Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Intermittent Fasting is a gimmick?

233 replies

NeedToChangeName · 10/06/2023 20:51

I know a few people who swear by Intermittent Fasting and make a big deal of only eating between 12 noon and 8pm

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LimitIsUp · 11/06/2023 08:49

larkstar · 10/06/2023 22:35

Either you haven't read all of the science behind it.. or you didn't understand it... or you just have no idea what science actually is. You don't have to be a genius to type a search term into YouTube to find some simple explanations... or maybe no amount of evidence or proof can change your mind... in which case - you do you.

Glad you posted this. I was irritated by OP too

WhatTheHeckyPeck · 11/06/2023 08:37

aloofflooty · 11/06/2023 08:21

@aloofflooty you would just change your hours so you eat at say 6am, then have an 8 hour window yo eat so up to 4pm?
No dinner

Well, there's no way I'm just going to stop eating dinner for the rest of my days 🤣

6-4 is actually 10 hours, 6-2 is the 8 hour "window" which is ridiculous. The idea of doing a 10 hour shift then not eating anything when I get home is laughable.

aloofflooty · 11/06/2023 08:21

@aloofflooty you would just change your hours so you eat at say 6am, then have an 8 hour window yo eat so up to 4pm?
No dinner

Well, there's no way I'm just going to stop eating dinner for the rest of my days 🤣

itsgettingweird · 11/06/2023 07:45

aloofflooty · 10/06/2023 21:35

Does anyone manage it with a super early start to do running? I get up at 5am to exercise 4/5 days a week, leave for work at 7.30 and then work full time in a busy on my feet physical job (where I can't have a late breakfast at 11 or whatever) If I didn't eat until lunchtime I don't think I'd be very productive or engaged and think I would feel a bit ill. After running I'm usually STARVING by 8am. But maybe I'm missing something.

This is why IF doesn't work for me.

I'm up at 4 and walk 5.8k at 5am because my dd is a swimmer.

So I have overnight oats at 6.30am because my job is very busy sometimes and on my feet and I've been known to not get lunch until 1.30/2pm.

The problem with not eating breakfast then is I have to grab some biscuits because my blood sugar is so low I'm shaking and can't concentrate.

I try not to eat past 6pm but that relies on me getting dinner or time to make dinner and take it with me because ds also trains every evening too.

I'm guessing IF is also very dependent on lifestyle and activity?

Fairislefandango · 11/06/2023 07:31

Also read that it’s good for digestion ….the stomach and intestines don’t like being constantly bombarded with snacks.

It's the opposite of good for my digestion. It gave me constipation so I had to stop it. It didn't really make me lose weight anyway, maybe because it wasn't that big a change for me - I never do post-dinner snacking anyway, so all I was doing differently skipping breakfast.

Miceeatinglollypops · 11/06/2023 07:18

It’s just calorie deficit by another name - no more, no less - all the benefits people describe would happen in any other calorie deficit too. I don’t know why people think it’s some magical thing, it’s literally the same as any other diet!

AmenAmin · 10/06/2023 23:41

I don’t quite get it. I have a similar eating window naturally, just not the same hours. I eat roughly between 10am and 6pm. I tend to skip breakfast but get hungry mid-morning then I don’t usually eat after dinner. I generally eat mid-morning, light lunch then dinner.
I’m pretty average sized, just within a normal bmi range but squishy in the middle. No magic

Panda89 · 10/06/2023 23:35

It worked amazingly for me. I lost the 2.5 stone that I have always struggled with and kept it off, still eat this way now.
I’ve never bloated anymore, don’t feel like I’m depriving myself, my skin cleared up (acne) and I feel generally great.

friedgoldeggs · 10/06/2023 23:20

I lost 5 stone doing IF - it was amazingly easy, and I felt incredible. Unfortunately put it all back on after having my DS but will be starting it again

JMSA · 10/06/2023 23:12

I could do this easily BUT don't have a healthy relationship with food. So I'd be worried that I'd eat anything and everything in between. The timeframes themselves wouldn't bother me though.

