Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all films <5 years problematic in some way

269 replies

anon666 · 10/06/2023 00:24

I guess it might be a sign of rapid progress, but recently I've watched:

Pretty Woman
Dirty Dancing
Bend it like Beckham

All of which have a girl/woman falling for an authority figure. It really looks creepy to a modern eye. Or does it? Am I being too Gen Z about the whole thing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
kelsaycobbles · 10/06/2023 10:47

Sorry but that last exchange reads as if porn is fine but showing a woman falling for a rich powerful man is dangerous and harmful

To me the first is always wrong and the second is much more contextual- if you had films also with bloke falling for rich powerful woman then they would just both be fairy stories

Although I guess it would be nice if they fell for nice people instead - although that gets you into the territory of the most sickly sweet American movies

PurpleBugz · 10/06/2023 10:41

MMMarmite · 10/06/2023 01:08

I've just come from the "are most men degenerate" thread and the contrast is eye opening. Criticism there of porn culture, despair that young women are conditioned to put up with it.

While here, teenagers who are very clear on noticing sexism and disliking it in entertainment are called "too gen Z" and "insufferable".

Yup. This is why we have such a problem we are conditioned to see women questioning this sort of thing too genZ or snowflake

I agree with the OP. But I also think there is bad messages in more recent films too. We just have to watch with a critical eye and teach our kids to have a critical eye

DisquietintheRanks · 10/06/2023 10:41

MissTrip82 · 10/06/2023 01:41

Don’t worry, there’s still plenty of sexist drivel being made now.

It’s fine and normal for a person of at least average intelligence to think about films and how their message is influenced by society.

As always, have only ever seen the word woke used by complete arseholes. Same with ‘professionally offended’ and ‘virtue signaling’. They’re a type.

Depends. Can you think about it with your mouth shut? Or is it necessary to "enlighten" the poor fuckers keeping company with you?

HeadNorth · 10/06/2023 10:35

This is a really enjoyable discussion - I agree that Dirty Dancing has more than stood the test of time - and a young girl maturing and learning about life and her sexuality is a key life experience that DD does well.

I also agree that films shouldn't have to provide role models or exemplers of social responsibility, but that doesn't mean it isn't fun to critique and unpick them. I love doing it with my daughters - they bring their more recent upbringing to bear and it is fun.

I still think Pretty Women is vile - I thought so at the time and I still do.

Simianwalk · 10/06/2023 10:26

Oh god it's turned into all new films are shite.
We had a binge recently of films some where shite but enjoyed Everything Everywhere, Nomadland, The Fabelmans, Parasite and The Dig. There has been loads so rubbish but it was ever thus.

thecatsthecats · 10/06/2023 10:19

I have written a book where a woman falls for a slightly older authority figure.

I'd find it horribly disappointing if anyone dismissed it out of hand without having even read it on that basis.

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 10/06/2023 10:16

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 10/06/2023 01:19

Die Hard is about as old as Dirty Dancing (1987 vs 1988). Jurassic Park is around the same age as Pretty Woman (1993 vs 1990). The Story of the Weeping Camel was made the year after Bend it like Beckham (2002 and 2003). None have a girl/woman falling for an authority figure, and I challenge you to find anything at all problematic in the camel one.

I rather like the love-interest plotline in Die Hard. He's been an arse, she's lost patience with him. Capitalism is leading her to have to hide her private life at work and battle with the patriarchy on all fronts. He realises he's been an arse but can't work out how to make it right. She is forcibly reminded of his good points and the fact that he is committed to their relationship, and they work together as a team. She uses her specific abilities to look after the hostages and negotiate at the same time as he's using his somewhat more blockbuster friendly skill set.

Baldieheid · 10/06/2023 10:08

Baldieheid · 10/06/2023 10:07

Depressing, isn't it. Storytelling is a dying art. I gender modern movies and TV unwatchable due to the special effects. I'm epileptic and flashing images and light effects rule out many shows for me.

I doubt they have a good impact on non epileptic brains either, tbh.

That odd "gender" was meant to say "find". Weird autocorrect.

Baldieheid · 10/06/2023 10:07

Depressing, isn't it. Storytelling is a dying art. I gender modern movies and TV unwatchable due to the special effects. I'm epileptic and flashing images and light effects rule out many shows for me.

I doubt they have a good impact on non epileptic brains either, tbh.

