Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alan Carr - stuffs herb into mouth of team member who says she is allergic to it

210 replies

cakeorwine · 10/06/2023 22:59

‘I used to say awful things’: Alan Carr on divorce, dating and the skit that haunts him | Alan Carr | The Guardian

Idiot. There is so much to say about this - power, control and a total lack of understanding of allergies.

"We’re in a big echoing loft with wood floors and he’s talking to his team as if they are all on stage and I – sitting in the corner – am the audience. He wants to know why one of them is picking bits out of her salad. He doesn’t accept that she’s allergic to coriander. Whoever heard of being allergic to coriander?"

There are six of us in this photo studio, including Carr’s manager, makeup, wardrobe and a publicist from ITV. He picks up the coriander and stuffs it into the mouth of the woman who said she was allergic. “See!” he declares, triumphant. “You’re not really allergic. If you were, you’d be dead by now.” He cackles. Everyone else cackles. It’s like the canned laughter of witches"

I just don't know what to say about this. Some allergies are less well known but still cause allergic reactions. And should be taken seriously.

‘I used to say awful things’: Alan Carr on divorce, dating and the skit that haunts him

He’s the extrovert who used to pick on others for laughs. But after struggling in lockdown and a bruising separation, the comic insists he’s grown up – and is happier than ever

https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2023/may/27/alan-carr-interview-i-used-to-say-awful-things

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Florissant · 11/06/2023 19:59

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 11/06/2023 09:23

@LimitIsUp how is it "clearly "?

Allergies differ in the seriousness of a reaction, what kind of contact is needed for a reaction, the form the allergen is in (raw,cooked etc. ) and so on.There is no clearly.

That is true. Nice to see a post with common sense.

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 18:57

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 14:22

Heaven forbid that I take what someone says at face value. Hmm

But he didnt say it. He's never said anything publicly.
If you believe his solicitor when he says Tymon was scared about losing his job, then you must believe the solicitor when he says Tymon wasn't going to sue. As it turned out be a lie that Tymon wasn't going to sue, then it's only natural that it would be a lie that he was scared about losing his job. Which let's not forget, not only did he not lose but he actually got a promotion.
Anyway, we're just going round in circles now so probably best not to keep going on about it. Neither of us will persuade the other to think differently. 🙂

cakeorwine · 11/06/2023 14:22

Soontobe60 · 11/06/2023 14:17

If your DD were allergic to coriander, would she choose a salad with it in? My DD hates coriander - isn't allergic - but would not even touch a salad with it in because it’s impossible to guarantee every last piece has been removed. I mean, it’s not like being allergic to, say, eggs and taking a hard boiled egg off the top of a salad is it?

DS doesn't eat salads so that's not a problem.

He is careful around what he eats - although it's a problem when somethings have generic labels such as "herbs, spices".

But you can see that some people on here would remove coriander if they had an allergy to it. And continue to eat from the food. That's their way of dealing with an allergy.

Each person finds their own way. I am sure they get used to people not believing their allergy but they don't expect others to try and shove food into their mouth that they say they are allergic to.

OP posts:
VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 14:22

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 14:02

Tymon never said he feared for his job. "The source" said he did but the source also said he wasn't going to sue. Tymon went to his solicitor straight after the incident. Someone at the solicitors said Tymon feared for his job and mentions suing. Maybe I'm cynical but that points to Tymon setting up the back ground to suing. As in "it was even more traumatic because I feared for my job", which equals more money.
People who have been assaulted don't usually have a solicitor on speed dial who speaks to the press anonymously. People intending to sue do that. He's perfectly entitled to compensation. What happened to him was unacceptable. But the idea he was an insignificant dogsbody just keeping quiet so he didnt lose his job is nonsense. He was the producer of Top Gear, BBC's biggest earner. He got over a £100,000+ settlement. He got a promotion.

Heaven forbid that I take what someone says at face value. Hmm

Soontobe60 · 11/06/2023 14:17

cakeorwine · 10/06/2023 23:27

I have a DS who has allergies (some rarer than the well known ones) so it's made me really cross.

It's hard to get some people to take the lesser well known ones seriously.

