Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To eat dairy even though baby has suspected allergy?!

64 replies

milkinmum · 10/06/2023 12:31

I've had differing advice from two different consultants - my infant is exclusively breastfed and hasn't yet started weaning and shows signs of mild allergy through my breast milk, I think I've noticed a link to dairy. He has mild eczema that is controlled through regular ointments and has mucusy runny poos. However he is a happy smiley baby, his weight gain is beautiful and he feeds and sleeps well.

One consultant advised an elimination diet for 6 weeks to see if those symptoms resolve

One consultant said if he does have an allergy that actually because it's mild and manageable and he's thriving that it's best to keep it in his system so his body doesn't reject it totally and that he should outgrow it soon enough anyway.

I have asked for clarity on what the better route is and got told only I know how much my baby is suffering or not?!

As much as I don't want him to have eczema on more concerned about lifelong allergy so I guess I'm resonating more with the continuing as normal route, but I feel guilty eating things that I do suspect he is allergic too?!

OP posts:
Hairbrushhandle · 10/06/2023 20:34

I think the problem stih continuing dairy is that your baby might well start dropping off on the growth charts because they're not absorbing foods properly, which can also lead to anemia and a lot of other issues.

Personally, I'd go with dairy free for a few months and then eat it every other week or something and see how it goes. But anecdotally, my DC were both dairy free for 5 years and can now tolerate all dairy so I wouldn't worry too much about the allergy worsening. I'd worry more about gut damage and growth problems.

Alloveragain3 · 10/06/2023 20:28

@MrsMikeDrop

It isn't clear cut like this. In some cases, excluding and avoiding the food can make an allergy worse.

If the baby is content, it may well be better to not restrict any foods

MrsMikeDrop · 10/06/2023 20:25

Why would you if there was some risk to your baby?

Rainbowshit · 10/06/2023 20:19

DisquietintheRanks · 10/06/2023 15:44

Absolutely. As long as your baby isn't actively dying, what's a bit of gut damage? Imflammed, damaged intestines are good for babies and - if you are lucky - can lead to more exciting allergies later on.

This is utter nonsense. I have two DC with multiple anaphylactic allergies both taking part in immunotherapy trials.

Current advice is if you can tolerate your allergen with symptoms as mild as the OPs Dc is to not cut out the allergen as tolerance will increase the more you invest the allergen.

Alloveragain3 · 10/06/2023 20:18

@pinksquash13 Hmm... I don't follow any others quite like that but the Natasha Foundation one is good for knowing what's going on in the allergy world

Mars27 · 10/06/2023 20:13

Alloveragain3 · 10/06/2023 20:00

Yes, it's his most recent Instagram post! He's there under dradamfox

I read the post and it's not really "mums shouldn't do an exclusion diet" written in back and white. It's a measured post and takes into consideration a variety of situations. He does say that they should do an exclusion diet if necessary.

He says that an exclusion diet may stop breastfeeding because it's very restrictive and who wants to go on potatoes, courgette and rice only like I did when you could be eating cake and feeding Neocate to the baby? I just wish I had introduced Neocate sooner but I still don't regret having persisted with bf even after introducing DS to Neocate.

pinksquash13 · 10/06/2023 20:12

@Alloveragain3 thanks, that's a useful account to follow. Any other recommendations?

I have had so much conflicting advice. It does seem like even the professionals don't know.

If I were you, I'd definitely keep it in my diet. The milk ladder is such a pain, I can't even tell you. If you LO isn't suffering hugely, definitely don't put yourself/ him through the reintroduction.

If you felt like you need to do something, you could exclude pure mik and yog and keep everything else. These are easier to swap out for alternatives IMO.

Rainbowshit · 10/06/2023 20:10

My DS was anaphylactic to dairy until we did the SOCMA immunotherapy trial. He now can tolerate as much dairy as he wants. This was done by him eating dairy every day in ever increasing amounts.

We first knew if his allergy at a few weeks old. It was passing through my breast milk.

Unlike your DC he was screaming all the time and not sleeping so I cut milk out.

My advice to you would be to not stop eying dairy if your DC is perfectly happy.

Alloveragain3 · 10/06/2023 20:00

Yes, it's his most recent Instagram post! He's there under dradamfox

Mars27 · 10/06/2023 19:57

Alloveragain3 · 10/06/2023 19:45

There's no clear answer as the medical professionals can't agree. They simply don't have the data.

My son had (and has) severe allergies, including to milk.

