Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stay in loveless marriage because we cannot afford to separate

139 replies

Hillbilly · 10/06/2023 21:48

Our marriage is dead although we rub along ok together. Two DCs, 17 and 15. There is no way we can afford to live separately and provide two homes for them. The 17 yr old still has another year in education and because we live in London and he may not go to Uni (although he would want to leave home- that's another story - so difficult to afford to live here independently) then realistically we would both need places that can accommodate both kids. DS2 poss may go to Uni but who knows. Both of us self employed and we love the area we live in. To sell the flat (ex council) would not give either of us enough to buy again. My business is heavily dependent on the area we live in (wealthy client base). Both on our mid/late 50s. We have talked about it but no solutions 😞

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
unicorncrumble · 19/06/2023 22:24

OP, are you happy? Do what makes you happy. If that's some sort of co-habiting because you e had children together and happily rubbing along then do it. Happily divorced couples are few and far between but it happens and it's awesome when it does. You do you x

Hillbilly · 19/06/2023 18:58

@HangerLaneGyratorySystem I'm sorry to hear of your situation. I've had a fair amount of emotional turmoil over the years as to our situation but interestingly, I'm now in a much more balanced place. We've also been brushing it under the carpet for years. The fact that we are now talking about the future, snd separating at some point is a good thing. The how of it is what we need to work out.
Best of luck to you ❤️

OP posts:
HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 18/06/2023 00:41

I am 60 and am divorcing H after 30+ years. On here I read about a book called Decision Time, and I used the techniques described in the book to help me - the premise is how to make a decision when there is no "best" outcome, when weighing up the pros and cons means you are none the wiser. It also talked about sticking to your values. My STBExH has a lot of issues, mostly with me. We've had at least 20 years of unhappiness, since DD2 was born really, and I stupidly stayed all these years, scared of the consequences, we were mired in debt although now all we owe is the mortgage (also been interest only for years) so that will take a third of our equity at the get go (if we ever sell!). So not quite the same as you OP, things are not ok but we have made one room into a bedsit and we just share kitchen and bathroom. Now are are stuck unable to sell our house, although the divorce comes through next month.

I'd never want to meet anyone else, the thought of it makes me sick. I'm walking away with what's left of my dignity and yes, I am facing having to move away from everyone, having less pension, no one to help out if I am ill etc., (although now adult DDs will help, they'll live with me for the time being at least). Interesting as many of my friends had the reactions I've seen on here and now I understand it a bit more - most people favour financial stability over any morals or values, but I couldn't do it, I couldn't go on. I feel desperately sad that we didn't make a go of it, but we stopped making a go of it many years ago, so that's where the regret lies for me, that I waited.

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 16/06/2023 09:42

Principal is the outstanding mortgage amount, currently you're on interest only so the amount owed never gets smaller. A normal loan repayment is part principle (amount owed) and part interest. You say you can pay 1/3 of that amount at the end of the term, so I'm guessing you have some savings toward this? I think uou mentioned no savings so maybe this is a different way you have to repay. If you have managed to save something towards paying the loan you might be able to use that as proof to show you can repay the actual amount owed, maybe by getting a new mortgage for a longer period of time. hichmeans you can the mortgage amount back more slowly. Your accountant should be able to tell you if this is a viable option. They should also check if there's any penalties for early repayment.

On the rooms situation, if one of your DS ends up going to university perhaps the big room could become DS1&2 shared room and you and DH could take a small room each. Might be helpful to keep this in the back of your mind as an option if you don't want/can't afford to move long term and feel a need for some space or privacy.

JFDIYOLO · 16/06/2023 00:40

Your relationship has shifted - you co parent well enough but you're more like housemates now.

Your options are limited and there are some things you've concluded you can't change because of finances.

So what CAN you change, to make things easier?

You're sharing a bed? This must be awkward.

Time to alter your arrangements. Sell the double bed.

Buy bunk beds for the boys - they can share the biggest room. They will be off living their own lives in a few years and it won't harm them in the meantime to give you some space.

Then you have your own separate rooms, keeping the single beds and doing your own thing. My mother and her late partner had separate rooms their last few years and described themselves as 'companions' rather than partners. It worked.

Hillbilly · 16/06/2023 00:10

@EliflurtleTripanInfinite appreciate your input. Def my ignorance but don't really understand the first paragraph about the mortgage which is why we probably need to see our accountant and our mortgage advisor.
The bedrooms are too small for DS1 to share on visits after they have left home. DS1 is most likely to go into work/apprenticeship post 19 when they finish college.
Re the situation with me and H, we have both checked out, and are now talking about our future and separation albeit tentatively. I don't think there's a need to change our bed to 2 singles.
I think after almost 10 years of decline, we are starting to be in a position emotionally to start to talk about what the future looks like and this thread had been very helpful to me 😊

OP posts:
EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 15/06/2023 21:44

Can you go back to paying principle and interest on the mortgage? If you show you can manage that refinancing at end of term might be an option depending on your ages and income.

If you can find a way to pay or refinance the mortgage one option longer term could be if either of the DC go to university they can stay in the other DCs room when home and then you and DH have a room each. You could currently change bedroom to 2 single beds put a divider down the middle. If you're amicable you don't necessarily need to sell, the issue is that it needs to all be above board. It's not fair to stay for years if DH doesn't know you've checked out and the marriage is over for you.

Rainbowsandfairies · 13/06/2023 09:31

Thanks for the advice xx

ArcticSkewer · 12/06/2023 22:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Leave the op and her thread alone. Ask for your own posts to be deleted if you wish.

Rainbowsandfairies · 12/06/2023 22:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/06/2023 21:58

Financial security is important, and the reality is that without that you can find that freedom from one prison is merely a transfer to another

But OP doesn't have financial security now. And the future looks worrying, regardless of staying married - a problematic mortgage & never planning to retire (what about infirmity or illness?)

OP I'm glad you are starting the process of planning with H. Good luck 💐

Rainbowsandfairies · 12/06/2023 21:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rainbowsandfairies · 12/06/2023 21:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hillbilly · 12/06/2023 20:33

Thank you everyone for all your feedback. I fully acknowledge that it's a shit show in regards to the mortgage but this thread has prompted me to talk to H briefly (as DS2was about to arrive) about us needing to see our accountant and to start thinking about future plans re our situation.
I already feel better for having shared it anonymously. My friends are amazing but I've bored them to tears over the years with my domestics 😳

OP posts:
Hillbilly · 12/06/2023 19:04

@NextTimeItsOver it's unlikely either of us will retire given the state of our finances.

OP posts:
IneedanewTV · 12/06/2023 08:12

“Truth be told, not that many men are going to be looking for a woman who is 48-50+, when they're on the hunt for a new romantic partner. A few will. Many will not. Many women in that age group will also find it hard to get a job with a decent amount of hours, let alone forge a shiny new career. “

I agree with most of this post but find the above extremely negative. I was 48 when I divorced, same as many of my friends. All the women I know including myself have gone on to meet men of their age. Yes there are the men who do date younger (including my ex) but there are men out there that want to date women of their age.

regarding jobs, if you have been a SAHP for many years then yes you will find it difficult to get a £50k job. But a lot of us don’t go 100% stay at home and manage to keep a career going for the very reason of you just don’t know what is around the corner. My divorce had no impact on my career. Yes obviously I have less disposable money as most costs are not halved when you live on your own. However, you can happy and have a very good life. The difference between the OP and my situation is that we had a repayment mortgage and pensions. That’s the OPs big mistake.

NextTimeItsOver · 12/06/2023 07:36

I think this is doable when the kids are about and you are working but once you both retire you might find it impossible. I like my husband but found it quite an adjustment when we both retired. 🫤 I think splitting up when you are older can be difficult too because of health issues and concerns about living alone.

