Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother has a secret wife

156 replies

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 17:51

I am from an Indian culture and born in India.
My Brother moved away aged 18 and has been very successful in life.
I came to know that aged 23 he married someone he knew my parents would absolutely never agree with.
She was older than him by 8 years and a single parent. Beautiful, educated and lovely as I've met her but my parents would never bother with him again.
I don't know why he did it but he took her to India and married her with all his friends around. I found out when I visited him in the U.K. He really wanted to get married and start a family but didn't want to deal with the aggression, emotional blackmail and disowning at the start of family life he said.
My Brother isn't married to anyone else back in India, has his own money and own indefinite leave to remain. He's not 'playing' her he clearly adores her and they have a baby boy.
Now I have kept this secret for two years and my attitude is it's not my secret to tell.
I know he loves his Wife and is just scared of the reaction. I don't agree with what he's done and think he should absolutely tell my parents but actually it's not my secret and it's not my place to give an ultimatum to tell them either.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 18:54

Azandme · 10/06/2023 18:47

My DP of over four years is Indian. I am older, divorced, with a child. He left India two years before we met.

His parents have known about me for
two and a half years. They are modern and yet traditional. His sister had an arranged marriage, and he was expected to have the same. He is considered very eligible.

In the two and half years they have known about me we have dealt with the following:

His mum introducing him to families and their eligible daughters whilst he was in India for a family wedding. Despite him telling her not to.

They asked him to strand me alone in a different. I was already on the plane as he was working away so we were meeting there - they begged him not to get on his plane.

Told him that our relationship is wrong on every level.

I went to India to meet them, we had what appeared to be a nice dinner, very friendly and welcoming. Next day they called him, told him they would not accept me, and listed a whole litany of things that were "wrong" with me. These included: age, divorced, referred to my ds as baggage, I'm only after his money (we're actually pretty much equal in terms of personal finances), religion, and a whole host of other things. All about what I am, nothing about who I am - apparently they liked me as a person, but in no way did they want me with him.

They even said that if he felt OBLIGED to be with me because it had been so long THEY would speak to me and get me to go away. 🤨

Needless to say, he chose me.

It has been incredibly painful for both of us. Me, because it's hurtful to be judged so negatively because of my race, and status, not to mention my beautiful, clever, funny boy being called "baggage". Him because he's seen a very ugly, judgemental side to his parents, who he loves.

And you wonder why your brother hasn't told them? He's protecting HIS family from them. What an awful situation your parent's beliefs have put them in.

My partner's parents are actually nice people, except for this one (giant) issue. Sadly, they failed to realise that the judging isn't one way, and I was also judging them. I am in no hurry to spend any time with them, and that will bite them when we have children. I gave them the chance to hurt me once. They don't get to do that again.

So many similar stories. I'm so sorry you went through this.

OP posts:
TonTonMacoute · 10/06/2023 18:52

Your brother has put you in a very difficult position OP, and I sympathise.

He has done all this and created this situation, he should tell your parents and deal with the consequences, whatever they are. I assume there will be a big row and lots of upset, but the sooner it's out in the open the sooner rifts can start to be mended.

It may be that might take a long time, but it's not fair on him to drag you into this, and I think you should point this out to him.

Its all very well posters condemning your parents for very traditional views, but that's who they are and they deserve a certain amount of respect however rigid their outlook.

Azandme · 10/06/2023 18:47

My DP of over four years is Indian. I am older, divorced, with a child. He left India two years before we met.

His parents have known about me for
two and a half years. They are modern and yet traditional. His sister had an arranged marriage, and he was expected to have the same. He is considered very eligible.

In the two and half years they have known about me we have dealt with the following:

His mum introducing him to families and their eligible daughters whilst he was in India for a family wedding. Despite him telling her not to.

They asked him to strand me alone in a different. I was already on the plane as he was working away so we were meeting there - they begged him not to get on his plane.

Told him that our relationship is wrong on every level.

