Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother has a secret wife

156 replies

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 17:51

I am from an Indian culture and born in India.
My Brother moved away aged 18 and has been very successful in life.
I came to know that aged 23 he married someone he knew my parents would absolutely never agree with.
She was older than him by 8 years and a single parent. Beautiful, educated and lovely as I've met her but my parents would never bother with him again.
I don't know why he did it but he took her to India and married her with all his friends around. I found out when I visited him in the U.K. He really wanted to get married and start a family but didn't want to deal with the aggression, emotional blackmail and disowning at the start of family life he said.
My Brother isn't married to anyone else back in India, has his own money and own indefinite leave to remain. He's not 'playing' her he clearly adores her and they have a baby boy.
Now I have kept this secret for two years and my attitude is it's not my secret to tell.
I know he loves his Wife and is just scared of the reaction. I don't agree with what he's done and think he should absolutely tell my parents but actually it's not my secret and it's not my place to give an ultimatum to tell them either.
AIBU?

OP posts:
StaunchMomma · 10/06/2023 19:49

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 18:21

No they do not consider them their grandchildren in any way.

This is just disgusting.

I really don't blame your brother if he has nothing to do with them and keeps his child away.

And as for it being more important that your brother's child is a BOY, well, just eye rollingly ridiculous.

My son would not be going anywhere near people who thin like that.

OfficerPastiche · 10/06/2023 19:46

Also OP I do get that from the kids' POV it's not fair on them to be a secret. But, better that than the damage from them being known and not wanted.
Again, it will come out eventually. And as Indians are very gossipy I'm surprised that your parents don't know...maybe they do and are choosing to ignore the truth.

ReachForTheMars · 10/06/2023 19:46

You reap what you sow.

They made him feel he would be disowned so he hides things. Its obvious that would happen.

You tell and he will disown you.

The friends that attended his wedding and gorged themselves on his hospitality and want you to do something that they wont do? Fuck them.

StaunchMomma · 10/06/2023 19:46

Fair play to your brother. It's HIS life and he is clearly living it happily and while taking nothing from his parents/the family.

I hope he is very happy with his own little family and continue to put them first.

You are absolutely right that it is not your story to tell.

Hbh17 · 10/06/2023 19:45

Your brother is an adult who can do whatever he likes. It is absolutely not your place to get involved (nor is it anyone else's business, including your parents).

PlinkPlonkFizz · 10/06/2023 19:45

You sound very detached about your parents treatment of your DC as not being "real," grandchildren. It might be painful to consider but I'd wonder if subconsciously, you are considering outing your brother's secret to even the score and cause him the same hurt as you've been subject to.
Also, if he is disinherited, more for you. I know that is probably a cruel thing to accuse you of, but the potential for absolute family fallout here is so high, you need to ask yourself exactly why you are even considering doing anything to tell your parents. I think the stakes are way too high to be thinking about it at all. Families can be so toxic.

OfficerPastiche · 10/06/2023 19:44

YABU OP.
I'm also of South Indian descent, marrying a white British man.absolutely this may be hardcore 'culture' but people choose whether to cling onto it or not.
As Ir happens my parents are accepting and have laid down the law to th rest of the family but her siblings are not and have broken up their children's relationships.to 'unsuitable' people including a lovely girl who just happened to not be Indian.
He's doing the right thing by protecting his family. Don't interfere.

One day it will all come out and he can deal with the fall out then but not your place. Just give him your support.

readbooksdrinktea · 10/06/2023 19:42

Aquamarine1029 · 10/06/2023 19:14

You know how awful your parents are yet you're still considering telling them your brother's private business?

What?

I really don't understand this either. Why would you purposefully want to wreck his life? Strange.

GingerScallop · 10/06/2023 19:42

GingerScallop · 10/06/2023 19:37

My sister married an Indian man. She wasnt a secret but wasnt really accepted. They were married for 25 years until bil's death yet one of his brothers still refers to herby the Punjabi equivalent of the N word. She has constantly had to prove her humanity despite absolutely adopting his culture in dress, food, religion. Your brother has to figure out what works for him and his family.

And actually 25 years later that brother still doesnt acknowledge her if he meets her, doesnt speak to her or her kids unless forced but has probably spoken to them less than 100 words in 25 years. Just hallos of he has to. If your parents op wont even acknowledge your kids as their grandchildren they are really unlikely to accept your sil. My sister too had years of his family bringing pics of nice indian girls he could marry even after 20+ years! His kids heard these suggestions. Its incredible really

GingerScallop · 10/06/2023 19:37

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 18:54

So many similar stories. I'm so sorry you went through this.

My sister married an Indian man. She wasnt a secret but wasnt really accepted. They were married for 25 years until bil's death yet one of his brothers still refers to herby the Punjabi equivalent of the N word. She has constantly had to prove her humanity despite absolutely adopting his culture in dress, food, religion. Your brother has to figure out what works for him and his family.

FigTreeInEurope · 10/06/2023 19:33

"Its all very well posters condemning your parents for very traditional views, but that's who they are and they deserve a certain amount of respect however rigid their outlook."

No they don't. They sound like racists, who should probably go to the grave with their silly ideas. You can't have international travel, the Internet, and a global economy, and still make concessions for this shit.

diddl · 10/06/2023 19:30

But probably still want their hands on the grandson and want him over in India and to show off to everyone.

So perhaos not even interested in him as a person, just a trophy?

Is your brother intending to tell them?

diddl · 10/06/2023 19:28

So you weren't invited to the wedding & he wasn't intending to tell you?

Floppyelf · 10/06/2023 19:27

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 18:24

I'm not sure how they will react.
They have a grandson which they will be delighted with I think.
So maybe that will soften the blow.
I remember my Brother desperately hoping the baby was a boy as he felt this would act as a bit of a cushion to the blow they were about to receive.
We don't know how they will react.
Probably disown him to be honest.
But probably still want their hands on the grandson and want him over in India and to show off to everyone.

Then its simple? Their backward views will die with them when they die. Start distancing yourself from the relatives who don’t treat your children like your children…

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 19:26

ThreeLocusts · 10/06/2023 19:20

OP you sound like a very loyal, decent sister unfairly put under pressure by others to divulge your brother's secret. You don't sound interfering or just out to create drama at all, whatever some pps say.

No reason to fee guilty about keeping your db's secret at all. Sorry your parents are so cruel about your children. Enjoy your son and your nephew Flowers

Thank you 😊
I'm definitely not interested in 'drama'.
Feeling guilty that's all.
My parents are toxic but other family members (such as my grandma) are not and they also don't know and my grandma is very unwell and will never know she had a grandson.
The whole situation is sad.
My grandma and some other family members are the main reason I stay in contact with my parents in the way I do.
But I do completely understand my Brother's reasons and feel it's absolutely not my secret to tell.

OP posts:
ThreeLocusts · 10/06/2023 19:21

Sorry, your children, whatever their sex

ThreeLocusts · 10/06/2023 19:20

OP you sound like a very loyal, decent sister unfairly put under pressure by others to divulge your brother's secret. You don't sound interfering or just out to create drama at all, whatever some pps say.

No reason to fee guilty about keeping your db's secret at all. Sorry your parents are so cruel about your children. Enjoy your son and your nephew Flowers

Aquamarine1029 · 10/06/2023 19:14

You know how awful your parents are yet you're still considering telling them your brother's private business?

What?

ShimmeringShirts · 10/06/2023 19:09

I’m so sorry that is your parents view to your children. That must be incredibly hurtful Flowers

Starwarslover · 10/06/2023 19:08

@Lissaaaaaa i find the way you dismiss your own children as your parents grandchildren really strange!! Do you not see them as your children?! Mad that you feel sorry for your parents not having a grandchild when they have 2!

i think your brothers doing the right thing (for him), you said yourself your parents would be done with him so I can’t see what good would come from telling them? This way he gets the happy life he deserves plus a relationship with your parents

Anaemiafog · 10/06/2023 19:07

If this is true that child is better off never knowing those grandparents. How sad your DB needs to hide his truth. Why would you inflict such an awful attitude on his DW and DC? I'd run with your DC too.

DojaPhat · 10/06/2023 19:06

I don't understand the angst you're going through because by your own admission it's not your secret, nor your story to tell, nor did you play an active role in facilitating the relationship. It seems the issue is more the draw of the potential huge family drama with pending fallout and recriminations. None of that need happen if you focus on your own life. Confused

SleepQuest33 · 10/06/2023 19:04

Nope. He's actually their only grandchild tooNope. He's actually their only grandchild too as my children were both conceived via donor egg (but a close relative). As I always knew I couldn't have my own children.

So they worry they will have no grandchildren.
And they have a BOY grandchild which to them is even more special. as my children were both conceived via donor egg (but a close relative). As I always knew I couldn't have my own children.

So they worry they will have no grandchildren.
And they have a BOY grandchild which to them is even more special.

am I reading this correctly op? They don’t see your children as their grandchildren? Doesn’t that upset you? My sis in law has an adopted child who gets treated by the entire family just like any of my children.
I would have stopped talking to them completely in your case.

Azandme · 10/06/2023 18:58

Lissaaaaaa · 10/06/2023 18:54

So many similar stories. I'm so sorry you went through this.

I'm so sorry you're going through it too. Different angle, same cause.

EpicChaos · 10/06/2023 18:56

As you say, it's not your secret to tell, nor is it your place to demand that he does.