is picking bits out of her salad. He doesn’t accept that she’s allergic to coriander. Whoever heard of being allergic to coriander?"

There are six of us in this photo studio, including Carr’s manager, makeup, wardrobe and a publicist from ITV. He picks up the coriander and stuffs it into the mouth of the woman who said she was allergic. “See!” he declares, triumphant. “You’re not really allergic. If you were, you’d be dead by now.” He cackles. Everyone else cackles. It’s like the canned laughter of witches"

I just don't know what to say about this. Some allergies are less well known but still cause allergic reactions. And should be taken seriously.

‘I used to say awful things’: Alan Carr on divorce, dating and the skit that haunts him

He’s the extrovert who used to pick on others for laughs. But after struggling in lockdown and a bruising separation, the comic insists he’s grown up – and is happier than ever

https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2023/may/27/alan-carr-interview-i-used-to-say-awful-things

OP posts:
SquatBetty · 11/06/2023 08:50

It's an interesting interview, apart from the coriander business, there's a few other significant bits and various words used which seem to imply that Carr is a bit of a cunt in real life.

Maybe he is or maybe it's a hatchet job from the Guardian - who knows?

Caffinefree · 11/06/2023 08:50

I pick out and pick round the food that I am allergic to as it won’t cause me immediate life threatening issues but the vomit, the bloating, the pain when I have eaten them without initially realising is horrid. I am amazed at the over confidence shown here about how this woman probably wasn’t allergic. Bit like the nursery staff who deliberately fed my allergic ds a fruit that isn’t a usual allergen as “she didn’t want him to miss out” which is what he did when it was a week before he was well enough to return to school.

Mirandawrongs · 11/06/2023 08:50

I’m allergic to lavender and it’s everywhere!
I can walk past it and as long as I don’t touch it I don’t need my epipen.
I can however, dig it out of the garden and be fine.

even so, the attitude towards someone’s allergies are almost abusive on here.
would they have found it funny if he’d smashed a cream cake into their face just because he wanted to?
is it just banter?
tom foolery? Just like John Barrowman??

Mooserp · 11/06/2023 08:50

Gtsr443 · 11/06/2023 08:21

Did he though?
Did he force her to eat it?
Did he force her to open her mouth and make her chew and swallow it?
Did he hold her down to ensure she did it?
Did he threaten her with getting the sack if she didn't comply with his demands?

Or does he know he really well and do they have a long standing relationship and friendship and regularly arse about and did he just shove it towards her because she's one of those allergic to everything type people that aren't actually allergic to anything?

That's exactly what I thought. Could be an 'in joke'. It seems unlikely he would do something genuinely unpleasant and aggressive in front of a journalist.

CurlewKate · 11/06/2023 08:47
  1. Some allergies are contact only, so yes you can pick the offending item off a plate. But
  2. It doesn't matter why she didn't want to eat coriander. It tastes vile to some people-like soap. She didn't want to eat it. His behaviour was appalling.
maddening · 11/06/2023 08:42

YukoandHiro · 11/06/2023 08:32

I totally get where you're coming from but the problem is that when people use "allergy" when they mean "intolerance", some people think my epi pen carrying children will only feel a bit queasy or get the runs if they come across their allergen so it's not that big a deal and/or I'm a mad helicopter parent.

I think everyone ought to be clear about the language used.

Clinicians now talk about "immediate allergy" and "delayed allergy" or IGE and non-IGE which might be better to use than intolerance

Tbh while not life threatening an intolerance reaction is awful, it can be many hours of severe pain, exhaustion, sweating, feeling hollowed out etc as well as impacting bowel movements so being blasé about the impact of these because it is not immediately life threatening is not nice, or necessary imo both can be true

VDisappointing · 11/06/2023 08:42

Apparently some people have a different gene and coriander tastes like soap - its likely she was just using 'allergy' as a short cut but regardless that is appalling behaviour if it happened.

wildfirewonder · 11/06/2023 08:36

Apricotflanday · 11/06/2023 00:39

I'm allergic to coriander, among other things, and I would pick the leaves out where possible. Obviously if it's chopped into small pieces and mixed in it isn't possible, but I'm allergic to basil also and I just take the leaves off pizza or whatever.

My allergy is serious. Often it means intense itching, lips swelling, and a hoarse voice and wheezy breathing as my throat swells. If someone put something I was allergic to in my mouth it would also cause me panic, fear and distress.

I'm finding it upsetting reading comments here suggesting an allergy can't be serious if we can take the items we're allergic out and avoid eating them. My experience of allergies is that people often try to dismiss, deny and undermine my needs and it can be frightening because although some people will stop at rudely questioning me, others will not bother to avoid putting ingredients I'm allergic to in the food or might go as far as Carr is alleged to have done.
(I have known people do similar, such as putting an allergen in someone's drink as a 'joke'.)

So please stop denying our medical conditions!

Just want to amplify this.

A lot of disgusting posts on this thread minimising Carr's behaviour and minimising allergies in general.

Florissant · 11/06/2023 08:35

TheDogthatDug · 11/06/2023 08:21

As a PP has already said, someone with an allergy would not simply pick the coriander out and eat the rest, it could still cause an allergic reaction because the other food could be contaminated by it. Perhaps this woman has the gene that makes coriander taste horrible. I have it, coriander tastes like disinfectant to me and I pick the bits out of my food as well.

So the woman in the article is lying?

Princesspeach31 · 11/06/2023 08:34

Ah this is disappointing! Especially as I have a friend who was a runner on the Allan Carr Show years ago and absolutely loved him - apparently he was very sweet and kind.

YukoandHiro · 11/06/2023 08:32

NumberTheory · 11/06/2023 07:40

There are plenty of things people have allergies to that probably won’t send them into anaphylactic shock immediately it or anything it’s touched gets past their lips.

I have an allergy to a substance used in surgery that got sewn inside me and just got a little swelling and an itchy rash (which was how we found out I was allergic).

I also have a food intolerance that I often call an allergy because it’s not as well understood. I’m not allergic, my life isn’t in any danger, but it makes me throw up if I eat it so I try to avoid it. If I talk about it as an intolerance people think I mean I just don’t like it (not the case - I love it and have from time to time deliberately planned to have it and then be somewhere where throwing up won’t disturb anyone) so I say allergy for ease when it won’t result in more work for someone.

I totally get where you're coming from but the problem is that when people use "allergy" when they mean "intolerance", some people think my epi pen carrying children will only feel a bit queasy or get the runs if they come across their allergen so it's not that big a deal and/or I'm a mad helicopter parent.

I think everyone ought to be clear about the language used.

Clinicians now talk about "immediate allergy" and "delayed allergy" or IGE and non-IGE which might be better to use than intolerance

cakeorwine · 11/06/2023 08:30

Gtsr443 · 11/06/2023 08:02

Bollocks.
You know nothing about how Alan and his team interact. But I do.

Same person interjects later on to say she'd look after him if he needed a hip replacement.
He says no it would be like Misery. (Which is a good gag)
The coriander stuffed victim has the agency to leave his employ at any point - she hasn't been trafficked fgs. They were all just pissing about and they get on like a house on fire.

Is Alan Carr the new (gay male) target for MN now the Schofield thing has died down?

Being gay does not let you off putting something into someone's mouth if they say they are allergic to it.

If this was an article about any celebrity doing this, then there would and should be concerns.

Do you think it's appropriate to do something like this?

OP posts:
CurtainsForBea · 11/06/2023 08:29

That's really interesting @YukoandHiro . We have had a few really bad winters with DS's cold urticaria. But the past one was quite reasonable and managed with piriton only so I have been cautiously optimistic!

Weal · 11/06/2023 08:27

Gtsr443 · 11/06/2023 08:21

Did he though?
Did he force her to eat it?
Did he force her to open her mouth and make her chew and swallow it?
Did he hold her down to ensure she did it?
Did he threaten her with getting the sack if she didn't comply with his demands?

Or does he know he really well and do they have a long standing relationship and friendship and regularly arse about and did he just shove it towards her because she's one of those allergic to everything type people that aren't actually allergic to anything?

I honestly can’t imagine a way in which someone could put something in my mouth, that I didn’t want, that was done in a friendly arsing about type of way. Simply can’t imagine it. I can imagine a cunty type person doing it and pretends it’s just a joke.

YukoandHiro · 11/06/2023 08:26

CurtainsForBea · 11/06/2023 08:23

That has made me feel physically ill.

remember the child who died at school because other kids threw cheese at him because he was allergic to dairy?

I have a child who has a peanut allergy. My aunt scoffed when she heard this and said that there were no such things as allergies in her day and she would feed him a peanut butter sandwich when I was not looking. Guess who never is permitted to go near my child?

He also has a rare allergy (cold urticaria) that means he is literally allergic to the cold. Rainwater on the skin? Hives. Went swimming in the sea? Ebded upo in A&E (which is how we found out about it) he cannot drink cold drinks or eat ice cream because his throat might swell and he needs his epipens. Try explianing this one to people who think it is a load of arse.

Alan Carr committed assault. No dressing it up. Stuffing anyhting into someone's mouth is assault anyway. Add on an allergy or an intolerance and it could be deadly.

And all played for laughs.

