Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stay in loveless marriage because we cannot afford to separate

139 replies

Hillbilly · 10/06/2023 21:48

Our marriage is dead although we rub along ok together. Two DCs, 17 and 15. There is no way we can afford to live separately and provide two homes for them. The 17 yr old still has another year in education and because we live in London and he may not go to Uni (although he would want to leave home- that's another story - so difficult to afford to live here independently) then realistically we would both need places that can accommodate both kids. DS2 poss may go to Uni but who knows. Both of us self employed and we love the area we live in. To sell the flat (ex council) would not give either of us enough to buy again. My business is heavily dependent on the area we live in (wealthy client base). Both on our mid/late 50s. We have talked about it but no solutions 😞

OP posts:
Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 20:35

whumpthereitis · 11/06/2023 18:50

If you’re otherwise comfortable, want to maintain your lifestyle, and remain in the area in which you live, then it’s absolutely legitimate to prioritise those things and make that choice.

Financial security is important, and the reality is that without that you can find that freedom from one prison is merely a transfer to another.

We aren't comfortable financially but slightly improved since I started my business. We have been hand to mouth in the past. Our "lifestyle" is nothing to write home about. We get by.
We need to have a frank discussion about the mortgage that's for sure.

OP posts:
Blip · 11/06/2023 19:25

Do you have two bedrooms or three?
How long do you expect it to be before you can have your own bedroom?

Are you sharing a 4'6" standard double bed at the moment? If so can you at least move to twin beds or a superking?

whumpthereitis · 11/06/2023 18:50

If you’re otherwise comfortable, want to maintain your lifestyle, and remain in the area in which you live, then it’s absolutely legitimate to prioritise those things and make that choice.

Financial security is important, and the reality is that without that you can find that freedom from one prison is merely a transfer to another.

greyhairnomore · 11/06/2023 18:35

If your mortgage is interest only and you have no plans to pay it off you might as well cut your losses , sell it and move on. You might be able to get on the ladder in a cheaper part of the country ?

LizzieSiddal · 11/06/2023 18:32

Much better to address this now than get the end of the term and be forced into decisions.

There is a middle ground though. Stay in the flat until the Dc have finished school.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/06/2023 18:07

IneedanewTV · 11/06/2023 17:52

The interest only mortgage is a real concern. I hope you are on a very low long term fixed rate. With a repayment mortgage you get to a certain point where you start clearing a tiny part of the principal and each year it gets better. With an interest only mortgage how do propose to pay it off? The bank will not be kind. They will want their money at the end of the term. This would be my main concern.

Mine too. Much better to address this now than get the end of the term and be forced into decisions.

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 18:06

LaurieFairyCake · 11/06/2023 18:01

Does your Dh not contribute much then - if you're at maximum capacity what is HE doing?

We contribute equally to household expenses including mortgage

OP posts:
LaurieFairyCake · 11/06/2023 18:01

Does your Dh not contribute much then - if you're at maximum capacity what is HE doing?

IneedanewTV · 11/06/2023 17:52

The interest only mortgage is a real concern. I hope you are on a very low long term fixed rate. With a repayment mortgage you get to a certain point where you start clearing a tiny part of the principal and each year it gets better. With an interest only mortgage how do propose to pay it off? The bank will not be kind. They will want their money at the end of the term. This would be my main concern.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/06/2023 17:47

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 17:38

My business is prob at the max it can be in the format it is.

Reformat? Franchise? Sorry I’m such an insufferable Pollyanna that I’m trying to see that as an opportunity. I hate seeing a woman having her happiness so dependent on a man.

and you’ll have to sell (or remortgage) anyway when your mortgage term ends. I’d do it now. And be happy.

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 17:38

BitOutOfPractice · 11/06/2023 16:46

“So if you are happy to rub along until your kids have left home then tbh that is what I would do. “

but op isn’t happy is she? That’s why she’s here.

is your business scalable op? That’s what I’d be doing! Looking to being financially independent and happy, quick sharp. Living together but apart will kill you slowly but surely.

My business is prob at the max it can be in the format it is.

OP posts:
IneedanewTV · 11/06/2023 17:38

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 02:16

We live in a very wealthy area but even so if we sold the flat neither of us would be able to stay in the area. We have nothing left over at the end of each month even with a low mortgage. There is no leeway financially.

Most couples divorcing have to change location and move to a cheaper area or cheaper street. With the money from a house in London you could both afford somewhere in the suburbs or kent etc . In the end you have one life and yesterday has gone. Once the children leave then what. I have a friend who stayed in a loveless marriage. Her H had a terrible accident. She is now his carer and hates it. But she can’t walk away now as she made her bed.

