Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of parenting guidance is flawed?

69 replies

Cellocecilia · 10/06/2023 17:05

I am a scientist by ‘trade’ and since having my first daughter at the end of last year I can’t get over how flawed much of the official advice/guidance and even medical instructions are around new babies. Honestly as an analytical thinker having DD has been a bit maddening in terms of analysing all the information coming my way.

For example, I had a c-section and was told I couldn’t lift anything heavier than my baby, she was born 6lbs. People have babies twice that size. So that’s flawed advice. There objectively must be a maximum weight people post op should lift. I however suspect that might be less than some babies weigh and therefore the NHS don’t want to be telling new mothers not to lift their own babies, or it’s more than an average baby but they don’t trust the masses to correctly assess the weight of objects they wish to move.

Secondly the ‘don’t roll a baby onto their front to sleep, but once they can roll themselves onto their front you don’t need to roll them back’ physiologically there is no difference in position or sleep safety if a baby is rolled onto their front or they roll themselves onto their front, if they can roll from front to back.

The guidance seems to be based on it not being practical to expect or tell parents to sit up all night rolling their babies back over, not because it’s safe for babies to sleep face down if they roll themselves there. There is also some argument that by the time most babies can roll from back to front they’ve got past the most dangerous months for SIDS and their breathing is more mature.

Same applies to the safe sleep guidelines, it doesn’t help that all the ‘recent’ guidance was published at the same time so no one really knows what factor contributed the most to the reduction in SIDS. For example the theory on why it’s better for a baby to sleep in it’s parents room until 6 months is based on the fact that noise from parents will prevent baby from falling into too deep a sleep, this would be achieved by just having white noise, soft music playing or a fan on.

I put in a FOI request to the lullaby trust to get access to the data sources for their safe sleep guidelines and it’s a very interesting read to say the least.

So AIBU to be so frustrated by the lack of scientific basis for most of the guidance we are given as new parents?

OP posts:
SunbathingDragon · 10/06/2023 18:00

Just to take one of your examples, who told you that you can’t pick up anything heavier than your baby and what guidelines did they get it from? The medical belief is that there is no safe lifting limit but it is widely acknowledged that the overwhelming majority of women will pick up their own baby whether they are recommended to do so or not.

JaniceBattersby · 10/06/2023 17:58

Charities aren’t subject to the Freedom of Information Act so it’s odd that you were given the data at all.

RightWhereYouLeftMe · 10/06/2023 17:57

every c section parent I know lifted things heavier than their child, as they had to, but some lifted items that were pretty damn heavy so might have done with being told to definitely not lift more than 10kg for example.

If they lifted something heavier than their baby "because they had to", why wouldn't they lift something heavier than a given weight "because they had to".

Also it's hard to judge whether a shopping bag etc is heavier than a certain weight. I can't judge if something is more than 3kg for example. I can tell you if it's heavier than one or both of my children though. And would find that even easier if they were a newborn who I carried all the time.

Jazzybean · 10/06/2023 17:54

ThatFraggle · 10/06/2023 17:38

You are a scientist. People become parents who struggled to or didn't finish school. Or who have art PhDs.

Do you want them to ask, hmm, what's your educational background? You started a business after school? It's a publicly traded company now? High school, ok, here's the high -school level pamphlet. And liberal -arts, non-scientific pamphlet for your husband.

You understand that health professionals need to communicate important information to a wide range of people.

"Don't lift anything heavier than a baby." Easy to understand.

Do you want them to say: The majority of studies indicated that the upper limit for lifting is 10kg, and provided that the patient is not in the top ten percentile for obesity and provided that there were no complications, 90% of women should be able to safely lift up to ten kg, but ten percent suffered surgical stitches coming lose when lifting over 5 kg, so to err on the side of caution an upper limit of 5 kg is advised.

Or just 'don't lift anything heavier than your baby.'

You are free to read all the peer-reviewed articles on everything. You can make an informed choice.

There are people who last read a book in school. They also need information to keep their babies safe and alive, and that information needs to be digestible.

100% this.

It’s hard enough getting some parents to understand the most basic of information.

I work in health visiting. The majority of advice appears to err on the side of caution (when compared with the evidence) on the basis that most people won’t do everything ‘perfectly’.

