Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how to get over inheritance resentment?

286 replies

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 07:43

I know this is a very sticky subject on this board.

I really try and don't want to care, but all around me there are people who are inheriting large sums of money through inheritance, allowing them to live comfortably and do things that people who never inherit would never be able to do.

A lot of these people have inherited by default from aunts or uncles who don't have children, rather than through their parents. Sometimes from people they didn't even bother with when they were alive, so it seems crass they are profiting from their death.

I will likely never inherit a dime, and I have made my peace with that, it's only money at the end of the day and we can't take it with us. We will all end up in the morgue no matter how much is in our bank accounts. It is better to have your loved ones living than dead to give you an inheritance. But lots of my peers are relying on inheritance to fund their retirement / pay off their homes which puts a bit of panic in me as I will be funding this myself somehow. I sometimes think I would rather die before retirement as I don't think I'll be able to fund it.

I think inheritance creates a very unequal society as poor people will likely have nothing to leave, making the gap between rich and poor even wider.

OP posts:
Robinni · 10/06/2023 10:18

I think you’re directing your energy in the wrong direction OP.

Rather than be resentful of others with family who have worked hard and are entitled to leave it to whomever they please….

You could have developed a career for yourself and made your own money.

Unless you have disability of some description, in which case your position is more difficult.

The best way to approach this is to try and accept one’s lot in life and adjust accordingly to meet your goals.

If you want a good pension and to pay off mortgage there are ways to do this without inheritance; many who inherit still have success/wealth in their own right.

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 10:16

@WomblingTree86 I think it depends on age and generation. I know many millennials under 40 or so who have openly said they are relying on inheritance to buy a house.

And then there are parents who gift their children a deposit after they have inherited, so the children have benefited from the inheritance indirectly.

OP posts:
Moraxella · 10/06/2023 10:15

@Changes17 BTL has been disincentivised - now market rents are through the roof as supply dwindling

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 10/06/2023 10:11

Last comment wasn't meant to be snarky at anyone who does inherit BTW. Life is full of difference. I don't think it's healthy or productive to focus on what you don't have. Everyone's human and a bit of envy is normal, but ultimately you have to pull your big girl pants up and get on with it. I'm a big believer in concentrating on what you do have and crucially, what you can do (if possible) to change your situation if you are unhappy with it.

Changes17 · 10/06/2023 10:11

Housing does need to cost less. We shouldn’t be in the position where people have to inherit to be able to buy a house.
I’d support rent controls, so that people can have secure tenancies for a reasonable amount. That would reduce the incentive to buy to let - and reduce house prices, though they are coming down as a result of interest rates rising.

WomblingTree86 · 10/06/2023 10:10

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 09:58

Yes I think the main issue is housing. It is very hard to get on the housing ladder and gather a deposit unless you receive money from family in the form of a gift, or inheritance. If housing was affordable for people from earning a wage without having to receive help, things would be much more equal.

I'm not sure many people are using inheritance to get on the housing ladder. Most people who inherit are probably middle-aged and already on it if they are ever going to be. I'm in my late 50s and my parents are still alive (thankfully) and they may well need care at some point so they might not have much money left anyway.

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 10/06/2023 10:08

I have had one inheritance - £1000 left to me by one of my grandparents a few years ago. The remaining GPs all predeceased her. My DM had nothing except debts - I paid for her funeral. My DF also has substantial debts and I provide him with regular financial support.

I have friends who have been able to pay off mortgages, or retire earlier than planned, because of inheritances (often property-based in the SE). But there is no property for me or my sibs to inherit, so we won't be getting anything because there is nothing to offer. I'm fine with it. I've been making my own way in life since I left home aged 18. I choose to think about the fact that I've worked hard and been able to get myself to a position where I can help my family, rather than waiting for them to die so they can help me.

user1469908585 · 10/06/2023 10:07

Nothing in life is ‘Fair’ looks, intelligence, health, the country, parents and time you are born in is complete chance. You might be lucky, you might not!

It has been a conscious decision for us to have two children so that we are financially comfortable and one day they will have a healthy inheritance.

WickedSerious · 10/06/2023 10:07

Ylvamoon · 10/06/2023 08:15

Why don't you start searching for that rich aunt, uncle or other childless rich relatives in your family?
You can then plan for that all important inheritance...

This is exactly what my NDN is doing,it's fascinating to watch and the person in question isn't even related to him.

