Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how to get over inheritance resentment?

286 replies

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 07:43

I know this is a very sticky subject on this board.

I really try and don't want to care, but all around me there are people who are inheriting large sums of money through inheritance, allowing them to live comfortably and do things that people who never inherit would never be able to do.

A lot of these people have inherited by default from aunts or uncles who don't have children, rather than through their parents. Sometimes from people they didn't even bother with when they were alive, so it seems crass they are profiting from their death.

I will likely never inherit a dime, and I have made my peace with that, it's only money at the end of the day and we can't take it with us. We will all end up in the morgue no matter how much is in our bank accounts. It is better to have your loved ones living than dead to give you an inheritance. But lots of my peers are relying on inheritance to fund their retirement / pay off their homes which puts a bit of panic in me as I will be funding this myself somehow. I sometimes think I would rather die before retirement as I don't think I'll be able to fund it.

I think inheritance creates a very unequal society as poor people will likely have nothing to leave, making the gap between rich and poor even wider.

OP posts:
WomblingTree86 · 10/06/2023 19:09

7Worfs · 10/06/2023 18:08

If you are comparing a business transaction of exchanging goods/services to giving money to your children I don’t know what to tell you. 🤷‍♀️

I don't see that there is a difference in terms of being "taxed twice".

PimpMyFridge · 10/06/2023 18:53

Of course no one would turn down a bequest. Because the system is set up so that you'd have to be mad to, and one individual standing against the norm isn't going to change anything. Doesn't mean you can't wish that societywas organised differently.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 10/06/2023 18:37

catslovelife · 10/06/2023 08:05

"You certainly know some really awful people."

Maybe but money brings out a really ugly side in a lot of people. I have even seen this with my own father and his elderly childless aunt. He has persuaded her to cut everyone else out of her Will bar him, because he has made himself invaluable to her. She knows he is after her money but she is so dependent on him now.

I don’t think it’s brought out your best side, OP.

I also don’t believe you’d turn down a bequest if one unexpectedly came your way. I think you’re just pissed off that you’re not getting anything and they are.

7Worfs · 10/06/2023 18:08

WomblingTree86 · 10/06/2023 17:53

It's the “same money” if you pay a tradesman -they are still taxed on it even though you have also been taxed on it. I'm sure you wouldn't suggest that they don't pay tax because you've already paid tax. That's not how taxation works. Your children won't even have to pay inheritance tax unless you and your partner give them over a million.

If you are comparing a business transaction of exchanging goods/services to giving money to your children I don’t know what to tell you. 🤷‍♀️

WomblingTree86 · 10/06/2023 17:53

7Worfs · 10/06/2023 13:35

Piffle. It’s the same money taxed all over, and let’s pretend children have nothing to do with their parents, yeah? Back in the real world, most people push themselves really hard and make sacrifices, so that their children don’t have to.

If IHT becomes a threat to me, I’ll make sure to transfer the money to my children way earlier, send the money abroad, and just work way, way less. Which will impact the current tax I’m paying.

It's the “same money” if you pay a tradesman -they are still taxed on it even though you have also been taxed on it. I'm sure you wouldn't suggest that they don't pay tax because you've already paid tax. That's not how taxation works. Your children won't even have to pay inheritance tax unless you and your partner give them over a million.

SquaresandStarlings · 10/06/2023 16:25

There's been a lot about this in the press recently, particularly in the US - it's being predicted that western society is going to become divided into two stratas very soon: comfortable home-owners who inherited and a much poorer strata who haven't, and who will never be able to buy a home.

kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 16:03

Taxes need to be shared fairly yes

Use your vote and make it count

StarchySturgess1 · 10/06/2023 16:00

You’re right - that’s why inheritance tax is so important to share the wealth.

Share it with whom? Tory MP's and their mates? Pull the other one. IHT specifically isn't benefitting anyone in need.

MintJulia · 10/06/2023 15:51

Abolishing inheritance allowances would simply change people's tactics. I'm not sure it would lead to a more equal society.

At the moment, I intend to downsize in retirement to as close to the IHT limit as possible and leave everything I can, to my ds.

If there was no inheritance tax allowance, I would, instead, spend my money on things that will reduce my ds' overheads while I am alive, so he can pay off his mortgage sooner. Or pay for my (as yet nonexistent) grandchild's school fees.

Either would give me pleasure and since I've earned my money and paid tax on it already, I would be entitled to spend it how I wish. But I don't see how it would make life more equal.

kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 15:47

Grief can't people understand the difference between what happens at a society level and what happens to an individual?

Just because you can chew your toes doesn't mean it's normal and everyone else can. Similar jus because you know a person whose luck bucked the trend doesn't mean the overall trend isn't real and having a dominant effect on people's lives

JusthereforXmas · 10/06/2023 14:50

kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 13:46

People handing over huge inheritance to their children got it in most cases off the back of rising house prices, not their uniquely hard work

Rising house prices triggered by the great council house sell off, which now means the children of those who profited can buy homes and those that would need social housing get the absolute dregs of homes with the added benefit of paying rent to people who want to pay the mortgage on their property portfolios

It's a selfish individualistic society that benefits no one on the long run - pay as you go for health and education and private estates with private roads and private police if you have the money and eat the leftovers if you don't

No they didn't... My mam finally got fortunate enough to buy her house (after decades of hard work) at peak bubble its worth LESS now than she paid 20 years ago.

Whatnextcrazyworld · 10/06/2023 14:32

I believe there have often been murmurings about reforming IHT but not abolishing it.

Life isn't "fair". You could give a dozen people in similar circumstances an inheritance of several hundred thousand pounds and they would all deal with it differently: some would spend, spend, spend and end up not passing on a penny to anyone or any charity; others would invest it, quietly helping family and friends in need along the way; others would use what they needed and leave the remainder in inheritance to others. So many options - who is to say which is right and wrong? I'd rather live in this country and inherit nothing than, by accident of birth, be born in many other places in the world!

Out of interest, what's you're opinion of lottery winners who end up as (multi) millionaires - not through hard work and financial planning but through pure luck? Not a penny of that money goes in tax in their lifetime and, if they don't spend it all, what do you think happens to it when they die? Should they give it back to the lottery?

RoxyMuzak · 10/06/2023 14:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

7Worfs · 10/06/2023 13:51

No, house prices exploded when UK’s net migration started to be in the hundreds of thousands annually.

kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 13:46

People handing over huge inheritance to their children got it in most cases off the back of rising house prices, not their uniquely hard work

Rising house prices triggered by the great council house sell off, which now means the children of those who profited can buy homes and those that would need social housing get the absolute dregs of homes with the added benefit of paying rent to people who want to pay the mortgage on their property portfolios

It's a selfish individualistic society that benefits no one on the long run - pay as you go for health and education and private estates with private roads and private police if you have the money and eat the leftovers if you don't

7Worfs · 10/06/2023 13:35

WomblingTree86 · 10/06/2023 13:26

They aren't going to tax you even more. If you are dead the money will no longer be yours. They will be taxing the receiver who has neither earned it or paid tax on it yet.

Piffle. It’s the same money taxed all over, and let’s pretend children have nothing to do with their parents, yeah? Back in the real world, most people push themselves really hard and make sacrifices, so that their children don’t have to.

If IHT becomes a threat to me, I’ll make sure to transfer the money to my children way earlier, send the money abroad, and just work way, way less. Which will impact the current tax I’m paying.

scoobydoo1971 · 10/06/2023 13:28

My parents worked very hard to turn their lives around from rags to riches. They made sacrifices, wise financial plans and a little bit of risk taking that grew a successful business. In their later years, I left my career to move near them, and to care for my father for a few years before his death, helped out with the family business and then over ten years of care for my mother. When they died they decided who got their money, and rightfully so as they worked hard, paid taxes and lived productive lives providing jobs and services to others. I didn't change my financial behaviour because of the expectation of inheriting money. If I had inherited nothing, I would still be comparatively well-off from using the advice and skills handed down from them to acquire my own assets. I studied hard in my field, worked when I could and bought my first flat in my 20's (a complete dump that I renovated to make enough money to buy another). I learned some wise financial planning from them in my youth, and business skills. I would gladly give the inheritance back to have them both alive and well. However, it was their wish to give their kids the assets, and my children will now benefit from that as I am in no rush to spend it all, and would feel guilty wasting it. When I die, I will want to make sure my children are provided for. It is hard out there for young people with the cost of University, housing and cost of living being as it is. When I was young, first time ownership of property was do-able on one salary, and students got grants. Tax wasn't what it is now. If inheritance tax was changed, it would encourage people to gift to their families while alive, or not bother saving so much. Not everyone will inherit money, and money cannot buy happiness. However, it does give some security and stability to those fortunate enough to benefit. If you are looking for some target for your anger, how about the British Government? They are utterly disengaged with the needs of the population, especially after the pandemic, scandals, cost of living crisis etc.

WomblingTree86 · 10/06/2023 13:26

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 10/06/2023 13:04

My husband and I both left school at 16, had no financial help from anyone, worked for many years, took risks, made sacrifices and have accumulated what most would consider substantial wealth. Isn’t that social mobility?
We enjoy a very comfortable early retirement. We have Already paid massive amounts of tax, when we die our estate will be subject to further massive taxes. It’s our money, we made it and want to leave it to our children. How can you justify taxing us even more?

They aren't going to tax you even more. If you are dead the money will no longer be yours. They will be taxing the receiver who has neither earned it or paid tax on it yet.

kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 13:25

Yes some people can work hard and improve their lot

But if you look across society as a whole the percentage of poor people who move up the wealth ranks is much lower now than in the 50s to 70's.

Because it's been made harder - no grammar / private school assistance for the bright kids, no university fees paid and well paying jobs more centralised in London which makes it hard for people from outside to get as they would need accommodation and can't look after family if they do move away - family who are more likely to need support if they are in the poorer regions of the uk

comingintomyown · 10/06/2023 13:19

It’s natural to resent it a bit if those around you are getting lump sum’s through inheritance but it is what it is.
I haven’t seen your answer to the question what are you doing to improve your financial position?

TakeMe2Insanity · 10/06/2023 13:10

Try and remember “these” people have been through a bereavement and you have benefited from the death because they would have paid 40% tax on the amount which went into the public purse so yes you benefited too.

PimpMyFridge · 10/06/2023 13:09

@Lovepeaceunderstanding yup, and when you are taxed even more, where are the societal mechanisms to pass it on. Uni grants are gone. Social support, health care, the the safety net stuff to catch you if you fall out ladders to help you climb up have been dismantled. If the coffers swell from taxed inheritances that money will not appear to those at the bottom to help at all.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 10/06/2023 13:04

KnitMePurlMe · 10/06/2023 07:58

You’re right - that’s why inheritance tax is so important to share the wealth. Inheritance in this generation will make society more and more unequal as so many people have made huge sums on property values and this will filter down creating a much wider inequality gap than ever before.

No answer to it but I get you.

My husband and I both left school at 16, had no financial help from anyone, worked for many years, took risks, made sacrifices and have accumulated what most would consider substantial wealth. Isn’t that social mobility?
We enjoy a very comfortable early retirement. We have Already paid massive amounts of tax, when we die our estate will be subject to further massive taxes. It’s our money, we made it and want to leave it to our children. How can you justify taxing us even more?

Bronwynbay · 10/06/2023 12:59

5128gap · 10/06/2023 09:53

People who don't get an inheritance have to deal with the loss of their parents too. Its not like grief is reserved for beneficiaries of wills. I'm sure there's many people who would forego inheritance to have their loved one, but that's not on the table. Its lose them with an inheritance or lose them without. And I can assure you that having the money not to worry about funeral costs or lost income for any caring you did, and having some peace of mind about your own financial future is a lot easier than not.

Thank you for saying this better than I could. The grief is the same regardless of whether you are lucky enough to inherit.

Dog GIF by ViralHog
Daisylookslost · 10/06/2023 12:53

MintJulia · 10/06/2023 08:18

Society is unequal in every way.

I'm one of six siblings and my df was on minimum wage. And was keen on beer and betting. The chance of me inheriting anything is nil. Just as I was a free school meals child, never went on a school trip, never had new clothes, never had a bike or a foreign holiday. I could go on.

I can either get all twisted and angry and let it spoil my life, or I can thank my lucky stars that I am healthy, solvent and in employment. That my ds is equally healthy. The sun is out, it's the weekend and I'm about to do parkrun because my pulled muscle has finally healed. 🙂

If you can't change something, you just have to move on. If not, the only person you are hurting is you.

This

Swipe left for the next trending thread