Emptycrackedcup · 12/06/2023 02:40

I'd officially separate and tell everyone, then live as flatmates for x amount of time until children have left, then sell the house and downsize. My aunt and uncle did this for 10 years, and quite honestly it was confusing for their kids and the rest of the family as we weren't sure what was going on. So I'd be honest at least about that to your kids, friends and family. I know a few couples who live together separate. Just be aware, one of you might meet someone else.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/06/2023 22:41

Seconding what others say: your situation is probably just about sustainable in the short to medium term but it's the lack of a long-term plan which is worrying.

I'm normally a confident advocate in divorce being the best option when a relationship has broken down and I don't believe in people martyring themselves "for the children" but in your case you do seem to rub along together in a fairly workable and cordial way. So I think you can paper over the cracks for a bit and possibly until both your children have left home. I can totally appreciate how destructive a split would be now if there's no urgent need for it.

What would concern me is that over time you seem not to have a gameplan. The relationship is tolerable now because its keeping the family together but over time that will ebb away: particularly if one or both of you become emotionally involved with someone else. This simply isn't sustainable if you are literally sharing a bed.

I would be inclined to sit down with your husband very calmly admit that you both want out of the marriage over time, you both realise this isn't something which will happen in the next 2-3 years or whatever it is, but that you need to put a plan in place. That should clear the air a bit and will allow you to focus. You may then be able to introduce your children to the idea in a cordial way so they can get their heads around it. By the time they do move out you will have got them used to it and hopefully can move forward with minimal disruption.

EbonyRaven · 11/06/2023 22:34

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 22:25

@EbonyRaven thank you for your post. And to everyone else on each side of the fence.
This thread is very helpful to me. In part because it makes me realise I'm not alone, my situation is not uncommon.
I have the most wonderful friends who mostly live nearby. I could not imagine life with them as a support network. I work hard, exercise and have a good social like, albeit usually seeing friends in their homes or mine over a glass of wine rather than dinners out or anything else pricey.

😘 Good luck and peace and happiness whatever you decide! 😊

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 22:25

@EbonyRaven thank you for your post. And to everyone else on each side of the fence.
This thread is very helpful to me. In part because it makes me realise I'm not alone, my situation is not uncommon.
I have the most wonderful friends who mostly live nearby. I could not imagine life with them as a support network. I work hard, exercise and have a good social like, albeit usually seeing friends in their homes or mine over a glass of wine rather than dinners out or anything else pricey.

OP posts:
EbonyRaven · 11/06/2023 21:41

@jajajajaja

Not being able to afford to live anywhere remotely near where their businesses are and not being able to provide 2 lots of housing for the dc will not make for happy parents. That's the point. That is the whole point of the post.

All of this. ^ It's all very well saying LTB! Many people on here say this but how many have actually done it? Also, the older you are, and the more entwined your lives are, (and especially when kids are involved,) the harder it becomes to leave. Many women downgrade their career/work life, and their income takes a hit, and it's really hard to make ends meet on their own. FFS it's hard enough with a double income. As you say, they won't be '2 happy parents apart' if they're on the bones of their arse, with fuck-all to their name, like many people ARE when a couple split up.

Soooo many posters on here claim they left their DH, or someone they know did, (at 50-55!) and went on to do a uni degree, get a £50K per year job, a whole new bunch of friends, a quirky little apartment in a 'naice' area of town, and a shiny new man (always younger - and great at sex.) 🙄

The reality for the vast VAST majority of women is that she will be alone, poor, living in a squalid flat/bedsit on her own, will have very few friends (all the friends in couples will keep their distance,) and she will be working all the hours God sends in a minimum pay job just to make ends meet.

No Jason Mamoa lookalike with a 20 million pound bank balance, a Ferrari, and a 7 bedroom house in Cheshire (with 15 acres of land,) is going to come and sweep her off her feet. Truth be told, not that many men are going to be looking for a woman who is 48-50+, when they're on the hunt for a new romantic partner. A few will. Many will not. Many women in that age group will also find it hard to get a job with a decent amount of hours, let alone forge a shiny new career.