RoxyMuzak · 10/06/2023 10:02

I had an elderly uncle who became a widower at age 60. About five years later he met a lovely woman and told his kids he planned to marry her. They were outraged! She was, according to them, trying to get her 'her hooks' into him, and get her hands on what was, they felt, by rights 'our house when he's gone'. Another thing that they didn't like about her was... that she was a Catholic! They had never been in a C of E church in their lives except for weddings, 'Christenings', and funerals. I said I hoped he would do what was right for him and be happy, and got a mouthful from one of them.

Xrays · 10/06/2023 10:01

The thing is where do you draw the line? Should we all live in some communist type state where everyone is given the same basic salary and a state / council house fully funded by the state to live in so everyone has the same? 🤷‍♀️

I come from a long line of people inheriting. It means I was mortgage free at 36 and don’t have to work. But, I’m disabled and actually day to day we have a fairly low income. We’re certainly not the uber rich type. But yes we’re a lot more comfortable than most in that we don’t have housing costs. And unless something happens to me as I get older than means I’ll have to pay for my own care then dd and Ds will inherit from me and the cycle will continue. It’s just the way our family works and always has done.

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 09:58

kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 09:48

Inheritance is supporting a very unequal society and propping up house prices - it's how most ( that's not all ) people get on the housing ladder

I still think it's a opportunities to raise taxes , enable a more equal meritocracy, without directly harming the people who worked for their money

That said - what a small inheritance could do for me personally would be lovely

Yes I think the main issue is housing. It is very hard to get on the housing ladder and gather a deposit unless you receive money from family in the form of a gift, or inheritance. If housing was affordable for people from earning a wage without having to receive help, things would be much more equal.

OP posts:
emmylousings · 10/06/2023 09:53

Aslanplustwo · 10/06/2023 08:15

What the hell is wrong with everyone at the moment?? So many posts about non issues. Life isn't fair OP, maybe it's time you learned that and just got on with your own life instead of being jealous of others.

It's not a non-issue (like how many times you change sheets). As others have pointed out, it perpetuates economic inequality. And can be challenging emotionally if your on the wrong side of it. We all know life isn't fair...does that mean never discuss any aspects of unfairness? Daft comment.

5128gap · 10/06/2023 09:53

SoupDragon · 10/06/2023 09:09

You sound very bitter and with a "if i can't have it, it's wrong!" attitude.

I'd rather have my parents back than any of the inheritance. No amount of money would make that loss better.

People who don't get an inheritance have to deal with the loss of their parents too. Its not like grief is reserved for beneficiaries of wills. I'm sure there's many people who would forego inheritance to have their loved one, but that's not on the table. Its lose them with an inheritance or lose them without. And I can assure you that having the money not to worry about funeral costs or lost income for any caring you did, and having some peace of mind about your own financial future is a lot easier than not.

thecatsthecats · 10/06/2023 09:50

katmarie · 10/06/2023 07:54

I'm not likely to inherit anything from my parents, they have nothing to leave. All my aunts and uncles have their own children. So I'm probably never going to receive any kind of substantial bequest. But I've known that all my life. So I started paying into a pension as soon as I started work at 18, and I've made all my financial decisions based on the knowledge that it's me paying for it. Not sure what else you can do really. Being resentful over something that absolutely isn't going to change seems like a waste of energy.

I can reasonably guess that I'll be in receipt of at least three significant inheritances (not "retire now" money but "put myself in the position to retire at 55" money.

I have still acted as you have done - because that's what the people I will probably inherit from have done!

Most of the people I know with generational wealth are the same. They're not rich as croesus - they've just been cautious with assets.

MakeItRain · 10/06/2023 09:48

I get what you're saying. I inherited from a parent. Not a massive amount in the grand scheme of things, but enough to hugely help towards a small house and leave me with an affordable mortgage. I will be forever grateful and cannot imagine the position I'd be in without it (divorced with young children when I bought). I look at today's mortgages and rents and I don't know how people manage. I know this doesn't help you, but I completely understand your frustration and resentment and know I would feel the same. We don't have lots left over for holidays/many material things these days and sometimes I get envious of people with huge wealth. Money can't buy happiness or health though, and in the end you have to take pleasure in things like the company of friends and family, walks in lovely places, growing plants etc!

Sothisisitthen · 10/06/2023 09:48

This is all kinds of weird. My parents need financial support rather than the other way around. We won’t get a dime either. It is what it is.