I did exclude dairy when he was very small, as it seemed to help his eczema and reflux. However, I reintroduced it into my diet when he was 18 months and still breastfeeding, with no issue.

Dr Adam Fox (a prominent UK allergist) has come out and said most mums shouldn't exclude it from their diet, as it only passes through the milk in tiny amounts. However, he says if the baby's symptoms can't be controlled medically, mum should then try an exclusion diet.

Can you please quote where Dr Fox said this? I'm just curious because my DS was a patient of his and of Dr George DuToit at Evelina's and the advice we had was the direct opposite of what you're saying

YukoandHiro · 10/06/2023 19:48

Keeping up with the thread... the thing is you may not know until you're weaning if you're over reacting or imagining things. I had certainly convinced myself there was nothing wrong then we introduced weetabix with formula on and within three days her skin was peeling off. Came off diary and egg and nuts immediately tests showed egg and cmpa. By 9 months she reacted to milk with hives on contact. Still allergic now at age 6 but can tolerate baked (up to pancakes)

Alloveragain3 · 10/06/2023 19:45

There's no clear answer as the medical professionals can't agree. They simply don't have the data.

My son had (and has) severe allergies, including to milk.

I did exclude dairy when he was very small, as it seemed to help his eczema and reflux. However, I reintroduced it into my diet when he was 18 months and still breastfeeding, with no issue.

Dr Adam Fox (a prominent UK allergist) has come out and said most mums shouldn't exclude it from their diet, as it only passes through the milk in tiny amounts. However, he says if the baby's symptoms can't be controlled medically, mum should then try an exclusion diet.

Runninghappy · 10/06/2023 19:43

My baby (now a teenager) was very unhappy, cried constantly, mucusy poos, eczema and ended up in hospital twice after trying a mouthful of formula. I was advised to breastfeed but no one mentioned cutting out dairy and I don’t know why, but I didn’t realise how much got through to her. As soon as we switched to neocate at 18 months old, she totally changed and life began for us both. I absolutely would cut it out and see if the eczema and poo improve.

My daughter is now 14, has never been able to even try the milk ladder and has had to use her epipen twice in the last couple of years due to accidental exposure to milk. It’s very sad and allergies aren’t well understood.

milkinmum · 10/06/2023 19:40

Chasingadvice · 10/06/2023 19:29

Don't be selfish.

How am I being selfish?! When I first suspected a dairy allergy I instantly cut it out for two weeks before being told by a consultant to re-introduce as it wouldn't be the cause. I've since continued to chase it up with my GP and health visitor because I've had a niggling feeling somethings still up and I didn't want him to be fobbed off. I'm literally only thinking about not cutting dairy out because one consultant suggested this way he's less likely to end up without a lifelong dairy allergy. I literally can't see what's selfish, all I am thinking about is him, nothing is to do with myself?

OP posts:
Chasingadvice · 10/06/2023 19:29

Don't be selfish.

CurlyTandtheTangles · 10/06/2023 19:28

Often with CMP and lactose it's causing upset in the gut and can lead to severe ulcers and stomach bleeding.
From our experience I'd be tempted to stop all dairy for a couple of months and if re-introducing it try dairy in baked/cooked products rather than 'raw'.

Mars27 · 10/06/2023 19:21

@Ilovetea42 A restrictive diet does not affect your milk supply. I went full vegan from 4 months until 9 months (when I stop breastfeeding) and still had milk for England. The only thing that can affect your supply is if you're dehydrated.

@Begonias oh god, that is horrible, people who think they know best. But there's a good chance your DD had an allergy and not intolerance. It's very hard to distinguish one from the other because symptoms are basically the same but you can tell by the intensity of the symptoms.

@milkinmum Forgot to say that not every reaction is instant like an anaphylactic shock. Most babies with food allergies will have a delayed reaction. Anaphylactic shock is rare in babies.

Mars27 · 10/06/2023 19:05

milkinmum · 10/06/2023 18:44

He's had a few bottles of kendamil, never drank more than a few ounces and he hasn't had an instant reaction. I've been suspicious his eczema is slightly more red the day after. I really don't know if I'm over analysing or if something is wrong. Annoyingly I cut dairy out for two weeks a few months ago only for the consultant at the time to say it's impossible for him to be allergic through breastmilk so I resumed a normal diet. Wish I'd stuck at it now!