Lovingitallnow · 10/06/2023 17:54

Also you're being massively presumptuous that most people would be able to identify the weight of their kids, school bags, tables, dining chairs, books, kettles, roast in a roasting tin, toy boxes etc. whether it's 5kg or 7 or 2.

RogersOrganismicProcess · 10/06/2023 17:53

Love the idea, that “definitely do not lift anything heavier than 10 kg” will work better, than nothing heavier than your baby, whilst acknowledging that parents push boundaries.

I’m not sure too many parents would be confident in estimating which objects weigh 10kg, yet I am sure they would be able to roughly assess if something weighed more or less than a baby they hold regularly.

Reugny · 10/06/2023 17:53

Yes I would like for those giving out medical advice to give factual information. Or at least make it available for those that want it.

Good luck with that.

Some maternity healthcare professionals can't give out correct vitamin advice, and the information isn't hard to find.

You are ignoring that you (and the people you know) may actually have more knowledge than some of the maternity professionals treating you.

Lovingitallnow · 10/06/2023 17:52

Because new parents have a baby to look after. They can't relax and recuperate.

Cellocecilia · 10/06/2023 17:52

Lovingitallnow · 10/06/2023 17:50

How would you know something is 10kg? Would you measure it before you lift it? Or would you need to weigh everything before your section? The reality is a lot of people won't know what 10kg feels like.

Most items are quite easy to either judge the weight or have it listed

again, after most other surgeries patients are given clear weight limits in terms of what to carry. Why are new parents different?

OP posts:
ThreeFeetTall · 10/06/2023 17:51

I think you need to let it go OP otherwise you will drive yourself mad. I agree with the points you have made, but public health info is different from what you do as a scientist.

Cellocecilia · 10/06/2023 17:50

NewNovember · 10/06/2023 17:47

No it's so a baby regulates their breathing to their parents it's nothing to do with noises .

It’s definitely not, the studies the lullaby trust cite using on their safe sleep guidelines are pretty clear with their conclusions, many split out white noise and fans and saw the same beneficial reduction in SIDS occurrences

OP posts:
Lovingitallnow · 10/06/2023 17:50

How would you know something is 10kg? Would you measure it before you lift it? Or would you need to weigh everything before your section? The reality is a lot of people won't know what 10kg feels like.

Lovingitallnow · 10/06/2023 17:49

You do know there's no known cause for SIDS? It's all down to correlation and there's no scientific basis behind any of it? Also every mother and child and family is different so the advice is for an entire population regardless of your mobility, financial situation or family circumstance. It's a best fit scenario. As pp already said often the guidelines takes into account what people are most likely to respond to instead of scientific excellence? It's why policy makers are not just scientists or statisticians or analysts but a combination of many different streams. It's no good having incredible guidelines that the lay person can't understand or apply to their own situation.

Reugny · 10/06/2023 17:48

Cellocecilia · 10/06/2023 17:41

The second part of your comment is exactly why the guidance is flawed tbh. There is no physical difference in a baby being put on their front (if they can roll back) and those that roll themselves onto their fronts in terms of aspirating milk, being able to breathe properly etc.

If a baby rolls themselves onto their front their windpipe is just as much in front as a baby who is put on their front.

You are ignoring the fact that babies are individual.

So some babies who can roll, stop rolling in their sleep when refining another motor skill.

So the simplest public health message to give is put your baby to sleep on their back (and if they roll over themselves leave them alone).

NewNovember · 10/06/2023 17:47

Cellocecilia · 10/06/2023 17:05

I am a scientist by ‘trade’ and since having my first daughter at the end of last year I can’t get over how flawed much of the official advice/guidance and even medical instructions are around new babies. Honestly as an analytical thinker having DD has been a bit maddening in terms of analysing all the information coming my way.

For example, I had a c-section and was told I couldn’t lift anything heavier than my baby, she was born 6lbs. People have babies twice that size. So that’s flawed advice. There objectively must be a maximum weight people post op should lift. I however suspect that might be less than some babies weigh and therefore the NHS don’t want to be telling new mothers not to lift their own babies, or it’s more than an average baby but they don’t trust the masses to correctly assess the weight of objects they wish to move.

