Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Intermittent Fasting is a gimmick?

233 replies

NeedToChangeName · 10/06/2023 20:51

I know a few people who swear by Intermittent Fasting and make a big deal of only eating between 12 noon and 8pm

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
VaddaABeetch · 11/06/2023 10:23

I go to the gym for 5.30…heavy weights. I don’t eat until 11. I’m still making great gains.

blobby10 · 11/06/2023 10:21

Gwenhwyfar · 11/06/2023 10:10

You don't have to have a protein shake just afterwards, that's been debunked.
If you are hungry early in the day you just have your eating window earlier.

Thank you for replying!there are so many do’s and don’t’s around food I get completely confused!

elrider · 11/06/2023 10:18

I think simplifying it to skipping breakfast and not snacking in the evening is misleading as even if that is the 8h window you choose, you're forgetting about drinks. E.g. you can't have your usual teas or coffees with milk in the morning or your glass of wine/gin and tonic/diet Coke/hot chocolate/tea with milk or whatever in the evening. That's what's giving your digestion a proper break. Those saying you eat in that window naturally, I'd be interested to know if you naturally only drink water (or black coffee/tea) as I doubt that's the case for most people so you're actually not doing it already.

The cells have time to have a good clear out once you've not been consuming any calories for 14+ hours so it's for more than weight loss. Your skin can get brighter, you can reduce your risk of various diseases, etc. Damaged and old cells get the boot which they think will decrease risk of developing some cancers as well.

off · 11/06/2023 10:16

NeedToChangeName · 10/06/2023 20:51

I know a few people who swear by Intermittent Fasting and make a big deal of only eating between 12 noon and 8pm

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

AIBU?

Yeah, to me those are two different ways of framing the same thing, one of them ordinary language describing a thing many people naturally happen to end up doing anyway, and one of them making it a whole conceptual Thing, sounding a bit wanky and selling glossy paperback manuals. The only real difference is psychological.

But psychology is 90% of the battle when it comes to diet and health. Giving it a name, making it a whole Thing, and formalising it in a framework can help some people get their eating into a manageable and sustainable pattern that helps them avoid overeating (and may have some metabolic benefits), without having it gradually drift at the edges. It also helps if people want to do scientific studies, to have specific named eating patterns they can compare.

To be fair tho, back when the Style and Beauty board denizens were all about the "hot cloth cleansing", all I could think was "isn't that what we used to call washing your face with a flannel?" Grin

LadyBird1973 · 11/06/2023 10:13

I am finding that I'm not eating larger meals during my window - my appetite does seem to have reduced.
I'm perimenopausal and struggling to lose weight though. I know all the experts say that HRT doesn't make you put in weight but I'm not convinced.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/06/2023 10:10

blobby10 · 11/06/2023 10:02

How does IF work if you go to the gym at 5am and do a hard workout- burning 500 calories? The fitness people say have a protein shake/breakfast afterwards but if IF hours are 11am-7pm then do I just not eat? I’m not trying to provoke anything just genuinely interested as I want to try it!!😎

You don't have to have a protein shake just afterwards, that's been debunked.
If you are hungry early in the day you just have your eating window earlier.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/06/2023 10:09

Oakbeam · 11/06/2023 09:46

You still have to eat healthily though, not fast food.

The beauty of the fasting “diets” is that you can eat anything you want. You are just using a strategy to facilitate eating less of it.

As long as you are in overall calorie deficit at the end of the day, or week, you will lose weight.

No, it's not about eating LESS, it's about eating within a certain window.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/06/2023 10:05

SallySailor · 11/06/2023 09:06

They don't seem to actually have worked that out yet. Other schools of thought advise a tiny bit of milk in tea/coffee doesn't make any difference

Correct. They don't know yet.

blobby10 · 11/06/2023 10:02

How does IF work if you go to the gym at 5am and do a hard workout- burning 500 calories? The fitness people say have a protein shake/breakfast afterwards but if IF hours are 11am-7pm then do I just not eat? I’m not trying to provoke anything just genuinely interested as I want to try it!!😎

Oakbeam · 11/06/2023 09:59

I'm exactly the same and yet a stone overweight!

I managed to get to two stone overweight just eating between 6 and 8 in the evening. The problem was I was eating (and drinking) too much in those two hours.

There is no magic to it. If you stuff your face between 12 and 8 or on the five days you aren’t fasting on the 5:2, you will gain weight.

There is no magic to a fasting diet. The results come form eating less overall than you normally would.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/06/2023 09:58

RhosynBach · 10/06/2023 21:09

If you skip breakfast and snacks you’re reducing your calories so how can it be a gimmick?

No, you're not reducing your calories. Your other meals will get bigger with no breakfast.
You can still snack with IF, just within a certain time window.

Welliehead · 11/06/2023 09:52

AmenAmin · 10/06/2023 23:41

I don’t quite get it. I have a similar eating window naturally, just not the same hours. I eat roughly between 10am and 6pm. I tend to skip breakfast but get hungry mid-morning then I don’t usually eat after dinner. I generally eat mid-morning, light lunch then dinner.
I’m pretty average sized, just within a normal bmi range but squishy in the middle. No magic

I'm exactly the same and yet a stone overweight!

Oakbeam · 11/06/2023 09:46

You still have to eat healthily though, not fast food.

The beauty of the fasting “diets” is that you can eat anything you want. You are just using a strategy to facilitate eating less of it.

As long as you are in overall calorie deficit at the end of the day, or week, you will lose weight.