Consultant was talking out of his bumhole and it makes me so angry! Of course the baby won't be allergic to your breast milk, he will be allergic to whatever you ate, which in turn it will be passed onto to your baby via breast milk. I don't know if you're here in the UK but if it close to you I'd ask to be referred to one the following clinics: Evelina's, King's or Addenbrookes. The ignorance when it comes to allergy is absolutely staggering, GPS don't have a clue and even paediatricians don't know much about it since it's still a very underfunded field of study. Not least people who think allergy is just someone being fussy or picky.

rose88xx · 10/06/2023 18:57

FWIW my baby always had runny mucusy poos, all sorts of colours. A paediatrician told me there was nothing to worry about if he didn’t seem in discomfort. As a PP said it can be due to fast letdown and oversupply. I also wondered about dairy and other allergies at the time.

Now he’s on more solids (and BF) he eats everything with no sign of allergy and does normal solid poos!

milkinmum · 10/06/2023 18:44

He's had a few bottles of kendamil, never drank more than a few ounces and he hasn't had an instant reaction. I've been suspicious his eczema is slightly more red the day after. I really don't know if I'm over analysing or if something is wrong. Annoyingly I cut dairy out for two weeks a few months ago only for the consultant at the time to say it's impossible for him to be allergic through breastmilk so I resumed a normal diet. Wish I'd stuck at it now!

OP posts:
Begonias · 10/06/2023 17:58

My eldest has lactose intolerance and we found out the hard way. At hospital I breastfed her and she was fine came home and MIL was adamant on giving her formula which I begrudgingly gave in to. That first night of formula feeding was like the scenes out of the exorcist. Poor DD was throwing up had diarrhoea constantly, all night. So I did the sensible thing and told husband to take her to his mum as she insisted on formula(we lived with his mum at the time).
Following morning took DD to the GP and was told she had lactose intolerance. So she was breastfed which meant I had to eliminate dairy from my diet. Even me having milk in tea would set her off. It was tough but we found alternatives to dairy.

batsandeggs · 10/06/2023 17:10

I’d exclude for a period to see if it improves. If it does then you can confirm your suspicions and reintroduce dairy if you feel he’s comfortable and it’s manageable.

I suggest this because it will probably help to know in advance when he starts weaning if dairy is an issue, particularly if he starts to get more uncomfortable at that stage. It saves you the bother of then eliminating and reintroducing (to confirm) at a later stage, and when it might be more uncomfortable for him. You can just eliminate right away.

My son has a dairy allergy and we had an extremely difficult time getting our GP to take me seriously. Thinks took a significantly more difficult turn when he started weaning and having confirmed while breastfeeding I was able to fully explain to GP, eliminate right away and get referred to dietician.

chilliplant634 · 10/06/2023 16:59

But OP's baby is gaining weight well, is happy and thriving. He feeds and sleeps well. I'm not sure it warrants OP excluding dairy. I personally would be more concerned about the eczma especially if baby needs ointments and things for it.
I'm not sure how old the baby is or whether he is on solids or not? I would be more cautious to see how he reacts to actual dairy when he ingests it directly himself, as it will be much stronger than what comes through breastmilk.

Doctors do give differing advice, its partly down to how they have assessed the situation and applying their clinical judgement. Similarly, there aren't always hard and fast answers with parenting and OP will have to make the judgement on what route she wants to take.

YukoandHiro · 10/06/2023 16:21

Mars27 · 10/06/2023 15:31

But allergy comes in different ways OP. Sometimes it's just mild eczema and sometimes it's a whole variety of symptoms.

Even if it's just mild eczema and funny poos that doesn't mean it's not worth doing the whole food exclusion diet. Runny mucous poo is a sign that his guts are hurt. My DS had those poos and I thought it was normal till the day I saw blood in his nappy.

Food exclusion diet is a pain the arse but it's the only way you'll know for sure. Good luck

Yes exactly this - OP you need to do it so you can work out exactly what's going on

YukoandHiro · 10/06/2023 16:20

DisquietintheRanks · 10/06/2023 15:44

Absolutely. As long as your baby isn't actively dying, what's a bit of gut damage? Imflammed, damaged intestines are good for babies and - if you are lucky - can lead to more exciting allergies later on.

Oh piss off.

Multiple allergy parent twice over here.

Don't you remember what it's like at the beginning. How you have no idea what you're doing and second guess everything? And you never get good consistent advice from all the professionals involved until you get to the full paediatric allergy referral which so many kids with milder CMPA never get.

There's absolutely no need to be like this.

This fucking site.