Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Intermittent Fasting is a gimmick?

233 replies

NeedToChangeName · 10/06/2023 20:51

I know a few people who swear by Intermittent Fasting and make a big deal of only eating between 12 noon and 8pm

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Lemonyfuckit · 11/06/2023 11:06

For all the people who do it and it works for them - do you have milk in your morning tea/coffee? - the windows aren't so much of an issue for me as I often don't eat breakfast or if I do I prefer it later anyway, but it's the milk in my morning coffee that I'm struggling with the thought of giving up. Not a huge calorific latte or cappuccino but just some skimmed milk (but quite a big splash) in a filter coffee. There seems to be two schools of thought - one even that will start raising your blood sugar thus defeating the effectiveness, and another that it won't make much difference.

Wanderingowl · 11/06/2023 11:05

WingBingo · 11/06/2023 10:52

When you don’t eat for a while, several things happen in your body.
For example, your body changes hormone levels to make stored body fat more accessible and initiates important cellular repair processes.
Here are some of the changes that occur in your body during fasting:

  • Insulin levels. Blood levels of insulindrop significantly, which facilitates fat burning (1Trusted Source).
  • Human growth hormone (HGH) levels.The blood levels of human growth hormone (HGH) may increase dramatically. Higher levels of this hormone facilitate fat burning and muscle gain, and have numerous other benefits (2Trusted Source, 3Trusted Source, 4, 5).
  • Cellular repair. The body induces important cellular repair processes, such as removing waste material from cells (6).
  • Gene expression. There are beneficial changes in several genes and molecules related to longevity and protection against disease (7).

The thing is, almost none of the studies on humans show that fasting within a time period before we experience sarcopenia has any of these benefits. And this is especially true of women. On the other hand exercise brings about all of these benefits and more.

The only proven benefit of intermittent fasting on humans is that any strict form of eating restriction almost always results in lowered calorie consumption. So if IF works for a person and they enjoy it, then there is no harm in doing it. But if they want the benefits of autophagy, they are unlikely to be getting that through IF. A really good exercise programme, on the other hand, guarantees it.

CherryYree · 11/06/2023 11:02

I have been having tea with milk in the morning, but nothing else until around 12.30/1. I then stop eating from 6pm.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 11/06/2023 10:57

Happyvalleyfan · 10/06/2023 21:37

I think you just need to choose the window you do want to eat in - so eat earlier but last meal also earlier.

Exactly and if you are starving because you have a physical job then you need to eat earlier and just stop eating earlier.

2thumbs · 11/06/2023 10:57

I’ve been doing it for around 4 months now, for the first time (by effectively skipping breakfast and not snacking as you say), and I have found it to be very effective (for me) in conjunction with making sensible choices around food and drink when I do eat. I am down to a good weight and I tend not to feel hungry throughout the day. If there are additional benefits beyond that then even better. But I can understand why it might not work for others.

PuppyMonkey · 11/06/2023 10:57

I’d be a bit worried that the only way I’d be able to get through the morning without my breakfast would be to drink lots of tea (I have milk, no sugar).

CaveMum · 11/06/2023 10:54

DiscoBeat · 11/06/2023 09:44

What do people drink when on the 12-8 routine? The thing that would bother me is not having my morning coffee!

I drink black coffee and water in the mornings. I stick to the “no milk” as I’ve read that it can trigger an insulin response even from a small amount, but other people choose to have a bit in their morning coffee/tea. Totally up to you.

WingBingo · 11/06/2023 10:52

When you don’t eat for a while, several things happen in your body.
For example, your body changes hormone levels to make stored body fat more accessible and initiates important cellular repair processes.
Here are some of the changes that occur in your body during fasting:

  • Insulin levels. Blood levels of insulindrop significantly, which facilitates fat burning (1Trusted Source).
  • Human growth hormone (HGH) levels.The blood levels of human growth hormone (HGH) may increase dramatically. Higher levels of this hormone facilitate fat burning and muscle gain, and have numerous other benefits (2Trusted Source, 3Trusted Source, 4, 5).
  • Cellular repair. The body induces important cellular repair processes, such as removing waste material from cells (6).
  • Gene expression. There are beneficial changes in several genes and molecules related to longevity and protection against disease (7).

About Insulin: What It Is, How It Works, and More

Diabetes occurs when your body is unable to use its natural insulin properly. Learn more about manual insulin injections and how they help treat diabetes.

https://www.healthline.com/health/type-2-diabetes/insulin

IMustDoMoreExercise · 11/06/2023 10:50

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

Well, I do it and that is exactly what it is and is why it works. I

WingBingo · 11/06/2023 10:50

Your body reacts to the fasting differently to overall calorie deficit.

There is science behind it, it’s not just skipping meals.

Didn't a scientist win the Nobel prize for science when she identified that when you are in a fasting state your cells repair themselves?

Chocolate23 · 11/06/2023 10:48

I have tried it. It was just another way of reducing calories for me. I lost the same amount of weight calorie counting.

