Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all films <5 years problematic in some way

269 replies

anon666 · 10/06/2023 00:24

I guess it might be a sign of rapid progress, but recently I've watched:

Pretty Woman
Dirty Dancing
Bend it like Beckham

All of which have a girl/woman falling for an authority figure. It really looks creepy to a modern eye. Or does it? Am I being too Gen Z about the whole thing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LaMaG · 10/06/2023 15:49

Thanks for clarifying!

NotAMug · 10/06/2023 15:35

LaMaG · 10/06/2023 15:26

I have a feeling she was only 16. Doesn't it say in the narrative at the start that she had just turned 16? Haven't seen it in years so I might be wrong.

Sorry just googled and it says shes 17. It doesn't help that the actors were 10 yrs older so he looked like an older man as 34, she was about 27ish I think.

LaMaG · 10/06/2023 15:26

NotAMug · 10/06/2023 07:13

I just don't understand why people have to tear these older films apart. Most mentioned are great films, fiction, not real FFS. Dirty Dancing for instance, she is 18, he is 24, he's hardly some 40 yo creepy man is he, they met first, he wasn't teaching her. Amazing dancing, great cast. I first saw it at about 8 yo, didn't understand the adult bits obv so no harm done, I thought Penny had a tummy ache, it literally didnt cross my mind at all, as a teen it was more eye opening but some important issues raised. No need for all the fuss.

Its great for people to be more woke in the true sense of the word but gen X are on another, ridiculous level, I'd be embarrassed to hear my kids coming out with such drival. The good news is that the kids slightly younger than gen Z are generally not buying into all the nonsense from what I can tell. They are more mature, more tolerant and do not just follow the crowd. There is hope for the future!!

I have a feeling she was only 16. Doesn't it say in the narrative at the start that she had just turned 16? Haven't seen it in years so I might be wrong.

Kanaloa · 10/06/2023 15:12

PocketBattleship · 10/06/2023 11:25

So, to be clear: just because the man is older, he's creepy? Right.

If the older man is constantly leching after young women who could be his daughter then yeah, he’s creepy. But no, he isn’t creepy because he is whatever (say 55) age. He’s creepy because he wants to cast himself opposite women in their early 20s constantly.

Sleepydoor · 10/06/2023 14:31

anon666 · 10/06/2023 11:31

Honestly I wasn't trying to lecture anyone or, god forbid, "virtue signalling". I was genuinely curious to see if it was just me that had re-watched these films recently with different eyes.

I thought maybe it was some kind of progress that we had made in society, maybe women recognising that we're not men's pawns any more.

Also I think I am permanently changed because I have seen IRL someone groomed by a much older man, a predator, and it's horrifying in real life and deeply creepy.

Nothing like any of the romantic films or stories where a coach/teacher/instructor seduces a young naive teenager. I've seen it through the disillusioned eyes of someone who realises that the "love of their life" is in fact a serial predator who has moved on while breaking their heart.

It's just made me see these narratives with new eyes, and made me wonder why we fill young women's heads with this stuff then wonder why they fall in love with older, predatory and ultimately abusive men.

Looking at the AIBU stats, it's a very personal sentiment.

I don’t think the AIBU stats tell you anything. “Are all movies <5 years problematic in some way?” All is such an absolute term and you actually meant >5 years anyway. You sparked an interesting conversation though!

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 12:27

There's a difference between MotherOfDragonflies DSs watching a film with questionable behaviour in it at ages 16-18 when they old enough to analyse and question that, and having the film used as nanny for younger children whilst Dparent puts the dinner on.

A PP said that age restrictions are important. Problem is that age restrictions don't stop an undiagnosed autistic girl aged 6 from seeing Snow White...

MotherOfDragonflies · 10/06/2023 12:21

We deliberately expose our DC to older movies and I am pleased to have brought up two teen boys (18 and 16) who I think are very aware of the feminist viewpoint on issues and who see through all the gender nonsense but are thoughtful and sensitive. Clearly there is still a different approach to some issues from the younger generation but in general I think we have taught them balance.

We watched The English Patient last night with DS1 (18). It’s uncomfortable in places; deliberately so. RF’s character is obsessive and “stalkery” - certainly by todays standards. It shows the reality of an affair and has some quite “passionate/forceful” sex scenes. DS1 couldn’t actually talk at the end of it because he was crying so much with the raw emotion of it.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 12:15

Disney animated features are awful for messaging towards girls until very recently.

Snow White: rescued from murder because the man instructed to kill her develops a conscience, rescued from starvation and exposure by seven men, then rescued from choking and married by yet another man. Be pretty, innocent and charming and a man will rescue you. Great message for young women, that.

Beauty And The Beast is basically the template for male abuser, female co-dependant.

It's only with Shrek and later films that I've seen this subverted with "action princess".

marshamarshmallow · 10/06/2023 12:12

BarelyLiterate · 10/06/2023 12:04

OP, is your daughter aware that Bend it Like Beckham was written, produced & directed by British Asians, that the lead actress Parminder Nagra is a working class woman from Leicester and that the film was widely praised for being an authentic & sensitive portrayal of the difficulties faced by young British-born Asians who feel conflicted as they try to navigate two different & often clashing cultures? If not, maybe she should recognise that she has a lot to learn…

Hear, hear.

For these very reasons, Bend it Like Beckham is held in high regard. On a scholastic note, it is often included/taught as part of any Film Studies course.

Bernadinetta · 10/06/2023 12:12

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 11:44

Mad Max Fury Road isn't sanitised either, and it's much more recent.

I'm over 40 and lose track of when films came out.

Mad Max Fury Road came out in 2015, two years ago Twelve Years a Slave and 8 years ago.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 12:07

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 10/06/2023 12:05

Pretty Woman jumps through loads of hoops to set up an artificial situation where he hires a prostitute but he's not "the sort of guy who uses prostitutes".

He's also a guy who can't keep a woman because he's a terrible boyfriend, but that's fine because he learns and grows through the influence of our heroine. ...

So Pygmalion meets Beauty And The Beast then.

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 10/06/2023 12:05

Jemandthehologramsunite · 10/06/2023 05:20

Pretty Woman always confused me. How did she "win" by getting a guy who was into prostitutes?

Pretty Woman jumps through loads of hoops to set up an artificial situation where he hires a prostitute but he's not "the sort of guy who uses prostitutes".

He's also a guy who can't keep a woman because he's a terrible boyfriend, but that's fine because he learns and grows through the influence of our heroine. ...

BarelyLiterate · 10/06/2023 12:04

OP, is your daughter aware that Bend it Like Beckham was written, produced & directed by British Asians, that the lead actress Parminder Nagra is a working class woman from Leicester and that the film was widely praised for being an authentic & sensitive portrayal of the difficulties faced by young British-born Asians who feel conflicted as they try to navigate two different & often clashing cultures? If not, maybe she should recognise that she has a lot to learn…

marshamarshmallow · 10/06/2023 11:48

Also, and perhaps most surprisingly, Pretty Woman is one of the few mainstream Hollywood films that advocates safe sex and condom use.

marshamarshmallow · 10/06/2023 11:46

Even though parts of Pretty Woman are highly problematic and glamourise prostitution, there is still a very clear message that prostitution is not glamorous, and for some, fatal. The latter point is made in the first scene - Pretty Woman opens with a murdered prostitute found in a dumpster. At its outset, the film is showing us that women who sell sex will be punished. Indeed, by the film's end, Vivian has been attacked by her client's lawyer. She also decides to move to San Francisco to go back to school, having realised prostitution isn't for her.

The saccharine ending of Vivian and Edward riding off in the limo together was added after test audiences didn't like the original ending where they went their separate ways. That would have been the better, more realistic ending.

Am by no means defending Pretty Woman, but it isn't quite the happy hooker film many like to think it is.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 11:44

Bernadinetta · 10/06/2023 07:43

What’s Twelve Years a Slave got to do with it? The movie came out in 2013, ten years ago, so it’s not an example of Gen Z accepting unsanitised films if that’s what you were trying to use it as? Gen Z-ers will have been about 8 years old when that film came out.

