Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Intermittent Fasting is a gimmick?

233 replies

NeedToChangeName · 10/06/2023 20:51

I know a few people who swear by Intermittent Fasting and make a big deal of only eating between 12 noon and 8pm

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Fairislefandango · 11/06/2023 17:49

You should be eating a good wholesome breakfast. Having no breakfast is shockingly bad.

Utter nonsense. Where is your evidence? This line, probably dreamed up by Mr Kellogg, has been debunked. It may have been true for a while that there was some correlation between healthiness and eating breakfast, but if you sell generations of people the idea that it's healthy to eat breakfast, guess what? People who care about their health and look after it in other ways will tend to obey and eat breakfast. Hence the correlation. But correlation is not causation.

Article about why skipping breakfast is not bad for you
here .

How lobbyists made breakfast 'the most important meal of the day'

We’ve tied all sorts of ills to a failure to sit down to a hearty breakfast. But research and history show that skipping our granola bowl does not, in fact, harm our health

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2016/nov/28/breakfast-health-america-kellog-food-lifestyle

Watchkeys · 11/06/2023 17:39

@Denimdreams

I tend to agree. I was hoping soapysuds could enlighten us.

BansheeofInisherin · 11/06/2023 17:35

Up until I was 40 I ate 3 meals a day and was an effortless size 8.
But I think eating 3 meals is unnecessary in peri-menopause, unless you are super active. My family is full of super slim diabetics.

Denimdreams · 11/06/2023 17:32

Watchkeys · 11/06/2023 17:07

@Soapyspuds

Why is it shockingly bad not to eat breakfast?

It isn't.
Some blokes in the 70s decided they could sell more if they got people hooked on carby foods.
Once they did that they invented SW/WW 🤑

Denimdreams · 11/06/2023 17:18

Comedycook · 10/06/2023 21:40

I do it. I've recently lost 17lbs. I cannot eat three meals a day and lose weight. As soon as I eat breakfast, I cannot stop eating. Its all or nothing for me.

Same.
It's not just about missing meals, it's how your metabolism works.
If I eat breakfast I'm eating all day.
16:8 is fantastic for me, no cravings, I don't feel hungry and I'm losing weight, no foggy head or exhaustion Smile

Watchkeys · 11/06/2023 17:07

@Soapyspuds

Why is it shockingly bad not to eat breakfast?

DragonflyLady · 11/06/2023 17:00

off · 11/06/2023 14:21

"Diabetes nurse" (every one that I've ever seen, at least) has such a massive hard-on for porridge, and how amazing it is for satiety and blood glucose and so on, and IMO it's a load of bull, at least for me. When I was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes I tested myself with a lot of different foods, at regular intervals after eating them, and surprise surprise, boiling up a load of starchy carbs to make them more digestible and eating them as a soft goop sends my blood sugars through the roof. I'm way better off from a blood sugar perspective eating a bowl of muesli than a bowl of porridge without sugar, even if the muesli has plenty of dried fruit.

Thankfully, mine doesn’t! I actually can manage porridge if I put some cream in it and have a short walk after it. But I rarely need breakfast these days. My mum insists it’s the best thing for Diabetes cos that’s what her nurse tells her and she won’t listen to me!!

Mimilamore · 11/06/2023 16:57

Most definitely not... 4 stone down with it, old so think in stones, best thing I've ever done

Watchkeys · 11/06/2023 16:29

I think there's quite a lot on this thread that demonstrates that we don't know what it means when we say a food/dietary habit is 'good for you'. Most things are good for us and bad for us both at the same time, to varying degrees. Broccoli may be high in nutrients, but give you indigestion. Ice cream might be physically unfavourable, but a couple of scoops might improve your mood, and thereby lower your stress. Early nights might improve your physical health, but wreck your social life. Fasting may encourage sarcopenia, but increase autophagy.

There's nothing that is only good for us. There are benefits to most things.

Fasting is something that humans evolved with. For some, the pros will outweigh the cons. For others, not.

TheOrigRights · 11/06/2023 15:53

To many people I apparently skip breakfast.
I don't, I just have it really late; around midday.
Left to my own devices I would sleep from 1am - 9am, work from 10am - 6pm, and do some sport in the late evening. I'm a night own and sports wise I perform better in the evening (I'd MUCH rather go out at 10pm than 6am in this heat).

I'd have breakfast around midday, something light early evening, dinner around 9pm and some fruit around 11pm.

As I have a son at school and a job I need to fit in with those hours. I still don't feel hungry for breakfast though. I can manage myself as I wfh. It gets in a pickle when I travel for work and know that if I don't have breakfast I won't make it through till lunch time, or I have to get up super early to exercise.

My point? We are all different and need to find what works for us (within the life we lead).

I also match the findings which showed that slim people compensate for eating more than they need by naturally eating less in the following days.

NewPinkJacket · 11/06/2023 15:24

Soapyspuds · 11/06/2023 14:26

If you skip breakfast and snacks you’re reducing your calories so how can it be a gimmick

You should be eating a good wholesome breakfast. Having no breakfast is shockingly bad.