Hols8 · 10/06/2023 09:48

The way I see it is that there are worse inequalities in the world than me not inheriting and my friends inheriting. It’s just life. So I just think carefully about retirement and savings and have done since the day I started working.

I also know more than a couple of people who also inherited from childless great aunts and things so it’s not unheard of, to those doubting the OP. It was (middle class) friends at university. Large sums too in some cases - tens of thousands - which they could even access at that age and spent, in part, on things like travelling around the world. I would have loved to have gone to just one of the countries as a student/graduate.

Despite seeing this difference when still fairly young, I don’t think about inheritance (in the same way I’m not relying on state pension - God knows how old I’ll be when I get my pension and what it’ll be). Mainly because for me to inherit (if I even do - caring fees are high!), it’d mean life without my both parents which I don’t want to think about. I come from a WC/poor family so that’s the only way I’d possibly inherit. I know some people though who see inheritance as a justification for getting a bigger mortgage or not really worrying about savings. I could never take such a gamble personally.

kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 09:48

Inheritance is supporting a very unequal society and propping up house prices - it's how most ( that's not all ) people get on the housing ladder

I still think it's a opportunities to raise taxes , enable a more equal meritocracy, without directly harming the people who worked for their money

That said - what a small inheritance could do for me personally would be lovely

HerbsandSpices · 10/06/2023 09:47

One thing I'm against is elderly people with huge wealth not using that wealth to fund their care when they get older. Yes, maybe exclude the family home - with a limit. There is no need to be sitting in a huge expensive house while the state picks up the cost. Yes, they have worked hard for it (maybe) but having the means to fund your care should be one of the benefits of having worked hard and amassed wealth. If they have to sell the house to fund it, sell the house. Don't hold onto it just to leave an unearned inheritance to your children.

WheresSpring · 10/06/2023 09:47

Thing is, inheritance tax is usually only paid by the less/mid wealthy. Anyone with serious money to leave has usually been employing a specialist tax solicitor for years to make sure they/their heirs avoid paying. I have a good friend who makes a very very good living from this. That’s the rub, the super wealthy usually don’t pay! Eg, to protect farmers from losing their family farm you can pass agricultural land down with no tax - so they just buy enormous estates and hand these on….

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 09:45

@Testina it won't... I have replied upthread about where all my father's money goes.

OP posts:
JusthereforXmas · 10/06/2023 09:45

That's life.

My mam worked really, really hard (career woman who sacrificed to fight her way up) and unfortunately died very young (before retirement age) and as such I got over 100k in her will from shares, pension, savings etc... (the physical estate house, furniture, car etc... went to her husband). My mam prioritized financial security and dedicated her life to securing it. I grew up just me and my mam with no family really and wished I had had a big family. I would honestly rather have my mam (my whole family) back than the money.

My friends mam was lovely too. She unfortunately died a few years ago too and my friend inherited nothing. Friends mam didn't prioritise money at all but prioritized 'community'. Her mam never 'officially worked' (although she took in and cared for dozens of kids the system gave up on with no financial help from the care system) and she lived in a council house so there was nothing to inherit. My friend now has a MASSIVE family (not all blood) who support each other through these years since the loss but no one received inheritance.

Good people don't always get 'rewarded' with money but thats not the people who dos fault. That doesn't mean they didn't get 'anything' though they likely do realise they inherited something other than finance from the loved ones lifestyle.

I don't know anyone who has ever inherited from aunts/uncles/grandparents in real life... that seems to just be a mythical forum thing.

Testina · 10/06/2023 09:43

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 08:05

"You certainly know some really awful people."

Maybe but money brings out a really ugly side in a lot of people. I have even seen this with my own father and his elderly childless aunt. He has persuaded her to cut everyone else out of her Will bar him, because he has made himself invaluable to her. She knows he is after her money but she is so dependent on him now.

Uh?
So your dad is practically extorting money from his aunt, and then… what are you going to do if/when some of that residual wealth passes on to you?

5128gap · 10/06/2023 09:42

I completely agree OP. Its a hard pill to swallow when you realise that no matter how hard you work, however much you sacrifice, you will have never enjoy the benefits some others recieve, unearned and undeserved. However, unfortunately life does not deal us a fair hand in any aspect really, health, relationships, success, so all you can do is play your own cards the best you can. Don't compare your life with other people, only with distance travelled yourself. Happiness and satisfaction comes in many forms, hand outs being just one of them. Focus on the others, value the deeper satisfaction of everything you do achieve being the result of your own efforts, and be proud of that.