I went to India to meet them, we had what appeared to be a nice dinner, very friendly and welcoming. Next day they called him, told him they would not accept me, and listed a whole litany of things that were "wrong" with me. These included: age, divorced, referred to my ds as baggage, I'm only after his money (we're actually pretty much equal in terms of personal finances), religion, and a whole host of other things. All about what I am, nothing about who I am - apparently they liked me as a person, but in no way did they want me with him.

They even said that if he felt OBLIGED to be with me because it had been so long THEY would speak to me and get me to go away. 🤨

Needless to say, he chose me.

It has been incredibly painful for both of us. Me, because it's hurtful to be judged so negatively because of my race, and status, not to mention my beautiful, clever, funny boy being called "baggage". Him because he's seen a very ugly, judgemental side to his parents, who he loves.

And you wonder why your brother hasn't told them? He's protecting HIS family from them. What an awful situation your parent's beliefs have put them in.

My partner's parents are actually nice people, except for this one (giant) issue. Sadly, they failed to realise that the judging isn't one way, and I was also judging them. I am in no hurry to spend any time with them, and that will bite them when we have children. I gave them the chance to hurt me once. They don't get to do that again.

Coffeetree · 10/06/2023 18:45

Except remember that he has ILR? Therefore stands to receive absolutely no benefit from the marriage?

Anklespraying · 10/06/2023 18:44

WhereYouLeftIt · 10/06/2023 18:39

"So they worry they will have no grandchildren."
They have three grandchildren. Two they won't acknowledge (your children) and the third your brother has never told them because they would disown him.

Honestly, your parents should be kept a secret from their grandchildren - to protect the grandchildren.

Exactly, it's no loss to those kids is it?

Anklespraying · 10/06/2023 18:42

Chatillon · 10/06/2023 18:35

He has the right to live in the U.K. so desirable back home and they could marry him to someone they see as a very good catch.

Hmm...there are lots of people getting 'married' to gain British citizenship.

Sounds a very toxic family.

Some things never change.

This was a plotline of Hanif Kureshi's wonderful book The Buddha of Suburbia set in the 1970s published 40 years ago.

MaidOfSteel · 10/06/2023 18:41

They won't acknowledge the kids you gave birth to as their own grandchildren? Frankly, you owe them nothing. I'm not surprised your brother keeps things from them.
Stay out of it. And don't feel bad for doing so.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 10/06/2023 18:41

So your parents wouldn't be happy with your brother's marraige & don't acknowledge your children as their grandchildren?

Despite this backwards thinking cruelty you are considering telling them? Why on earth do you think they deserve to know? Their attitude is exactly why they haven't been told.

If it wasmy brother, I would be happy fir him and proud he built himself a happy life inspite of them.

Culture is never any excuse for judgment or cruelty. You are old enough to use your own judgement & step outside your parent's narrow mindedness.

Mummyoflittledragon · 10/06/2023 18:41

I hope your brother sees your children as his nieces ( I think they’re girls from what you’ve said). Cherish the family that you have with him. Build the connection with your nephew and sil. It sounds as if you should continue to keep your parents at arms length to avoid upsetting your children.

diddl · 10/06/2023 18:40

Glad to have a Grandson

Soften the blow.

They really don't deserve to know.

I cannot fathom treating a child of mine so badly.

You have moved away from them.

He has decided to not tell them.

Perhaps different sides of the same coin?

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 10/06/2023 18:40

Your parents don't consider your children to be their grandchildren.

They don't deserve a relationship with any of you, your brother has done the right thing!

I'm surprised you have any contact with them tbh

Mythril · 10/06/2023 18:40

So the only reason you want to tell is to ease your own guilt for being a "bad daughter?" Despite the fact this would bring a heap of shit onto your brother? And all this for parents from whom you also keep your distance because they've denied your children?

WhereYouLeftIt · 10/06/2023 18:39

"So they worry they will have no grandchildren."
They have three grandchildren. Two they won't acknowledge (your children) and the third your brother has never told them because they would disown him.