Eat like a queen in the morning
Princess in the aftenoon
Peasant in the evening

You should be eating a good wholesome breakfast. Having no breakfast is shockingly bad.

I thought this tosh disappeared in the 1970s.

What is 'shockingly bad', is people forcing food into themelves when they're not hungry and their body doesn't need or want it.

I'm 54 and I haven't eaten breakfast since I left junior school.

I've never suffered from weight problems in my life. I eat when I'm hungry and stop when I'm full.

off · 11/06/2023 14:51

fellrunner85 · 11/06/2023 14:47

Yeah, fair point. As I said, I do realise that it might be unreasonable of me to be irritated by it!

Fair enough Grin

Gwenhwyfar · 11/06/2023 14:49

"You should be eating a good wholesome breakfast. Having no breakfast is shockingly bad."

Complete rubbish.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/06/2023 14:48

"No, you're not fasting, you're just skipping breakfast "

Breakfast itself has the word fast in it!

fellrunner85 · 11/06/2023 14:47

Yeah, fair point. As I said, I do realise that it might be unreasonable of me to be irritated by it!

off · 11/06/2023 14:42

But if giving it a special name and making it into a Thing is psychologically useful for some individuals, helps them put clear and manageable boundaries around their eating when they would otherwise struggle to moderate their diet, then why not?

fellrunner85 · 11/06/2023 14:36

Does anyone manage it with a super early start to do running?

Yes, me. I just want coffee when I get back from my run though, so it doesn't feel like I'm depriving myself.

It does irritate me (probably unreasonably so) when people bang on about "fasting" though.
No, you're not fasting, you're just skipping breakfast and not eating any snacks. Which is what millions of people do every day without feeling the need to give it a special name and make it into a Thing.

Comedycook · 11/06/2023 14:35

for me once I start eating I find it hard to stop

Me too. I wonder why. Even when I switched to low carb, I thought it would help but it didn't. I tried eggs with courgette and feta for breakfast thinking it would fill me up, it took away my hunger, but I still kept eating.

WeRateSquirrels · 11/06/2023 14:30

Soapyspuds · 11/06/2023 14:26

If you skip breakfast and snacks you’re reducing your calories so how can it be a gimmick

You should be eating a good wholesome breakfast. Having no breakfast is shockingly bad.

Eat like a queen in the morning
Princess in the aftenoon
Peasant in the evening

Surprisingly, your experience is not universal 🙄. I feel MUCH better not having breakfast. There’s no law saying everyone has to have 3 meals a day.

itsmellslikepopcarn · 11/06/2023 14:30

It worked for me, I lost 3 stone over 6 or so months. It really depends on your relationship with food; for me once I start eating I find it hard to stop.

Soapyspuds · 11/06/2023 14:26

If you skip breakfast and snacks you’re reducing your calories so how can it be a gimmick

You should be eating a good wholesome breakfast. Having no breakfast is shockingly bad.

Eat like a queen in the morning
Princess in the aftenoon
Peasant in the evening

Siameasy · 11/06/2023 14:25

It pretty much is that, skip breakfast and stop that mindless late night eating and drinking. It’s kept me slim and I’m pushing 50.

Soapyspuds · 11/06/2023 14:24

Yes of course it's a gimmick.

Yes the person might lose weight in the short term but in the long term they are highly unlikely to continue that lifesysle.

Why people feel the need to overcomplicate something that is so simple is beyond me. Eat fresh non processed foods, eat a sensible amout relative to how active you are. That is it!

off · 11/06/2023 14:21

MavisMcMinty · 11/06/2023 13:54

Exactly what I found! I’d read porridge is really good for you as a breakfast, controls blood sugars for HOURS afterwards, fills you up until lunchtime, etc., so started taking microwave porridge into work. It just kick-started my appetite and I didn’t stop eating all day!

"Diabetes nurse" (every one that I've ever seen, at least) has such a massive hard-on for porridge, and how amazing it is for satiety and blood glucose and so on, and IMO it's a load of bull, at least for me. When I was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes I tested myself with a lot of different foods, at regular intervals after eating them, and surprise surprise, boiling up a load of starchy carbs to make them more digestible and eating them as a soft goop sends my blood sugars through the roof. I'm way better off from a blood sugar perspective eating a bowl of muesli than a bowl of porridge without sugar, even if the muesli has plenty of dried fruit.

JadeSeahorse · 11/06/2023 14:16

I have an underactive thyroid diagnosed in 2013.

Started on Levothyroxine and began 16:8 combined with 5:2 at the same time and lost 3 stone in just a few months.

I am now back to a comfortable size 10, exercise for 10.minutes twice daily and still do 15:9, i.e. I only eat between 1300 and 2100 hrs.

Has worked fantastically well for me and I am fitter and slimmer now than I have been for 20 years. Can highly recommend! (I'm over 60 too!)