TheOrigRights · 11/06/2023 10:48

Oysterbabe · 10/06/2023 21:05

Yes, skipping breakfast and no evening snacks is basically it. That doesn't make it a gimmick.

Giving it a name makes it look some sort of amazing idea or invention. It isn't.

TheHighQueenOfTheFarRealm · 11/06/2023 10:47

It's not exactly a gimmick but just a reminder to everyone to stop eating constantly and to make better decisions.

You don't have to stick to that timeframe. You can 'fast' between meals too. So eating breakfast at 8, lunch at 12, having a small snack and/or dinner/supper by 8pm and then nothing til breakfast will also work (depending on what you're eating). It's how people traditionally ate in this country and people were slim and there was less illness like diabetes.

CherryYree · 11/06/2023 10:47

BMI has gone from 26 (overweight) to 24 (healthy weight).
Much easier to do than 5:2 imo and I'm feeling really good for it too.

CaveMum · 11/06/2023 10:45

I have a friend who is a gastroenterologist. She said almost every single Dr in her department practises intermittent fasting and many of them do OMAD (one meal a day). These are the people who know about digestion/health etc, if it’s good enough for them…

I started IF (usually 16:8) in summer 2020 after piling on lockdown weight. I lost a stone in 6 weeks (I wasn’t overweight but was at the upper limit of a “healthy” BMI) and have maintained it ever since. I allow my self to lapse on occasion and don’t beat myself up about it.

MrsSkylerWhite · 11/06/2023 10:45

LadyBird1973 · Yesterday 21:29
@Zarataralara , nuts and cheese and bread are quite calorific, even though they are good for you. You might just be going above the calories your body needs.”

This. You still need to keep a check on the calories.

CherryYree · 11/06/2023 10:43

I've done this for 2 months and lost 14 lbs so far.

Lcb123 · 11/06/2023 10:43

I don’t think it’s a gimmick-i do this in general (although with a shorter gap overnight), it’s really healthy to give your body a break.

Snoken · 11/06/2023 10:42

It had worked for me on multiple levels. I started early April, only had 3kg to lose, which I have done now. I also lowered my blood pressure which is now at 121/82 (was 133/86) and my arthritis has almost disappeared as the long fasts break down inflammation in the body. I have gained energy and I sleep like a log for 8 hours a night.

Winecrispschocolatecats · 11/06/2023 10:42

Years ago I tried the 5:2 version of intermittent fasting (eat normally for 5 days, restrict calories and time frame for 2 days) and the difference to my menopausal stomach was amazing! I've let that slip in recent times and really need to get back into it - a gimmick is only a gimmick if it doesn't work. Otherwise, it's a pro tip :)

TennisWithDeborah · 11/06/2023 10:40

It worked for me. I got my BMI down from 35 to 29 in four months. I ate what I wanted (although I will say that I don’t have a sweet tooth, so naturally ate no choc, cake etc). Also hit the gym and did 12k steps daily. Got loads of compliments. Felt good. Clothes loosened or became too large.

Then, I was stuck. For a few weeks, I lost nothing. So am now doing IF but with calorie counting too. Bread/crisps is my weakness so it isn’t easy.

I am a maths and modern languages person not a scientist, so I won’t comment on the science aspect, being unqualified to do so. All I can do is relay my story.

deathbyhayfever · 11/06/2023 10:36

Needing intermittent fasting is a cultural thing. In many places, it's unheard of to be constantly eating, snacking, drinking tea loaded with milk and worst sugar.
People have 3, 4 at most, regular small meals and their whole life doesn't revolve around food, snacks, "treats!".

Some people have taken the notion of human being natural grazers to try to justify their unhealthy food patter and it has become a bit too fashionable. "Grazing" and and a handful of food throughout the day has never meant it was natural to eat 4 full meals and snack every 30minutes in between.

It's not a gimmick to remove all unnecessary snacks, stop one from waking up in the middle of the night to raid the fridge and stop all these unhealthy behaviour.

A pro-athlete might need to "refuel" after intensive training sessions, within the frame of a very strict diet they tend to have, you don't even need "a banana" to refuel after running coach to 5k, or a zumba class. A banana won't hurt you, but it's usually unecessary.

Summerishereagain · 11/06/2023 10:29

A gimmick is a trick designed to attract attention. The research is very clear that it has medical benefits. Obviously if people pig out for 8 hours it won’t help them lose weight so in that way it isn’t a trick to eat what you want and still lose weight.

Sothisisitthen · 11/06/2023 10:26

I’ve done this for a while now and it works well for me. I generally eat lunch around 12:30 and I finish eating by 8pm at the latest but often earlier. I also am on a low sugar diet so I eat large amounts of greens, certain types of dairy and protein during that time.

erlangshen · 11/06/2023 10:24

the only thing worked for me really. Within the 8 hrs I eat whatever I feel like.

Swipe left for the next trending thread