DiscoBeat · 11/06/2023 09:44

What do people drink when on the 12-8 routine? The thing that would bother me is not having my morning coffee!

Divebar2021 · 11/06/2023 09:40

@PuppyMonkey

There are two different methods… the 5:2 where you restrict your calories heavily on 2 days and the 16:8 where you restrict your calories for the 8 hour window and fast the rest of the time and potentially do that daily.

twinklystar23 · 11/06/2023 09:37

I went to a nutritionist years ago. The protocol was to eat regularly, with snacks which would be something like 1/2 apple 6 & Nuts, a last snack shortly before bedtime which incorporated protein.
So the diet was
No nightshade veg
No tea coffee or alcohol
No dairy or derivatives
No wheat
Lost loads of weight.
Now trying this diet as the above is restrictive though I have tried to do it again
While not being to rigid, but sadly not losing much, so may be due to the menopause (or that glass of wine 😅) the 16 8 is working for me pleased to see the weight coming off, though I've always eaten breakfast, and always very healthy, and concerned about the need to maintain consistent blood sugar levels, which prevents the impulse to snack on usually high carb/sugar food.

LadyBird1973 · 11/06/2023 09:35

I think it might be easier to stick to if you aren't eating lots of sugar/empty carbs in your 8 hours.
I'm new to IF but have attempted it in the past and got all weak and faint because my body was used to having cereal or toast and biscuits with sweet coffee in the morning. Since I've cut out most sugar I find I'm not starving in the morning and don't need food first thing to get over the shakiness of having blood sugar dip.
I don't think I could do it if I still felt like I needed sugar.
That aside, I think it works for weight loss because you are eating less food. But it makes sense to me that our bodies might need a break from constant digestion.
I don't think I'm doing this strictly because I do have a little bit of cream in my coffee in the morning but if it's keeping me out of the biscuit tin then I'm all for it.

PuppyMonkey · 11/06/2023 09:25

I didn’t realise that IF was now about “eating in an 8 hour window”. The original Michael Moseley documentary was about restricting calories on two days and eating what you like on five wasn’t it? When did it all change?

I don’t eat after I’ve had my dinner at 6 anyway. Would my two Weetabix at 7-ish in the morning really be so awful for me? Plus the zillion cups of morning tea?

Butchyrestingface · 11/06/2023 09:16

You still have to eat healthily though, not fast food.

I didn't. I did the 5:2 for a year or so and lost tonnes of weight, notwithstanding the fact I ate like a hog the rest of the time.

Oakbeam · 11/06/2023 09:14

Agree that it is just the packaging and marketing that is a gimmick.

All you are doing is eating less, whichever flavour of intermittent fasting you choose. Which, surprise surprise, results in weight loss.

irishfeminist · 11/06/2023 09:11

It works for a lot of people but I hated it. I exercise early in the morning and couldn't go for hours with no food. I tried it for two months and lost a little weight but that was more because I was consuming fewer calories than the timing. I continued to watch calories while resuming my small breakfast and continued to lose weight. I never snack after dinner anyway. Each to their own.

SallySailor · 11/06/2023 09:06

Sunshineandflipflops · 11/06/2023 09:03

If you are doing IF then the only things you are supposed to have outside the 8 hour eating window is water/black coffee/black or herbal tea. Soya milk will start to raise your blood sugar.
Obviously do what works for you but just letting you know in case you weren’t aware.

I love a cup of tea in the morning but have got used to black coffee since doing IF. That first cup of tea is lovely!

They don't seem to actually have worked that out yet. Other schools of thought advise a tiny bit of milk in tea/coffee doesn't make any difference

Divebar2021 · 11/06/2023 09:06

I understand what the OP means…. She isn’t saying that the process is a gimmick she’s saying that packaging it and selling it as “ A THING” is a gimmick. “ I know let’s call it 16:8 or 5:2 …. That will look good in the Daily Mail when I’m flogging my next book” kind of way. I’ve done both of those by the way and I’ve read the science and was persuaded as I’ve been persuaded by all the other science that has been trotted out eg “ the benefits of eating breakfast” and “why low fat is the bees knees”. I sometimes skip breakfast and if I work out in the morning I don’t feel hungry til lunch. I personally just see it as a way of reducing my overall calories. If you wake up starving then skipping breakfast is probably not for you but something else probably is.

Sunshineandflipflops · 11/06/2023 09:03

lochmaree · 10/06/2023 23:11

I'm a newbie to IF, try to do 16:8, but if I'm starving I have my breakfast anyway. its rare that's necessary though. I have a cup of tea with soya milk in the morning. it's been so much easier than I expected and I have lost weight. it's easier to eat healthily and less snacks too.

If you are doing IF then the only things you are supposed to have outside the 8 hour eating window is water/black coffee/black or herbal tea. Soya milk will start to raise your blood sugar.
Obviously do what works for you but just letting you know in case you weren’t aware.

I love a cup of tea in the morning but have got used to black coffee since doing IF. That first cup of tea is lovely!

Watchkeys · 11/06/2023 08:56

Eating 3 times a day or more regularly is a much more modern concept than the necessity of regular fasting that we evolved with. Early man right until the agricultural revolution (which, in terms of our evolution, is 'the start until quite recently') fasted regularly, as most wild animals do, certainly at some times of the year.

We are evolved to fast. We are not evolved to 'Pop down to Asda because I've not eaten for 2 hours and I'm dying for some biscuits'

Swipe left for the next trending thread