Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all films <5 years problematic in some way

269 replies

anon666 · 10/06/2023 00:24

I guess it might be a sign of rapid progress, but recently I've watched:

Pretty Woman
Dirty Dancing
Bend it like Beckham

All of which have a girl/woman falling for an authority figure. It really looks creepy to a modern eye. Or does it? Am I being too Gen Z about the whole thing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DemiColon · 11/06/2023 00:18

I suppose this means Guess Who's Coming to Dinner is down the tubes too.

DemiColon · 11/06/2023 00:15

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 22:47

Scroll up three posts? The owner of the club encourages the Ivy League waiters to seduce the guests’ daughters. Eww.

It's not entirely true though.

He encourages them to flirt with them and date them and keep them happy.

But the background to that are these are the kinds of young men the parents at the resort would like to see their daughters-of-marrying-age date. They are studying to be doctors and lawyers, and are from good Jewish families. It's probably one of the places the young people in these families get to go out of their own local community and meet a lot of other young Jewish people they don't already know.

That's why Baby's parents are quite happy to have their elder daughter date one of the waiters. Or for that matter, for Baby to date the son of the owner of the resort, who is probably about the same age as Johnny.

The fact that Robbie is a creep is really down to Robbie, there's no reason to think all the waiters were like him. Johnny's not a creep, but he's working class and probably Catholic. In the 60s, it's not surprising that people the age of Baby's parents might have, at best, really mixed feelings about marrying out.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 11/06/2023 00:02

Full disclosure, I didn't get as far as the end dance because I had got so angry about Ivy League waiter lying about knocking up the working class female dancer.

Kanaloa · 10/06/2023 23:37

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 22:47

Scroll up three posts? The owner of the club encourages the Ivy League waiters to seduce the guests’ daughters. Eww.

That’s got nothing to do with whether Johnny and Baby’s relationship is inappropriate - he isn’t one of the Ivy League waiters being encouraged! In fact the resort owner and the Ivy League waiter are depicted as being gross/creepy and Baby dislikes them.

Sleepydoor · 10/06/2023 23:25

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 22:47

Scroll up three posts? The owner of the club encourages the Ivy League waiters to seduce the guests’ daughters. Eww.

It's clear that you are supposed to see this character as being hypocritical and sleazy in that moment. He's not the hero of the movie. A movie can have antagonists or bad guys without making the premise of the movie problematic.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 22:47

NeverendingCircus · 10/06/2023 22:32

I've never understood that either. That dance at the end is gorgeous. They both adore each other. Nothing manipulative at all.

Scroll up three posts? The owner of the club encourages the Ivy League waiters to seduce the guests’ daughters. Eww.

NeverendingCircus · 10/06/2023 22:32

Sleepydoor · 10/06/2023 10:56

I don’t understand why pp find Dirty Dancing problematic. Baby is 17 and it’s the summer before she goes off to college.

I've never understood that either. That dance at the end is gorgeous. They both adore each other. Nothing manipulative at all.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 21:20

The owner of the club encourages the Ivy League waiters to seduce the guests’ daughters.

Eww.

Sleepydoor · 10/06/2023 21:05

The owner of the club encourages the Ivy League waiters to seduce the guests’ daughters. He told the working class staff to stay in their place. Johnny was fired for messing with the good jewish girl from a rich family.

anon666 · 10/06/2023 20:52

Sleepydoor · 10/06/2023 16:50

Johnny in Dirty Dancing is not her dancing teacher.

You know what, this never occurred to me, and I think this is to an extent a red herring. He's a professional teacher at the holiday camp. She is one of the clients. The very fact that he would be fired for sleeping with one of the guests should set off some red flags. The fact that she is 17 is the other oddity.

17 is really young for an older man to seduce. If the film had been cast with a real 17 year old instead of the super confident 23 year old Jennifer Gray, the inappropriateness and vulnerability would have showed through.

As it was, I can see why no-one finds the film itself creepy, but I think age matched casting would show up the storyline for what it is - an older, mature man in a position of authority/responsibility seduces a schoolgirl.

But happy to agree to differ.

