Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all films <5 years problematic in some way

269 replies

anon666 · 10/06/2023 00:24

I guess it might be a sign of rapid progress, but recently I've watched:

Pretty Woman
Dirty Dancing
Bend it like Beckham

All of which have a girl/woman falling for an authority figure. It really looks creepy to a modern eye. Or does it? Am I being too Gen Z about the whole thing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SquirrelSoShiny · 10/06/2023 08:58

Gtsr443 · 10/06/2023 06:10

For what its worth I always hated Pretty Woman and I'm a Gen Xer.

I can't wait to see what artistic gems Gen Z is going to come up with.....

Sam and Sam are non binary and use they/them pronouns. They are exactly the same age. They work in ethically sourced yoghurt and vegan socks. They never have sex unless both parties have agreed to it in writing. They spend their days staring at the wall worrying about climate change and living their truth.
ChatGPT is their only friend.
The End.

😂😂😂

HMMOG · 10/06/2023 08:55

ended up thinking Bennet was a really creepy seedy man with a very skewed idea of sexuality

You know it’s fiction, not autobiography?

I think some of this stuff is also related to growing old ourselves. I remember seeing Dead Poet’s Society as being about an inspiring teacher who encouraged his pupils to throw off the shackles of social expectations…watched it again recently and I saw this but also a teacher who crossed boundaries and sacrificed his pupils to his own ideas of what was right. But I think that’s because it’s a good film- it’s morally complex and that means it can bear both interpretations.

wildfirewonder · 10/06/2023 08:53

Hidinginaonesie · 10/06/2023 08:40

Life isn’t woke. It never was and it probably never will be.
Older men have always fancied younger women. Younger women have always fancied men in positions of power. Not all, but many.
Sometimes it’s ok and it works out. Sometimes not. Most of the time people end up with partners of a similar age because the other is a bit of a fantasy. Hence movies…….

There have always been people branded 'liberal' 'pc' ' woke' by the other side, all the way through time.

Life is complicated and humans are messy but that doesn't mean we all have to think any old shit shown on film is fine.

Misogyny in films is real and evident in some cases. So is homophobia, so is racism, so is class prejudice.

You can tell a story of e.g. an age-gap relationship in a way that rings true or a way that looks like a pervy old director's naff fantasy.

gogohmm · 10/06/2023 08:48

Pretty woman was meant to be a light a fluffy film, with dark undertones from the prostitution - a modern day fairy tale, not to be taken seriously. I still like it

NeverendingCircus · 10/06/2023 08:47

There has been a huge moral shift. I watched History Boys with my teens, remembering it as being about a teacher who inspired his pupils to think beyond their ordinary lives. DC asked why I had recommended a film about a paedophilic teacher who preys on his pupils.

We watched Withnail, which I remembered as being a hilarious film about two louche out of work actors. DC asked why I had recommended a film about a predatory, sexually abusive older man.

Also during lockdown I watched a lot of Alan Bennet's Talking Heads. I know he was a dear old national treasure but almost every monologue I watched had really perverted, creepy sexual material at its heart. a mother lusting after her own teenage son and her friend saying that's normal, she lusts after her own son too? Ew. And the creepy one about the wife being blindfolded and forced to have sex with all the neighbours... I ended up thinking Bennet was a really creepy seedy man with a very skewed idea of sexuality.

LunaNorth · 10/06/2023 08:45

GabriellaMontez · 10/06/2023 07:40

My much bigger issue with pretty woman is that it glamorises prostitution. Along with the various messages about money/beauty/success.

But hey, I would rather watch that, than something inoffensive and gender neutral probably with trigger warnings.

If you get a chance, have a look online at the original script. It would have been a very different, and much better movie, imo. Very gritty.

Ilkleymoor · 10/06/2023 08:43

Dirty dancing is also the only example I can think of where a woman has an abortion and it is the right decision for her. Any judgement is aimed at the doctor that butchers her and the prick who got her pregnant.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 10/06/2023 08:43

User135644 · 10/06/2023 08:28

What about the constant explicit sex scenes in modern shows? That's no better.

Yes! And has anyone else noticed how the sex positions seem to have changed. I've noticed on about 80% of things I've watched, the norm now seems to be 'taking the woman from behind'. Just when you think we might be making some progress ... 🤨

YukoandHiro · 10/06/2023 08:41

MMMarmite · 10/06/2023 01:08

I've just come from the "are most men degenerate" thread and the contrast is eye opening. Criticism there of porn culture, despair that young women are conditioned to put up with it.

While here, teenagers who are very clear on noticing sexism and disliking it in entertainment are called "too gen Z" and "insufferable".

I've been on that thread.

I didn't see much despair they're putting up with it, more sadness and frustration that it's a constant thing to battle against

wildfirewonder · 10/06/2023 08:40

Questionssquestionss · 10/06/2023 08:28

Another person just looking for problems in media past/present. Honestly how boring is your life to have this much time on your hands to be offended like this?!

I would say people of average intelligence can think quesions at the same time as doing other things so it is not about having time on your hands.

If someone is the type not to think, it is not due to having no 'time on your hands' but not having an active brain, I'd suggest.

Whatever you think, it doesn't really require empty time to do it.

QueenofKattegat · 10/06/2023 08:40

jotunn · 10/06/2023 07:33

Dirty Dancing is an interesting choice as the abortion story line wouldn't remotely get past the studios and some of it is very interesting in terms of class power dynamics. The relationship of Robby and Baby's dad because they're the same class for example...

I was always impressed with how the abortion storyline was dealt with. In a great many american films/tv shows they always portray abortion as utterly vile and the woman must be punished by dieing or losing her maaaaan. Remember in The Walking Dead, how everyone treated Lori for wanting to have an abortion in the middle of a zombie apocalypse ffs!

On the "older man/younger woman" thing - I remember when I first watched The Handmaids Tale and thinking Nick was so much younger than June. He actually wasn't though was he, we (the audience) were just not used to seeing a woman in a relationship with a man her own age so it made it look as though Nick was the younger one. Interesting to me.

Hidinginaonesie · 10/06/2023 08:40

Life isn’t woke. It never was and it probably never will be.
Older men have always fancied younger women. Younger women have always fancied men in positions of power. Not all, but many.
Sometimes it’s ok and it works out. Sometimes not. Most of the time people end up with partners of a similar age because the other is a bit of a fantasy. Hence movies…….

NotAMug · 10/06/2023 08:38

Mummyoflittledragon · 10/06/2023 08:14

I was also like op. My parents didn’t talk to me so I was hopelessly naive and unprepared for teen romances. I thought my boyfriend would be mine forever and rescue me from my life, thus gave myself so completely. I didn’t have many books but devoured the ones I was given. Catherine Cookson and handed down mills and boon. I should have been spending my days at the library broadening my horizons but didn’t even know I was allowed to go on my own. No wonder I believed in such fairy tales.

But these films shouldn't be banned or not exist due to poor parenting from a few, its the equivalent of a parent in my DSs class sending a group WhatsApp asking everyone in the class to stop their DCs going on the PlayStation during the week as her DC tantrummed when she asked him to come off.

I can totally understand how some people may believe these films to be similar to RL, I admit I didn't really think of it from your point of view, I still don't think anything should change but just shows why the kids PSHE lessons are so important at school and to ensure they consist of the correct content for teens.

wildfirewonder · 10/06/2023 08:36

Ylvamoon · 10/06/2023 08:10

I find the grooming/ conditioning that is happening now far more scary than a bit of light entertainment in the form of a film back in the 80's or early 90's.

Yes, because you are of your generation, presumably you are struggling to understand the next.

It is very common for older people to think younger people are doing life wrong, and that society is going to hell in a handcart, but the reality is the ratio of dickheads is roughly the same whatever birth year you look at.

I'm old, but happy to be termed 'woke' by the type of twats who use the term. I was woke 30 years ago, just people called me 'PC' then.

HMMOG · 10/06/2023 08:33

Pretty Woman has always been absolutely grim- that’s nothing to do with changing mores.

But I think one thing that has changed is that (some) people now expect films to be moral exemplars, that if something is presented in a film it’s necessarily presented with approval, and the only characters who behave badly will be clearly identified as baddies. It’s such a simplistic approach to fiction. In another context it really struck me in some of the responses to Cat Person (the short story that went viral a few years ago))- people trying to point out ways in which the female protagonist had behaved badly, like it was some sort of gotcha. But protagonists have always behaved badly, made mistakes, shown human failings of all kinds. That’s part of what makes fiction rewarding. The idea that it’s a bad film if it shows people being bad feels like a massive step backwards, culturally.

Questionssquestionss · 10/06/2023 08:28

Another person just looking for problems in media past/present. Honestly how boring is your life to have this much time on your hands to be offended like this?!

User135644 · 10/06/2023 08:28

Ponderingwindow · 10/06/2023 00:48

Finding films and tv shows to watch with my Gen Z child is next to impossible. She is absolutely insufferable about how every piece of entertainment that doesn’t conform to the current to the standards is problematic. We try to explain the context of era and she says she just can’t find it entertaining. Even recent media is difficult because sometimes standards change within a matter of months.

What about the constant explicit sex scenes in modern shows? That's no better.

User135644 · 10/06/2023 08:27

Saturday Night fever is particularly bad.

Followill · 10/06/2023 08:23

PocketBattleship · 10/06/2023 00:51

Why? What's your beef with age gap relationships?

It's not the age gap as such. It's the same old troupe of creepy old man shags young blond bird. I could count on one hand how many times it is reversed so a younger man falls for an older woman.

Hohofortherobbers · 10/06/2023 08:20

Recently watched bend it like Beckham, they really didnt need that dodgy creepy coach character who the girl's families should have been quite rightly suspicious of. The film would have been far better if he had just been an innocent supportive coach.

SwordToFlamethrower · 10/06/2023 08:20

I hate the word "problematic". It is a stupid woke word the kids use to suck the joy out of anything

Mamaneedsadrink · 10/06/2023 08:19

Applesinmyhouse · 10/06/2023 07:30

Bend it like Beckham is is a very progressive film, depicting a brown girl following her dream and succeeding in a ‘masculine’ hobby and the difficulty of being a second generation immigrant. It shows how commonplace racism is, and how it can feel caught between two cultures.
You cannot mention it in the same sentence as Pretty Woman, which is a great film but not the fairy tale some make it out to be.

Dirty Dancing on a surface level is a film about a holiday fling. It is very progressive for its time as it shows abortion and how fucking dangerous unregulated abortion is and how few choices (usually working class) women really end up having as they’re caught with the short stick again and again. If you're going to woke analyse films at least do it properly.

I'd agree, Bend it like Beckham was an excellent movie

SoftCoeur · 10/06/2023 08:18

I think that fiction of any genre, including fantasy, stands or falls on the truth of its characters. Excellent fiction should depict people as they are, not as we might wish them to be. Give us real, complex characters with behaviours and motivations that strike true, not ciphers mouthing platitudes and right think.

Most classic films from about 2012 or earlier understood this. That, and their understanding of the purpose and mechanisms of storytelling, is why they are still beloved.

Most people know when they're being preached at, and quite rightly don't like it.

Inthedarkagain · 10/06/2023 08:14

I'm in my 40's and these films make me cringe now. But they are of the time and if we don't have access to them we can't see how things have changed. I do find that we are forcing modern opinions into films and TV a bit too quickly though. We have people who tick certain boxes, but the character is not developed and I think that is worse because it is obvious they are only in the programmes for that reason. It's almost that our old movies and TV had such an entrenched narrative that they don't know how to adapt their stories to 'gen z' views.

My mum has always commented about the old movies from the 50's where the man would slap the angry woman (Calamity Jane springs to mind, used to love that film as a kid, but it is pure sexism), so it's not just 20 year olds who have noticed, my mum is 70! But yes, pretty woman is pretty dodgy. I always thought Labrinth had a bit of an odd storyline, but loved the film as a kid. Never liked SATC that much as I think it made women look very superficial and unlikable too. I think it had the opposite effect to what was intended.

Mummyoflittledragon · 10/06/2023 08:14

NotAMug · 10/06/2023 07:46

I couldn't disagree more, even I didn't buy into it at 14/15 as being remotely like real life. Its fiction and no one is telling women to suck it up. Anyone with any sort of intelligence understands the context surely. Even my teen boys do as we have these conversations. The current age 18-25 yo have no resilience. It's getting ridiculous. Surely it's a way to open up communication and discuss healthy relationships, body image etc etc. No need to ban stuff or only make fully politically/woke films forever more.

I was also like op. My parents didn’t talk to me so I was hopelessly naive and unprepared for teen romances. I thought my boyfriend would be mine forever and rescue me from my life, thus gave myself so completely. I didn’t have many books but devoured the ones I was given. Catherine Cookson and handed down mills and boon. I should have been spending my days at the library broadening my horizons but didn’t even know I was allowed to go on my own. No wonder I believed in such fairy tales.