Mummy08m · 11/06/2023 17:30

AscensionToCheese · 11/06/2023 17:16

I don't mean mismatched values, I meant what people value enough to stay.
Financial security? A 'life partner' they can do stuff with?

I have dated people who were fundamentally 'good' and did what they were supposed to. Because of that I would say 'good communication' i.e. they would do the school run, not be stingy, etc.

However we didn't actually have much in common, enough to want to spend time together as a couple. And I have seen this pattern across many couples, beyond the kids there's nothing to talk about. People change too, across the decades of life.

Some people value financial security above all else and so opt to stay, preferring to fill the gap with friends. Some choose to break up, and find that life partner who accompanies them on trips, shared hobbies etc.

I appreciate this perspective...I guess we are all clouded by our own experiences/observations and I guess I've seen so many awful, awful relationships.

Also I suppose I'd been misunderstanding what good communication means until your comment - I assumed if you communicate well then you must be spending time together in order to do so. But as you put it, it could just mean texts like "I'm late for school pick up, can you do it today - sure i can do pickup, we need milk so grab that on your way home". In that case, yeah that's not good communication in my book.

Good communication, for me, means sharing your hopes/fears, opinions, wants/needs, day-to-day feelings, long term goals etc. If you can do that with someone, that's...a good marriage in my view.

But we don't know which type of "good communication" op and her dh have.

AscensionToCheese · 11/06/2023 17:16

Mummy08m · 11/06/2023 17:04

I agree but if values were mismatched I can't see how a marriage could last long enough to have teenage kids. Or how communication could be so good.

It sounds like OP communicate well and coparent well. That's...a pretty incredible achievement in my experience of marriages in my family and wider friends. Based on those two facts alone, this marriage would make it into the top few percentiles of marriages I have seen...!

I don't mean mismatched values, I meant what people value enough to stay.
Financial security? A 'life partner' they can do stuff with?

I have dated people who were fundamentally 'good' and did what they were supposed to. Because of that I would say 'good communication' i.e. they would do the school run, not be stingy, etc.

However we didn't actually have much in common, enough to want to spend time together as a couple. And I have seen this pattern across many couples, beyond the kids there's nothing to talk about. People change too, across the decades of life.

Some people value financial security above all else and so opt to stay, preferring to fill the gap with friends. Some choose to break up, and find that life partner who accompanies them on trips, shared hobbies etc.

Mummy08m · 11/06/2023 17:04

AscensionToCheese · 11/06/2023 16:59

But it's about what people value, yes?
I have seen many 'ok' marriages break up because say, the wife wanted to go out and do things, the husband just wanted to stay home and be boring.
Or sometimes, I'm not condoning affairs but you never know what you're missing until it appears in front of you.

I agree but if values were mismatched I can't see how a marriage could last long enough to have teenage kids. Or how communication could be so good.

It sounds like OP communicate well and coparent well. That's...a pretty incredible achievement in my experience of marriages in my family and wider friends. Based on those two facts alone, this marriage would make it into the top few percentiles of marriages I have seen...!

AscensionToCheese · 11/06/2023 16:59

Mummy08m · 11/06/2023 16:47

I'm sorry if it sounds like I'm harping on - I did read what you said that there's really no chance of reviving the marriage. I guess I'm just trying to understand because I can't work out how this fits with the comment I'm quoting.

I've got lots of broken-up marriages in my extended family - basically my parents, grandparents, all my aunts and uncles, nearly all of them have been divorced at least once each. I've seen my fair share of the dozens of ways a marriage can go wrong: infidelity, alcohol abuse, domestic violence, emotional bullying, neglect of children etc I've seen lots of examples. In nearly every example I've seen there's been one party (ok, usually the man) who has been the dickhead to start with, although after years of discord the other person also becomes vengeful/violent and everyone sucks. I've seen knives brandished, suicide threatened, police called.

I've never seen two people who are fundamentally ok people, communicate well, co-parent well, live together peacefully...and still not stay married.

I totally appreciate that we don't have a full picture because you've only posted a few posts and you don't have to tell us more, of course. But I hope you see what I'm getting at.

Maybe you'd respond (fairly!) that my bar is too low. It isn't in fundamentals. My husband was by my side for 36h through my labour with dd and never took a break. He'd take a bullet for me and I would for him. He's about a good a guy as I can find. But yeah, we have had issues like infidelity (that was me, many years ago) and dry spells of no sex, and silent spells due to depression (that was him, on another occasion). But the way I feel about marriage is like, if he's a fundamentally ok guy, it's always worth trying to give it another go.

Thanks for listening to my Ted talk lol

But it's about what people value, yes?
I have seen many 'ok' marriages break up because say, the wife wanted to go out and do things, the husband just wanted to stay home and be boring.
Or sometimes, I'm not condoning affairs but you never know what you're missing until it appears in front of you.

EarringsandLipstick · 11/06/2023 16:55

@LizzieSiddal

That's really interesting. I didn't know that.

Yes, I can imagine that line of thinking re moving / downsize. When I bought my first house, I did so planning to move within 5 years, it was a starter home in my eyes. A few years on, recession + related unemployment hit, and a few years later I was a single parent & struggling just to manage the mortgage. I'm relieved to have a home (major housing crisis where I live) but it's far from what I planned for this stage in my life

Snowy2022 · 11/06/2023 16:54

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 16:48

@LizzieSiddal H is also an optimist and has talked a good talk about massively increased income over the years. I can't disclose exactly what my employment status has been over the last 20, except to say I have always worked (school hrs when kids were little), and sometime after that I became self employed and full time. I cannot earn any more than I do already.

@Hillbilly

Mhmmm. Funny that! in reading all your posts the only thing that stood out was info about your DH and finances/ work. Must say your comment here doesn't surprise me and it is exactly as I expected.

Also, I believe the financial mess is really what's destroying your relationship. Sorry if finance cannot be resolved/ improved as it explains why you are certain you want out.

Quitelikeit · 11/06/2023 16:53

You haven’t given any precise figures

such as what is your property worth? How much is outstanding on your mortgage? If the bank have allowed interest only then they believed yoh when you said you were going to be able to pay it off

You must both be earning at least 2k?

Does your son have a weekend job? Can he contribute?

BitOutOfPractice · 11/06/2023 16:48

So you’re going to have to sell this property anyway, to pay off the mortgage? I’d be ripping that plaster off sooner rather than later op.

maranella · 11/06/2023 16:48

YANBU to suck it up until your DC have finished school. I wouldn't be splitting up and forcing my DC to move school during their finals years either OP and putting them first is entirely reasonable.

But what happens in three years' time? Once your DC have finished school you will have an opportunity to sell your flat and both move somewhere cheaper, so and at that point it will not be reasonable to stay in a dead marriage.

So, if I were you, that's what I'd be putting my energy into planning and preparing for - the next stage once your DC no longer need you to be living where you are.

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 16:48

@LizzieSiddal H is also an optimist and has talked a good talk about massively increased income over the years. I can't disclose exactly what my employment status has been over the last 20, except to say I have always worked (school hrs when kids were little), and sometime after that I became self employed and full time. I cannot earn any more than I do already.

OP posts:
Mummy08m · 11/06/2023 16:47

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 12:46

@Mamai90 it's not a miserable atmosphere at all. In fact it's a fairly happy household and for the most part we co parent pretty well.

I'm sorry if it sounds like I'm harping on - I did read what you said that there's really no chance of reviving the marriage. I guess I'm just trying to understand because I can't work out how this fits with the comment I'm quoting.

I've got lots of broken-up marriages in my extended family - basically my parents, grandparents, all my aunts and uncles, nearly all of them have been divorced at least once each. I've seen my fair share of the dozens of ways a marriage can go wrong: infidelity, alcohol abuse, domestic violence, emotional bullying, neglect of children etc I've seen lots of examples. In nearly every example I've seen there's been one party (ok, usually the man) who has been the dickhead to start with, although after years of discord the other person also becomes vengeful/violent and everyone sucks. I've seen knives brandished, suicide threatened, police called.

I've never seen two people who are fundamentally ok people, communicate well, co-parent well, live together peacefully...and still not stay married.

I totally appreciate that we don't have a full picture because you've only posted a few posts and you don't have to tell us more, of course. But I hope you see what I'm getting at.

Maybe you'd respond (fairly!) that my bar is too low. It isn't in fundamentals. My husband was by my side for 36h through my labour with dd and never took a break. He'd take a bullet for me and I would for him. He's about a good a guy as I can find. But yeah, we have had issues like infidelity (that was me, many years ago) and dry spells of no sex, and silent spells due to depression (that was him, on another occasion). But the way I feel about marriage is like, if he's a fundamentally ok guy, it's always worth trying to give it another go.

Thanks for listening to my Ted talk lol

BitOutOfPractice · 11/06/2023 16:46

“So if you are happy to rub along until your kids have left home then tbh that is what I would do. “

but op isn’t happy is she? That’s why she’s here.

is your business scalable op? That’s what I’d be doing! Looking to being financially independent and happy, quick sharp. Living together but apart will kill you slowly but surely.

LizzieSiddal · 11/06/2023 16:38

Sorry last post was to @EarringsandLipstick