Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister-in-law's wedding. Would you expect time off work to be paid or unpaid?

168 replies

saltandvinegardiscos · 10/06/2023 16:15

I've got a friend who works as a TA. She's asked for leave from work for a day, so she can go to her husband's sister's wedding.

She's fuming, because work has said she can take the day, but it will be unpaid.

Personally, I think that's fair. The policy says it's at the discretion of the headteacher.

Anyone else who works in schools or in jobs where you can't just book annual leave, what would you expect in this circumstance?

OP posts:
Kitcaterpillar · 11/06/2023 11:37

OfficerPastiche · 10/06/2023 23:15

@Kitcaterpillar you are conflating several unrelated things.
TA's cannot 'manage their own time' because their primary job is to be present during school hours and they need ratios. It's not being treated like a child to have a job that you cannot 'make up' later.

Also, it's not even the wedding of an immediate relative. it's her sister in law, not her own sister.

If you really want to compare the public sector is quite flexible and able to provide term time working for loads of jobs that don't require it, such as programmers, simply to retain staff. I don't know where you were employed, as again 'public sector' is massive and covers everyone from driving instructors to senior civil servants but round here they are some of the better ones to work for. Lower pay and bureaucracy, but otherwise flexibility.

No, and that's why I said my perception may be skewed. Because working in an environment where I should feel grateful to attend a funeral - which has been mentioned more than once in this thread - sounds untenable to me.

I didn't suggest that TAs can manage their own time. But would note ratios are unlikely to be an issue.

The primary issue I'm highlighting is that schools are in the midst of a recruitment crisis. There are endless threads here about it. TAs are often cited as underpaid. If I had a valued yet underpaid staff member in the midst of a recruitment crisis, I would see giving them a paid day off as a low price to pay for retaining them.

CalamityClam · 11/06/2023 10:00

I’m a headteacher and I authorise with pay the vast majority of the time. My staff are grateful and don’t take the piss.

Schools are different to businesses though in that if we often have to pay over the odds to replace the absent member of staff: there’s no way a class can’t have a teacher, and often TAs need replacing for the day too as they work with children with SEN, contribute to lunchtime ratios etc.

from September the budgets are even tighter and granting paid leave will definitely become a thing of the past.

This is why teachers are striking and it’s likely heads will too on the next round. Support your striking schools!

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 11/06/2023 09:56

j should’ve known this really as DM was a teacher for many years and she didn’t take time off during term time (despite having a chronically sick child with asthma). When we were sick we were left in bed and she’d come back at lunchtime (a 30 min drive) to give us lunch and check we were ok, my step grandmother occasionally came over for the day (paid) but apart from that we were on our own. But she did switch from full time to job share which was half the week and helped her in that respect (not always easy to get job share(. She did go to help nurse her uncle dying of cancer but can’t recall if this was in school holidays or was special paid or unpaid leave. Again down to headteachers, some were lovely and wouldn’t have minded giving days off for special reasons others wouldn’t have given it. Actually once when I was a teenager and between schools (changing) in term time) I had to go in with her for a few days and on one occasion helped out with a school trip.

Starseeking · 11/06/2023 09:46

Someone who works in a school is extremely lucky to have had term-time leave granted, paid or unpaid (this should be unpaid, as it's not a close relative life threatening situation or bereavement).

Groovee · 11/06/2023 09:45

In my LA we get 5 days a year classed as special leave. But some colleagues end up using them as childcare days so when something like a wedding comes along they need to take it unpaid.

justprance · 11/06/2023 09:44

I am a teacher and any additional term time leave is unpaid.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 11/06/2023 09:43

Unpaid. I have no idea how TA’s work and get holiday outside of school holidays though!

LlynTegid · 11/06/2023 09:41

Unpaid.

I understand anyone wanting a weekday wedding because of lower costs and some other practicalities possibly, but if you knew one of your relatives was a teacher or in another school role, wouldn't you pick a date in school holidays? Assuming you really wanted them there.