lochmaree · 10/06/2023 23:11

I'm a newbie to IF, try to do 16:8, but if I'm starving I have my breakfast anyway. its rare that's necessary though. I have a cup of tea with soya milk in the morning. it's been so much easier than I expected and I have lost weight. it's easier to eat healthily and less snacks too.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 10/06/2023 22:52

ShandaLear · 10/06/2023 21:56

The only way to lose weight is by being in a calorie deficit. That’s science and the laws of physics. All diets are designed to put you in a calorie deficit , where you burn more calories than you eat. They just do this in different ways:

Atkins/low carb - restricts carbs
16:8 - restricts time available to eat
Weightwatchers - restricts fats

Etc. Etc.

The effectiveness of these is moderated by hunger, so choose the one that’s the most filling and satisfies you for longest.

evidence is that the effectiveness of them is far from simply moderated by hunger, that’s a massive leap and not supported by research
there are many different causes why diets fail and some of it is due to emotions, some due to ultra processed foods and addiction to food, for some people we know hormones do actually play a part. Hunger , or more specifically the hormones that signal hunger, do have a part to play for some people, but only for some

this is why diets don’t work. There is no evidence that the majority of people keep weight off they’ve lost. All evidence is quite the reverse- people regain overctoyicwlly 5 years and end up even more overweight than where they started. Even in cases of gastric surgery a lot of people regain weight, and the new weight loss drugs are even being prescribed just for 12 months even whilst acknowledging that once stopped people put the weight back on and more. The science behind that, which is slowly emerging is very interesting, and it will probably eventually unlock the key to keeping slim in the first place.e but almost all expert scientist will agree loosing weight once gained is a particularly ineffective solution. There are some very interesting articles for instance, that now show that caloric intake between societies of highly active lifestyles (eg hunter gatherer tribes) actually differs little from healthy weight individuals in western world with no exercise. The evidence is pointing out that the body is very adapted to regulate calorific burn rates at a steady rate irrespective of levels of activivty. Activity is clearly beneficially and needed for all sorts of reasons, but weight loss is not one of them, despite what gyms would have us think and the old chestnut “energy in equals energy out” is a complete fallacy and doesn’t take into account the vast majority of our energy is needed to survive as warm blooded animals - we have to keep the internal boiler on at all other costs.

yep, right now best hope people who are overweight have is the variety of diets, injections, tablets and gastric sleeves. But it ain’t simply hunger that make them fail over and over.

Happyvalleyfan · 10/06/2023 22:46

BansheeofInisherin · 10/06/2023 22:37

I think OP is right in that people constantly talking about IF is boring. I don't talk about it. Just do it quietly. Also if I am out with friends, I will skip it for that night, so as not to bore everyone stiff.

Do people talk about this IRL? That would be v dull. However - doesn’t make it a gimmick.

BansheeofInisherin · 10/06/2023 22:37

I think OP is right in that people constantly talking about IF is boring. I don't talk about it. Just do it quietly. Also if I am out with friends, I will skip it for that night, so as not to bore everyone stiff.

larkstar · 10/06/2023 22:35

Either you haven't read all of the science behind it.. or you didn't understand it... or you just have no idea what science actually is. You don't have to be a genius to type a search term into YouTube to find some simple explanations... or maybe no amount of evidence or proof can change your mind... in which case - you do you.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 10/06/2023 22:34

I really liked doing this. Lost some weight. I found not eating really for2 days of week was sooo much easier than dieting 7 days a week.

BUT, like a small cohort of people I found that on (typically) 2nd fasting day (I fasted tues and Thursday ) I would eat the evening low cal/ low fat meal and then within2 hours go into catastrophic “dumping”. Sometimes I’d make it through evening meal, and then do “dumping” after breakfast on Friday morning randomly. Sometimes I’d get an attack on the Tuesday fast day, or Wednesday morning. . The “dumping” was not nice- severe agonising abdominal pain first for about 40 mins with increased feelings of nausea , then violent vomiting and diarrhoea . Sometimes both simultaneously. Would go on for 4 hours. Hot/cold sweats. As it was often in evening I’d still be trying to stop it at midnight and be complexly exhausted . It took me ages, stupidly, to link it to the fasting.

