Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Intermittent Fasting is a gimmick?

233 replies

NeedToChangeName · 10/06/2023 20:51

I know a few people who swear by Intermittent Fasting and make a big deal of only eating between 12 noon and 8pm

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
GettingStuffed · 11/06/2023 14:10

You are righ t I intermittently faster yesterday, forgot to have breakfast, went out for a late lunch and had a piece of toast for dinner. Not intentional. It works because not having breakfast or evening snacks cuts the calories you are eating

TheFTrain · 11/06/2023 14:05

It's completely cleared up my hayfever.

MavisMcMinty · 11/06/2023 13:54

Comedycook · 11/06/2023 13:30

I'm terrible with breakfast....as soon as I eat it, it's like it sets me off and I will just eat and eat all day. It doesn't matter what I have....eggs, porridge...whatever it is sets me off. Its why I've failed at so many diets as they all involve breakfast....it just doesn't work for me. I find it easier to skip it

Exactly what I found! I’d read porridge is really good for you as a breakfast, controls blood sugars for HOURS afterwards, fills you up until lunchtime, etc., so started taking microwave porridge into work. It just kick-started my appetite and I didn’t stop eating all day!

GAWI · 11/06/2023 13:53

I just call it not eating until I'm hungry on a morning.
It's helped me notice how my body responds to certain foods. Eg lots of carbs and I'm constantly hungry. Plenty of fat and protein and some vegetablesand I do much better.

I used to have ups and downs with blood sugar, which was making the sport I do difficult and thought I was one of these people who need to constantly snack or I get wobbly. It turns out I don't.

Comedycook · 11/06/2023 13:30

I'm terrible with breakfast....as soon as I eat it, it's like it sets me off and I will just eat and eat all day. It doesn't matter what I have....eggs, porridge...whatever it is sets me off. Its why I've failed at so many diets as they all involve breakfast....it just doesn't work for me. I find it easier to skip it

RavingStone · 11/06/2023 13:21

Not sure if this has already been said but fasting is much easier if your last meal isn't heavy on white carb. Protein and high fibre works really well for me and means I wake up feeling good, not hungry or faint.

Hairbrushhandle · 11/06/2023 13:11

ThursdayFreedom · 11/06/2023 12:02

@Hairbrushhandle work out the latest you can have breakfast so you don't feel like that, then work backwards from that to see what time you need to start fasting.

you might need to compromise on you ratio if the timings simply don't work for you.

I think it's probably because my DC wake me at 5. So by 8 I'm faint.

Quackinquavers · 11/06/2023 13:04

Low carb and IF went from 33 to 25 BMI. Swimming 4 times a week for an hour. Losing the belly fat. Still drink alcohol so cutting back on that to make a bigger impact. 🙂

fireflyloo · 11/06/2023 12:58

I lost 4 stone doing 5.2. It totally changed how I eat. I now do IF without even thinking about it. First food of the day around 1pm and then main meal around 6ish. Small snack before bed.

DragonflyLady · 11/06/2023 12:55

I guess that’s what I naturally do - I have lunch at 11ish then tea at teatime. Still Diabetic though.

TheHighQueenOfTheFarRealm · 11/06/2023 12:48

@Hairbrushhandle what are you eating the night before? I used to get like this if I had high carb meals or too much late night snacking. If I have more protein at dinner and no sugary or carby snacks, I don't get that feeling.
It's could be a sign of insulin sensitivity.

LimitIsUp · 11/06/2023 12:25

DiscoBeat · 11/06/2023 09:44

What do people drink when on the 12-8 routine? The thing that would bother me is not having my morning coffee!

Black coffee, black tea and water - but then I have never had milk or sugar in tea and coffee

MavisMcMinty · 11/06/2023 12:07

I did the 5:2 for ages and lost all my extra weight, albeit quite slowly. What I loved about it was that it got all the dieting over and done with in two days, so anyone who’s really good at starting diets but lapses within a few days should do very well on the 5:2.

I did my two fast days on my busiest days at work because I was too busy to eat. I might spend the evening fantasising about all the buttered crumpets I’d eat the next day, but I’d rarely actually eat those buttered crumpets the next day. I’d go to bed hungry but overnight my appetite would reset itself to zero and I never woke up hungry or needed breakfast after a fast day.

Of course it all went to pot when an M&S Simply Food opened just a few minutes walk away from my office, but since retiring I do (naturally, not deliberately) 16/8 or more usually 18/6 and have lost all that M&S Simply Food weight!

ThursdayFreedom · 11/06/2023 12:02

Hairbrushhandle · 11/06/2023 11:24

If I don't eat breakfast I feel physically sick by 8am, like morning sickness. I have to sit down and let the wave of nausea pass and then eat otherwise I'm actually vomiting. I also get shakey and don't trust myself to drive for example. How do you get behind that?

@Hairbrushhandle work out the latest you can have breakfast so you don't feel like that, then work backwards from that to see what time you need to start fasting.

you might need to compromise on you ratio if the timings simply don't work for you.

ThursdayFreedom · 11/06/2023 11:58

Lemonyfuckit · 11/06/2023 11:06

For all the people who do it and it works for them - do you have milk in your morning tea/coffee? - the windows aren't so much of an issue for me as I often don't eat breakfast or if I do I prefer it later anyway, but it's the milk in my morning coffee that I'm struggling with the thought of giving up. Not a huge calorific latte or cappuccino but just some skimmed milk (but quite a big splash) in a filter coffee. There seems to be two schools of thought - one even that will start raising your blood sugar thus defeating the effectiveness, and another that it won't make much difference.

@Lemonyfuckit

as far as IF goes, yep 2 schools of thought, personally I don't think a big splash would make a difference.

but as far a BG goes, you're better off with cream or full fat milk. The fat helps with the carbs in the milk.

ThursdayFreedom · 11/06/2023 11:50

Chocolate23 · 11/06/2023 10:48

I have tried it. It was just another way of reducing calories for me. I lost the same amount of weight calorie counting.

@Chocolate23

But it's not just about weight loss, it's about all the other benefits of giving your body a longer stretch of not eating.

aloofflooty · 11/06/2023 11:45

Is there any research into the social / emotional / communication impact etc? By that I mean by skipping meals the impact it has on you connecting with others and what they perceive from you doing that?

Let's say you have an early window and skip dinner every day. That's the main meal they encourage you to sit together as a family, model good eating and develop social communication. Yes you can sit there and not eat and still talk but that's modelling something quite different. Is it ok for young kids to do too?

Also the emotional impact on not eating a particular meal, the quality of life / social side?

I'm not criticising the gastro science, just interest in the wider holistic impact.

WeRateSquirrels · 11/06/2023 11:29

I love 16:8. It’s been really effective at keeping my weight stable (I’m 51). I absolutely could not be bothered to calorie count.

From a purely practical perspective, I appreciate not having to faff around with food in the mornings. I stick to black coffee and water whilst fasting. I can exercise fasted just fine.

Hairbrushhandle · 11/06/2023 11:24

If I don't eat breakfast I feel physically sick by 8am, like morning sickness. I have to sit down and let the wave of nausea pass and then eat otherwise I'm actually vomiting. I also get shakey and don't trust myself to drive for example. How do you get behind that?

Panda89 · 11/06/2023 11:19

Yeah I drink black coffee and water (2-3l daily)
Then in my window (13:00-19:00) I’ll have tea with milk also.

I also sleep so much better as I don’t snack in the evening anymore.

Divebar2021 · 11/06/2023 11:17

@Wanderingowl.

Hey I just wondered what your job is? You seem quite qualified in this area. If someone tells me to “read the research” I think “shit I’m not qualified to interpret the research” or identify whether the scientists are making erroneous links. ( or whether they’re being funded by the Avocado council of something ). After all we were told fat was the enemy and eggs were bad for cholesterol and then sugar and carbs were the enemy. So although I want research backed by good science I don’t know good science when I see it

BobShark · 11/06/2023 11:16

I've used this one n the past and it removed my sugar cravings.

The 5:2 diet, though nothing beats a good balanced diet, for some having rules makes this easier.

CherryYree · 11/06/2023 11:15

Lemonyfuckit · 11/06/2023 11:06

For all the people who do it and it works for them - do you have milk in your morning tea/coffee? - the windows aren't so much of an issue for me as I often don't eat breakfast or if I do I prefer it later anyway, but it's the milk in my morning coffee that I'm struggling with the thought of giving up. Not a huge calorific latte or cappuccino but just some skimmed milk (but quite a big splash) in a filter coffee. There seems to be two schools of thought - one even that will start raising your blood sugar thus defeating the effectiveness, and another that it won't make much difference.

I have been doing something like 19:5 for a couple of months. I do have my morning tea with milk, but then only drink water throughout the day after. I have lost 14lbs so far and feeling pretty good!

2thumbs · 11/06/2023 11:10

I drink black coffee and water throughout the day, which is probably part of the reason IF works for me (that is, my fluid intake is effectively calorie-free). I’ve always taken my coffee that way so it was no change.

ThursdayFreedom · 11/06/2023 11:10

Miceeatinglollypops · 11/06/2023 07:18

It’s just calorie deficit by another name - no more, no less - all the benefits people describe would happen in any other calorie deficit too. I don’t know why people think it’s some magical thing, it’s literally the same as any other diet!

No, it's not. Having a large gap between eating benefits your body in lots of ways, do some reading.