Mad Max Fury Road isn't sanitised either, and it's much more recent.

I'm over 40 and lose track of when films came out.

anon666 · 10/06/2023 11:31

Honestly I wasn't trying to lecture anyone or, god forbid, "virtue signalling". I was genuinely curious to see if it was just me that had re-watched these films recently with different eyes.

I thought maybe it was some kind of progress that we had made in society, maybe women recognising that we're not men's pawns any more.

Also I think I am permanently changed because I have seen IRL someone groomed by a much older man, a predator, and it's horrifying in real life and deeply creepy.

Nothing like any of the romantic films or stories where a coach/teacher/instructor seduces a young naive teenager. I've seen it through the disillusioned eyes of someone who realises that the "love of their life" is in fact a serial predator who has moved on while breaking their heart.

It's just made me see these narratives with new eyes, and made me wonder why we fill young women's heads with this stuff then wonder why they fall in love with older, predatory and ultimately abusive men.

Looking at the AIBU stats, it's a very personal sentiment.

OP posts:
PocketBattleship · 10/06/2023 11:25

Followill · 10/06/2023 08:23

It's not the age gap as such. It's the same old troupe of creepy old man shags young blond bird. I could count on one hand how many times it is reversed so a younger man falls for an older woman.

So, to be clear: just because the man is older, he's creepy? Right.

Squirrelsnut · 10/06/2023 11:11

I watched Pretty Woman, The Breakfast Club etc back in the 80s and even as a teen I was rolling my eyes at parts of the plot. Being raised by a feminist helped. Still enjoyed them as entertainment though. People aren't stupid by and large and can do their own 'filtering' without being babied.

anon666 · 10/06/2023 11:03

Eek, not my dad. My dd.

Stupid autocorrect

OP posts:
anon666 · 10/06/2023 11:03

Jemandthehologramsunite · 10/06/2023 05:20

Pretty Woman always confused me. How did she "win" by getting a guy who was into prostitutes?

Haha, brilliant. I did think that - this is a guy who treats women like shit. His wife, his girlfriend. He sacked them because they weren't at his beck and call. Then he hires a prostitute who is at his beck and call.

I guess I'm watching it with my dad, and I'm realising that far from a romantic ideal, these films are giving young naive girls the idea that this stuff is aspirational. 😬

I'm just seeing them with new eyes, that's all. I'm not trying to invoke some kind of "culture wars".

OP posts:
off · 10/06/2023 11:00

If "problematic" means something like "implicit or explicit moral messaging, assumptions or portrayals I disagree with", then almost everything from every era that has any human complexity is going to be problematic, but I think we can cope with imperfection.

The last few films I watched were In the Heat of the Night, David and Lisa, Men in Black, Analyze This, and Everything Everywhere All at Once. I could find objectionable aspects to probably all of these, and those aspects tend to go "pling!" in my brain while I'm watching or emerge while I'm thinking about the films afterwards, but that's okay with me. I'm planning to watch Birth of a Nation tonight, and expecting to find that about as problematic as it's possible for a film to be.

MichelleScarn · 10/06/2023 10:58

DisquietintheRanks · 10/06/2023 10:41

Depends. Can you think about it with your mouth shut? Or is it necessary to "enlighten" the poor fuckers keeping company with you?

Absolutely not, the message of 're-education and cancelling' anything you don't agree with has to be delivered loudly and publicly, just to make sure everyone around you knows how superior and saintly you are compared to the Dirty Dancing viewers.

Sleepydoor · 10/06/2023 10:56

I don’t understand why pp find Dirty Dancing problematic. Baby is 17 and it’s the summer before she goes off to college.

CountTo10 · 10/06/2023 10:48

Slightly off tangent but what about Jennifer Lawrence's new film 'No Hard Feelings'? She plays a woman who is paid by the parents of a sheltered 19 year old to sleep with him before college to make him more worldly. He doesn't know this is the plan and thinks she genuinely likes him and wants to date him. Couldn't believe it was being made in this day and age and imagine if the sexes were reversed!? Made me feel a bit sick honestly!

Give me Pretty Woman any day!