And now I have stopped fasting diet due to this ,but I find it happens now if I skip any meal , I have to eat something at least everything 4 hours. It has been bloody awful, I have had some very public embarrassing accidents. Even happened during my sons graduation. I even gave up work and retired early in part due to this as I travelled and flew a lot and wasn’t able to eat at my normal meal times due to times zones and I was in a mess gastrically. I had loads of hospital tests to see what was happening, but no reason ever found, I have to live with it now 5 years after quitting the fast diet.
I’ve read up this happens to some people. I’ve read up on how to stop it with all sorts of weird stuff you have to take even people taking meds. I really did not want to do that . I’m still living with consequences of something I never used to have issues with prior to fasting diet.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 10/06/2023 22:25

So much scientific peer reviewed research which supports intermittent fasting. My elder son is a GP as is his FIL both are very supportive and enthusiastic about IF. Maybe look at the research.

NowItsSpring · 10/06/2023 22:22

DrManhattan · 10/06/2023 20:58

Not a gimmick, it really works. Give it a go.
No skipping of anything, you just eat in a smaller time frame. Love it. Been doing it for years and years.

This. Totally works for me - a stone and a half down without feeling like I have been on a diet.

RavingStone · 10/06/2023 22:01

Definitely not a gimmick! I eat 3 meals still, just in a slightly condensed time, fasting minimum 14 hours but ideally 16 or longer. I find it works better if I stop eating around 6pm. Has improved migraines hugely and lost me 2 inches from my waist so far.

BansheeofInisherin · 10/06/2023 21:59

I used to think breakfast was the most important meal of the day, but I have changed my mind on this. For children, perhaps. It's not easy though.

ShandaLear · 10/06/2023 21:56

The only way to lose weight is by being in a calorie deficit. That’s science and the laws of physics. All diets are designed to put you in a calorie deficit , where you burn more calories than you eat. They just do this in different ways:

Atkins/low carb - restricts carbs
16:8 - restricts time available to eat
Weightwatchers - restricts fats

Etc. Etc.

The effectiveness of these is moderated by hunger, so choose the one that’s the most filling and satisfies you for longest.

MavisMcMinty · 10/06/2023 21:56

I’ve done it since my teens, and am still almost as slim at (nearly) 60. It’s easy for me, I don’t feel hungry until I’ve been awake for 5 hours, and only eat when I’m hungry. Definitely don’t believe people need three meals a day, or that breakfast needs to be as soon as you get up in the morning (obviously talking about adults not children). I eat what I want, as much as I want, but have to feel hungry first.

I’ve said that before on MN and people have replied they feel hungry ALL THE TIME. I can’t imagine anything worse.

Notimeforaname · 10/06/2023 21:47

I only eat between 5/6pm and midnight. It's what's always worked for me. Not to lose weight but to fit in with my habits and job.
I have a sporty job that requires me to be fit. I've eaten like this since I'm 17. I'm 37 now and pretty much the same size as I was at 17.

TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed · 10/06/2023 21:47

It’s great for blood sugar as once it’s dropped after your last meal you’ve got hours of it staying low.

Also read that it’s good for digestion ….the stomach and intestines don’t like being constantly bombarded with snacks.

LiftyLift · 10/06/2023 21:46

aloofflooty · 10/06/2023 21:35

Does anyone manage it with a super early start to do running? I get up at 5am to exercise 4/5 days a week, leave for work at 7.30 and then work full time in a busy on my feet physical job (where I can't have a late breakfast at 11 or whatever) If I didn't eat until lunchtime I don't think I'd be very productive or engaged and think I would feel a bit ill. After running I'm usually STARVING by 8am. But maybe I'm missing something.

I run in the morning a few days and usually end up caving in. I have found having a protein shake or a hot tea staves off the hunger until lunch.