OP posts:
Dolphinnoises · 10/06/2023 20:51

DemiColon · 10/06/2023 10:05

The point about Pygmalion surely is that the "remaking" of the female woman is purely superficial, she was already what she needed to be, everyone is just deceived by the outer trappings, partly because they are shallow. But she remakes the man in a much more profound way - he becomes a different sort of person.

It depends how far back you want to go. The one George Bernard Shaw based his on was a statue which came to life…

QueefQueen80s · 10/06/2023 18:39

@PocketBattleship Yes older men who go after young women are creepy as fuck.

LaMaG · 10/06/2023 18:33

I should clarify when I say seeing it again in my 20s that was about 20 yrs ago, am in my 40s as my opinion probably reflects!!

LaMaG · 10/06/2023 18:30

Yes it's a fair power balance. And he is the one who gets fired spoiler alert 😂 for having a relationship with a client, not on account of her age. Robbie wouldn't have gotten fired cos he was the 'right' sort. I love the scene when baby tells Penny she envies her and Penny is like are you serious? My parents were very protective and I was always jealous of the girls who were out hanging around the streets being themselves while mine only talked about education. I totally see why Baby was jealous - I remember thinking first time I saw it at 13 that I wish my mum would kick me out at 16 so I could be myself too. I wished someone had rescued me from my corner!!. Seeing it again in my 20s and it's a very different context. BUT privilege comes at a high cost and I love that Johnny saw that in her and showed her parents that she was more than just their version of her.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 10/06/2023 17:53

Johnny in Dirty Dancing is not her dancing teacher.

And she's the one with the financial and social capital.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 10/06/2023 17:32

Disney reckons that the Jungle Book is 'problematic', so it's a load of old arse.

Ponderingwindow · 10/06/2023 17:08

I always thought the disapproval in Dirty Dancing was because of class and because the Dad thought Johnny was the one that got Penny pregnant. It’s even emphasized when Johnny is jealous that the Dad is accepting of Robby, another worker dating a daughter, but a worker attending college. Age never even entered my mind as an issue at play.

The whole movie is a commentary on social class in America. The abortion plot emphasizes the dire economic position faced by a young woman with no resources. Baby’s romance isn’t about her romance, it is about opening her eyes to the world she has never seen because she has been protected and coddled. Sure it is wrapped up in fun songs and dance numbers, but the people who made that movie knew exactly what they were doing.

junglejane66 · 10/06/2023 17:03

Harrythehappypig · 10/06/2023 01:02

I can’t think of a single film where a middle aged male actor is paired with a woman of the same age. I suppose in the last Top Gun there was only an 8 year gap. Watching Cobra Kai at the moment and there’s a nearly 2 decade age gap between that of the two older male leads and their female partners. Other than teen and “gritty reality” films, when are ages similar?

African Queen

Sleepydoor · 10/06/2023 16:50

anon666 · 10/06/2023 16:19

I would likely have said the same until I saw with my own eyes the way certain older men can use and abuse the naivety of young girls. In real life it's often very different to fairy tales or romcoms.

I think the whole issue of safeguarding has brought me to a point where I realise there are men who serially take advantage of young women's naivety to portray themselves as a gallant rescuer when they are in fact a creep. The whole of the male community involved in the Rotherham scandals played into this exact vulnerability. Girls can buy groomed into dependency so easily. If I hadn't witnessed the transition with my own eyes I would probably not have picked up on it. ☹️ It's not just girls, boys the same.

I wonder if any of you would approve of a relationship between a schoolteacher and a pupil in the same way as you're happy to tell me off for finding a football coach or a dance teacher to be a slightly problematic romantic hero. I just think we've become a bit wiser.

PS none of this was about the British Asian community element of BILB. It was totally the coach falling for a pupil.

Johnny in Dirty Dancing is not her dancing teacher.

PumpkinQueen1 · 10/06/2023 16:37

I grew up in the 80s, and my dad used to bring lots of videos home from work which his mates assured him were suitable for kids eg Rambo, Commando, and many other cert 18 action movies.