There seems to be SO many posters on here who claim they (or LOADS of people they know,) left their husband after 25-30 years plus, and went on to have a shiny new life full of wonder, riches, fabulous friends, a lovely boho apartment, a great career, and a lovely sexy man 15 years younger than them. In real life, I have never known this happen. The woman who is living on the bones of her arse and struggling to make ends meet, with few friends, and fighting to get more than 16 hours a week in their minimum pay job is the norm, NOT the chick-lit novel version with the amazing hew life.

DH earns OK, I earn less but still OK. Combined income, no kids at home, and no mortgage leaves us with a good amount of surplus income and a decent life. Nice car (only one, don't need 2,) a nice cottage in a lovely rural area, and decent holidays, meals out, day trips, and the ability to go and buy a new pair of shoes/trainers, new coat, new jeans, new haircut, new tops etc, without having to check we have enough money in the bank. Got a decent amount of savings. (Probably our combined salary for about 9 or 10 months.)

But if we split, there's no WAY I would be as well off alone. Yeah we could split the proceeds from the house, but my share wouldn't give me enough to buy something else. I'd need a mortgage of £100K to add to it to even buy a 1-bed flat, and like fuck am I buying a flat anyway! I would never take a £100K mortgage on alone in my early 50s... Probably wouldn't even get one! If I did, it would cost me about £900 a month, and I'd be paying it til I am 70!

Me and DH have had good times and bad times, we get on brilliantly sometimes and are soulmates, and have some great times together. Other times I want to slap him around the head with a wet haddock, and wish he'd fuck off the the far side of fuck. It can be a relief when he goes out to work, and I have the house to myself, and also it can be a relief when he comes home, and I feel at peace with him there, and love chatting to him, and I do love him. That's marriage. That's a relationship. That's what it's like. (For us and many others.)

My marriage, for the most part is fine, though it's had its ups and downs, but would I trade financial security, a lovely cottage in a middle class village, a nice car, holidays abroad, good surplus income, luxuries when I want them, only having to work 18 hours a week etc, for a life alone, being forced to work full time, living in a little private let flat that takes half my wages, no-one to chat to at home, no-one at breakfast, no-one at supper, no-one to say 'let's go to the beach for the day' to, no-one to go for an impromptu pub lunch with, no-one to go on holiday with, no-one to share life's burdens and trials with??? Nope.

Even if my marriage was loveless (and it's not,) I would still stay. My life is much better with my husband, than it would be without him. For many reasons. We have had some times over the years when I have questioned everything, and wondered whether I should leave/whether I'd be better off leaving etc (especially in the first 10 years,) but now - after nearly 30 years together, I am SO glad I stayed. So is he!

And don't anyone ask 'what if HE decides to leave YOU?' It's a moot point, because he hasn't left me, and isn't likely to.

@Hillbilly NGL I would absolutely stay if I were you. Unless your marriage is crushingly bad, why leave? It's overrated being alone and poor LOL. As I say, so many posters on here celebrate it and promote it, as some fabulous existence, but for most (married) women (who are in a maybe not brilliant, but fairly OK marriage,) it's not a great idea to leave the marriage, and they are much better staying put.

Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 20:44

@whumpthereitis

"Financial security is important, and the reality is that without that you can find that freedom from one prison is merely a transfer to another."

Exactly this.

OP posts:
Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 20:43

greyhairnomore · 11/06/2023 18:35

If your mortgage is interest only and you have no plans to pay it off you might as well cut your losses , sell it and move on. You might be able to get on the ladder in a cheaper part of the country ?

It's not that we have no plans to settle the mortgage, we have some of it covered. We probably need to speak with our accountant.
Neither of us would want to leave London. For each of us our whole support network is here. It's home. I realise that may sound unrealistic.

OP posts:
Hillbilly · 11/06/2023 20:37

@Blip it's a large double. At least a year before freeing up another room.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread