Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how to get over inheritance resentment?

286 replies

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 07:43

I know this is a very sticky subject on this board.

I really try and don't want to care, but all around me there are people who are inheriting large sums of money through inheritance, allowing them to live comfortably and do things that people who never inherit would never be able to do.

A lot of these people have inherited by default from aunts or uncles who don't have children, rather than through their parents. Sometimes from people they didn't even bother with when they were alive, so it seems crass they are profiting from their death.

I will likely never inherit a dime, and I have made my peace with that, it's only money at the end of the day and we can't take it with us. We will all end up in the morgue no matter how much is in our bank accounts. It is better to have your loved ones living than dead to give you an inheritance. But lots of my peers are relying on inheritance to fund their retirement / pay off their homes which puts a bit of panic in me as I will be funding this myself somehow. I sometimes think I would rather die before retirement as I don't think I'll be able to fund it.

I think inheritance creates a very unequal society as poor people will likely have nothing to leave, making the gap between rich and poor even wider.

OP posts:
HerbsandSpices · 10/06/2023 11:28

Dervel · 10/06/2023 11:26

Approximately 70% of wealthy families lose their wealth by the next generation, with 90% losing it the generation after that. The significant majority of those who have wealth today earned it. However it’s not popular to actually look at the data, as there is a lot of desire like you OP have demonstrated to sit in resentment, and a lot of politicians can capitalise upon this resentment as a vote winner. This it perpetuates.

I’d personally like to see a better social safety net, but that would require ransacking the coffers of everyone more, including you OP. Even if you ransacked the wealth of the entire 1% (or even 10% for that matter), you may be able to fund a portion of some social programs, but not all of them and not comprehensively. Suddenly people get a lot less socialist when it involves their own hard earned money.

Furthermore if you were to ransack all inheritance at 100% the very wealthy would suddenly feel like emigrating to countries like Australia or New Zealand where inheritance tax sits at 0%. The world has never been fair. Some people are born more intelligent than others, better looking, taller, better genetic health. No political theory or philosophy currently exists to level the playing field.

I would personally be willing to pay more tax for a fairer and more equitable social system in the areas of health and educational opportunities, in particular.

Hopingforagreatescape · 10/06/2023 11:28

BorgQueen · 10/06/2023 11:21

You have no idea how much an inheritance can help.
We inherited <£100k a couple of years ago.
It enabled us to give £25k to DD that she put towards a house deposit, it also enabled DH to give up a well paid stressful career involving 12 hour days and nights that he’d grown to hate - he took almost a year off and paid £10k to retrain so he could go self employed. He’s been working for himself for the last 8 months and is a different person. He now works around 25-30 hours a week, drives around in his little van to peoples’ homes, services/repairs their boilers and gets given a cup of tea for his trouble.
That money transformed our lives and DD’s, we’ve still got £30k squirelled away and that security is lovely, we’d never had much in the way of savings before.
So in my eyes YABVVU

That's exactly what the OP is saying, surely. You've had an inheritance, which has been a massive help. I too have friends who have had large inheritances recently and been able to retire early from jobs they hate and/or set up their own businesses.

Dervel · 10/06/2023 11:26

Approximately 70% of wealthy families lose their wealth by the next generation, with 90% losing it the generation after that. The significant majority of those who have wealth today earned it. However it’s not popular to actually look at the data, as there is a lot of desire like you OP have demonstrated to sit in resentment, and a lot of politicians can capitalise upon this resentment as a vote winner. This it perpetuates.

I’d personally like to see a better social safety net, but that would require ransacking the coffers of everyone more, including you OP. Even if you ransacked the wealth of the entire 1% (or even 10% for that matter), you may be able to fund a portion of some social programs, but not all of them and not comprehensively. Suddenly people get a lot less socialist when it involves their own hard earned money.

Furthermore if you were to ransack all inheritance at 100% the very wealthy would suddenly feel like emigrating to countries like Australia or New Zealand where inheritance tax sits at 0%. The world has never been fair. Some people are born more intelligent than others, better looking, taller, better genetic health. No political theory or philosophy currently exists to level the playing field.

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 11:25

BorgQueen · 10/06/2023 11:21

You have no idea how much an inheritance can help.
We inherited <£100k a couple of years ago.
It enabled us to give £25k to DD that she put towards a house deposit, it also enabled DH to give up a well paid stressful career involving 12 hour days and nights that he’d grown to hate - he took almost a year off and paid £10k to retrain so he could go self employed. He’s been working for himself for the last 8 months and is a different person. He now works around 25-30 hours a week, drives around in his little van to peoples’ homes, services/repairs their boilers and gets given a cup of tea for his trouble.
That money transformed our lives and DD’s, we’ve still got £30k squirelled away and that security is lovely, we’d never had much in the way of savings before.
So in my eyes YABVVU

Erm, you have actually proven my point.

OP posts:
kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 11:23

But Borg - you benefitted but wouldn't it be better if we had a society where no one had to rely on that money to have a decent job and a home ? Why should only those with inherited wealth have that luck ?

kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 11:22

Anyone who suggests that anyone who fails to make themselves wealthy has somehow failed personally is wrong and pretty naive . And usually very privileged and unable to recognise that privilege

It's not your fault
Life is unfair however and we need to make the best of it
Whilst trying to change the world to make it better also , which means identifying things like inheritance which propagate none merit based inequality

BorgQueen · 10/06/2023 11:21

You have no idea how much an inheritance can help.
We inherited <£100k a couple of years ago.
It enabled us to give £25k to DD that she put towards a house deposit, it also enabled DH to give up a well paid stressful career involving 12 hour days and nights that he’d grown to hate - he took almost a year off and paid £10k to retrain so he could go self employed. He’s been working for himself for the last 8 months and is a different person. He now works around 25-30 hours a week, drives around in his little van to peoples’ homes, services/repairs their boilers and gets given a cup of tea for his trouble.
That money transformed our lives and DD’s, we’ve still got £30k squirelled away and that security is lovely, we’d never had much in the way of savings before.
So in my eyes YABVVU

NashvilleQueen · 10/06/2023 11:19

You need to get past it I am afraid. Some people have rich relatives and some don't. I didn't so I got what was in my mums bank account when she died. She didn't own her own home. Thankfully I have a great job and pension so I don't need a windfall.

Having said that those who live their lives in the expectation that they'll inherit a large sum may end up disappointed because (a) the family member might live well into their 90s and so it's a long old wait or (b) need full time care which is ludicrously expensive. Better to be able to fund yourself in my book.

TizerorFizz · 10/06/2023 11:19

You cannot rely on anyone else! You have to do it for yourself. When only the very rich had property, most people got £0 from their parents. Most people were dead before 70 years old. House buying and private pensions is a relatively modern thing for ordinary people. Most, going back a couple of generations were poor and owned nothing. So house ownership makes a difference. I know some people got a council house and kept paying rent. Others took the gamble and bought property with the expense of maintaining it. How people felt about property was the main thing that gave modern day wealth. Or starting a successful company.

So OP: women are doing it for themselves! Time to start!

Gowlett · 10/06/2023 11:18

Most of my friends have had help from the Bank of Mum & Dad. Then inheritance from their parents / relatives. And they’re still not happy…

Fisharejumping · 10/06/2023 11:18

Focus on the things you do have: health (hopefully); you are alive; you are in a nice marriage, have nice friends.

ultimately, the things that matter don’t cost a penny. I have two close friends who are suddenly incapacitated; they have become disabled overnight. Makes you realise that your mind, health and life are worth billions, are beyond value.

I once went to a billionaire’s house. They Had all this original art - Picasso’s, classical artists. Even an Ancient Greek bust. But it seemed so odd to see them in a domestic setting. I go to museums where the art is beautifully displayed. They had a cinema room and gym. I have all these things too - although I share them with the rest of the public and am happy to do so because I love people watching and feeling part of a community.

And the billionaire was so odd. Having so much money distances you from others. I know that you don’t want this level of wealth OP and we could all do with a little more to make our lives that bit smoother, but it is what it is.

OP, perhaps you should ingratiate yourself with these rich friends and who knows they might leave you something in their will.

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 11:16

OutdoorPillow · 10/06/2023 11:09

I think you need to be mad at your own shortcomings here, OP.

If you wish to be wealthy and haven’t been able to achieve it through your own hard work or luck, that’s on you.

You need to learn to paddle your own canoe.

Do you really think it's that easy?

Maybe take a look at the average wage these days versus the average rent cost and typical mortgage payments.

Even if you earn a good wage over £35k or so, you won't have much left over if you are paying rent, bills etc by yourself, let alone able to afford a deposit.

OP posts:
Kpo58 · 10/06/2023 11:16

Even if we abolished inheritance tomorrow, it won't make the world a fairer place. All that will happen is that the rich will give their children money much earlier or in different ways, more money will leave the country as people enjoy more foreign holidays (as why should the government get hold of my hard earned cash?) and some people will work less as what's the point of working more if the kids will see no benefit from it?

Andanotherone01 · 10/06/2023 11:12

I will likely never inherit a dime, and I have made my peace with that,
You obviously haven’t though, have you. Comparison is the thief of joy etc.
My parent inherited absolutely nothing, yet still made a good life for themselves.

Robinni · 10/06/2023 11:12

NOTANUM · 10/06/2023 10:33

Interesting.. Most people I know see their inheritances being slashed by care/nursing home costs. It’s £5K/month folks!

I haven’t inherited anything and won’t but have always known that so am working on my own to build up a stock pile. I won’t get there as soon as others who get money from relatives, win the lottery or get shares in uniform startups. But that doesn’t matter - I’m doing okay and am healthy enough.

Generally speaking it’s about 1-2 years from the point of care being needed until death (from being a carer and a lot of involvement with nursing homes).

Say £750 a week £39k/yr for a care home place. If someone has a pension giving them about 20k a year, plus attendance allowance for care/mobility giving them £5291 (usual for care home resident). You’re looking at a deficit of about 14k, plus other costs which are minimal (clothing, hair cuts etc). They don’t spend a lot really; no point for clothes, they get wrecked.

So you might be looking at a 30k loss in inheritance over a two year period…. Which isn’t much if you are inheriting a house + cash. Also, bear in mind, most will have pension a bit over 20k, and the individual can usually be temporary resident for about a year, which means their house isn’t taken into account.

Many also sign over house much earlier or set up a limited company to avoid..

The only people who tend to be disproportionately affected are those with state pension only, who haven’t understood the system. But they don’t tend to have a lot to pass on anyway.

OutdoorPillow · 10/06/2023 11:09

I think you need to be mad at your own shortcomings here, OP.

If you wish to be wealthy and haven’t been able to achieve it through your own hard work or luck, that’s on you.

You need to learn to paddle your own canoe.

Grumpigal · 10/06/2023 11:08

I get it OP.

I don’t think it’s wrong or unreasonable to feel some level of envy towards people who are given a benefit you yourself won’t ever receive.

its not saying “no one should get an inheritance” - it’s purely just recognising that some people are fortunate to get financial assistance through sizeable inheritances where others don’t have that same experience and that does create a level of disparity especially in later life when older relatives start to pass away. That’s all. It’s totally understandable surely?

Obvs most of us would rather have our relatives here than the money but it’s possible to take the emotion out and just look at the financial benefit of an inheritance without the sentimental guilting.

Twobyfour · 10/06/2023 11:05

You have to make the best of what life throws at you.

Don’t get eaten up by bitterness, just look at Princes Harry and William. Harry is rich by anyone’s standards but he is obviously bitter at being the “spare”.

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 10/06/2023 11:04

I think it’s just one of those things that people have very little control over and can seem very unbalanced but that’s not going to change. People can leave whatever they want to whoever they want.

I don’t have any hugely wealthy relatives so don’t expect any great inheritance. Maybe a bit when my dp pass away but certainly not enough to fund retirement etc.

I can’t be jealous or resentful of people having gained through someone dying, that’s such a dark place to be. You really need to find a way to let go of these feelings, it’s not healthy to be weighed down by these sorts of feelings.

HerbsandSpices · 10/06/2023 11:01

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 10:59

I agree health is the most important thing, but even that is easier if you are wealthy...if you have money you can afford to go private, if you don't you have to rely on the NHS and wait months/years for procedures.

Wealth can buy some perks, for sure. I guess the perk of them going private is it does take some pressure off the public lists. In an ideal world we'd all have an equal shot at everything but that's not reality, so we practice contentment and make the most of what we do have.

FarmGirl78 · 10/06/2023 10:59

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 08:05

"You certainly know some really awful people."

Maybe but money brings out a really ugly side in a lot of people. I have even seen this with my own father and his elderly childless aunt. He has persuaded her to cut everyone else out of her Will bar him, because he has made himself invaluable to her. She knows he is after her money but she is so dependent on him now.

I'm confused as to whether you think she should disinherit him because he's made himself invaluable to her because of her wealth, or that she made a good choice to disinherit all the other relatives who haven't bothered her. You say you'd disinherit niblings who you weren't close to, but seem to be criticising her for doing the same? Would you happier if she disinherited everyone and left it to the dogs home? If her fortune goes to your Dad, who you don't seem to have a high option of, I assume you'll be refusing anything that he subsequently leaves to you?

HerbsandSpices · 10/06/2023 10:59

PauliesWalnuts · 10/06/2023 10:58

One thing to remember is that one in five women born in the 70’s will have no children. So, the number of people leaving inheritances to people who aren’t their children will increase, if it’s not spent on care in later life. I am not leaving my estate to distant cousins who I don’t even have a current address for, so it’s going to my friends children and a smaller amount to my friends, who have embraced me into their families because I don’t have anyone. My instructions are that for those under 50, the money is to be used appropriately, whilst over 50’s (my friends) are to use it inappropriately 😁

Love it :-)

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 10:59

I agree health is the most important thing, but even that is easier if you are wealthy...if you have money you can afford to go private, if you don't you have to rely on the NHS and wait months/years for procedures.

OP posts:
PauliesWalnuts · 10/06/2023 10:58

One thing to remember is that one in five women born in the 70’s will have no children. So, the number of people leaving inheritances to people who aren’t their children will increase, if it’s not spent on care in later life. I am not leaving my estate to distant cousins who I don’t even have a current address for, so it’s going to my friends children and a smaller amount to my friends, who have embraced me into their families because I don’t have anyone. My instructions are that for those under 50, the money is to be used appropriately, whilst over 50’s (my friends) are to use it inappropriately 😁

HerbsandSpices · 10/06/2023 10:57

WomblingTree86 · 10/06/2023 10:49

I obviously didn't mean 20 something year old as they aren't a previous generation! I meant boomers and generation X, and maybe the pre war generation. I bought my first house in the 90s and certainly did not have to scrimp and save for years to get a deposit.

I'm late Gen X, we bought our first extremely humble home in the mid-90s, and it was hard work to get there. We literally started with nothing and had to work for every cent. It was probably quite an embarassing home for quality, but it was ours and it was a very happy home. We knew we would never buy a home in our city of origin so we moved to another city where homes were cheaper.

You were talking about millennials needing an inheritance to buy a house. I know millennials who have achieved their first home with no help with deposits and the like. Of course it's not easy, and I do think it's harder, but possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread