Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Intermittent Fasting is a gimmick?

233 replies

NeedToChangeName · 10/06/2023 20:51

I know a few people who swear by Intermittent Fasting and make a big deal of only eating between 12 noon and 8pm

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Delatron · 15/06/2023 15:49

It can lower the metabolism for some people and affect thyroid function in women especially. Then that has an impact on hormones such as cortisol. It’s very individual as to whether it works for you and dependent on lots of factors.

Watchkeys · 15/06/2023 13:46

FrogsWormsandCaterpillars · 15/06/2023 09:47

No you don’t, as long as you’re in a calorie deficit you will lose weight. You can eat 5000 calories of healthy food and you’d gain weight, eat 14/1500 calories of shit food and (Depending on your deficit) you’ll lose weight

So, the body's only way of dealing with a kcal deficit is to burn fat? What about when it lowers the metabolism? Where does that come into the equation? Or does metabolism stay exactly the same for everybody all the time, regardless of what/when they eat?

Delatron · 15/06/2023 13:04

TheOrigRights · 15/06/2023 10:55

I think rather than the fasting, it's the adoption of healthier eating and being a healthy weight BY ANY MEANS that gives you a longer life span rather than fasting per se. If fasting is what enables someone to have a healthier body then good, but I imagine eating a good, balanced diet (at any time of day) and exercising is probably better overall.

I think this is true. And we have to remember we are all different.

Don’t forget most of the research on fasting was done on sedentary (therefore not particularly healthy) middle aged men.

That doesn’t mean that those results translate to an active perimenopausal woman (or a woman at any lifestage really).

Also yes you could eat 1,000 calories of rubbish and maybe lose weight but would you be healthy?

LadyBird1973 · 15/06/2023 12:04

I remember years ago when I was trying to diet, my mum saying that if I was on a thousand calorie limit, I could just eat 3 mars bars and a multivitamin if I wanted!
God, I miss those days Grin

My mum has since done a complete about face and has learned about insulin spikes and effects of upf and now I can't move without her chucking a vitamin at me!

Yes, you could lose weight on 3 mars bars a day if you were in calorie deficit but you wouldn't be healthy.

TheOrigRights · 15/06/2023 10:55

Southoftheriver32 · 15/06/2023 10:43

It’s no gimmick, it’s been proven that fasting can add 10 years to your life. We burden our bodies with too much food and for the majority of the population it’s not even food that they’re eating, it’s toxic garbage.

I think rather than the fasting, it's the adoption of healthier eating and being a healthy weight BY ANY MEANS that gives you a longer life span rather than fasting per se. If fasting is what enables someone to have a healthier body then good, but I imagine eating a good, balanced diet (at any time of day) and exercising is probably better overall.

Southoftheriver32 · 15/06/2023 10:43

It’s no gimmick, it’s been proven that fasting can add 10 years to your life. We burden our bodies with too much food and for the majority of the population it’s not even food that they’re eating, it’s toxic garbage.

Sartre · 15/06/2023 10:19

It does work if you’re trying to lose weight though. I was almost 18 stone about 8 years ago, BMI was 38 so close to morbid obesity. I started the 5:2 diet as well as exercising daily and I lost 7 stone in 12 months, healthy weight and BMI within a year. I dropped the weight so quickly doing it. May seem unhealthily quick but have kept it off.

FrogsWormsandCaterpillars · 15/06/2023 09:47

Meerkitkat · 10/06/2023 21:14

You still have to eat healthily though, not fast food.

No you don’t, as long as you’re in a calorie deficit you will lose weight. You can eat 5000 calories of healthy food and you’d gain weight, eat 14/1500 calories of shit food and (Depending on your deficit) you’ll lose weight

TheOrigRights · 15/06/2023 09:35

mum2jakie · 14/06/2023 22:40

I've started this week with a 12-8pm eating window. Much easier to do while it has been so hot in the daytime anyway as I don't have as much appetite in this heat. I am having one single cup of tea with a splash of milk in when I wake up - couldn't function without it!

That's pretty much my regular eating pattern. I'd never considered that I do IF.

mum2jakie · 14/06/2023 22:40

I've started this week with a 12-8pm eating window. Much easier to do while it has been so hot in the daytime anyway as I don't have as much appetite in this heat. I am having one single cup of tea with a splash of milk in when I wake up - couldn't function without it!

Yerroblemom1923 · 13/06/2023 13:50

It doesn't need a fancy name. I've eaten like this for years because it's compatible with my work. No lunch break and I hate rushing a sandwich down my neck at top speed so would much rather eat when I get home and can enjoy it in a relaxed environment.
Holidays, family gatherings and meals out with friends are a nightmare as they throw a spanner in the works as I'm always being nagged to eat breakfast, lunch etc. I wish people weren't so critical of other people's food circumstances.

mumlikeaboss · 13/06/2023 13:29

TheMurderousGoose · 12/06/2023 14:14

I do find the autophagy side of fasting to be very interesting. Although that state only occurs with fasts longer than 24 hrs I believe.

I don't think it's as simple as you hit 24 hours and 'bam' autophagy starts happening...

I'm pretty sure I've read that autophagy happens at some level in everyone, even if they only fast for 10-12 hours overnight - but the longer you fast, the more that process ramps up.

mumlikeaboss · 13/06/2023 12:59

Welliehead · 13/06/2023 12:33

So why does black coffee not trigger an insulin response? There's no sugar in unsweetened almond milk. It's less sweet than cows milk.

Something to do with coffee being a bitter taste...? means it doesn't set off the cephalic phase insulin response. Also it has no nutrients to speak of.

Almond milk, like anything else that essentially contains a nutritional content, will set off an insulin response (if only a relatively small one). I would also say it tastes food-like, even if it's not sweet - your body knows there's something coming in that needs digesting.

mumlikeaboss · 13/06/2023 12:55

Yes you are BU... That's exactly what intermittent fasting is 😂

Welliehead · 13/06/2023 12:33

CaveMum · 13/06/2023 11:31

@Welliehead it's not about the calories, it's about triggering an insulin response in the body which effectively ends your fasted state as the aim is to have insulin levels low in order to fat burn..

So why does black coffee not trigger an insulin response? There's no sugar in unsweetened almond milk. It's less sweet than cows milk.

Desperatenow1 · 13/06/2023 12:27

NeedToChangeName · 10/06/2023 20:51

I know a few people who swear by Intermittent Fasting and make a big deal of only eating between 12 noon and 8pm

To me, this just sounds like (1) skip breakfast and (2) no snacks after dinner

AIBU?

It's not a gimmick, but it is just as simple as you state...some people like to make it there's a real science behind it and they've only just thought it up but it's really very simply cutting out a few meals.

Yerroblemom1923 · 13/06/2023 12:18

As a PP said it's great because it trains your body not to feel hungry. People often ask me incredulously how I can go until 3 or 4pm without eating, but I'm just used to it and I don't think about food. It's quite freeing actually.

Outofthepark · 13/06/2023 12:09

BansheeofInisherin · 10/06/2023 21:15

It's worked pretty well for me and helped reverse my pre-diabetes.

Nice! I did this too but with a different eating plan (every 3 hrs even to bedtime if I wanted but much less and much better good than before, along with some exercise).

coronabeer · 13/06/2023 12:04

@Cornflakesaredabomb

Time Restricted Eating is limited your eating to a set window - day, between 8am and noon, or between 10am and 6pm, which seems to be a popular choice.

Intermittent Fasting is about eating a restricted diet on a number of set days per week, and eating normally on other days. For example, on the 5:2 diet, you eat a very low calorie diet for 2 days (usually between 500 and 800 calories, depending which version you follow), and eat normally on the other days.

Some people do a bit of a hybrid approach with elements of both. Nutrition research treats the two patterns separately and it isn’t clear, for example, that what is true for TRE will necessitate be true for IF (and vice-versa).

TheOrigRights · 13/06/2023 11:56

Cornflakesaredabomb · 13/06/2023 11:49

What defines IF as opposed to TRE?

I was curious, so looked it up:

People who practice time-restricted eating typically eat during an 8- to 12-hour daytime window and fast during the remaining 12 to 16 hours. Unlike intermittent fasting, which involves caloric restriction, time-restricted eating permits a person to eat as much as they want during the eating window.

Essentially (and simplistically) eating fewer calories than you need will result in weight loss. If people find it easier to do that by adopting a named eating plan or treating it like a project (TRE, fasting, SW) then that's fine, but I do think people can over-complicate things, or get hung up on it.

Cornflakesaredabomb · 13/06/2023 11:49

coronabeer · 13/06/2023 11:39

I think what most people are describing here is TIme Restricted Eating (TRE), rather than Intermittent Fasting.

They are both effective weight loss strategies because they generally lead to fewer calories being consumed in total. Research shows that 16:8 fasting in itself does not lead to superior weight loss compared to a diet matched for calories.

What defines IF as opposed to TRE?

coronabeer · 13/06/2023 11:39

I think what most people are describing here is TIme Restricted Eating (TRE), rather than Intermittent Fasting.

They are both effective weight loss strategies because they generally lead to fewer calories being consumed in total. Research shows that 16:8 fasting in itself does not lead to superior weight loss compared to a diet matched for calories.

CaveMum · 13/06/2023 11:31

@Welliehead it's not about the calories, it's about triggering an insulin response in the body which effectively ends your fasted state as the aim is to have insulin levels low in order to fat burn..

Welliehead · 13/06/2023 11:11

Surely unsweetened almond milk is fine. It barely has any calories at all.

MrsLully · 13/06/2023 10:59

Cornflakesaredabomb · 13/06/2023 10:40

Is it just herbal tea or black/tea coffee until you officially break fast?

This is the sticking point for me. I have unsweetened almond milk in my tea as it doesn’t cause me glucose spikes but I can’t face it black and my first morning cuppa is one of the happiest points in my day.

Oh I did struggle with this, I always have sugar in my coffee. What I did was cut back the amount of sugar a bit every day, and I ended up with a wee bit of vanilla sweetener on black ice coffee instead.
So for the first few weeks I wasn't properly fasting but was losing weight all the same. I realised though when I managed to cut all the sugar out that I wasn't all that hungry and could wait much better until 13:00 or even 14:00. I suppose I wasn't getting my blood sugar spiked and it helped.
The main thing is to get started, even if you aren't doing it "properly". The results will get you much more motivated than any amount of research on how to do it by the book.