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/06/2023 10:06

I want to defend DD too! I saw it in the cinema when it came out, we all danced our way home. I watched it more recently in my late 40s and loved it all over again. I’d go so far as to say it’s a feminist movie. Agree with pp about Penny’s choice being validated, the true “villains” unmasked (Robby and the social structures that allowed HIM to be a serial predator, don’t forget he’s preying on Baby’s sister), and Johnny supporting Penny. Also yes Baby is younger but not that much, she has agency at every point, she makes her own choices and she becomes sexually mature and liberated. Johnny also sticks up for her and sees that she is a strong woman with a life ahead of her. Class is a strong theme, as much as social conservatism. There‘a a LOT there! Tbh the only thing it would take to “correct” some of the criticism would have been to cast much younger actors and then I don’t think anyone would blink. But then we wouldn’t have had Patrick Swayze…
Pretty Woman - love Julia Roberts but really, yuk.
Beckham - watched it in the last ten years, thought, why is the camera foregrounding Keira half naked (club scene) in a supposedly feminist film? Why is she the only one with sexual and relationship agency? Why is she the only “fully rounded” character? I thought this was about the Asian community? Oh, the white girl is the centre of the story. How predictable. (I am white). A League of Their Own did sport better and East is East did immigrant community better.

I think generally - watch everything, discuss everything, critique everything.

DemiColon · 10/06/2023 10:05

Dolphinnoises · 10/06/2023 05:40

Pretty Woman is another working of the Pygmalion story (man makes his ideal woman) which is yuck before you even get to the prostitution. See also Weird Science, My Fair Lady.

I loved Ferris Bueller but rewatching there was all sorts of cringe in there (not least “so that’s how they do things in their family” - awful!)

Bend it like Beckham I still love. OK yes alright, Joe is older. But it’s the exception that proves the rule. I accept this statement is without logic.

The point about Pygmalion surely is that the "remaking" of the female woman is purely superficial, she was already what she needed to be, everyone is just deceived by the outer trappings, partly because they are shallow. But she remakes the man in a much more profound way - he becomes a different sort of person.

anotherside · 10/06/2023 09:47

Honestly, this is why we’re left with drivel like all the Marvel movies now or worse the Fricken PC/woke reboots

Yeah the quality of mainstream US cinema has fallen off a cliff the last twenty years. The best picture selections have been pretty pitiful for a decade or more compared to what they used to be.

It would be easy to point the finger at woke culture or whatever but I think the reality is more boring: the studios discovered that the Marvel/other franchise endless sequel films have guaranteed box office returns while the old style picture simply doesn’t. And then it is true that the market domination of these teen/young adult type films has the knock on effect that most other films that aren’t Marvel etc will still to cater to this powerful young demographic, which is also easily reached for promotion purposes via YouTube/Facebook etc. The result is you get a ton of Marvel movies and easy to market reboots, lots of edgy unfunny comedies, gross out comedies, lots of teenager aimed fantasy and a bit of sci fi. But the classic grown up Hollywood type drama/comedy/sci fi aimed at adults, or the classic whole family type film, is nearing extinction.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 10/06/2023 09:29

Ilkleymoor · 10/06/2023 08:43

Dirty dancing is also the only example I can think of where a woman has an abortion and it is the right decision for her. Any judgement is aimed at the doctor that butchers her and the prick who got her pregnant.

Well, quite. If you look beyond the basic 'boy meets.girl' part of the story Dirry Dancing becomes quite a different film. Critique of snobbery and class structures, the horrors of illegal abortion, a very rare movie example of a man and woman (Johnny amd Penny) being friends who respect and support each other without any romantic relationship. And, as you say, no judgement towards Penny for wanting the abortion - just towards the people who put her in that position.

There's an episode of The Movies That Made us about DD, and it's really interesting. The screenwriter had to fight hard with the studio to keep a lot of those elements in. It was always intended to be a film with a message - the fluff was just a vehicle to smuggle it in.

PurpleParrotfish · 10/06/2023 09:28

My memories of watching Bend It Like Beckham 20 years ago were that it was a film about a girl’s ambition to play football (a ‘non-feminine’ activity), dealing with culture clash, racism, family and friendship. I’d remembered the romance bit as “the two friends both fancy the coach and it comes between their friendship but then they make up”.
I had to check the plot just now on Wikipedia, and obviously a romance with the coach isn’t ideal, but given that I’d forgotten about it, it’s hardly the main message of the film. And the film ends with them sort of together but she’s heading off to the US to train and leaving him behind so I still think the positives outweigh the negatives.

WonderingWanda · 10/06/2023 09:27

HMMOG · 10/06/2023 08:33

Pretty Woman has always been absolutely grim- that’s nothing to do with changing mores.

But I think one thing that has changed is that (some) people now expect films to be moral exemplars, that if something is presented in a film it’s necessarily presented with approval, and the only characters who behave badly will be clearly identified as baddies. It’s such a simplistic approach to fiction. In another context it really struck me in some of the responses to Cat Person (the short story that went viral a few years ago))- people trying to point out ways in which the female protagonist had behaved badly, like it was some sort of gotcha. But protagonists have always behaved badly, made mistakes, shown human failings of all kinds. That’s part of what makes fiction rewarding. The idea that it’s a bad film if it shows people being bad feels like a massive step backwards, culturally.

Exactly this, explained more eloquently than I could.

WonderingWanda · 10/06/2023 09:25

If we sanitise everything we watch then how will we learn about real life. In real life there are creepy people. I was a teen in the 90's and loved films like Dirty Dancing and Pretty Woman. I didn't watch them and dream of being rescued by an older man, I loved the films for what they were but was fully aware that the reality of life for prostitutes was very different to what was portrayed in the film. I was also keenly aware as a 15 yo girl that the relationship between baby and Johnny was very unrealistic and in real life a man that much older would be some sort of predator. Do people now imagine that in the 90's we were all running around starry eyed waiting for older men?

PurpleParrotfish · 10/06/2023 09:16

User135644 · 10/06/2023 08:27

Saturday Night fever is particularly bad.

Saturday Night Fever is pretty dark, but was always meant to be. Just because it’s got an upbeat soundtrack it doesn’t mean the film is lighthearted!

Baldieheid · 10/06/2023 09:14

Woke virtual signalling content is already a turn-off. I forced myself to finish the first episode of And Just Like That, tried episode 2 and gave up in despair after a few mins. It's like I'd been transported to a different planet, which, to be fair, is an accurate reflection on current times for me.

Swrigh1234 · 10/06/2023 09:08

Some people will looks for fault in all films and music from the past.

It’s no different to how some of the stuff being made made now with woke virtue signalling content will look ridiculously hilarious in the future.

Kanaloa · 10/06/2023 09:08

HMMOG · 10/06/2023 08:33

Pretty Woman has always been absolutely grim- that’s nothing to do with changing mores.

But I think one thing that has changed is that (some) people now expect films to be moral exemplars, that if something is presented in a film it’s necessarily presented with approval, and the only characters who behave badly will be clearly identified as baddies. It’s such a simplistic approach to fiction. In another context it really struck me in some of the responses to Cat Person (the short story that went viral a few years ago))- people trying to point out ways in which the female protagonist had behaved badly, like it was some sort of gotcha. But protagonists have always behaved badly, made mistakes, shown human failings of all kinds. That’s part of what makes fiction rewarding. The idea that it’s a bad film if it shows people being bad feels like a massive step backwards, culturally.

This is such an interesting post and it really sums up an issue I’ve had even at uni. People criticising creative writing in workshops with ‘the narrator comes across like not a nice person’ or deriding texts like Confederacy of Dunces because the protagonist is unlikeable, with no passing thought that perhaps that is an authorial choice.

If literature, film etc is to be any good, it likely won’t have the protagonist ‘goodie’ who does everything correctly and is morally superior, and the antagonist ‘baddie’ who the author consistently reminds us is wrong and bad. If that’s what you want to read or watch then it’s probably best to stick to works aimed at very young children.

tabulahrasa · 10/06/2023 09:07

Whatifthegrassisblue · 10/06/2023 08:43

Yes! And has anyone else noticed how the sex positions seem to have changed. I've noticed on about 80% of things I've watched, the norm now seems to be 'taking the woman from behind'. Just when you think we might be making some progress ... 🤨

One of the reasons is, it’s easier to film without touching, the actors can do it with a deflated Pilates ball between them.

Ardiaei · 10/06/2023 09:06

Gtsr443 · 10/06/2023 06:10

For what its worth I always hated Pretty Woman and I'm a Gen Xer.

I can't wait to see what artistic gems Gen Z is going to come up with.....

Sam and Sam are non binary and use they/them pronouns. They are exactly the same age. They work in ethically sourced yoghurt and vegan socks. They never have sex unless both parties have agreed to it in writing. They spend their days staring at the wall worrying about climate change and living their truth.
ChatGPT is their only friend.
The End.

You should write that as a Black Mirror episode!

Baldieheid · 10/06/2023 09:05

Ylvamoon · 10/06/2023 08:10

I find the grooming/ conditioning that is happening now far more scary than a bit of light entertainment in the form of a film back in the 80's or early 90's.

This.

Huge generalisations coming now.

I love that the youngsters are critically evaluating older movies and understanding what makes the situations portrayed problematic.

I hate that the youngsters do not critically evaluate the current media they are consuming.

ShimmeringShirts · 10/06/2023 09:03

“Cuties” is much less than 5 years old and one of the most vile child sexualised movies I’ve ever had the displeasure to watch 30 minutes of. I’d take dirty dancing over that any day of the week.