Honestly, your parents should be kept a secret from their grandchildren - to protect the grandchildren.

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 18:38

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 10/06/2023 18:35

I'm off out for my 5the wedding anniversary with my dh tonight, no one knows we're married

It's your secret to keep, tell anyone and you risk losing your db and potentially your dp.

Wow. How come?

OP posts:
sherbertyellowteddy · 10/06/2023 18:38

Oh OP. Don't feel guilty by keeping this secret, your brother has chosen this for a reason and it's so he can be happy. And it sounds like his judgement regarding your parents was correct.

I think your parents sound awful for not accepting your children as their grandchildren, and I wouldn't blame you at all for cutting contact with them. They don't deserve the title of Grandparent purely because of the way they have treated your children.

Coffeetree · 10/06/2023 18:37

I agree its not your place to tell.

For some reason I suspect they know (or suspect) and are turning a blind eye because they don't want to deal. Literally how do they not know? If everyone else knows. When they facetime him does he leave the house?

Does he receive money from them? Or he hopes to inherit? I don't see any reason for him to keep the secret. So what, they'll kick off? And then things will be awkward?

I'm genuinely sorry to bring up this about your brother, but if something should happen to him, his wife would be in a really difficult position in terms of care, burial, etc. His parents might try to take over and shut her out. He should really make arrangements. If I were his sister I would gently bring this up with him, once, but otherwise leave it alone.

InSpainTheRain · 10/06/2023 18:36

It's not your secret to tell. I wouldn't tell your parents just enjoy your relationship with your bro, sil and the son. What your parents don't know can't hurt them although I would think at some stage the secret will get out.

MerryMarigold · 10/06/2023 18:35

I kind of hope he doesn't tell them because it would be so hurtful for your children (and you) to see your nephew celebrated whilst your children are denied.

Who is saying you're a bad daughter for not telling your parents, if none of your family know. Surely not your brother's closest friends.

Chatillon · 10/06/2023 18:35

He has the right to live in the U.K. so desirable back home and they could marry him to someone they see as a very good catch.

Hmm...there are lots of people getting 'married' to gain British citizenship.

Sounds a very toxic family.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 10/06/2023 18:35

I'm off out for my 5the wedding anniversary with my dh tonight, no one knows we're married

It's your secret to keep, tell anyone and you risk losing your db and potentially your dp.

MayThe4th · 10/06/2023 18:33

Think it's more the culture and the people they've been brought up around. nope. We need to stop excusing vile and abusive behaviour because of culture. Your parents are vile. I don’t care what culture they’re from. If I posted the same as you have and I’m English people would say my parents were hideous and to go NC.

People need to start realising that culture isn’t an excuse to behave however you want and be above criticism.

If I were your brother I would disown my parents.

And tbh you would do well to do the same.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 10/06/2023 18:33

I've been quite wracked with guilt these days as some friends who attended the wedding have said as I'm family I am a disgrace for not saying anything.
I'm letting my parents down.
I'm a bad Daughter etc.

Fuck 'em. You are a great daughter and sister in a really tough spot. You take care of yourself. xx

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 18:33

FrostyFifi · 10/06/2023 18:32

I'm not liking the sound of your parents tbh, they're incredibly cruel in their attitude to your children.

Yup.
Preaching to the choir I'm glad to say.
I also keep my distance and have moved out of country.
But for several reasons do keep in contact.

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/06/2023 18:32

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 18:21

No they do not consider them their grandchildren in any way.

That’s vile.

In your shoes I’d follow your brother’s example of building a life that doesn’t include your parents in any way.

And i think it highly likely your nephew will be less damaged by “they weren’t very nice people so we just stayed away from them” than your children will be if you allow your parents around them when they make their feelings clear about the donor eggs.

LakeTiticaca · 10/06/2023 18:32

Say nothing. Your brother is happy with his little family. Its up to him to tell them or not. They might make life difficult if they don't approve of his freely made choice. Its his life, let him get on with it

Swipe left for the next trending thread