If your DD were allergic to coriander, would she choose a salad with it in? My DD hates coriander - isn't allergic - but would not even touch a salad with it in because it’s impossible to guarantee every last piece has been removed. I mean, it’s not like being allergic to, say, eggs and taking a hard boiled egg off the top of a salad is it?

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 14:02

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 12:57

You're right that Tymon never gave an interview. His comments were reported in the press. https://www.pressreader.com/uk/sunday-mirror/20150315/281625303781331

He did fear for his job.

Tymon never said he feared for his job. "The source" said he did but the source also said he wasn't going to sue. Tymon went to his solicitor straight after the incident. Someone at the solicitors said Tymon feared for his job and mentions suing. Maybe I'm cynical but that points to Tymon setting up the back ground to suing. As in "it was even more traumatic because I feared for my job", which equals more money.
People who have been assaulted don't usually have a solicitor on speed dial who speaks to the press anonymously. People intending to sue do that. He's perfectly entitled to compensation. What happened to him was unacceptable. But the idea he was an insignificant dogsbody just keeping quiet so he didnt lose his job is nonsense. He was the producer of Top Gear, BBC's biggest earner. He got over a £100,000+ settlement. He got a promotion.

longtompot · 11/06/2023 13:51

monsteramunch · 11/06/2023 13:27

And even if someone just doesn't like something, and isn't allergic, shoving it into their mouth against their will is still absolutely fucking bizarre and unacceptable behaviour.

Absolutely agree, I forgot to say that in my post.

Radyward · 11/06/2023 13:50

Doesnt surprise me. went to see him in his stand up show in london and He was shocking.so unfunny- nothing likeable about him and up to this point i believed his tv persona.

DarkDayforMN · 11/06/2023 13:38

It's so insane that anyone is defending him. Imagine if he'd been the author of the AIBU post.

"I shoved coriander into my employee's mouth because I don't think she's really allergic to it and now lots of people are saying I'm an abusive POS but I think I've totally reformed, AIBU?"

bussteward · 11/06/2023 13:31

jojo1067 · 11/06/2023 09:31

What is interesting is that so many people are taking what a journalist has written as absolute fact without hearing the other side of the story. And so the subject is vilified on the word of one person. We truly are in an age of trial by social media.

You don’t think journalists report facts, sub-editors double check, editors run anything whiffy past legal lest they get a libel suit on their hands?

cakeorwine · 11/06/2023 13:29

I wonder what he thought when the article came out?

I wonder if he has actually read it and wondered if he might not come across very well with this incident?

OP posts:
monsteramunch · 11/06/2023 13:27

longtompot · 11/06/2023 13:25

Yanbu. I thought the same when I read the article last week. All I could think, hope of him, was he knew he very well and knew she didn't like the taste of it rather than a full blown allergy. But that said, no one should ever mess about where allergies are concerned. It's not a joke to have your mouth and throat swell up.

And even if someone just doesn't like something, and isn't allergic, shoving it into their mouth against their will is still absolutely fucking bizarre and unacceptable behaviour.

longtompot · 11/06/2023 13:25

Yanbu. I thought the same when I read the article last week. All I could think, hope of him, was he knew he very well and knew she didn't like the taste of it rather than a full blown allergy. But that said, no one should ever mess about where allergies are concerned. It's not a joke to have your mouth and throat swell up.

Clymene · 11/06/2023 13:21

cakeorwine · 11/06/2023 13:13

If it didn't happen the way described, then I am sure we will see some kind of statement from him?

Or indeed any of the other people there, including the woman who said she was allergic to coriander.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 13:14

Gtsr443 · 11/06/2023 07:42

I cannot believe that anyone would read the whole article and their takeaway would be - coriander. Ffs.

He speaks with great self awareness about how his comedy has changed and his failings and weaknesses and the sexual abuse of women by comedians like Louis CK.

But yeah. Coriander.

Yet he doesn't see the parallel between forcing your cock into someone's mouth and forcing unwanted food into someone's mouth? He's paying lip service to changing his tune and the writer has cleverly made that obvious.

cakeorwine · 11/06/2023 13:13

If it didn't happen the way described, then I am sure we will see some kind of statement from him?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 11/06/2023 13:12

ReachForTheMars · 11/06/2023 13:04

Agreed. How can anyone believe he literally picked up multiple pieces of coriander, forced simeone's mouth open and put it inside.