BusyMum47 · 11/06/2023 09:39

Unpaid leave & grateful it was granted at all, in term time! (I'm a Teaching Partner)

No-one gets paid leave at my school unless it's time off in lieu for hours worked over contract.

That's just the way it is. We get a lot of annual leave as it is - albeit not at a time of our personal choosing but we really can't complain, as it covers all the main holidays & the entire Summer!!

MistressIggi · 11/06/2023 09:24

I've been given a paid day to attend a graduation, same for a funeral - that has come down to HT's discretion and fortunately she wasn't a twat about it.

Isitthathardtobekind · 11/06/2023 00:51

Of course unpaid. Many wouldn’t be given the time off in term time and if you do get time off for something like this, it’s unpaid whether you are in the office/TA or teacher.

UsingChangeofName · 10/06/2023 23:26

Well, several posters have said she's lucky to be getting the day off at all.

.........because it is part of her contract that all holidays have to be taken outside of term time. You know that when you work in a school. As a pp has said, you can't put the class into a filing cabinet and pick the work up on another day - she is employed because she is needed to support the children.
Some people find that difficult to imagine that not everyone works in roles that can be 'done at another time'.
Term time jobs are massively sought after where I live. TAs that come out of private daycare think they've won the lottery.

Batalax · 10/06/2023 23:23

I don’t think the rest of the staff will think much to her getting a free extra day off than them. Unpaid is fair.

HatchetJob · 10/06/2023 23:23

I’m surprised she was allowed! I’ve seen support staff be refused days off for their own children getting married (forcing them to quit).

I’ve seen more allowances for teachers (secondary) even to the point they have been paid to go to friends weddings. But that’s the nature of teaching/support roles.

I think she’s gotten a good deal!

Gettingbysomehow · 10/06/2023 23:23

In my NHS department we have to book everything 3 months in advance or we can't go. We are very understaffed. I can only dream of a paid day off for a wedding. I cant even go to my nephews christening because I wasn't given 3 months notice.

OfficerPastiche · 10/06/2023 23:15

@Kitcaterpillar you are conflating several unrelated things.
TA's cannot 'manage their own time' because their primary job is to be present during school hours and they need ratios. It's not being treated like a child to have a job that you cannot 'make up' later.

Also, it's not even the wedding of an immediate relative. it's her sister in law, not her own sister.

If you really want to compare the public sector is quite flexible and able to provide term time working for loads of jobs that don't require it, such as programmers, simply to retain staff. I don't know where you were employed, as again 'public sector' is massive and covers everyone from driving instructors to senior civil servants but round here they are some of the better ones to work for. Lower pay and bureaucracy, but otherwise flexibility.

ThatWhiteElephant · 10/06/2023 22:52

She is lucky to get the day off and yes as a TA it would be unpaid, going by the schools that I have worked in.

MistressIggi · 10/06/2023 22:48

Riverlee · 10/06/2023 22:34

No one is saying she can’t go, just that she shouldn’t be expected to be paid for that day.

Well, several posters have said she's lucky to be getting the day off at all.

Kitcaterpillar · 10/06/2023 22:44

MrsAvocet · 10/06/2023 22:19

A sister's wedding is a big, important, unmovable event. In a 'normal' job, people would have the ability to take AL. TAs don't have that option. It would seem sensible, amid a school recruitment crisis, to add some flex into the system.
People in "normal" jobs may be able to take annual leave for events like this but they don't have 13 weeks when they are not required to be in work. Virtually every TA I know has been attracted to their job in a large part because it is term time only working. The downside of that of course is that stuff like this happens. You can't opt for a job with term time only working and then expect to be treated like people with "normal" jobs when it suits you.
If you look at comparable jobs in other public services - health care assistants, carers, civil service admin assistants etc - they may have more flexibility when they take their leave but they probably only get 25/27 or so days a year and they almost certainly wouldn't be given another paid day to attend a wedding if they'd used them all. And they also often go above and beyond the call of duty and are jobs with recruitment and retention issues. Of course it would be nice to be able to be that flexible but imagine if every public servant took additional paid leave every time they had a family event - who'd fund that and how would services run? Why should this TA get special treatment? She hasn't been denied the opportunity to attend the wedding (and its her SIL, not her sister so not even a relative) she's just not going to be paid, which is probably what would happen in most jobs anyway.
Every job has its pros and cons and you can't have your cake and eat it - fixed working patterns and flexible leave arrangements are mutually exclusive surely?

I mean... I'm not a TA and I work in a private sector job where everyone is treated like an adult and manages their own time so maybe my perception is skewed. BUT if I was running a school and I had a valued workforce, I would be letting people have days off for weddings and funerals because recruitment is expensive and retention and goodwill is important 🤷🏼‍♀️

All this thread really confirms to me is I'll never return to the public sector.

Alwayswonderedwhy · 10/06/2023 22:40

She's very lucky to get the time off. I'd be grateful and accept it will be unpaid.

elodiedie · 10/06/2023 22:39

If leave isn’t allowed for important events then you just get people calling in sick, which is worse.

UsingChangeofName · 10/06/2023 22:38

MrsAvocet · 10/06/2023 22:19

A sister's wedding is a big, important, unmovable event. In a 'normal' job, people would have the ability to take AL. TAs don't have that option. It would seem sensible, amid a school recruitment crisis, to add some flex into the system.
People in "normal" jobs may be able to take annual leave for events like this but they don't have 13 weeks when they are not required to be in work. Virtually every TA I know has been attracted to their job in a large part because it is term time only working. The downside of that of course is that stuff like this happens. You can't opt for a job with term time only working and then expect to be treated like people with "normal" jobs when it suits you.
If you look at comparable jobs in other public services - health care assistants, carers, civil service admin assistants etc - they may have more flexibility when they take their leave but they probably only get 25/27 or so days a year and they almost certainly wouldn't be given another paid day to attend a wedding if they'd used them all. And they also often go above and beyond the call of duty and are jobs with recruitment and retention issues. Of course it would be nice to be able to be that flexible but imagine if every public servant took additional paid leave every time they had a family event - who'd fund that and how would services run? Why should this TA get special treatment? She hasn't been denied the opportunity to attend the wedding (and its her SIL, not her sister so not even a relative) she's just not going to be paid, which is probably what would happen in most jobs anyway.
Every job has its pros and cons and you can't have your cake and eat it - fixed working patterns and flexible leave arrangements are mutually exclusive surely?

This.

Perhaps she should be looking at why the SiL has chosen to get married on a day she might not have been able to attend........
Before booking anything for our wedding, we checked with all the important people.

JudgeJ · 10/06/2023 22:37

CurlyTandtheTangles · 10/06/2023 16:54

Currently leadership teams in schools need to think carefully saying a complete no to an adhoc day off (unpaid) for an important event if it is a decent, reliable, hard working members of staff.

Because these staff are very much valued. Not easy to replace, and costly to replace if they think "fuck it... I'll start looking for a job elsewhere"

If they start making decisions based on 'decent, reliable, hard-working' staff then they are laying themselves open to accusations of favouritism. They need to have a firm policy and stick to it.

Riverlee · 10/06/2023 22:34

No one is saying she can’t go, just that she shouldn’t be expected to be paid for that day.

MistressIggi · 10/06/2023 22:31

Sierra26 · 10/06/2023 18:36

From annual leave allowance = paid
If not from annual leave allowance = discretionary unpaid

Do posters honestly not see the problem here..?

To those saying how grateful she should be to be allowed to go at all, we can't keep TAs at my school, if you refused to let them attend a close family wedding I think they'd just hand their notice in.