He probably should have watched them first to check, but this was the 80s, he'd only just bought our first video player, and it was a different world back then!

I am a huge movie fan, and really enjoy watching the old films I grew up with.

But I did draw the line when I recently rewatched Predator 2, when Bill Paxtons character has an argument with a woman, and asks 'is this bitch on the rag'.

I thought nothing of it at the time though, because that was the norm.

Attitudes towards women, and their roles in films has definitely changed for the better since I was a kid. There was definately a hell of a lot of gratuitous female nudity back in the 80s/90s. I don't remember there being many strong women role models at all.

I have two daughters, and i think its great that there are far more strong female characters in films these days. I really loved taking them to see Captain Marvel. Funnily enough, not a lot of men seem to like that film.

anon666 · 10/06/2023 16:19

LaMaG · 10/06/2023 15:55

Being honest i take v little notice of what the young folk think cos half of it makes no sense. Women need to be portrayed as empowered but at the same time they can't be in love with or a sexual relationship with an older man til they are about 20 cos women are too f*ing stupid to make decisions about themselves and need to be protected. It's a complete paradox. People have forgotten that women are or at least were more mature than their male counterparts, so it's actually more likely a 16 or 17 yr old would be attracted to an older man cos they feel that boys their own age are childish idiots.

I would likely have said the same until I saw with my own eyes the way certain older men can use and abuse the naivety of young girls. In real life it's often very different to fairy tales or romcoms.

I think the whole issue of safeguarding has brought me to a point where I realise there are men who serially take advantage of young women's naivety to portray themselves as a gallant rescuer when they are in fact a creep. The whole of the male community involved in the Rotherham scandals played into this exact vulnerability. Girls can buy groomed into dependency so easily. If I hadn't witnessed the transition with my own eyes I would probably not have picked up on it. ☹️ It's not just girls, boys the same.

I wonder if any of you would approve of a relationship between a schoolteacher and a pupil in the same way as you're happy to tell me off for finding a football coach or a dance teacher to be a slightly problematic romantic hero. I just think we've become a bit wiser.

PS none of this was about the British Asian community element of BILB. It was totally the coach falling for a pupil.

OP posts:
LaMaG · 10/06/2023 16:16

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 16:02

And you completely ignore the huge power imbalance between a teen and an older man. He's got financial and social capital that she lacks. That's where the safeguarding concerns come from.

No I think it very much depends on the context and personality of the 2 people but I don't agree this blanket safeguarding thing. For example an 18 yr old girl student dates a 25 Yr old man who is working, that shouldnt automatically ring bells. Same girl dating her college professor then yes there's an imbalance of power.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 10/06/2023 16:02

LaMaG · 10/06/2023 15:55

Being honest i take v little notice of what the young folk think cos half of it makes no sense. Women need to be portrayed as empowered but at the same time they can't be in love with or a sexual relationship with an older man til they are about 20 cos women are too f*ing stupid to make decisions about themselves and need to be protected. It's a complete paradox. People have forgotten that women are or at least were more mature than their male counterparts, so it's actually more likely a 16 or 17 yr old would be attracted to an older man cos they feel that boys their own age are childish idiots.

And you completely ignore the huge power imbalance between a teen and an older man. He's got financial and social capital that she lacks. That's where the safeguarding concerns come from.

LaMaG · 10/06/2023 15:55

Being honest i take v little notice of what the young folk think cos half of it makes no sense. Women need to be portrayed as empowered but at the same time they can't be in love with or a sexual relationship with an older man til they are about 20 cos women are too f*ing stupid to make decisions about themselves and need to be protected. It's a complete paradox. People have forgotten that women are or at least were more mature than their male counterparts, so it's actually more likely a 16 or 17 yr old would be attracted to an older man cos they feel that boys their own age are childish idiots.

KnittedCardi · 10/06/2023 15:54

I have two gen Z DD's, they love all the rom coms, inc. the ones mentioned. They also love things like Friends, and Life on Mars, and many, many, other, so called problematic film/TV. They also read all the classics when children, and have no issue with any of them. They were of their time, and are enjoyable as such.