At best it was probably picked up and pretended to feed it to person.

There are plenty of stories of things that celebrities have done that people would not believe.

But have happened.

OP posts:
ReachForTheMars · 11/06/2023 13:04

user1471453601 · 11/06/2023 00:04

It seems highly improbable that one person could forcibly stuff something into another person's mouth without using a degree of force that would overpower someone. In the normal run of things, if someone tried to put something in your mouth, you'd either move your head away, or bat their hand away.

Improbable it happened the way it was described

Agreed. How can anyone believe he literally picked up multiple pieces of coriander, forced simeone's mouth open and put it inside.

At best it was probably picked up and pretended to feed it to person.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 12:57

Gracewithoutend · 11/06/2023 02:09

No, but they might sack her for swatting his hand away. Think about it, how else was she going to stop him?

They're not going to sack her for self-defence.

My memory of the time is that JC went to his boss once he had sobered up and fessed up. The guy said when interviewed that he feared for his job. JC got JC sacked.

He was the producer of Top Gear. As far as I know he's never given an interview.
He sued JC and BBC for racial discrimination and personal injury, and received a £100,000+ settlement. He was promoted. And his attacker was, rightly in my opinion, sacked.

You're right that Tymon never gave an interview. His comments were reported in the press. https://www.pressreader.com/uk/sunday-mirror/20150315/281625303781331

He did fear for his job.

PressReader.com - Digital Newspaper & Magazine Subscriptions

Digital newsstand featuring 7000+ of the world’s most popular newspapers & magazines. Enjoy unlimited reading on up to 5 devices with 7-day free trial.

https://www.pressreader.com/uk/sunday-mirror/20150315/281625303781331

Tessisme · 11/06/2023 11:35

CurlewKate · 11/06/2023 11:31

It doesn't actually matter whether she was allergic or not.

I agree.

To me it seems like an aggressive act, rather than a funny one.

CurlewKate · 11/06/2023 11:31

It doesn't actually matter whether she was allergic or not.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 11/06/2023 10:55

As for the idea that it's all a bit of journalist whimsy, any editor is going to challenge a description of a criminal act by an identifiable person - because if it didn't happen they are going to be sued for libel. The writer had better be damned sure of the facts before it gets into print.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 11/06/2023 10:52

It's the allergy, itself I'm arguing about because I'm not seeing it. It may have been the case but looking at this article, I'm not seeing it as a serious allergy.

Are you an immunologist, @Artycrafts? A medical doctor with specific training in allergies? A lawyer?

I'm guessing not, because you are unbelievably wrong about this.

1 There are multiple types of allergy. And varying degrees of severity for each type.

A reaction can be immediate and serious, immediate and mild, delayed and serious, or delayed and mild. ('Mild' can still be very unpleasant, but not life threatening) And some reactions are dose dependent.

If you have a mild,.dose-dependent allergy it is perfectly reasonable to pick out the ingredients if it's only a few bits.

My DP and DM both have oral allergy syndrome (which is the type of allergy coriander usually causes). If they pick the ingredient in question out of a salad the reaction is very slight tingling, so not enough to bother sending the dish back. Eating a handful.of it would cause a much bigger and more troublesome reaction For the next 24 hours. Their reaction is fairly quick but not immediate - it takes a few minutes - and if it was a small amount it's not visible to an external observer. So when Carr thinks he's 'disproved' the allergy, he is wrong.

I have a more serious (but still not life threatening) allergy of a different type. I could eat a whole bowl of the problem food and show no reaction at all for several hours. But eating even a teaspoon of it means I will be noticably ill for several weeks, and it takes about 3 months for the damage caused to heal.

  1. None of that is actually relevant because stuffing an unwanted item into a person's mouth is assault whether they have an allergy or not. If the person has an allergy (especially if the attacker knows about it), that raises the charge from common assault to at least ABH.
OP posts:
monsteramunch · 11/06/2023 10:22

Goady because I disagree? Yeah, ok

What do you disagree with though? What is it the OP has said that you think is incorrect or unreasonable?