Fucker.

Ugh I feel your pain. Also have DDs with multiple allergies and don't trust most people around them and food.

RE cold urticaria, my eldest had this from age 2 to 5 and then seemed to randomly outgrow. She's only 6 now so we'll see this autumn, but it can suddenly disappear apparently

Clymene · 11/06/2023 08:25

@TheDogthatDug - that's not true. I'm allergic to kiwi. I avoid it altogether usually but if I pick it out of a ready made salad and don't drink the juice, I can eat the rest of it.

itsgettingweird · 11/06/2023 08:24

DuranNotSpandeau · 10/06/2023 23:42

Shitty behaviour but the story is very weird. I have DS and various family and friends with food allergies and there is no way they would just pick out their allergen from a plate of food and eat the rest.
But that's just my take on the wider story. Which doesn't detract from the fact that comes out of this as a hideous individual.

Agree.

The behaviour isn't great and it sounds like the age old powerful people using others for their jokes and lols.

However I don't believe it's written as the absolute truth because you don't pick out food you're allergic too as it leaves traces.

Also it gets in your hands which then risks you getting it on clothes and mouth etc.

It's very odd all round.

monsteramunch · 11/06/2023 08:24

did he just shove it towards her

Well no, the article is clear. If the author is telling the truth, and I don't imagine it would have been worth her lying, then he didn't 'just' do that.

"He picks up the coriander and stuffs it into the mouth of the woman who said she was allergic."

Clymene · 11/06/2023 08:23

I think the point of including that in the article @Gtsr443 is to show that he is not interested in other people's boundaries

CurtainsForBea · 11/06/2023 08:23

That has made me feel physically ill.

remember the child who died at school because other kids threw cheese at him because he was allergic to dairy?

I have a child who has a peanut allergy. My aunt scoffed when she heard this and said that there were no such things as allergies in her day and she would feed him a peanut butter sandwich when I was not looking. Guess who never is permitted to go near my child?

He also has a rare allergy (cold urticaria) that means he is literally allergic to the cold. Rainwater on the skin? Hives. Went swimming in the sea? Ebded upo in A&E (which is how we found out about it) he cannot drink cold drinks or eat ice cream because his throat might swell and he needs his epipens. Try explianing this one to people who think it is a load of arse.

Alan Carr committed assault. No dressing it up. Stuffing anyhting into someone's mouth is assault anyway. Add on an allergy or an intolerance and it could be deadly.

And all played for laughs.

Fucker.

monsteramunch · 11/06/2023 08:22

Do you know him personally @Gtsr443?

TheDogthatDug · 11/06/2023 08:21

As a PP has already said, someone with an allergy would not simply pick the coriander out and eat the rest, it could still cause an allergic reaction because the other food could be contaminated by it. Perhaps this woman has the gene that makes coriander taste horrible. I have it, coriander tastes like disinfectant to me and I pick the bits out of my food as well.

Gtsr443 · 11/06/2023 08:21

Motnight · 11/06/2023 08:13

Hahaha. That's right. Man in power has every right to force one of his employees to eat something she doesn't want to. Nothing to see here!

Did he though?
Did he force her to eat it?
Did he force her to open her mouth and make her chew and swallow it?
Did he hold her down to ensure she did it?
Did he threaten her with getting the sack if she didn't comply with his demands?

Or does he know he really well and do they have a long standing relationship and friendship and regularly arse about and did he just shove it towards her because she's one of those allergic to everything type people that aren't actually allergic to anything?

Clawdy · 11/06/2023 08:17

topnoddy · 11/06/2023 08:03

Another attention seeking unfunny twat

Exactly.

monsteramunch · 11/06/2023 08:17

I was disappointed (as I liked Alan Carr) that he seemed to say the abuse victim of Justin Lee Collins' horrific abuse was also to blame for that abuse.

"He was obviously in a toxic relationship and he’s now sorted himself out. I didn’t want to throw him under the bus because he’s a good friend and he’s sorted himself out."

Framing a man doing the stuff Justin Lee Collins did to her as 'a toxic relationship' was hugely minimising and victim blaming IMO... awful.

--

Collins compelled her to write down in a notebook all her previous sexual encounters in graphic detail. She said he forced her to quit social networking websites, always sleep facing him and throw away DVDs because they featured actors she found attractive.

She claimed Collins attacked her while on trips to Miami and New York and said she had not shown anyone her bruises because she did not want to get "the love of my life" into trouble.

The court was played a secret recording Larke made during a row shortly before the couple split in July last year. Collins told Larke: "You bring the fucking demon out in me" and called her a "fucking slag". He also allegedly told her she had had sex with "blacks" and "ch-nks".