Secondly the ‘don’t roll a baby onto their front to sleep, but once they can roll themselves onto their front you don’t need to roll them back’ physiologically there is no difference in position or sleep safety if a baby is rolled onto their front or they roll themselves onto their front, if they can roll from front to back.

The guidance seems to be based on it not being practical to expect or tell parents to sit up all night rolling their babies back over, not because it’s safe for babies to sleep face down if they roll themselves there. There is also some argument that by the time most babies can roll from back to front they’ve got past the most dangerous months for SIDS and their breathing is more mature.

Same applies to the safe sleep guidelines, it doesn’t help that all the ‘recent’ guidance was published at the same time so no one really knows what factor contributed the most to the reduction in SIDS. For example the theory on why it’s better for a baby to sleep in it’s parents room until 6 months is based on the fact that noise from parents will prevent baby from falling into too deep a sleep, this would be achieved by just having white noise, soft music playing or a fan on.

I put in a FOI request to the lullaby trust to get access to the data sources for their safe sleep guidelines and it’s a very interesting read to say the least.

So AIBU to be so frustrated by the lack of scientific basis for most of the guidance we are given as new parents?

No it's so a baby regulates their breathing to their parents it's nothing to do with noises .

Cellocecilia · 10/06/2023 17:46

ThatFraggle · 10/06/2023 17:38

You are a scientist. People become parents who struggled to or didn't finish school. Or who have art PhDs.

Do you want them to ask, hmm, what's your educational background? You started a business after school? It's a publicly traded company now? High school, ok, here's the high -school level pamphlet. And liberal -arts, non-scientific pamphlet for your husband.

You understand that health professionals need to communicate important information to a wide range of people.

"Don't lift anything heavier than a baby." Easy to understand.

Do you want them to say: The majority of studies indicated that the upper limit for lifting is 10kg, and provided that the patient is not in the top ten percentile for obesity and provided that there were no complications, 90% of women should be able to safely lift up to ten kg, but ten percent suffered surgical stitches coming lose when lifting over 5 kg, so to err on the side of caution an upper limit of 5 kg is advised.

Or just 'don't lift anything heavier than your baby.'

You are free to read all the peer-reviewed articles on everything. You can make an informed choice.

There are people who last read a book in school. They also need information to keep their babies safe and alive, and that information needs to be digestible.

Yes I would like for those giving out medical advice to give factual information. Or at least make it available for those that want it.

It’s not easy to find most of this information, that’s the issue. I had to submit a FOI request and wait weeks to get most of the data.

It also leads to people taking risks they maybe shouldn’t. It’s very difficult to only lift stuff the same weight as your baby for 6 weeks after having a section, it would actually be helpful to know an actual maximum so people didn’t put themselves at risk, every c section parent I know lifted things heavier than their child, as they had to, but some lifted items that were pretty damn heavy so might have done with being told to definitely not lift more than 10kg for example.

OP posts:
Cassandra9 · 10/06/2023 17:45

Cellocecilia · 10/06/2023 17:31

But it’s not. The conclusion of the specific studies used to form the lullaby trust guidance all state it’s noise in general, a few even split out babies who slept with fans and white noise and it showed the same impact.

Some studies theorised parents could intervene if they noticed any issues with their baby, as a secondary reason for sleeping in the same room, but this relied on the parents being awake or close enough to the babies sleeping space to hear any slight concerns.

I thought it was the parents exhaled carbon dioxide nearby that would encourage/help baby take appropriate breaths rather than due to noise.

RogersOrganismicProcess · 10/06/2023 17:42

But if they are a roller they can roll back. If they are a tiny non roller, they just choke!

Cellocecilia · 10/06/2023 17:41

RogersOrganismicProcess · 10/06/2023 17:33

Isn’t is a case of non rolling baby, face down, less likely to be able to roll into a safe position if struggling. Whereas confident roller, more able to move? Also I thought face down baby was more likely to aspirate milk due to windpipe sitting in front.

The second part of your comment is exactly why the guidance is flawed tbh. There is no physical difference in a baby being put on their front (if they can roll back) and those that roll themselves onto their fronts in terms of aspirating milk, being able to breathe properly etc.

If a baby rolls themselves onto their front their windpipe is just as much in front as a baby who is put on their front.

OP posts:
RogersOrganismicProcess · 10/06/2023 17:40

ThatFraggle · 10/06/2023 17:38

You are a scientist. People become parents who struggled to or didn't finish school. Or who have art PhDs.

Do you want them to ask, hmm, what's your educational background? You started a business after school? It's a publicly traded company now? High school, ok, here's the high -school level pamphlet. And liberal -arts, non-scientific pamphlet for your husband.

You understand that health professionals need to communicate important information to a wide range of people.

"Don't lift anything heavier than a baby." Easy to understand.

Do you want them to say: The majority of studies indicated that the upper limit for lifting is 10kg, and provided that the patient is not in the top ten percentile for obesity and provided that there were no complications, 90% of women should be able to safely lift up to ten kg, but ten percent suffered surgical stitches coming lose when lifting over 5 kg, so to err on the side of caution an upper limit of 5 kg is advised.

Or just 'don't lift anything heavier than your baby.'

You are free to read all the peer-reviewed articles on everything. You can make an informed choice.

There are people who last read a book in school. They also need information to keep their babies safe and alive, and that information needs to be digestible.

👍this

ThatFraggle · 10/06/2023 17:38

You are a scientist. People become parents who struggled to or didn't finish school. Or who have art PhDs.

Do you want them to ask, hmm, what's your educational background? You started a business after school? It's a publicly traded company now? High school, ok, here's the high -school level pamphlet. And liberal -arts, non-scientific pamphlet for your husband.

You understand that health professionals need to communicate important information to a wide range of people.

"Don't lift anything heavier than a baby." Easy to understand.

Do you want them to say: The majority of studies indicated that the upper limit for lifting is 10kg, and provided that the patient is not in the top ten percentile for obesity and provided that there were no complications, 90% of women should be able to safely lift up to ten kg, but ten percent suffered surgical stitches coming lose when lifting over 5 kg, so to err on the side of caution an upper limit of 5 kg is advised.

Or just 'don't lift anything heavier than your baby.'

You are free to read all the peer-reviewed articles on everything. You can make an informed choice.

There are people who last read a book in school. They also need information to keep their babies safe and alive, and that information needs to be digestible.

Cellocecilia · 10/06/2023 17:37

McTerfy · 10/06/2023 17:33

You kind of did though, with your ‘I’m a scientist’ opening sentence. It came across very much, I’m a scientist so I know better.

I’m a physicist, doesn’t mean I know anything about safe sleeping positions for babies.

Nope, didn’t say I knew better, more that as someone who spends their entire life analysing data this has been a bit of a pet peeve of mine.

Most of the data sources the lullaby trust used also included suffocation deaths in their numbers, which really skews the data.

From the data the biggest factor is baby having their own space to sleep. The issue is the surrounding guidance which doesn’t have as much scientific basis behind it

OP posts:
ChristmasFluff · 10/06/2023 17:36

Whatever you do, don't look into vaccination and vaccination schedules.

The current vaccination schedule is not based on what is best for baby, but instead on what will ensure maximum vaxination take up. Yeah, on a population level, may be best. Or may not, since nno-one has properly assessed the differnece of delaying vaccination, particularly in breast fed babies.

And that might lead you to wuestion covid responses, PCR and then mRNA vaccines.

Or you might look at screening tests like cervical smears or beast screening - where other countries get a really informative brochure, but we just get told 'do it or die',

And all this is religion on mumsnet and elsewhere. You question any of it at your peril, and people who gave up science at 'O' level or earlier will tell you you're a fuckwit because some random scientist says something.

Unless that scientist is Linus Pauling, or Luc Montagnier, or any other (Nobel-prize-winning) scientist who dared go rogue.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 17:36

RightWhereYouLeftMe · 10/06/2023 17:33

OP is talking about babies who can roll. Once they can roll onto their fronts themselves, the advice is still that they must always been out down on their back.

Based on her other comments, I don't believe so.

HMMOG · 10/06/2023 17:36

TheWayTheLightFalls · 10/06/2023 17:09

You need Emily Oster’s books OP

Came here to say this.