Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Intermittent Fasting is a gimmick?

233 replies

NeedToChangeName · 10/06/2023 20:51

I know a few people who swear by Intermittent Fasting and make a big deal of only eating between 12 noon and 8pm

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TheOrigRights · 12/06/2023 14:27

TheOrigRights · 12/06/2023 14:26

@TheOrigRightswhile not conclusive, there is plenty of research that shows that doing cardio whilst in a fasting state is effective at aiding weight loss/fat burning/refusing insulin levels.

I will read those later if I have time. Do they talk about eating AFTER exercise though? I exercise first thing in the morning with no problem. I can run about 15 miles on a cup of tea. But god...I'd need at least a banana pretty soon after I got back.

nb I don't run for weight loss/fat burning - I just run.

TheOrigRights · 12/06/2023 14:26

@TheOrigRightswhile not conclusive, there is plenty of research that shows that doing cardio whilst in a fasting state is effective at aiding weight loss/fat burning/refusing insulin levels.

I will read those later if I have time. Do they talk about eating AFTER exercise though? I exercise first thing in the morning with no problem. I can run about 15 miles on a cup of tea. But god...I'd need at least a banana pretty soon after I got back.

TheMurderousGoose · 12/06/2023 14:14

I do find the autophagy side of fasting to be very interesting. Although that state only occurs with fasts longer than 24 hrs I believe.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 12/06/2023 13:34

MavisMcMinty · 12/06/2023 12:40

A consultant gastroenterologist I used to work with was a great proponent of intermittent fasting, for gut health. She was also as slim as a pin, although I’m actually struggling to remember any fat or obese doctors during my 35 years of nursing.

There's plenty of overweight GPS

MavisMcMinty · 12/06/2023 12:40

A consultant gastroenterologist I used to work with was a great proponent of intermittent fasting, for gut health. She was also as slim as a pin, although I’m actually struggling to remember any fat or obese doctors during my 35 years of nursing.

brunettemic · 12/06/2023 12:37

How true this is I don’t know but a friend of DH did it and he lost a lot of weight. Apparently the logic is that we’re not originally designed to have 3 meals a day, that’s just what society tells us to do and in actually fact intermittent fasting is most likely how early people lived and are, hence it works. Equally that could be utter nonsense!

Denimdreams · 12/06/2023 12:34

Stravaig · 12/06/2023 11:58

That queasy shaky feeling on waking, or between meals, vanishes once blood sugar has evened out.

My understanding is that we burn energy from available food first, then glycogen from the liver, and then body fat stores. A well functioning metabolism should be able to switch smoothly between fuel sources, invisibly to us. Fasting helps achieve this.

A tummy rumbling for 10 minutes, which passes, is genuine hunger. A gnawing, craving, restless feeling of wanting more, even just after eating, is fucked up regulation of blood sugar and/or hormonal and/or metabolic systems.

This is exactly how I understand it and my experience.
That gnawing hunger and craving has gone.
It's not a diet
No calorie counting etc
I can eat anything I like in the 8 hour window.
I prefer salad, vegetables, fruit anyway and am avoiding UPF .

Stravaig · 12/06/2023 11:58

That queasy shaky feeling on waking, or between meals, vanishes once blood sugar has evened out.

My understanding is that we burn energy from available food first, then glycogen from the liver, and then body fat stores. A well functioning metabolism should be able to switch smoothly between fuel sources, invisibly to us. Fasting helps achieve this.

A tummy rumbling for 10 minutes, which passes, is genuine hunger. A gnawing, craving, restless feeling of wanting more, even just after eating, is fucked up regulation of blood sugar and/or hormonal and/or metabolic systems.

Stravaig · 12/06/2023 11:48

16:8 only involves 'skipping breakfast' if that's the meal pattern you choose.
I do well on 16:8, or 15:9, or 17:7, or whatever suits that day. I 'break fast' at 7 am (or 6, or 8) with a sugared black coffee, or green tea plus strip of dark chocolate or a few berries. My first meal is around 11 am (or 10, or 12), my second meal around 3pm (or 2, or 4). Meals are roughly equal portions, and any dessert is eaten as part of a meal.

I'm mostly home-based at the moment, so I've been able to fall in to what is most natural to me. I did this to help recover from ongoing illness, but if I look back, there are many times in my life when this was my natural pattern. A sliver of sweetness first thing; lots of food late morning; and a similar amount late afternoon/early evening.

Snoken · 12/06/2023 11:45

@Welliehead You might but not much. Your body will target the stubborn fat during the last few hours of your fasting window (hour 12-16) and it will lower your blood pressure, inlammation levels etc. So there are other benefits to 16:8 even if your goal is not to lose weight.

Welliehead · 12/06/2023 11:16

So if you do 16.8, but eat the same calories that you normally would by eating breakfast, will you lose more weight?

LemonSwan · 12/06/2023 10:04

usernother · 10/06/2023 21:28

I don't like people trying to dress it up into something fancy by calling it intermittent fasting when it is just skipping breakfast and not eating after dinner.

Theres different levels of it so I think it’s right it has its own name.

I do agree 12-8 (actually called 16:8) is just fancy renaming of skipping breakfast though 🤣

But there is a whole sliding scale down to 23:1 (one giant meal a day)

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 12/06/2023 09:59

there is some evidence that even if you do 12:12 it helps and once you got 8pm -8am ie no snacking late evening you can try altering one by an hour then another hour so maybe 8am-7pm . I need to eat before I start work or I feel light headed as I have to start work by 9am the latest I can eat is 8.15-8.30am, I try and do dinner for 6-6.30 with no evening snacking so unless a treat day out with friends or celebrating I eat only 3 meals a day one mostly carb free ( don't count carbs in veg seeds or yogurt)in a 10 hour window it has helped me lose 2 stone in a year

TheOrigRights · 12/06/2023 09:50

Hardbackwriter · 11/06/2023 19:28

I run at 6am 3 days a week, go from that to the school run and to work which is another 6k-ish steps and don't find it a problem to then keep fasting until somewhere between 12 and 1 (I try and do an 18 hour fast) but I have a sedentary job. I can see how the combination could be too much, though it might be worth giving it a try. I found the first few days hard but I found it surprising how quickly I got used to it - I don't feel hungry in the morning at all any more really. And I actually feel more alert than I did before, and that's quite common apparently.

As a keen sportswoman, this sounds SO unhealthy. To run fasted and then not eat for HOURS afterwards cannot be good for your body.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 12/06/2023 09:31

It definitely works but as someone with a history of an eating disorder all I can think of is that it's just starving themselves. It's just extreme restriction rules.

It worries me that starving is pinned as 'healthy fasting' but of course everyone has different levels of willpower and healthier mindsets to cope with it.

ThursdayFreedom · 11/06/2023 22:06

Hairbrushhandle · 11/06/2023 13:11

I think it's probably because my DC wake me at 5. So by 8 I'm faint.

@Hairbrushhandle im always awake at 5 too & can't even blame the kids!!

what time do you think you need at eat by?

if it was 7, you could start fasting at 6 & do 13:11. Or if you could manage 5pm 14:10, but it really does change family life if you usually eat dinner together.

maybe just be a bit conscious if eat 2/3 well spaced meals and not snacking at all other than that. It will give you some of the benefits of fasting without feeling crap, then when the kids stop waking you up so early give it a go then?!

Comedycook · 11/06/2023 22:03

Like any diet, it will suit some people and not others. The hardest thing for me in terms of losing weight was trying to find a diet which suited me. I've tried them all. I like IF because in my eating window I eat pretty much whatever I want...I don't go crazy but I like that i don't have to cut anything out entirely.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/06/2023 20:36

"Also you are not just 'skipping breakfast', you are still break(ing your)fast, but after a minimum of 16 hours usually ( I do 18 hours)"

Well, except that breakfast also has the meaning of 'morning meal' I suppose. On the other hand, I see no problem with eating traditional breakfast food at any time of the day.

Darkstar4855 · 11/06/2023 20:31

I discovered it six years ago and went from a size 14/16 to a size 10 and have maintained that since, other than when pregnant/post natal. Total game changer.

If you understand the science around insulin levels, basal metabolic rate, ketogenesis etc. it makes a lot of sense. Our bodies did not evolve to be fed generous amounts of carbohydrate at regular intervals.

LimitIsUp · 11/06/2023 20:17

Gwenhwyfar · 11/06/2023 14:48

"No, you're not fasting, you're just skipping breakfast "

Breakfast itself has the word fast in it!

Also you are not just 'skipping breakfast', you are still break(ing your)fast, but after a minimum of 16 hours usually ( I do 18 hours)

XenoBitch · 11/06/2023 19:36

YABU, you just sound bitter about your friends finding something that works for them.

I need to get back into it, but when I did IF, I lost weight, had loads of energy, acid reflux disappeared. I did 16/8 with a weekly 36 hour fast. Honestly, after getting over the first 24 hours, I felt like a Duracell Bunny.
I have always struggled with breakfast anyway. My body does not like any food after getting up, so I can easily go a few hours after waking before eating.

Hardbackwriter · 11/06/2023 19:28

aloofflooty · 10/06/2023 21:35

Does anyone manage it with a super early start to do running? I get up at 5am to exercise 4/5 days a week, leave for work at 7.30 and then work full time in a busy on my feet physical job (where I can't have a late breakfast at 11 or whatever) If I didn't eat until lunchtime I don't think I'd be very productive or engaged and think I would feel a bit ill. After running I'm usually STARVING by 8am. But maybe I'm missing something.

I run at 6am 3 days a week, go from that to the school run and to work which is another 6k-ish steps and don't find it a problem to then keep fasting until somewhere between 12 and 1 (I try and do an 18 hour fast) but I have a sedentary job. I can see how the combination could be too much, though it might be worth giving it a try. I found the first few days hard but I found it surprising how quickly I got used to it - I don't feel hungry in the morning at all any more really. And I actually feel more alert than I did before, and that's quite common apparently.

Ontobetterthings · 11/06/2023 19:22

It's brilliant. Lost loads of weight on it

Hardbackwriter · 11/06/2023 19:20

elrider · 11/06/2023 10:18

I think simplifying it to skipping breakfast and not snacking in the evening is misleading as even if that is the 8h window you choose, you're forgetting about drinks. E.g. you can't have your usual teas or coffees with milk in the morning or your glass of wine/gin and tonic/diet Coke/hot chocolate/tea with milk or whatever in the evening. That's what's giving your digestion a proper break. Those saying you eat in that window naturally, I'd be interested to know if you naturally only drink water (or black coffee/tea) as I doubt that's the case for most people so you're actually not doing it already.

The cells have time to have a good clear out once you've not been consuming any calories for 14+ hours so it's for more than weight loss. Your skin can get brighter, you can reduce your risk of various diseases, etc. Damaged and old cells get the boot which they think will decrease risk of developing some cancers as well.

Having said upthread that yep, it's just skipping breakfast and evening snacks, I actually do agree with this - it is a bit more restrictive to that. I find one of the challenges is that it isn't very sociable - when I stick to it strictly I miss evening drinks, particularly, and I end up having to break it if I want to eat a meal out with friends because no one else wants to eat at kiddy tea time!

I drink herbal tea and black coffee in the morning, which took some getting used to but I'm used to now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread